What's new

Air India flight to bring Sarabjit Singh’s body back

You people also believed that Surjeet was innocent.

Going by your logic, if you knew he was guilty, you wouldn't have asked for his release, but in reality Surjeet admitted at Wagah that he was a spy.

So your logic goes bust.

Customs officials have stopped the body from being transferred since there is no NOC from foreign ministry nor a police report ascertaining cause of death.

In this case the prime witness himself said that Sarabjeet is innocent. Why would he say so if his fahter and relatives were killed by Sarabjeet ?
 
.
That would be relevant if we accepted that he was a terrorist. We don't accept he was one, we believe he was framed. You are free to believe otherwise. Only a complete blockhead would buy the idiotic theory that RAW would use an Indian to go around placing bombs inside a hostile city all by himself. Just a single individual doing some Rambo stuff........ Do you chaps really believe that there would have been no Pakistanis who RAW could have used? Do you think they would have used an Indian who might actually leave a trail & especially use a non-Muslim for that?

As the MEA said today..." if we believed he was guilty, we would have never asked for his release"


You are welcome to your narrative. Unlike in the case of Kasab where Pakistan tried everything from he was "Amar Singh" to he was in Nepal, India stood by Sarabjit Singh. He may or might not have been a spy but he almost certainly was framed for bomb blasts he did not commit. That remains our view which is why we treat him the way we do, more so in death because he most certainly was killed because he was an Indian. That is our connection.

As India's version is always universal truth for you despite that story was changed him being drunk former to smuggler, but this was the last version. Let me know what's your take on it

“Every resident of my village in India will endorse my version as Manjeet Singh, the real culprit responsible for the bomb blasts in Pakistan, has been arrested in India,”
Sarabjit's sister urges Pak to re-investigate brother's case | Liveindia
 
.
with the same coerced witness and formulated evidence??



after serving about 22 years??for espionage??

He was supposed to hang for his involvement in a bombing that killed 14 people. Thats a bit more than a spook. Obviously you are free to believe your news stories about what really happened.
 
.
She did have a lawyer. Earlier a British lawyer Jas Uppal but she failed to appear for the hearing and the case was dismissed by pak supreme court. later she hired a pakistani lawyer.

So, Is it our fault that she couldn't appear?
 
.
In this case the prime witness himself said that Sarabjeet is innocent. Why would he say so if his fahter and relatives were killed by Sarabjeet ?

YOu didnt answer my question nor prove the absurd logic.
 
.
He was supposed to hang for his involvement in a bombing that killed 14 people. Thats a bit more than a spook. Obviously you are free to believe your news stories about what really happened.

Then why would the man whose father and relatives were allegedly killed by Sarabjeet claim that he was was innocent ?
 
.
He was supposed to hang for his involvement in a bombing that killed 14 people. Thats a bit more than a spook. Obviously you are free to believe your news stories about what really happened.

lets keep aside our versions aside for a while..if his conviction was proved then isnt it cruel to make him suffer for 22 years and then kill him like this??he should have been hanged much earlier.that would save him a lot of suffering
 
.
lets keep aside our versions aside for a while..if his conviction was proved then isnt it cruel to make him suffer for 22 years and then kill him like this??he should have been hanged much earlier.that would save him a lot of suffering

Marcy appeals from his family delayed it and he was killed by jail-mates who are also on death row.
 
.
In this case the prime witness himself said that Sarabjeet is innocent. Why would he say so if his fahter and relatives were killed by Sarabjeet ?

Money could be a reason. Among many others. Again it was just not eyewitness acounts only. It did make the case easier nonetheless.
 
.
YOu didnt answer my question nor prove the absurd logic.

What there to answer in your question. No country claims her spies if caught . Surjeet was an informer of the army and intelligence. Sarabjeet was a farmer who crossed over and was arrested at wagah border.

Absurd logic to me is this that why would a man whose father and relatives are killed by a person claim that he's innocent.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
lets keep aside our versions aside for a while..if his conviction was proved then isnt it cruel to make him suffer for 22 years and then kill him like this??he should have been hanged much earlier.that would save him a lot of suffering

Read my earlier posts. I have said just that. There is the right way to do things and for it to come to this was shameful and sickening. Giving him a state funeral after what the last spy released giving out press statement said seems even worse. As a Pakistani. I don't know if I would react the same way if I was an Indian to his innocence because of media reports.. I always thought Kasab did it and should go to hell.. maybe you have different requirements from us then yourself.
 
.
Money could be a reason. Among many others. Again it was just not eyewitness acounts only. It did make the case easier nonetheless.


No amount of money can buy a person to speak for a person who has killed your family members. As far as i know it was only on the basis of eye witness on whose testimony the case was decided. Saleem Shaukat was a key witness of the case. Nothing was found from his possession to prove his involvement in the bomb blast.
 
.
No amount of money can buy a person to speak for a person who has killed your family members. As far as i know it was only on the basis of eye witness on whose testimony the case was decided. Saleem Shaukat was a key witness of the case. Nothing was found from his possession to prove his involvement in the bomb blast.

Did you just forget the Raymond Davis episode? I am sure you get as annoyed with people tagging conspiracy theories linked to framing Ajmal Kasab as well.. The courts spoke and some of us just keep blaming the others courts.. such an old and tasteless story.
 
.
Read my earlier posts. I have said just that. There is the right way to do things and for it to come to this was shameful and sickening. Giving him a state funeral after what the last spy released giving out press statement said seems even worse. As a Pakistani. I don't know if I would react the same way if I was an Indian to his innocence because of media reports.. I always thought Kasab did it and should go to hell.. maybe you have different requirements from us then yourself.

no sane person would support terrorists i condemn the acts of ttp and other factions in the same tone as i condemned the kasab's act.its just that we believe hes not linked to the blast .he might be a spy nothing more..many of ur fellow men believe that india supports ttp,baloch factions and several others to destabilize pakistan.if india wants to make some blasts it would have selected anyone of them.why would it send an indian all the way there to do the job alone??i dnt want to speculate too much.but its worth a tought
 
.
You people also believed that Surjeet was innocent.

Going by your logic, if you knew he was guilty, you wouldn't have asked for his release, but in reality Surjeet admitted at Wagah that he was a spy.

Being a spy is not necessarily the same as being involved with bomb blasts & killing of people. As I said in my post, Sarabjit Singh may or may not have been a spy but it is most unlikely (that is the best I can do) that he was involved in the bomb blasts. The reasoning behind that was that it would be extraordinarily foolish of RAW not to use locals & actually use a citizen of India and more specifically, a non-Muslim one to do blasts in Pakistan.

As India's version is always universal truth for you despite that story was changed him being drunk former to smuggler, but this was the last version. Let me know what's your take on it

Look, do I know what the absolute truth is? No I don't. All I have done is to use logic the way I see it. Do I have inside information? I most certainly don't. What I'm pointing out is why we believe he is not guilty & why he will be treated as a hero. There is no clear, unambiguous evidence that suggests otherwise. Pakistanis like you will believe what you will but the line taken by India & millions of Indians does not openly fly in the face of facts as we know them. Whether there are facts that exist but are not known to either of us, I cannot say. What I can is that the present evidence leaves plenty of room for us Indians to clearly believe what we do and do so without compromising on morality as you suggest we have..

. I always thought Kasab did it and should go to hell.. maybe you have different requirements from us then yourself.


Not at all, Kasab's guilt was never in doubt. This is not as straightforward a case as that. Hence the difference.

Money could be a reason.

Why do you assume that money could only work in the recantation but not in the original trial?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom