What's new

Winds of change: Productivity of Lok Sabha climbs to 103%

Brahmos_2

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Feb 19, 2013
Messages
1,412
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
NEW DELHI: Much like in government, the winds of change are blowing in the corridors of Parliament. After a deadlock of nearly three years, there is a flurry of activity on the floor of the House. In the last three weeks, the 16th Lok Sabha recorded a productivity of 103%, in sharp contrast to the 15th Lok Sabha that worked for only 61% of the scheduled time.

The remarkable jump can also be partly explained by the brute majority the NDA government enjoys in the lower House.

It is the first-time lawmakers who are leading the charge. In 2014, participation of first-time MPs in the debate on demand for grants increased by 58% with 158 first-timers speaking on the subject as compared to 100 in 2009.

Analysis by independent body PRS Legislative Research reveals an increase of 41% in participation by new MPs in discussing the railway budget. Interest in the general budget was also high with 26% more participation by legislators in 2014 as opposed to 2009.

In all, participation by first time MPs has gone up by 38.5% as compared to veterans whose participation has increased by 27% between 2009 and 2014.

There are 314 first-time MPs in this Parliament, up from 302 in 2009.

While it is early days yet, there is reason to believe this is not a flash in the pan. Organizations such as PRS and Swaniti that work closely with parliamentarians say they find greater awareness and accountability among legislators.

"Parliament is a forum for debate and discussion. These numbers indicate that MPs are reclaiming the deliberative space of Parliament," said Chakshu Roy, head of outreach at PRS Legislative Research.

"The MPs' increased participation in this session is one indicator of the seriousness with which they are approaching their role as legislators. Their participation in budgetary discussions is a healthy sign of their intent to keep the government accountable to the people," Roy added.

Swaniti CEO Rwitwika Bhattacharya described the transformation among parliamentarians and constituents as "dramatic". "Accountability was most apparent in this past election than ever before. I think that we are now starting to ask, 'What is the MP doing? Have they done anything for us that we can see?' And subsequently these are also the questions we hear from MPs. 'What can I do that you think will impact people? My constituents have told me they need a hospital. Can you assess and tell me how true it is? What have you done for other MPs that you would recommend to be replicated?' These are some of the questions we hear," she said.

Winds of change: Productivity of Lok Sabha climbs to 103% - The Times of India
 
.
NEW DELHI: Much like in government, the winds of change are blowing in the corridors of Parliament. After a deadlock of nearly three years, there is a flurry of activity on the floor of the House. In the last three weeks, the 16th Lok Sabha recorded a productivity of 103%, in sharp contrast to the 15th Lok Sabha that worked for only 61% of the scheduled time.

The remarkable jump can also be partly explained by the brute majority the NDA government enjoys in the lower House.

It is the first-time lawmakers who are leading the charge. In 2014, participation of first-time MPs in the debate on demand for grants increased by 58% with 158 first-timers speaking on the subject as compared to 100 in 2009.

Analysis by independent body PRS Legislative Research reveals an increase of 41% in participation by new MPs in discussing the railway budget. Interest in the general budget was also high with 26% more participation by legislators in 2014 as opposed to 2009.

In all, participation by first time MPs has gone up by 38.5% as compared to veterans whose participation has increased by 27% between 2009 and 2014.

There are 314 first-time MPs in this Parliament, up from 302 in 2009.

While it is early days yet, there is reason to believe this is not a flash in the pan. Organizations such as PRS and Swaniti that work closely with parliamentarians say they find greater awareness and accountability among legislators.

"Parliament is a forum for debate and discussion. These numbers indicate that MPs are reclaiming the deliberative space of Parliament," said Chakshu Roy, head of outreach at PRS Legislative Research.

"The MPs' increased participation in this session is one indicator of the seriousness with which they are approaching their role as legislators. Their participation in budgetary discussions is a healthy sign of their intent to keep the government accountable to the people," Roy added.

Swaniti CEO Rwitwika Bhattacharya described the transformation among parliamentarians and constituents as "dramatic". "Accountability was most apparent in this past election than ever before. I think that we are now starting to ask, 'What is the MP doing? Have they done anything for us that we can see?' And subsequently these are also the questions we hear from MPs. 'What can I do that you think will impact people? My constituents have told me they need a hospital. Can you assess and tell me how true it is? What have you done for other MPs that you would recommend to be replicated?' These are some of the questions we hear," she said.

Winds of change: Productivity of Lok Sabha climbs to 103% - The Times of India

@he-man,@sancho Meine phele hi kaha tha time doh perform jaroor karenge
 
.
4-f-220x162.jpg
 
.
Also heard the buzz in Delhi corridors of influence is that Nitin Gadkari is the man of action. Very resourceful and knowledgeable with an eye for fine details.
 
.
Also heard the buzz in Delhi corridors of influence is that Nitin Gadkari is the man of action. Very resourceful and knowledgeable with an eye for fine details.

First time drones used in riots and this is in Saharanpur.

Enough said!
 
. . .
@levina @Indischer - I'm not sure that I quite understand the barometers of this efficiency measurement - Participation doesn't necessarily equal Productivity ! :unsure:

Some of our Parliamentary sessions are filled with 'participation' - the kind that involves endless debates, accusations, table thumping & diatribes but I'm not sure if I'd consider that as a 'positive' indicator of anything except a bunch of talkative people....well 'talking' ! :undecided:
 
.
@he-man,@sancho Meine phele hi kaha tha time doh perform jaroor karenge

You are just blind Modi Bhakt.

@levina @Indischer - I'm not sure that I quite understand the barometers of this efficiency measurement - Participation doesn't necessarily equal Productivity ! :unsure:

Some of our Parliamentary sessions are filled with 'participation' - the kind that involves endless debates, accusations, table thumping & diatribes but I'm not sure if I'd consider that as a 'positive' indicator of anything except a bunch of talkative people....well 'talking' ! :undecided:

Dadaji, Productivity here means how much of the SCHEDULED time of LS was UTILIZED for business.
 
.
Dadaji, Productivity here means how much of the SCHEDULED time of LS was UTILIZED for business.

How does one measure that ? :unsure:

They could be making small talk with each other during that scheduled time for all anyone knows ! :undecided:
 
.
How does one measure that ? :unsure:

They could be making small talk with each other during that scheduled time for all anyone knows ! :undecided:

:hitwall:

Like 1 hour was scheduled for House, Question hour, debate, etc. Was the same hour utilized for things planned? Everything is LIVE ON NATIONAL CHANNEL - Lok Sabha TV.
 
.
How does one measure that ? :unsure:

They could be making small talk with each other during that scheduled time for all anyone knows ! :undecided:
--
you are partialy rigtt....
participation .. can be passive too....
--
here point is in 2 scenario...
1.participation in number
though its not qualitative one but quantittative...
its sad to see empty benches....
we cant gurantee that participation will tranform them but alteast inform them about other issue in parliament...
there are many who are ignorant aboout other issue tooo..
so welcome change... though purely on quantitaive issue..

2.Productivity...
here is diffrence...
last Lok sabah had one of lowest bills passed.. difuces ,, debate ..
blame both govt and oppotiton..
now things are going faster .. but still i cant commet about quality of debate..

if you want to see real core of indian democracy parliament see this
 
. . .
"I already told you, Give them time Performance is assured"

@Echo_419

I hope you also factor in that they were the main cause that the Lok Sabha was unproductive in the last years, because of numerous of issues created by them, that stopped debates or sessions. But I found it as silly that the Congress did that now too and justified it with BJPs past actions, sadly that's part of Indian politics.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom