Search results

Just because it was written by a Vietnamese it makes it true? You have no provided one citation from international scholars that recognize your ridiculous claims or even any archaeological artifacts. Stop stealing Chinese history(whether it be Han or minority).

They are already Sinicized they just hate admitting it:cheesy:

You can't even read a simple title,clearly demonstrates how ignorant Vietnamese are.

Again,read the title I'm not going to bother wasting my time with people who can't read Hanzi.

I have shown you Ming and Qing era maps...

Name an international scholar that recognizes Van Lang ruling Southern China,while no one denies the existence of Shang and Zhou. Dai Viet su ky Toan Thu is hardly ancient it is written at least 1,500 year after Van Lang's fall,while Chinese have oracle bones and Spring Autumn/Warring states...

Our history book is what your history books are tenuously based on at least Chinese have archaeology and international recognition while no one believes Van Lang ruled all the way to Dongting lake. PDF Vietnamese steal our inventions,culture,surnames,bureaucracy,heroes and claim our lands no...

Your history book are as useful as the toilet paper I use to wipe my bum. I can write whatever I want does it make it true?

How many times are you going to repeat your lies?

EastSea are you really going to argue that Vietnamese never mixed with Chams:cheesy: I can cherry pick pictures of Cantonese that look "Northern" will that rewrite historical reality that some Cantonese intermarried with Tai Kadai ethnicities?

If anything there are several Y chromosome clusters in China. No they didn't,only the elite of Minyue had descended from Goujian while Nanyue elites were hybrid Yue and Qin Chinese. Minyue/Dongou natives were forced to move in between the Huai and Chang Jiang not the other way around,everyone...

What do Cantonese have to do with Fujianese? They have their own separate Y haplogroup proportions. O M119,O2 M268,O P201 all exist in varying degrees in Northern Chinese populations. Are Vietnamese with O M117 Chinese,O M119 Austronesian or O M7 Miao? How many more lies are you going to...

I'll summarize why your assumption are wrong. 1.Minyue,Dongou natives were moved to the Huai and Chang Jiang. 2.Revised Censuses show that Southern minorities never outnumbered the Han Chinese in any era. 3.Genetic studies show that some Y chromosomes of modern day Fujianese originated from...

EastSea and his delusions,nobody cares what the Vietnamese wrote thousands of years later I already addressed his fabrications.:cheesy:

:cheesy: ever heard of Cai Xin,Wu Zhong etc he wasn't the only one who worked on the project. Furthermore Vietnamese architecture is derived from Chinese ones,as well as your surnames,ancient government,gods,script etc.

Tell me what did China adopt from Vietnam other than supposed firearm innovations?

:cheesy:

My point is later day additions often embellish the original story regardless Shangshu Dazhuan is predated by the Bamboo Annals. Even if Yuechang was located in modern day Vietnam I don't see how it proves the existence of Van Lang.

Our modern day one is compiled by Fu Sheng of the Western Han while Bamboo Annals was found from a grave dating to the Warring States. It doesn't matter if latter day books wrote this or that,the first texts didn't ie Jizi existed as the uncle of the last King of Shang however Jizi being...

Bamboo Annals are older than Shangshu Dazhuan.