Afghanistan sends first cargo to India via Chabahar Port today

[KRAIT]

Slow but steady increase.

 

[Glockaholic]

Good for both India and Afghanistan we don't give a shit

 

[BATMAN]

Afghanistan is puppy state of India, Iran and US.... so there's more chance that US and Indians in Afghanistan are shipping prohibited arms and explosives to India via Chabahr, otherwise Indian shipments to Afghanistan goes through Pakistan, which are heavily subsidized by state of Pakistan in shape of international loans which Pakistan take to build roads in order to facilitate smooth transit for Indian goods.

 

[AsifIjaz]

Problem is Afghanistan is putting large duties on Pakistani products even though its population is dying of hunger

Problem for them.... let them charge bro. As long as they don't trickle back here... i don't care if there is even a famine there.
These people do not understand the easy way. It would take a few years beating, back stabbing and manipulation for them to understand that their government and leaders were playing the tune ordered by india and the northern alliance.

 

[xyxmt]

The earlier news was India sending it to Afghanistan. Now it is Afghanistan sending it to India.

so it took 3 months between two transactions

 

[ADIL SHERDIL]

Good for both of them. Afghans and India can do whatever they want but we should remember in future what afghan are really made up of. Afghanistan situation is gonna destabilise in near future with American gone and power struggle and Taliban wanting a piece of the action but unfortunately the real victims are gonna be the people not the ruling elite who obviously will run to another country with the money looted from the people. Going away from the point. My point is we should keep in mind that we won't tolerate another influx of afghan refugees.
Let India take in few refugees this time and let the love spread between them.

 

[ziaulislam]

Problem for them.... let them charge bro. As long as they don't trickle back here... i don't care if there is even a famine there.
These people do not understand the easy way. It would take a few years beating, back stabbing and manipulation for them to understand that their government and leaders were playing the tune ordered by india and the northern alliance.

People think its black and White nothing is..

There at least some minority resentment among pushtoons of Pakistan too because of what PPPP and PMLN did and how rest of Pakistani ignored there pleas..
1. In 1990s food was closed at Punjab border by PMLN govt causing acute shortage ..even rich people had nothing to eat
2. FoR 10 years usa bombed FATA but people of Pakistan behaved like it was Afghanistan ..

If under above there is no resentment than pushtoons are not humans..but they are..

This resentment is than morphed into propoganda for some Afghans against Pakistan by india...

But the fault lines were created by our own peoples ...

Even today PMLN jokes on pushtoons being released from jails..this will not help bridge the gap

And dont tell me that PMLN has no following they got 1 crore legitimate votes

India is 10x better than us at Addresing their fault lines..media govt and politicians are one..they don't have for sale NGO polticans and media people

 

[AsifIjaz]

Its not about pmln or pti..
Its about afghans generally.. They were housed in our land and now feed of it but instead of a symbiotic relationship they have become parasitic.. Are like leeches..
They feed on us.. But curse us, bad mouth us or plan against our interest by siding with enemies..
All afghans are not bad but since most of them are unfortunately poort and illiterate hence easy target to be mislead or brainwashed. Its their problem as long has they been served by our country and long has they used our whatever meager health and education facilities that at e out there. I say enough of it. They are brothers in faith but are from across the border. They are welcome to pakistan if they come legally and pay for their stay and the facilities here.

 

[Rusty]

Limited trade is fine, tomatoes are not going to make much difference in the big picture.
Soon Taliban will be in the power structure and we still have the afghan population bomb.

End of the day, Afghanistan can't say boo without our permission.

 

[ziaulislam]

Its not about pmln or pti..
Its about afghans generally.. They were housed in our land and now feed of it but instead of a symbiotic relationship they have become parasitic.. Are like leeches..
They feed on us.. But curse us, bad mouth us or plan against our interest by siding with enemies..
All afghans are not bad but since most of them are unfortunately poort and illiterate hence easy target to be mislead or brainwashed. Its their problem as long has they been served by our country and long has they used our whatever meager health and education facilities that at e out there. I say enough of it. They are brothers in faith but are from across the border. They are welcome to pakistan if they come legally and pay for their stay and the facilities here.

Whats the narrative of afghans...?
Pushtoon are killed by punjabis...

What happened in 2006-2018..
someone from outside killed pushtoons and nobody cared(majority of voters aka punjab and sindh)..
Response was even though PTI performance was ordinary it got reelected while PMLN lost almost all of its seats in KPK

Its not rocket science

 

[AsifIjaz]

Whats the narrative of afghans...?
Pushtoon are killed by punjabis...

What happened in 2006-2018..
someone from outside killed pushtoons and nobody cared(majority of voters aka punjab and sindh)..
Response was even though PTI performance was ordinary it got reelected while PMLN lost almost all of its seats in KPK

Its not rocket science

This will happen. The issue has many dimensions i.e. from unlawful killing to fencing of the border to also sending the afghans back home esp the ones caught without documentation. Lets not also forget the fact that Nadra was more active in 2018 finding fake pakistanis.
Moreover there was a reason Afghanistan wanted to give the dead body of the martyred SP to PTM guys. Same way there is a reason afghans government officials follow them. Army has played well so far as we honestly don't know how many pakistanis are afghans, how many pakistanis have relatives in afghanistan and thus they still carry a soft corner or carry their narrative and we should avoid to antagonize any particular tribe at this point in time. Once the fencing is complete or phase 2 of it is in full swing along with the better roads in the area, the better business opportunities in FATA due to improvement in law and order situation along with integration of FATA in KPK then we will see the true picture. Lets wait for max 2 to 3 years for the above to start bearing fruits.

Regarding what afghans feel, well we shouldnt give a rats a** what they think. They need to be shown their true worth and that is exactly what is happening. They are afghans who are welcome in Pakistan but till the time they abide by our laws. Regarding pashtuns of Pakistan, well army is doing a tough job, they are at it and local population is more in favour of Army due to less to no oppression and no "jagga tax" on them. Its a tough and mind boggling job and army is playing well. Lets pray they continue to do so.

 

[ziaulislam]

This will happen. The issue has many dimensions i.e. from unlawful killing to fencing of the border to also sending the afghans back home esp the ones caught without documentation. Lets not also forget the fact that Nadra was more active in 2018 finding fake pakistanis.
Moreover there was a reason Afghanistan wanted to give the dead body of the martyred SP to PTM guys. Same way there is a reason afghans government officials follow them. Army has played well so far as we honestly don't know how many pakistanis are afghans, how many pakistanis have relatives in afghanistan and thus they still carry a soft corner or carry their narrative and we should avoid to antagonize any particular tribe at this point in time. Once the fencing is complete or phase 2 of it is in full swing along with the better roads in the area, the better business opportunities in FATA due to improvement in law and order situation along with integration of FATA in KPK then we will see the true picture. Lets wait for max 2 to 3 years for the above to start bearing fruits.

Regarding what afghans feel, well we shouldnt give a rats a** what they think. They need to be shown their true worth and that is exactly what is happening. They are afghans who are welcome in Pakistan but till the time they abide by our laws. Regarding pashtuns of Pakistan, well army is doing a tough job, they are at it and local population is more in favour of Army due to less to no oppression and no "jagga tax" on them. Its a tough and mind boggling job and army is playing well. Lets pray they continue to do so.

I am just explaining you whats happening ...
Fencing the boarder is going ro help but remeber 3000+ people died in dornes and similar amount in colateral and more by militants simply because the elected govt was sleeping for a decade

Afghans tool for propaganda will not be peoples sent back but PTM which has it valid reasons

 

[Arsalan 345]

good but this is only for limited time for india because there will be no more trade in near future.