What's new

2010 Top Ten Anti-Israel Lies

Solomon2

BANNED
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
19,475
Reaction score
-37
Country
United States
Location
United States
SIMON WIESENTHAL CENTER: 2010 TOP TEN ANTI-ISRAEL LIES

LIE #1
Israel was created by European guilt over the Nazi Holocaust. Why should Palestinians pay the price?


Three thousand years before the Holocaust, before there was a Roman Empire, Israel’s kings and prophets walked the streets of Jerusalem. The whole world knows that Isaiah did not speak his prophesies from Portugal, nor Jeremiah his lamentations from France. Revered by its people, Jerusalem is mentioned in the Hebrew Scriptures 600 times - but not once in the Koran. Throughout its 2,000-year exile there was continuous Jewish presence in the Holy Land, with the modern rebirth of Israel beginning in the 1800s. Reclamation of the largely vacant land by pioneering Zionists blossomed into a Jewish majority long before the onset of Nazism.

After the Holocaust, nearly 200,000 Shoah survivors found haven in the Jewish State, created by a two-thirds vote of the UN in 1947. Soon 800,000 Jews fleeing persecution in Arab countries arrived. In ensuing decades, Israel absorbed a million immigrants from the Soviet Union and thousands of Ethiopian Jews. Today, far from being a vestige of European guilt or colonialism, Israel is a diverse, cosmopolitan society, fulfilling the age-old dream of a people’s journey and ‘Return to Zion’- their ancient homeland.

LIE #2
Had Israel withdrawn to its June 1967 borders, peace would have come long ago.


Since 1967, Israel has repeatedly conceded, “land for peace.” Following Egyptian President Sadat’s historic 1977 visit to Jerusalem and the Camp David Peace Accords, Israel withdrew from the vast Sinai Peninsula and has been at peace with Egypt ever since.

In 1995, Jordan signed a peace treaty with Israel but neither the Palestinians nor 21 other Arab states have done so. In 1993, Israel signed the Oslo Accords ceding administrative control of the West Bank to the Palestinian Authority(formerly the PLO). The PA never fulfilled its promise to end propaganda attacks and drop the Palestinian National Charter’s call for Israel’s destruction.

In 2000, Prime Minister Barak offered Yasser Arafat full sovereignty over 97% of the West Bank, a corridor to Gaza, and a capitol in the Arab section of Jerusalem. Arafat said NO. In 2008, PA President Abbas nixed virtually the same offer from Prime Minister Olmert. In 2005, Prime Minister Sharon unilaterally withdrew from Gaza. Taken over by terrorist Hamas, they turned dismantled Jewish communities into launching sites for suicide bombers and 8,000+ rockets into Israel proper. In 2010, Prime Minister Netanyahu renewed offers of unconditional negotiations leading to a Palestinian State, but Palestinians refused, demanding more unilateral Israeli concessions, including a total freeze of all Israeli construction in East Jerusalem and the West Bank.

LIE #3
Israel is the main stumbling block to achieving a Two-State solution.

The Palestinians themselves are the only stumbling block to achieving a Two-State solution. With whom should Israel negotiate? With President Abbas, who, for four years, has been barred by Hamas from visiting 1.5 million constituents in Gaza? With his Palestinian Authority, which continues to glorify terrorists and preaches hate in its educational system and the media? With Hamas, whose Iranianbacked leaders deny the Holocaust and use fanatical Jihadist rhetoric to call for Israel’s destruction?

Today, it is a simple fact that while the State of Israel is prepared to recognize all Arab States, secular or Muslim, these states adamantly refuse to recognize Israel as a Jewish State and demand “the right of return” of five million so-called Palestinian “refugees” – a sure guarantee for Israel’s demise.

LIE#4
Nuclear Israel not Iran is the greatest threat to peace and stability.

Though never acknowledged by Jerusalem, it is generally assumed that Israel has nuclear weapons. But unlike Pakistan, India, and North Korea, Israel never conducted nuclear tests. In 1973, when its very survival was imperiled by the surprise Egyptian-Syrian Yom Kippur attack, many assumed Israel would use nuclear weapons--but it did not. Contrary to public condemnations, many Arab leaders privately express relief that Israeli nuclear deterrence exists. While Israel has never threatened anyone, Tehran’s mullahs daily threaten to “wipe Israel from the map.” The U.S. and Europe can afford to wait to see what the Iranian regime does with its nuclear ambitions. But Israel cannot. She is on the front lines and remembers every day the price the Jewish people paid for not taking Hitler at his word. Israel is not prepared to sacrifice another six million Jews on the altar of the world’s indifference.

LIE #5
Israel is an Apartheid State deserving of International Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaigns.

On both sides of the Atlantic, church groups, academics and unions are leading deceitful and often anti-Semitic boycott campaigns demonizing what they call the Jewish “apartheid” State.

The truth is that unlike apartheid South Africa, Israel is a democratic state. Its 20% Arab minority enjoys all the political, economic and religious rights and freedoms of citizenship, including electing members of their choice to the Knesset (Parliament). Israeli Arabs and Palestinians have standing before Israel’s Supreme Court. In contrast, no Jew may own property in Jordan, no Christian or Jew can visit Islam’s holiest sites in Saudi Arabia.

LIE #6
Plans to build 1,600 more homes in East Jerusalem prove Israel is ‘Judaizing’ the Holy City.


Enemies of Israel, exploit this phony issue. Jerusalem is holy to three great faiths. Its diverse population includes a Jewish majority with Muslim and Christian minorities. Since 1967, for the first time in history, there is full freedom of religion for all faiths in Jerusalem. Muslim and Christian religious bodies administer their own holy sites. Indeed, the Waqf is allowed to control Jerusalem’s Temple Mount, even though it rests on Solomon’s temple and is holy to BOTH Jews and Muslims.

Meanwhile, Jerusalem’s municipality must meet the needs of a growing modern city. The unfortunately-timed announcement during U.S. Vice President Biden’s visit of 1600 new apartments in Ramat Shlomo, was not about Arab neighborhoods in East Jerusalem, but for a long established, heavily populated Jewish neighborhood in Northern Jerusalem, where 250,000 Jews live (about the same population as Newark, N.J.) -- an area that will never be relinquished by Israel.

LIE #7
Israeli policies endanger U.S. troops in Afghanistan and Iraq.


The charge that Israel endangers U.S. troops in Iraq or the ****** region is an update of the old “stab in the back” lie that Jews always betray their own friends, and the libel spouted by Henry Ford and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion that “Jews are the father of all wars.”

U.S. General Petraeus has stated he considers Israel a great strategic asset for the U.S. and that his earlier remarks linking the safety of U.S. troops in the region to an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal (which 2/3 of Israelis want) were taken out of context. A resolution of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict would benefit everyone, including the U.S. But an imposed return to what Abba Eban called “1967 Auschwitz borders” would endanger Israel’s survival and ultimately be disastrous for American interests and credibility in the world.

LIE #8
Israeli policies are the cause of worldwide anti-Semitism.


From the Inquisition to the pogroms, to the 6,000,000 Jews murdered by the Nazis, history proves that Jew-hatred existed on a global scale before the creation of the State of Israel. In 2010, it would still exist even if Israel had never been created. For example, one poll indicates 40% of Europeans blame the recent global economic crisis on “Jews having too much economic power,” a canard that has nothing to do with Israel.

The unsettled Palestinian-Israeli dispute aggravates Muslim-Jewish tensions, but it is not the root cause. During World War II, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, a notorious Jewhater, helped the Nazis organize the 13th SS Division, made up of Muslims. Unfortunately, in addition to respectful references to Jewish patriarchs and prophets, the Koran also contains virulent anti-Semitic stereotypes that are widely invoked by Islamist extremists, including Hezbollah (whose agents blew up the Jewish Community Center in Buenos Aires in 1994), to justify murdering Jews worldwide. The disappearance of Israel would only further embolden violent Jew-haters everywhere.

LIE #9
Israel, not Hamas, is responsible for the “humanitarian catastrophe” in Gaza. Goldstone was right when he charged that Israel was guilty of war crimes against civilians.


The Goldstone Report on Israel’s defensive war against Hamas-controlled Gaza, from which 8,000 rockets were fired after Israel’s unilateral withdrawal in 2005, is a biased product of the UN’s misnamed Human Rights Council. The UNHRC is obsessed with false anti-Israel resolutions. It refuses to address grievous human rights abuses in Iran, North Korea, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Cuba and beyond.

Faced with similar attacks, every UN member-state including the U.S. and Canada would surely have acted more aggressively than the IDF did in Gaza.

Yet, Richard Goldstone, a South African Jewish jurist, signed a document prepared by investigators whose main qualification was rabid anti-Israel bias. He accepted every anonymous libel against the IDF. But he insisted that hearings in Gaza be televised, guaranteeing that fearful Palestinians would never testify about Hamas’ use of civilians as human shields and their hiding of weapons in mosques and hospitals. Harvard Professor Alan Dershowitz denounced Goldstone’s Report as a modern “blood libel” accusing Israeli soldiers of crimes they never committed.

LIE #10
The only hope for peace is a single, bi-national state, eliminating the Jewish State of Israel.


The One-State solution, promoted by academics, is a non-starter because it would eliminate the Jewish homeland. However, the current pressures on Israel are equally dangerous. In effect, the world is demanding that Israel, the size of New Jersey, shrink further by accepting a Three-State solution: a PA state on the West Bank and a Hamas terrorist state controlling 1.5 million Palestinians in Gaza. All this, as Hezbollah, Iran’s proxy in Lebanon, stockpiles 50,000 rockets, threatening northern and central Israel’s main population centers.

In 2010, most Middle East experts believe that the only hope for enduring peace is two states with defined final borders. But too many diplomats, pundits, academics and church leaders ignore the fact that current polls show that while most Israelis favor a Two-State solution, most Palestinians continue to oppose it.
 
. .
I have no skin in this fight but I have to call apologist lies on this. Too bad, I've always admired Simon Wiensenthal.
 
.
copy paste.... stuff.

no reasoning what so ever, would allow foreigners to settel (by force) into an alien land just because, roots of their religon eminate from Palestine..which technically, is holy place for three religons!

By no means this choice of region for the creation of new state is an accident!!!!!
Discussing what is on surface....if Arab neighbour hood is worst place to live than why Jews from all corners of globe are migrating to Israel?

War War and War... Israel's war with Egypt, Syria and Jordan is long over and non of those said states have any agressive designs towards Israel.
Most of Israel's problems eminate from within Palestine and as a direct consequence of his own policies.

BTW... Israel has been declared guilty of war crimes not only by Arabs but also by international organisations.
 
Last edited:
.
LIE#4
Nuclear Israel not Iran is the greatest threat to peace and stability.

Though never acknowledged by Jerusalem, it is generally assumed that Israel has nuclear weapons. But unlike Pakistan, India, and North Korea, Israel never conducted nuclear tests. In 1973, when its very survival was imperiled by the surprise Egyptian-Syrian Yom Kippur attack, many assumed Israel would use nuclear weapons--but it did not. Contrary to public condemnations, many Arab leaders privately express relief that Israeli nuclear deterrence exists. While Israel has never threatened anyone, Tehran’s mullahs daily threaten to “wipe Israel from the map.” The U.S. and Europe can afford to wait to see what the Iranian regime does with its nuclear ambitions. But Israel cannot. She is on the front lines and remembers every day the price the Jewish people paid for not taking Hitler at his word. Israel is not prepared to sacrifice another six million Jews on the altar of the world’s indifference.

arabs actually proposed the solution for non nuclear or nuke free zone of middle east, but the americans denied this progress because israel had the weapons.

btw iarael must have a good piece of land/water to test the nukes. it doesnt have one. also i think israel is bluffing the international community by not testing their nukes because if they do, their case will be weak and they will lose international confidence.

if israel disarms its nukes, iran should follow suit.

this is propaganda article anyway
 
Last edited:
.
you are providing arguments while Lies are judged by proofs which you don't have.
If you are attempting to refute the list you need to be specific, otherwise it is just an empty accusation, yes?

no reasoning what so ever, would allow foreigners to settel (by force) into an alien land just because, roots of their religon eminate from Palestine.
You do seem poorly informed. I recommend reading A Peace to End All Peace: Creating the Modern Middle East 1914-1922..

Israel has been declared guilty of war crimes not only by Arabs but also by international organisations.
Not long ago in D.C. I attended a function in a pro-Israel ambassador's residence. It was surrounded by iron fences and access was controlled be electronic gates. Several Jewish and pro-Israel organizations have similar security - and almost all of it is to protect against terrorism.

Most NGOs are not so fortunate. Anti-Israel lip service is the price they pay for peaceful access to Muslim countries and to lower the risk of militant Muslim terror attacks at home. They won't say so - admitting to such cowardice is an embarrassment - which makes their public anti-Israel or anti-Jewish stance all the more strident.

I note that you, too, do not deny the fundamental truth of the arguments presented in the list above.
 
Last edited:
. .
If you are attempting to refute the list you need to be specific, otherwise it is just an empty accusation, yes?

Come on Solomon , you know what i am talking about don't you.
 
.
Not all of them are correct but your rebuttals make deeply flawed points and some of these lies I have never heard expressed in an acceptable forum.





LIE #1
Israel was created by European guilt over the Nazi Holocaust. Why should Palestinians pay the price?


"Three thousand years before the Holocaust," Correct and not since then until 1950. By your argument there would be Mongol claims on Vienna and Turkish claims on Egypt.

LIE #2
Had Israel withdrawn to its June 1967 borders, peace would have come long ago.

I'll agree there would not have been a peace but to credit Israel a benevolent FP is disingenuous.


LIE #3
Israel is the main stumbling block to achieving a Two-State solution.

I can't credit anything else as Israel has total control and power over Palestinians living in the west bank and Gaza.

With whom should Israel negotiate? With President Abbas, who, for four years, has been barred by Hamas from visiting 1.5 million constituents in Gaza?

Israel's miscalculation. You legitimatized him with the Palestinian people, the moment you unfroze PA's funds and started paying him.



LIE#4
Nuclear Israel not Iran is the greatest threat to peace and stability.

I'll agree with this one. Israel needs a nuclear arsenal more than any other country today. No arguments from me. Nuclear Iran is definitely more destabilizing.


LIE #5
Israel is an Apartheid State deserving of International Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaigns.


Debatable. But even China the current bogey man doesn't have Apaches hovering over Tibet taking out religious leaders. Or settlers who think sniping Tibetan kids from their settlements is funny. Oh yeah isn't there some kind of wall?


LIE #6
Plans to build 1,600 more homes in East Jerusalem prove Israel is ‘Judaizing’ the Holy City.

Numbers and stats may differ but there is a visible settler movement and stuff like this
LIE #7
Israeli policies endanger U.S. troops in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Nah, this is a lie. The Americans pissed off people all on their own. Though their unconditional support for Israel does give their propagandists material to work with.

LIE #8
Israeli policies are the cause of worldwide anti-Semitism.

Agreed too. I don't blame jews or any individual for that matter for the policy of a state. BUT there may be others that don't feel the same way.

LIE #9
Israel, not Hamas, is responsible for the “humanitarian catastrophe” in Gaza. Goldstone was right when he charged that Israel was guilty of war crimes against civilians.

Israel is responsible. You control their movement, the flow of goods in and out, their fincial system. This is responsibility.


LIE #10
The only hope for peace is a single, bi-national state, eliminating the Jewish State of Israel.

BS A single state would still be dominated by a Jewish government. All we are asking you is to play nice with the Palestinians and stop treating them like **** (like you do with Palestinian-Israelis now). It would be a farce to think these two extremes are the only possibilities.


To conclude this is a TWO WAY street. To say that the arab world have no legitimate grievances and is out to harm Israel purely out of racism is dishonest. It is crap like yours that makes resolution in the area harder and harder.

And really are all Israelis saints?


 
Last edited by a moderator:
.

If you are most informed than why can't you answer one simple queistion!

Why is Israel the promised land?

I recomend you read all three religons before suggesting any book.

Any how, there is not much objection to the state of Israel but to their inhuman treatment with Muslims.

As you stated in your first post the reason of Israeli hate towards Muslims is their past war with its neighbors.
which i say is quite opposite.... the war was the result of Israeli hate towards Muslims...
I think you know nothing about holy crusades etc..

Israel's creation, its geography, its provocation ... all have religous roots...
Why do you think Israel had been fighting in every indo Pak war? why do you think Israel transfer all of its advance wepons to india? why do you think Israel consule India on defense matters?
It is all religon... and nothing is accident or matter of chance.
 
.
By your argument there would be Mongol claims on Vienna and Turkish claims on Egypt.
Both Turks and Mongols retain their homelands.
I'll agree there would not have been a peace but to credit Israel a benevolent FP is disingenuous.
By what standard?

I can't credit anything else as Israel has total control and power over Palestinians living in the west bank and Gaza.
Both Arabs and Israelis can agree that this statement is ridiculous.

Israel's miscalculation. You legitimatized him with the Palestinian people, the moment you unfroze PA's funds and started paying him.
A Palestinian Arab leader is only seen by Arabs as legitimate if Israel is paying him money?

...even China the current bogey man doesn't have Apaches hovering over Tibet taking out religious leaders. Or settlers who think sniping Tibetan kids from their settlements -
Disingenuous. Just because the Chinese don't have Apaches doesn't mean they don't have other weapons; the Chinese build their own gunships, and anyway Lhasa is too high for effective helicopter use. The Chinese have media control, large-scale settlement, and soldiery occupying Tibet, and many more soldiers can be deployed to Tibet quickly in the event of large anti-Han riots. If a Han chooses to shoot a Tibetan, why would we hear of it?

Numbers and stats may differ but there is a visible settler movement -
Sure there is. It's a property dispute, and like any other such, settling it is properly a matter of thorough consideration of facts and claims of all the parties involved. Very few Pakistanis can boast of hearing the Israeli side of things.

Israel is responsible. You control their movement, the flow of goods in and out, their fincial system. This is responsibility.
You are not disputing the Goldstone stuff, but the "humanitarian catastrophe" bit. Everyone knows the Israelis allow tens of thousands of tons of supplies in every week. When Hamas first executed their putsch the immediate fear of Arabs was that Israel would declare an unconditional siege of Gaza and starve the populace and leadership into submission. They were very surprised that didn't happen, but pretend otherwise for propaganda purposes.

Doubtless Gaza's economy would return to "normal" if the Hamas leadership sought peace with Israel rather than extermination of its Jewish population. You don't think their sticking with an uncompromising position saddles them with responsibility, do you?

BS A single state would still be dominated by a Jewish government. All we are asking you is to play nice with the Palestinians and stop treating them like **** (like you do with Palestinian-Israelis now)
Israelis know that they can't both let every Arab who wants to settle in Israel do so and keep a democratic Israel intended, as the League of Nations put it, as a Jewish National Home, for the Arab experience of tolerating minorities is very very poor.

To conclude this is a TWO WAY street. To say that the arab world have no legitimate grievances and is out to harm Israel purely out of racism is dishonest.
That's three claims, not one. Don't yo think they way you characterized them is itself dishonest? For the list did not claim the arab world has no legitimate grievances, or pin the blame on racism, or that every Arab was out to harm Israel.

It is crap like yours that makes resolution in the area harder and harder.
Except it's not c--p, it's a list of truths that make clear just how ugly the difficulties are.

And really are all Israelis saints?
We don't insist that every American, Pakistani, Saudi, Japanese, or Indian be a "saint" to accept they have a legitimate right to their own life and national culture. Why make that demand of Israelis? Should I demand that of you?
 
.
Haha! You have fallen for my trap card! THE HOLOCAUST CARD!!!

Well, shi-.
 
.
If you are most informed than why can't you answer one simple queistion! Why is Israel the promised land?
Religious stuff is outside the scope of this forum - you know that, and if you make the effort you can find answers elsewhere.

there is not much objection to the state of Israel but to their inhuman treatment with Muslims.
Do you think that should be #11, or would you include it in the Top Ten?

As you stated in your first post the reason of Israeli hate towards Muslims is their past war with its neighbors.
Don't stick words in my mouth, please. Did you not write what you meant or did you not read what I wrote?

which i say is quite opposite.... the war was the result of Israeli hate towards Muslims...
Have you really been taught this all your life?

I think you know nothing about holy crusades etc..
A red herring. If you insert something into a discussion, you must show its relevance.

Israel's creation, its geography, its provocation all have religous roots...Why do you think....It is all religon and nothing is accident or matter of chance.
By saying "It is all religion" are you not closing the door on any other reason or cause and effect? Are you not closing your own mind? Why should Pakistanis accept this?
 
.
I have a question. How is it fair that a Jew from, say, Argentina has the right to settle in Israel ("Aliyah") while a Palestinian forced out of his home and living in a Jordanian refugee camp does not have the right to return? The Palestinian (or his parents) was born in Israel, grew up in Israel, etc. The Argentine Jew only had descendants who were in Israel 3,000 years ago. So why should the Jew whose family left 3,000 years ago have preference over the Muslim whose family left say 50 years ago?
 
.
Haha! You have fallen for my trap card! THE HOLOCAUST CARD!!!

Well, shi-.

Attacking lies with lies is not a very effective tactics.

How is "Land of Peace" doing in reality, and why was Yitzhak Rabin assassinated?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom