Ahmedia worship place attacked in Karachi

[Mujahid Memon]

RSS ideology of destroying worship places slowly infesting across the border

 

[hussain0216]

I was hoping someone will talk about India in a thread related to Pakistani citizens. So thanks.

Also, are Indian Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis being prevented by law to call themselves Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis respectively?

Who cares about the name, it's a hindutva extremist communal state

That's why Sikhs are beginning to beat Indians abroad and at home, you have had major communal riots in the last few years

 

[Kuru]

Who cares about the name, it's a hindutva extremist communal state

That's why Sikhs are beginning to beat Indians abroad and at home, you have had major communal riots in the last few years

You still didn’t answer it

Are Indian minorities banned from calling themselves Muslims Sikhs or Christians ?

 

[villageidiot]

This is ‘whataboutery.’

It's necessary context to your comment about the freedom struggle.

Also, do you mean India has a law which prevents Muslims to call themselves Muslims ?

Maybe not yet but Modi he to mumkin he.

BTW, you are only marginally better than us, by virtue of having a secular constitution, as far the discrimination being codified in law is concerned. Otherwise, on ground
Otherwise, are minority places of worship not vandalized or destroyed in India?
Are minorities not lynched in India? In fact, you have more lynchings than us.

Let's both start with the baseline of 2014. Other than the sri-lankan manager, how many minority persons have been lynched in Pakistan since 2014 and how many in india?

I was hoping someone will talk about India in a thread related to Pakistani citizens. So thanks.

Also, are Indian Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis being prevented by law to call themselves Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis respectively?

No they are not being prevented by law but by instinct of survival. They have to be good muslims (and christians) or else they might find themselves unwanted.

buddhists, jains and parsis are relics and not significant in any way today. Neither are they a thread to Hinduism. So lets not count them in to show off india's plurality, shall we? Waste of bandwidth.

 

[villageidiot]

You still didn’t answer it

Are Indian minorities banned from calling themselves Muslims Sikhs or Christians ?

Jews in the third reich weren't banned from calling themselves Jews. Rather they were forced to wear their sacred Star of David? So, going by your logic, would you say that the jews in the third Reich, were not only not persecuted, but they expressed their religions identity everywhere they went?

 

[Kuru]

It's necessary context to your comment about the freedom struggle.

It’s okay I get it. Just wanted to show you that sometimes we need to draw comparisons and that doesn’t constitute ‘whataboutery,’ you know

Maybe not yet but Modi he to mumkin he.

BTW, you are only marginally better than us, by virtue of having a secular constitution, as far the discrimination being codified in law is concerned. Otherwise, on ground
Otherwise, are minority places of worship not vandalized or destroyed in India?
Are minorities not lynched in India? In fact, you have more lynchings than us.

Let's both start with the baseline of 2014. Other than the sri-lankan manager, how many minority persons have been lynched in Pakistan since 2014 and how many in india?

India is not perfect sir. India has its own share of pathetic people (after all we are 2nd most populous country so yeah, this is going to be there). We may always have these kinda people but the rule of law, or the constitution, remains equal to ALL.

My comment is for those who want to lecture us about minorities when they have LAWS persecuting their OWN MINORITIES. That’s all!

BTW, did you see Pathan, it is creating history in India box office where the lead actor belongs to minority community. 700cr is what I checked last.

Jews in the third reich weren't banned from calling themselves Jews. Rather they were forced to wear their sacred Star of David? So, going by your logic, would you say that the jews in the third Reich, were not only not persecuted, but they expressed their religions identity everywhere they went?

This comparison is SO wrong that I can’t even get started. Let’s keep it to the topic I.e. Pakistan has banned Ahmedias to call themselves Muslims, India have done no such thing to ANY community.

 

[Mirzah]

This is ‘whataboutery.’

Also, do you mean India has a law which prevents Muslims to call themselves Muslims ?

do you really need a official law when rioters and lynchers attack Muslims, the police sit on the sidelines and watch

 

[Kuru]

do you really need a official law when rioters and lynchers attack Muslims, the police sit on the sidelines and watch

If that’s the “norm,” there should be NOT A SINGLE MUSLIM alive in India. But last I checked, their population is growing.

Also, why are you talking about India in this thread ?

 

[hembo]

I was hoping someone will talk about India in a thread related to Pakistani citizens. So thanks.

Also, are Indian Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis being prevented by law to call themselves Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Muslims and Parsis respectively?

Is it worth to compare Indian affairs vs. Pakistani. That too in a Pakistani forum? Just be a spectator (mostly and in line with current Indian policy towards Pakistan) and enjoy the telenova.

 

[Mirzah]

If that’s the “norm,” there should be NOT A SINGLE MUSLIM alive in India. But last I checked, their population is growing.

Also, why are you talking about India in this thread ?

norm or not its becoming more frequent, I remember Delhi riots 2020 vividly, sure Pakistan can do better in treating minorities, but india is no better

https://twitter.com/x/status/1621398929634893825

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Indian minorities refused to listen to Jinnah and now they have to suffer through a hindutva extremist communal state

Indian SC themselves justified a mob attack on Babri Masjid and rewarded the Hindu extremists

You are no different than your Bharati cousins. The question you should be asking is, how do people become a different nationality because of religion? They don't. For example, Arab Muslims are Arab.

 

[terry5]

norm or not its becoming more frequent, I remember Delhi riots 2020 vividly, sure Pakistan can do better in treating minorities, but india is no better

https://twitter.com/x/status/1621398929634893825

WTH that is heartbreaking , she’s only a fragile little girl . What the **** man

 

[Great Janjua]

Qadianis aka Mirzais good they are denounced by the constitution.

 

[my2cents]

Wha

do you really need a official law when rioters and lynchers attack Muslims, the police sit on the sidelines and watch

I don't see your police doing anything above to prevent from vandalism.

 

[CLUMSY]

RSS ideology of destroying worship places slowly infesting across the border

Its always been here.
This awaam will always make issues out of non issues