What's new

A partial list of Indian claims later proved to be false

Status
Not open for further replies.

Saleem

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
1
The following letter in the nation lists four incidents where Pakistan was initially accused of complicity but later this proved inaccurate (perhaps others can add more; might it be possible to make a stick of a similar thread):

One must remind Mr Gates of four major incidents of terror for which Pakistan was initially blamed but the later investigations revealed that forces within India itself were to be blamed for these attacks. (1) After the September 29, 2008 synchronized bomb attacks in Malegaon (Maharashtra) and Madosa (Gujarat), that killed 5 and injured 80, the blame was put on ISI. Later when 11 people were arrested, including a Hindu Sadhu named Dayanand Pandey and another Sadhu Pragya Singh Thakur. The interrogations revealed that they were doing these acts of terror at the express instructions of a retired Major of the Indian Army, Samir Kulkarni and Lieutenant Colonel Srikant Prohit of India’s Military Intelligence. Further investigations established that RSS, VHP, World Hindu Council, BJP, Abhinav Bharat were behind this entire racket.
(2) Colonel Srikant Prohit was also involved in the February 17, 2007 ‘Samjhota Express bombing’ in which 68, mostly Pakistanis, were killed and 200 injured. Initially the blame was put on ISI but the Malegaon-Madosa bombings inquiry exposed the Prohit-led racket and turned the tide. (3) In April 2006, the Nanded explosion killed two Shiv Sena activists, the blame of which was put on Pakistan again but investigations provided evidence of extensive involvement of retired Indian military and Intelligence Bureau personnel. (4) Similarly in December 13, 2001 attack on Indian Parliament case, the Indian Supreme Court, in its August 3, 2004 pronouncement, set aside the charges of Pakistan’s involvement. Mr. Robert Gates should know that if any such attack does, indeed, take place again, India itself would be the most likely culprit because raising the bogey of terrorism against Pakistan has paid rich diplomatic dividends to India. -F. Z. KHAN, Islamabad, January 21.

A riposte to US threat | Pakistan | News | Newspaper | Daily | English | Online
 
This article also does not present a accuarate analysis. It is more to paint India in a bad colour rather than any though provoking idea. Few points are:

(1) Col. Purohit was not found guilty in Samjhota blast.
(2) Please do some research about parliament attack.

However I agree we have our share of idiots as well. Lack of education has a factor behind it. Fortunately there is a rising acknowledgement of this and govt has started taking all actions against any time of evil activities. :)
 
Agree with you friend but who investigated all this.

It was the Indian investigating agencies who got to the bottom of the issue and so today all Pakistan proudly quote at the drop of the hat. Learn to appreciate the fact that we have a transparent system which doesn’t discriminate and the law of the land will nail the guilty. As we don't run terror as a state policy we have nothing to hide or fear. The guilty will be punished in the due course.

On the other side you guys are still debating Kasab is a Pakistani or not and LET is a charitable organization or a terrorist organization in any case you are sure it is a strategic asset.

Before pointing out the spec in others eyes remove the log in yours.
 
Agree with you friend but who investigated all this.

It was the Indian investigating agencies who got to the bottom of the issue and so today all Pakistan proudly quote at the drop of the hat. Learn to appreciate the fact that we have a transparent system which doesn’t discriminate and the law of the land will nail the guilty. As we don't run terror as a state policy we have nothing to hide or fear. The guilty will be punished in the due course.

On the other side you guys are still debating Kasab is a Pakistani or not and LET is a charitable organization or a terrorist organization in any case you are sure it is a strategic asset.

Before pointing out the spec in others eyes remove the log in yours.

-Attack happens in india
-5 minutes later everything is blamed on pakistan and ISI
-An hour latter lame animations are showed how to attack Pakistan.
-Another hour goes by and senseless comments are made by generals.
-After 3 hours, more troops are moved to border.
-Investigations are done after a few days.
-Culprit changes his statements during his trials.

:yahoo::yahoo::yahoo:
 
-Attack happens in india
-5 minutes later everything is blamed on pakistan and ISI
-An hour latter lame animations are showed how to attack Pakistan.
-Another hour goes by and senseless comments are made by generals.
-After 3 hours, more troops are moved to border.
-Investigations are done after a few days.
-Culprit changes his statements during his trials.

:yahoo::yahoo::yahoo:

Buddy I agree this happens....and I don't appreciate it.

But that is how the world operates....now when there is a theft in a locality the police picks up the criminals in the area. Irrespective of the fact that they have done no wrong, for questioning. If the investigations prove otherwise in India they release the criminals and arrest the guilty.

No smoke without fire...right.
Chor ke dhadi me tinka

All this old sayings have a meaning if you understand. So the moral of the story is how you position yourself in this world.

BTW: Where was Kasab from....any idea?
 
The following letter in the nation lists four incidents where Pakistan was initially accused of complicity but later this proved inaccurate (perhaps others can add more; might it be possible to make a stick of a similar thread):

One must remind Mr Gates of four major incidents of terror for which Pakistan was initially blamed but the later investigations revealed that forces within India itself were to be blamed for these attacks. (1) After the September 29, 2008 synchronized bomb attacks in Malegaon (Maharashtra) and Madosa (Gujarat), that killed 5 and injured 80, the blame was put on ISI. Later when 11 people were arrested, including a Hindu Sadhu named Dayanand Pandey and another Sadhu Pragya Singh Thakur. The interrogations revealed that they were doing these acts of terror at the express instructions of a retired Major of the Indian Army, Samir Kulkarni and Lieutenant Colonel Srikant Prohit of India’s Military Intelligence. Further investigations established that RSS, VHP, World Hindu Council, BJP, Abhinav Bharat were behind this entire racket.
(2) Colonel Srikant Prohit was also involved in the February 17, 2007 ‘Samjhota Express bombing’ in which 68, mostly Pakistanis, were killed and 200 injured. Initially the blame was put on ISI but the Malegaon-Madosa bombings inquiry exposed the Prohit-led racket and turned the tide. (3) In April 2006, the Nanded explosion killed two Shiv Sena activists, the blame of which was put on Pakistan again but investigations provided evidence of extensive involvement of retired Indian military and Intelligence Bureau personnel. (4) Similarly in December 13, 2001 attack on Indian Parliament case, the Indian Supreme Court, in its August 3, 2004 pronouncement, set aside the charges of Pakistan’s involvement. Mr. Robert Gates should know that if any such attack does, indeed, take place again, India itself would be the most likely culprit because raising the bogey of terrorism against Pakistan has paid rich diplomatic dividends to India. -F. Z. KHAN, Islamabad, January 21.

A riposte to US threat | Pakistan | News | Newspaper | Daily | English | Online

This is all crap and highly prejudice.

The Purohit or Sadhvi (Not sadhu) are only claimed and arrested by police. The investigation and case is pending.

In India or any country govern by law one is innocent till he/she proved guilty beyond all the reasonable doubts.

As you are showing that you are believing what Indian media/police says then you should also believe them about ISI. You can't have different yard sticks.

So wait for the justice it takes time but guilty will be surely punished.
 
Buddy I agree this happens....and I don't appreciate it.

But that is how the world operates....now when there is a theft in a locality the police picks up the criminals in the area. Irrespective of the fact that they have done no wrong, for questioning. If the investigations prove otherwise in India they release the criminals and arrest the guilty.

No smoke without fire...right.
Chor ke dhadi me tinka

All this old sayings have a meaning if you understand. So the moral of the story is how you position yourself in this world.

BTW: Where was Kasab from....any idea?

This is not about a petty criminal we are talking about, so your gunna so start wars based on this ideology??

Osama was from Saudi Arabia did ameruca go attack saudi Arabia??
 
This is all crap and highly prejudice.

The Purohit or Sadhvi (Not sadhu) are only claimed and arrested by police. The investigation and case is pending.

In India or any country govern by law one is innocent till he/she proved guilty beyond all the reasonable doubts.

As you are showing that you are believing what Indian media/police says then you should also believe them about ISI. You can't have different yard sticks.

So wait for the justice it takes time but guilty will be surely punished.

exactly it takes times for investigations to be done, so india should hold its horses and wait for Pakistan to investigate the mumbai attacks.
 
Agree with you friend but who investigated all this.

It was the Indian investigating agencies who got to the bottom of the issue and so today all Pakistan proudly quote at the drop of the hat. Learn to appreciate the fact that we have a transparent system which doesn’t discriminate and the law of the land will nail the guilty. As we don't run terror as a state policy we have nothing to hide or fear. The guilty will be punished in the due course.

On the other side you guys are still debating Kasab is a Pakistani or not and LET is a charitable organization or a terrorist organization in any case you are sure it is a strategic asset.

Before pointing out the spec in others eyes remove the log in yours.

plzz start investigation of mumbai attack in the same fashion, with unbiased nuetral manner and we are sure youll get the clues which you are looking
 
We have done this mistake of blaming the ISI without any investigations, sometime these blames came from officers at lower level. If you see recently GOI has made efforts to educate the people involved not to point any fingers without investigating. In case of 26/11 our police had recorded conversation. I have seen this instant blaming has been reduced in recent past.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom