We need historical revisionism. This does not mean I consider Muslim rule as illegitimate like I consider British rule. But we should still be able to condemn the bad that Muslim rulers did.
You are right most of them were hardly Islamic at least on the political level. This disease actually...
Yes they may have had dreams but some of their actions can hardly be described as following in the footsteps of the Seal ﷺ. One is not judged on his dreams but his actions. That is the point.
Call a spade a spade. Condemn the unislamic things they did and praise the good things they did. It...
this still does not change the fact that many Muslim rulers from central asia just came for plunder and loot.
it does not change the fact that many things they did were unislamic. the redeeming factor are those Sufi saints. That is what converted Afghanistan, Pakistan and parts of Bharat into...
Yes but these two are not the only two we have.
Also most Pakistanis are not descended from Mughals. They, more likely, have ancestors from people who were part of the Mughal apparatus just like later on they became part of the British Indian apparatus.
The only difference is that at least...
Condemn the bad they did and praise the good they did. But remember it is part of Pakistan's history whether we like it or not, although I am open to historical revisionism.
Yes but Pakistan may introduce conscription for 'Total War' should that be forced upon her, but what she DOES not have is everything else that goes with that. She will run out of fuel and reserves very quickly and that million man conscript army should it ever arise will just end up rotting in a...
True but Afghanistan has back stabbed Pakistan since Pakistan came into being. So much for showing Muslim brotherly love when Pakistan was just a 'premature infant'.
Do not be fooled by this Muslim brotherhood-the vast majority of it is duplicitous in nature unfortunately.
Or even co-terminous Pakistanis?
I understand why missiles are named after warriors even from central asia and not philosophers or Sufis like Allama Iqbal or Maulana.
Although Pakistanis need to get over the romantic understanding of these central Asian warriors. They did many things: some good...
Whilst there is nothing morally wrong with race mixing one should choose the mix carefully. I am not a biological reductionist and blood is not everything but ask anyone who breeds horses, dogs, cattle etc etc that wily nily mixing has no negative effect on the offspring and you will soon be set...
He does not hate Pakistan or Pakistanis. He just wishes they actually followed Islam authentically. He disagrees with Allama Iqbal's view that the Republican State can be an authentic substitute of Khilafa. He studied in Pakistan under a Pakistani teacher whom he loved dearly. He even worked in...
I meant if he is not Modi of the extremist BJP, then so what? It is the leaders that need to appreciate Pakistan's peace gesture. Common Bharati citizens don't really have much say on policies.