Your opinion about Sahiba (Mirza Sahiba)

[Maarkhoor]

You all know about Mirza Sahiba....

Above song poet trying to justify the act of Sahiba on behalf of Sahiba,....

What do you people think about Sahiba's act what given circumstances what best she can do?

Note: This thread is about folk lore a/ real incident happen in around 18 march 1618.....

People who don't know Punjabi or this incident ....please google it.

@lastofthepatriots @fitpOsitive @Mrc @Iltutmish @waz
@MastanKhan @Imran Khan @Mirza Jatt

 

[waz]

You all know about Mirza Sahiba....

Above song poet trying to justify the act of Sahiba on behalf of Sahiba,....

What do you people think about Sahiba's act what given circumstances what best she can do?

Note: This thread is about folk lore a/ real incident happen in around 18 march 1618.....

People who don't know Punjabi or this incident ....please google it.

@lastofthepatriots @fitpOsitive @Mrc @Iltutmish @waz
@MastanKhan @Imran Khan @Mirza Jatt

The thing is she also died, as the result of her actions.
I think it was naivety and innocence on her part.

 

[fitpOsitive]

You all know about Mirza Sahiba....

Above song poet trying to justify the act of Sahiba on behalf of Sahiba,....

What do you people think about Sahiba's act what given circumstances what best she can do?

Note: This thread is about folk lore a/ real incident happen in around 18 march 1618.....

People who don't know Punjabi or this incident ....please google it.

@lastofthepatriots @fitpOsitive @Mrc @Iltutmish @waz
@MastanKhan @Imran Khan @Mirza Jatt

The story name should be Sahiban ty udy veer.
I mean what kind of mentality that was? Nas e challi si tay nas jana si.
Drama zanani.

 

[Kharral]

The story name should be Sahiban ty udy veer.
I mean what kind of mentality that was? Nas e challi si tay nas jana si.
Drama zanani.

Sada Baba ( Mirza ) marvana si Bebe (Sahiba ) ne, marva chadya sao

 

[Maarkhoor]

The story name should be Sahiban ty udy veer.
I mean what kind of mentality that was? Nas e challi si tay nas jana si.
Drama zanani.

Mirza took rest despite Sahiba advise him to continue escape but when she saw her brothers approaching and she knew also Mirza is master in archery and her brother would have no chance to survive she took decision to break Mirza's arrow so that she could beg her brother mercy and marry Mirza but that plans failed....but she took responsibility and took her life also.

The thing is she also died, as the result of her actions.
I think it was naivety and innocence on her part.

She caught in triangle, she love Mirza and she also love her family and don't wants because of her action mother curse her for losing all his sons....
Sh took one decision but proved fatal but she remains faithful with Mirza...she committed suicide when she saw Mirza died.

 

[Maarkhoor]

 

[fitpOsitive]

Mirza took rest despite Sahiba advise him to continue escape but when she saw her brothers approaching and she knew also Mirza is master in archery and her brother would have no chance to survive she took decision to break Mirza's arrow so that she could beg her brother mercy and marry Mirza but that plans failed....but she took responsibility and took her life also.

She caught in triangle, she love Mirza and she also love her family and don't wants because of her action mother curse her for losing all his sons....
Sh took one decision but proved fatal but she remains faithful with Mirza...she committed suicide when she saw Mirza died.

This story was kind of a puzzle. At one side I was angry at Sahiba that she got herself and her lover killed.
On the other side, she saved her brothers.
But two things really went wrong.
1) Why she ran on the first place?
2) When brothers reached, and they saw their alleged behnoi not throwing arrows on them, why they killed them both?

But folk stories are like that. I mean look at Sohni Mahiwal, Sassi Punno, Umer Marvi... Ay zananian dy puthy kam sary....

 

[Maarkhoor]

This story was kind of a puzzle. At one side I was angry at Sahiba that she got herself and her lover killed.
On the other side, she saved her brothers.
But two things really went wrong.
1) Why she ran on the first place?
2) When brothers reached, and they saw their alleged behnoi not throwing arrows on them, why they killed them both?

But folk stories are like that. I mean look at Sohni Mahiwal, Sassi Punno, Umer Marvi... Ay zananian dy puthy kam sary....

As per my best info the story is real......

She run away with him because she wants to live her life with Mirza but when both ambushed she decided may be because her brother love her so much so does she she might be thinking she might convince her brother....first she warn Mirza not to take rest but no avail ...again she finds herself in hot waters she saw brothers approaching.....just imagine her situation.....she made decision but cost her and Mirza's life and till Qayamah many people call her unfaithful but she was faithful not only to Mirza but also faithful to her family.

 

[fitpOsitive]

As per my best info the story is real......

She run away with him because she wants to live her life with Mirza but when both ambushed she decided may be because her brother love her so much so does she she might be thinking she might convince her brother....first she warn Mirza not to take rest but no avail ...again she finds herself in hot waters she saw brothers approaching.....just imagine her situation.....she made decision but cost her and Mirza's life and till Qayamah many people call her unfaithful but she was faithful not only to Mirza but also faithful to her family.

Very much puzzling. I mean it's the difference of perspective. The answer may be yes, the answer may be no.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

As per my best info the story is real......

She run away with him because she wants to live her life with Mirza but when both ambushed she decided may be because her brother love her so much so does she she might be thinking she might convince her brother....first she warn Mirza not to take rest but no avail ...again she finds herself in hot waters she saw brothers approaching.....just imagine her situation.....she made decision but cost her and Mirza's life and till Qayamah many people call her unfaithful but she was faithful not only to Mirza but also faithful to her family.

Good interpretation.

 

[Maarkhoor]

Very much puzzling. I mean it's the difference of perspective. The answer may be yes, the answer may be no.

Just listen this posted song once more...pls

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Just listen this posted song once more...pls

Still the best version my opinion:

 

[fitpOsitive]

Just listen this posted song once more...pls

See this the theme of this story. Never judge a person for his acts. Concentrate more on why he/she did. So clearly here Sahiban is innocent.

 

[fitpOsitive]

@Maarkhoor don't mind my jokes.

 

[Maarkhoor]

@Maarkhoor don't mind my jokes.

no issues but that story hit my heart....see her situation but people call her unfaithful...i just wanted to discuss topic bro....