Titanium100
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2019
- Messages
- 7,772
- Reaction score
- -10
- Country
- Location
'Shockingly racist': Foreign citizens fleeing Ukraine say they're being singled out at border
Giulia Carbonaro
Share
Almost half a million people have already fled Ukraine following Russia's invasion last Thursday. Among these were the many foreign citizens who until then were studying, working and living in the country now under attack.
But at the Polish border, where officials quickly mobilized to process over 300,000 of those fleeing, Indian and African students have reported being singled out over Ukrainians and being prevented from crossing into safety.
African residents in Ukraine wait at the platform inside Lviv railway station in west Ukraine. /AP Photo/Bernat Armangue
What's happening at the border?
The reports of unfair treatment and discriminatory behavior in the processing of Indian and African citizens at the Ukraine-Russian border have been many.
Several stranded students have shared videos and testimonies on social media showing how they were allegedly discriminated against at train stations and border posts, being prevented from boarding trains and buses and being held back while priority is given to Ukrainian nationals.
Nigerian authorities say that there have been cases of Nigerians being stopped at the border by Polish officials and refused entry to the country. South African foreign ministry spokesman Clayson Monyela tweeted that a group of South Africans, mostly students, was also stuck at the border.
More reports involved students from Kenya, Côte d'Ivoire, DR Congo, Ghana and India.
Some of the students who made it across the border, like Congolese student Prence Angale, said crossing the border was harder than the journey to get there.
"When we were leaving Ukraine, all was fine, but when we arrived at the (Polish) border, there was a bit of jostling, and we were being shoved back and all that, but things went well, we managed, thank God," said Angale talking to AFP.
"We had to stay outside, exposed to the cold that they have here, nobody tells us where we can find shelter, we are exposed to the cold," said another student.
India has already evacuated hundreds of students on special flights since the invasion started, but thousands remain stranded in Kyiv and Kharkiv.
They are now hoping their government will arrange to get them out of the country as soon as possible.
Several students who made it to the border with Poland tell of being harassed and brutalized by Ukrainian police.
Cases of racial injustice related to the wave of refugees from Ukraine are being shared through social media, with the hashtag #AfricansinUkraine being used on Twitter.
READ MORE:
Talks begin, Ukraine applies to join EU, Ruble crashes, Russia advances in the east
Kyiv kindness has shown 'how valuable life is'
Life in a temporary Kyiv air raid shelter
Is this a problem for students only?
The reports involve more than just students - but students account for a big part of Africans and Indians in Ukraine. There are about 76,000 foreign students studying in Ukraine, a quarter of whom are Indian, mainly enrolled in medical courses.
According to Ukraine's education ministry, Morocco, Nigeria, and Egypt are among the top 10 countries with foreign students in Ukraine. These three countries together send over 16,000 students to the Eastern European country, which is a cheaper alternative to universities in Western Europe or the U.S.
What are home countries doing about it?
African Union (AU) leaders have denounced the reports of mistreatment of Africans trying to flee Ukraine as "shockingly racist" and "in breach of international law."
AU chair and Senegalese President Macky Sall and AU Commission head Moussa Faki Mahamat urged "all countries to respect international law and show the same empathy and support to all people fleeing war notwithstanding their racial identity."
Several African countries are also mobilizing to help their citizens stranded in Eastern Europe.
Ghana's government said it would meet parents of students stuck in Ukraine on Tuesday and sent embassy officials to border points to help.
Kenya's authorities said 200 Kenyans already made it to safety, while a few are still stuck at the border.
DR Congo's Foreign Minister Christophe Lutundula said on Twitter that he would meet with the Polish ambassador to help 200 Congolese, mostly students, cross the border. Ivory Coast and Nigeria are making similar arrangements.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Monday he plans to send four senior ministers to Ukraine's neighboring countries to help in the rescue of some 16,000 Indians still in the country, most of whom are students.
Refugees wait in a line to enter a bus after fleeing from Ukraine, near the border crossing in Medyka, Poland. /AP Photo/Markus Schreiber
What's Poland saying?
Poland ambassador to Nigeria Joanna Tarnawska dismissed the claim of unfair treatment of African citizens at the border, telling local media that "everybody receives equal treatment," and she had reports that "some Nigerian nationals have crossed the border into Poland."
She added that African citizens were being allowed entry even with invalid passports and that they are allowed to remain in the country for 15 days.
But even the African students who made it across the Polish borders say that they were made to wait while priority was given to Ukrainian women and children.
The Nigerian embassy in Bucharest, Romania, said it had received 130 Nigerians from Ukraine, with more being processed having reached Warsaw or Budapest.
The Polish government has condemned the reports as "fake news."
Giulia Carbonaro
Share
Almost half a million people have already fled Ukraine following Russia's invasion last Thursday. Among these were the many foreign citizens who until then were studying, working and living in the country now under attack.
But at the Polish border, where officials quickly mobilized to process over 300,000 of those fleeing, Indian and African students have reported being singled out over Ukrainians and being prevented from crossing into safety.
African residents in Ukraine wait at the platform inside Lviv railway station in west Ukraine. /AP Photo/Bernat Armangue
What's happening at the border?
The reports of unfair treatment and discriminatory behavior in the processing of Indian and African citizens at the Ukraine-Russian border have been many.
Several stranded students have shared videos and testimonies on social media showing how they were allegedly discriminated against at train stations and border posts, being prevented from boarding trains and buses and being held back while priority is given to Ukrainian nationals.
Nigerian authorities say that there have been cases of Nigerians being stopped at the border by Polish officials and refused entry to the country. South African foreign ministry spokesman Clayson Monyela tweeted that a group of South Africans, mostly students, was also stuck at the border.
More reports involved students from Kenya, Côte d'Ivoire, DR Congo, Ghana and India.
Some of the students who made it across the border, like Congolese student Prence Angale, said crossing the border was harder than the journey to get there.
"When we were leaving Ukraine, all was fine, but when we arrived at the (Polish) border, there was a bit of jostling, and we were being shoved back and all that, but things went well, we managed, thank God," said Angale talking to AFP.
"We had to stay outside, exposed to the cold that they have here, nobody tells us where we can find shelter, we are exposed to the cold," said another student.
India has already evacuated hundreds of students on special flights since the invasion started, but thousands remain stranded in Kyiv and Kharkiv.
They are now hoping their government will arrange to get them out of the country as soon as possible.
Several students who made it to the border with Poland tell of being harassed and brutalized by Ukrainian police.
Cases of racial injustice related to the wave of refugees from Ukraine are being shared through social media, with the hashtag #AfricansinUkraine being used on Twitter.
READ MORE:
Talks begin, Ukraine applies to join EU, Ruble crashes, Russia advances in the east
Kyiv kindness has shown 'how valuable life is'
Life in a temporary Kyiv air raid shelter
Is this a problem for students only?
The reports involve more than just students - but students account for a big part of Africans and Indians in Ukraine. There are about 76,000 foreign students studying in Ukraine, a quarter of whom are Indian, mainly enrolled in medical courses.
According to Ukraine's education ministry, Morocco, Nigeria, and Egypt are among the top 10 countries with foreign students in Ukraine. These three countries together send over 16,000 students to the Eastern European country, which is a cheaper alternative to universities in Western Europe or the U.S.
What are home countries doing about it?
African Union (AU) leaders have denounced the reports of mistreatment of Africans trying to flee Ukraine as "shockingly racist" and "in breach of international law."
AU chair and Senegalese President Macky Sall and AU Commission head Moussa Faki Mahamat urged "all countries to respect international law and show the same empathy and support to all people fleeing war notwithstanding their racial identity."
Several African countries are also mobilizing to help their citizens stranded in Eastern Europe.
Ghana's government said it would meet parents of students stuck in Ukraine on Tuesday and sent embassy officials to border points to help.
Kenya's authorities said 200 Kenyans already made it to safety, while a few are still stuck at the border.
DR Congo's Foreign Minister Christophe Lutundula said on Twitter that he would meet with the Polish ambassador to help 200 Congolese, mostly students, cross the border. Ivory Coast and Nigeria are making similar arrangements.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Monday he plans to send four senior ministers to Ukraine's neighboring countries to help in the rescue of some 16,000 Indians still in the country, most of whom are students.
Refugees wait in a line to enter a bus after fleeing from Ukraine, near the border crossing in Medyka, Poland. /AP Photo/Markus Schreiber
What's Poland saying?
Poland ambassador to Nigeria Joanna Tarnawska dismissed the claim of unfair treatment of African citizens at the border, telling local media that "everybody receives equal treatment," and she had reports that "some Nigerian nationals have crossed the border into Poland."
She added that African citizens were being allowed entry even with invalid passports and that they are allowed to remain in the country for 15 days.
But even the African students who made it across the Polish borders say that they were made to wait while priority was given to Ukrainian women and children.
The Nigerian embassy in Bucharest, Romania, said it had received 130 Nigerians from Ukraine, with more being processed having reached Warsaw or Budapest.
The Polish government has condemned the reports as "fake news."
Last edited:
