What's new

Afghans push India for more arms, despite Pakistan's wary eye

Dawood Ibrahim

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 25, 2016
Messages
3,475
Reaction score
3
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
ISLAMABAD: India is set to deliver more arms to Afghanistan to help it fight Islamist militants, Kabul's envoy to New Delhi said, even if Pakistan is wary of closer military cooperation between countries lying to its east and west.

India has provided a little over $2 billion in economic assistance to Afghanistan in the last 15 years, but has been more measured in providing weapons in order to avoid a backlash from Pakistan, which sees Afghanistan as its area of influence.

Last December, after years of dragging its feet, New Delhi announced the supply of four attack helicopters in India's first transfer of lethal equipment to the government in Kabul since the hardline Islamist Taliban movement was toppled.

Kabul immediately deployed three of the Russian Mi-25 attack helicopters to go after insurgents, and the fourth will be inducted in the next few weeks.

Shaida Mohammad Abdali, the Afghan ambassador to India, said regional security was deteriorating and Afghan national forces were in dire need of military supplies to tackle the Taliban, Islamic State and other militant groups.

"We are grateful for the four helicopters. But we need more, we need much more. Today we are heading into a situation that is worrisome for everyone in the region including India," he told Reuters in an interview.

On Aug. 29, the head of the Afghan army, General Qadam Shah Shahim, is expected in New Delhi to submit a list of military equipment drawn up in consultation with the U.S. military, Indian defence officials said.

It is not yet clear how much would be paid for and how much would be handed over for free.

The equipment includes more Mi-25s, smaller helicopters used for transporting troops and medical emergencies, and spares for existing Russian-origin aircraft in the Afghan air force fleet.

"The agenda for the army chief's visit is clear. We will be finalising the enhancement of defence ties," Abdali said. India, he added, had told the Afghans that it would do whatever it could to meet the security forces' requirements.

INDIAN LEADER RANKLES PAKISTAN

The fact that much of the proposed equipment originates from Russia need not be a stumbling block to an agreement, the United States has said, despite Western sanctions against Moscow.

Russia and the United States share a common goal in stabilising Afghanistan, and India can act as a go-between to help re-equip Afghan forces which fall well short of the capacity required despite billions of dollars in U.S. spending.

The Afghan government lost control or influence of nearly 5 percent of its territory between January and May, the U.S. government's top watchdog on Afghanistan said in a report, highlighting the challenges its forces are facing.

But the move to increase cooperation with Afghanistan is likely to aggravate fears in Pakistan of being wedged between two hostile neighbours.

Relations with both countries have cooled lately.

Afghanistan says Pakistan must do more to stop militants operating on its territory, while India has blamed Pakistan for unrest in the disputed region of Kashmir.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi turned up the dial a notch by making a rare reference to Pakistan's restive Baluchistan province in a recent speech.

Asked about the prospect of closer military ties between Afghanistan and India, a Pakistan foreign ministry spokesman said the government did not comment on bilateral ties between two countries.

But he warned against attempts to destabilise Pakistan, which, like its arch-rival India, has a nuclear arsenal.

"Our expectation is that India should not be allowed to use Afghan soil to create instability in Pakistan."

According to an Indian defence ministry official, discussions with Kabul included the possibility of increasing the number of Afghan officers being trained in Indian military institutions each year from around 800 now.

U.S. SUPPORT

The United States, which has allocated more than $68 billion to train and equip the Afghan security forces since 2002, has welcomed greater Indian military assistance to fill shortfalls in hardware and personnel.

Earlier this month, the commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, General John Nicholson, held talks with Indian officials to find ways in which New Delhi could help the Afghan air force, which is struggling to maintain ageing Russian aircraft because of sanctions on Moscow.

Nicholson said donor nations had contributed $4.5 billion to Afghanistan, but those funds could not be used to buy Russian aircraft or spare parts because of the restrictions triggered by the conflict in Ukraine.

India is not constrained by such considerations and can export Russian-made equipment it already owns or source hardware and spares from Russia to send on to Afghanistan.

"Any additional aircraft or spare parts that India can provide Afghanistan would be greatly appreciated and welcomed by them to help build and maintain the Afghan Air Force," Nicholson said at the end of his trip.

A Russian diplomat said Moscow supported efforts to strengthen Afghan forces, even if it cannot directly equip it.

"Our policy is simple; we would not like to be involved directly, but we would support any initiative that strengthens the ability of the Afghan authorities to fight against terrorist groups and stabilize the situation in the country," the diplomat said.
 
.
ISLAMABAD: India is set to deliver more arms to Afghanistan to help it fight Islamist militants, Kabul's envoy to New Delhi said, even if Pakistan is wary of closer military cooperation between countries lying to its east and west.

India has provided a little over $2 billion in economic assistance to Afghanistan in the last 15 years, but has been more measured in providing weapons in order to avoid a backlash from Pakistan, which sees Afghanistan as its area of influence.

Last December, after years of dragging its feet, New Delhi announced the supply of four attack helicopters in India's first transfer of lethal equipment to the government in Kabul since the hardline Islamist Taliban movement was toppled.

Kabul immediately deployed three of the Russian Mi-25 attack helicopters to go after insurgents, and the fourth will be inducted in the next few weeks.

Shaida Mohammad Abdali, the Afghan ambassador to India, said regional security was deteriorating and Afghan national forces were in dire need of military supplies to tackle the Taliban, Islamic State and other militant groups.

"We are grateful for the four helicopters. But we need more, we need much more. Today we are heading into a situation that is worrisome for everyone in the region including India," he told Reuters in an interview.

On Aug. 29, the head of the Afghan army, General Qadam Shah Shahim, is expected in New Delhi to submit a list of military equipment drawn up in consultation with the U.S. military, Indian defence officials said.

It is not yet clear how much would be paid for and how much would be handed over for free.

The equipment includes more Mi-25s, smaller helicopters used for transporting troops and medical emergencies, and spares for existing Russian-origin aircraft in the Afghan air force fleet.

"The agenda for the army chief's visit is clear. We will be finalising the enhancement of defence ties," Abdali said. India, he added, had told the Afghans that it would do whatever it could to meet the security forces' requirements.

INDIAN LEADER RANKLES PAKISTAN

The fact that much of the proposed equipment originates from Russia need not be a stumbling block to an agreement, the United States has said, despite Western sanctions against Moscow.

Russia and the United States share a common goal in stabilising Afghanistan, and India can act as a go-between to help re-equip Afghan forces which fall well short of the capacity required despite billions of dollars in U.S. spending.

The Afghan government lost control or influence of nearly 5 percent of its territory between January and May, the U.S. government's top watchdog on Afghanistan said in a report, highlighting the challenges its forces are facing.

But the move to increase cooperation with Afghanistan is likely to aggravate fears in Pakistan of being wedged between two hostile neighbours.

Relations with both countries have cooled lately.

Afghanistan says Pakistan must do more to stop militants operating on its territory, while India has blamed Pakistan for unrest in the disputed region of Kashmir.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi turned up the dial a notch by making a rare reference to Pakistan's restive Baluchistan province in a recent speech.

Asked about the prospect of closer military ties between Afghanistan and India, a Pakistan foreign ministry spokesman said the government did not comment on bilateral ties between two countries.

But he warned against attempts to destabilise Pakistan, which, like its arch-rival India, has a nuclear arsenal.

"Our expectation is that India should not be allowed to use Afghan soil to create instability in Pakistan."

According to an Indian defence ministry official, discussions with Kabul included the possibility of increasing the number of Afghan officers being trained in Indian military institutions each year from around 800 now.

U.S. SUPPORT

The United States, which has allocated more than $68 billion to train and equip the Afghan security forces since 2002, has welcomed greater Indian military assistance to fill shortfalls in hardware and personnel.

Earlier this month, the commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, General John Nicholson, held talks with Indian officials to find ways in which New Delhi could help the Afghan air force, which is struggling to maintain ageing Russian aircraft because of sanctions on Moscow.

Nicholson said donor nations had contributed $4.5 billion to Afghanistan, but those funds could not be used to buy Russian aircraft or spare parts because of the restrictions triggered by the conflict in Ukraine.

India is not constrained by such considerations and can export Russian-made equipment it already owns or source hardware and spares from Russia to send on to Afghanistan.

"Any additional aircraft or spare parts that India can provide Afghanistan would be greatly appreciated and welcomed by them to help build and maintain the Afghan Air Force," Nicholson said at the end of his trip.

A Russian diplomat said Moscow supported efforts to strengthen Afghan forces, even if it cannot directly equip it.

"Our policy is simple; we would not like to be involved directly, but we would support any initiative that strengthens the ability of the Afghan authorities to fight against terrorist groups and stabilize the situation in the country," the diplomat said.
India equip one city govt of Afghanistan against terrorist,but never help to her ally country Syria against ISIS,although she provide weapons to ISIS.
 
. .
A good chunk of the arms provided will probably end up in the hands of insurgents, which is an unfortunate reality.

more war won't result in less war, and Afghanistan's and a certain other State's constant sabotage of peace talks has only resulted in more ruin. Afghanistan's history has proven that the only way to win, is to talk.

As well intentioned as Ghani was, he could never actually stop the extreme elements within his government and army from stopping peace talks. Now with Karzai actively undermining him, Ghani's days as president are now numbered.
 
. .
India is set to deliver more arms to Afghanistan to help it fight Islamist militants

Only to land in the hands of same very guys they were intended to be used against. On the contrary I dont get one thing and that is how wud these arms help ANA even a bit when much much more sophisticated weapons supplied by NATO could not turn the tide against talis? See here the famous phrase "Men behind Machine" comes into play.
 
.
About time Pakistan needs to officially recognize the Afghan Taliban as stake holders in Afghanistan and allow them to form their shadow government in Pakistan. Allow them to open their embassy in Pakistan just like they have in Qatar. And if a request for material support comes from Afghan Taliban including weapons, they should be provided as well. Lets not kid ourselves, there is nothing like Afghan government, its the factions supported by forigen powers to do their bidding. So what is stopping us to do the same?
 
.
About time Pakistan needs to officially recognize the Afghan Taliban as stake holders in Afghanistan and allow them to form their shadow government in Pakistan. Allow them to open their embassy in Pakistan just like they have in Qatar. And if a request for material support comes from Afghan Taliban including weapons, they should be provided as well. Lets not kid ourselves, there is nothing like Afghan government, its the factions supported by forigen powers to do their bidding. So what is stopping us to do the same?

You have my vote.
 
.
About time Pakistan needs to officially recognize the Afghan Taliban as stake holders in Afghanistan and allow them to form their shadow government in Pakistan. Allow them to open their embassy in Pakistan just like they have in Qatar. And if a request for material support comes from Afghan Taliban including weapons, they should be provided as well. Lets not kid ourselves, there is nothing like Afghan government, its the factions supported by forigen powers to do their bidding. So what is stopping us to do the same?
Yes , but there is something called NATO and US forces .Pakistan has guts to stand in front of them ?Be realistic
 
.
About time Pakistan needs to officially recognize the Afghan Taliban as stake holders in Afghanistan and allow them to form their shadow government in Pakistan. Allow them to open their embassy in Pakistan just like they have in Qatar. And if a request for material support comes from Afghan Taliban including weapons, they should be provided as well. Lets not kid ourselves, there is nothing like Afghan government, its the factions supported by forigen powers to do their bidding. So what is stopping us to do the same?
u can also officially recognize .. Pakistani taliban !

If only arms could have solved all the world problems
so why Zarb-e-Azab ?
 
.
Yes , but there is something called NATO and US forces .Pakistan has guts to stand in front of them ?Be realistic

We cannot stay idle and watch our enemy nations providing full support and arms to their proxies in Afghanistan. As for NATO and US, they couldnt do a jack militarily against us when they were at their peak in Afghanistan, so now the most you will hear is some random American congressmen having verbal diarrhea against Pakistan and thats about it.

u can also officially recognize .. Pakistani taliban !

Rather Khalistanis, Naxalites/Maoists would be better idea.
 
.
Arming is not enough and neither is just doling out billions of dollars like the Americans have done.

India should help Afghanistan's defence establishment at the ground level, i.e.
help train troops and military officers,
teach them efficient resource and troop management,
set up military training facilities and other infrastructure,
get them future ready with special tactics, future weapons and high tech support systems,
continuous war exercises,
regular training with India's specialised and special forces,
and of course project soft power and help them stabilise their economy, among other things.

As they say teach a man to fish and so on..........
 
.
We cannot stay idle and watch our enemy nations providing full support and arms to their proxies in Afghanistan. As for NATO and US, they couldnt do a jack militarily against us when they were at their peak in Afghanistan, so now the most you will hear is some random American congressmen having verbal diarrhea against Pakistan and thats about it.



Rather Khalistanis, Naxalites/Maoists would be better idea.
khalistan is dead .. naxalites are something u wont understand !! all their struggle is based on their facade of fighting on behalf of poor oppressed people .
 
. .
khalistan is dead .. naxalites are something u wont understand !! all their struggle is based on their facade of fighting on behalf of poor oppressed people .

And you thought Kashmir was dead as well after nearly decade of lull.

Proxy wars are very dangerous my friend, specially to those who live in glass houses. It seems this is something which has gone amiss on the likes of Modi and Ajeet Doval.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom