What's new

5 reasons why Afghanistan blames Pakistan.

Am i not allowed to have my laundry list? :D
It is much much better then a wish list of nuclear submarines, Mistral amphibious assault ship, inter-continental missiles, a 5th generation JF-17, new multi caliber assault rifles and what not that we see on daily basis.

So Amen to you wish brother :)

On a serious note, i will respect India for there sanity in this matter, THE ARE WISE ENOUGH NOT TO DO IT!
 
India will indeed send her Army in Afghanistan but it will be an army of engineers, doctors and para medics.

As of now we have some 300 engineers in Afghanistan. We have some Indians working in their Media industry. We have some Indian chefs too over there!

India used to run two field hospitals in the Northern Alliance controlled areas. Probably area of operation has been augmented.
 
Before operation search light, what was the situation on ground ?
Compare the economic situation of east and west pakistan before the war you will get your answer , what was the representation of east pakistanis in the goverment of pakistan or in the army it was a disaster waiting to happen :close_tema::close_tema::close_tema:
 
As of now we have some 300 engineers in Afghanistan. We have some Indians working in their Media industry. We have some Indian chefs too over there!

India used to run two field hospitals in the Northern Alliance controlled areas. Probably area of operation has been augmented.
So India has already 300 + troops stationed in Afghanistan. I would like the numbers enhanced to 3000+.
 
Haha every single message in this thread, is Pakistanis blaming India for every single issue, without backing it up with concrete information.

They can carry on crying about India, I dont mind :)
 
After 16 December massacre the PAF was on standing orders to be ready if needed to bomb the shit out of TTP bases in Nangarhar and Nuristan. The only reason why it didn't happen is because the meeting between COAS-DGISI-Dr.Ghani resulted in an understanding that if we went in and did it, the consequences would include destabilization of the fragile govt of Asraf Ghani. We didn't want a 'friendlier' govt to be replaced by someone like Karzai.

Ok fine PAF haven't bombed them but what happened to your so called worlds best intelligence agency ISI ? Why cant you super doper ISI go and kill him inside Afghanistan ? Oh wait you guys are very good in killing innocent afghans rather than a actual terrorist
 
Compare the economic situation of east and west pakistan before the war you will get your answer , what was the representation of east pakistanis in the goverment of pakistan or in the army it was a disaster waiting to happen :close_tema::close_tema::close_tema:

Does it give right to awami league to loot, kill and rape biharis and non biharis which caused operation search light ?
 
So India has already 300 + troops stationed in Afghanistan. I would like the numbers enhanced to 3000+.

There is also the security aspect to ponder about.

When India started the project to build a highway connecting Delaram to Zaranj, in the Nimroz province, the NATO flatly denied providing any security for the project. So, it is being guarded by ITBP presently, around 70-150 of them are there.

Anything bigger than this, and we will end up drawing too much attention, and not necessarily in a good way.
 
The main reason why Afghanistan blames Pakistan is Pakistan's use of religion as an instrument of state policy in ways that have been detrimental to Afghanistan over the years. It is quite shocking that a country that was founded on a religious basis can so cynically exploit their own religion for political purposes. I wonder what the Quran has to say about that.

Even those Pakistanis that accept that Pakistan made mistakes in Afghanistan, claim that those mistakes were a by product of supporting the Afghan jihad in the 70's & 80's, spurred on by US interests. Nothing could be more disingenuous.

Pakistan's use of religion as an instrument of state policy began right after independence when the 'defence of Islam' was the chosen means to convince the tribal militias to fight in Kashmir in 47. The use of religion to cause trouble in Afghanistan began soon after, in Daoud Khan's first term as Prime Minister in 53, with the radicalisation of the Nang Pashtuns with the Pakistani 'Islam over tribe' policy to try and counter Daoud's Pashtunistan policy. You have every right to pursue your strategic interests, but why do you keep using religion as the means?

This was followed by the use of the Haqqanis and their associates starting with Daoud's term as President in 1973, again well before the Soviet occupation. The Haqqaniya Network who were more traditionalists than fundamentalists were pushed to radicalise, particularly under Zulfiqar Bhutto, again to counter Daoud (by raising the fear of communism displacing Islam in Afghanistan). The results of that policy are felt even today.

What the Pakistanis did after the Soviet occupation, right up to the Taliban rule and even to the present day, is well known and doesn't require any exposition, except to the most die-hard Pakistani nationalist. You have done more than enough to earn the distrust of the Afghan people, and your effort to earn back their trust needs to last many more years to have an impact. That is, if peace with Afghanistan is really what you desire.
 
GULIBLE BENGALIS FED WITH CRAP shame on you man you are an utter disgrace to your forefathers do i really need to educate you about operation searchlight are you even a bengladeshi

No there still remains the genocidal breed of humans among regular Bangla Speaking people.

'Stranded Pakistanis' living in camps in Bangladesh – in pictures | Global development | The Guardian

SC unhappy over delays in case about Pakistanis stranded in Bangladesh - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
 
India will indeed send her Army in Afghanistan but it will be an army of engineers, doctors and para medics.
lol and what about Army of RAW Specialists to Provide Intelligence to TTP and Train them in Training Centers Constructed in Afghanistan ??
You are being Brotherly and Friendly for a Reason with Afghanistan !
And Your ill negative intentions will Backfire at you !
Mark My Words !
 
Afghanistan being hostile to Pak doesn't look pretty in the long run tbh..


How would we do trade with the Central Asia then? without Afghanistan ?


Its should be a serious matter of concern for Pakistani policy makers right now.
At some point of time we have to be PROVOCATIVE and if that happens then we can eliminate this 6KM worth of leverage as well.

Just look at the map of Badakhshan Province where Wakhan Corridor is located a narrow Strip that Narrowed down to the point of 6 KM only between Pakistan and Tajikistan Borders in Afghanistan in future we have to CHOKE this point to teach them the lesson.
 
5 reasons why Afghanistan blames Pakistan.

13-8-2015
by - Horus

5: There are elements within the Afghan security services like NDS who are more loyal to RAW than to the Afghan state. NDS is packed with Tajik and Uzbeks who are now living without the fat doll outs given to them by American taxpayers, that is where Indians come in to cop the bill. United States has refused to fund NDS after figuring out that it was nothing more than a nexus built to torture uncooperative Pukhtoon detainees who can be called Taliban without any evidence and tortured to an inch of their lives. India therefore has leverage on NDS which they utilize to blame Pakistan for the failures of Afghan state and to keep the pressure on Pakistan from two sides. People like Amarullah Saleh reflect that mindset.

4: Afghanistan's national unity govt in Kabul is built on a fragile ground. The cabinet and the houses of parliament are in the firm control of former northern alliance therefore it is challenging for a leader like Ashraf Ghani to balance the scales without being ousted by his own parliament. Blaming Pakistan keeps the 'house in order'.

3: Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF) which were raised by the Americans, were basically a re branded force packed with anti Pukhtoon Northern Alliance forces who fought for the foreign invasion forces in 2001 and were retrained and equipped by NATO and later ISAF. Now they are losing battle to the Afghan Taliban insurgents in a number of areas. According the the US military command, the ANSF is now losing up to 4000 soldiers a month due to demoralization, drug addiction and going AWOL (Absent With Out Leave). Pointing fingers at Pakistan saves Kabul the trouble to actually scrutinize its own security services.

2: Blaming Pakistan for Afghanistan's troubles makes Afghanistan look like a united country and makes Afghan National Unity Govt much more stronger and united than it really is. This is only ONE issue where even Ghani, Abdullah and Karzai agree. So in other words one anti Pakistan statement is all that is needed to make the ANUG look united and give a false sense of political normality. It also helps curb dissent and pacify those ranks in the military who would forcefully remove a Pukhtoon president who takes a much more reasonable line towards relations with Pakistan.

1: Blaming Pakistan keeps Afghan public sentiment in order. Like it or not, the Afghans have hated Pakistan much more than India has ever hated Pakistan since 1947. Afghans refused to accept Pakistan as a sovereign state, voted against its UN membership in 1948, joined up with KGB to create a violent insurgency in Balochistan in 1970s, fired Scud missiles into Pakistan and tried to create another insurgency in Khyber Pukhtoonkhuwa.

Even today all of the top terrorists Pakistan wants from Mullah Fazlullah who ordered to assassinate Pakistan's nobel peace laureate Mallala Yousafzai and orchestrated the APS massacre of 139 Pakistani children in a Peshawar school to Dr. Allah Nazar, the chief of BLF which carried out the Turbat massacre of 25 Pakistani laborers among other top terrorists are all hiding in Afghanistan with full assistance of NDS and RAW. Balach Marri the head of BLA who ran to Afghanistan after assassinating Akbar Bugti was also killed in Gramshar area in Helmand Afghanistan.

The top financier of TTP Latif-ullah-Mehsood (now in ISI custody) who was snatched by US SEALs from NDS protection in Afghanistan and TTP's spokesperson Shahid ullah Shahid was also killed in a US drone strike in Afghanistan. Therefore it is much easier and quicker to issue anti Pakistani tirade on the media to let Afghans come on the streets, burn some Pakistani flags, chant death to Pakistan, blame all of their troubles on Pakistan and discuss plans on how to expand Afghan territory to the Indus river, than to actually admit the fact that the Afghan state due to its internal fragility and incompetence has failed to protect its own citizens and is instead busy blaming a foreign country which always comes to its aid in order to create a false sense of political unity and control over state affairs. This is an unfortunate juncture where two Muslim states bite up and become a laughing stock to Hindustan.

Top post bro. Hit the nail on its head. The anti-Pakistan elements inside Afghanistan are obviously being sponsored and nurtured by India. It is high time we took things seriously in this regard.

All the more reason to kick out Afghans out of our beloved land and rid it from the Afghan menace.
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom