What's new

Why Is PPP Leadership Bent On Dividing Sindh?

Patriots

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 19, 2013
Messages
7,200
Reaction score
2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
d81f7cf180a6214d9bbb9efacea03a64.jpg

PPP`s Information Minister Sindh Sharjeel Inam Memon asked to show respect for the leadership of political parties. He also reiterated that the people would not bear division of Sindh at all. He was expressing his reaction on the Altaf Hussain`s response to Bilwal Bhutto`s tweet “Marsoon Marsoon, Sindh Na Daisun”on the demand of new provinces in Pakistan including Sindh. Earlier, Mr. Hussain had advised PPP`s chairman to avoid such remarks by saying, “You are a kid, call your father”.
Bilalwal Bhutto Zardari is presently the chairman of Pakistan People`s party which is the 2ndbiggest party of the country as far as its presence in the parliament is concerned. PPP is also the party whose founder Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto is considered to be the pioneer of 1973`s constitution. Perhaps, this is also the reason why PPP claims to have firm belief on democracy in the country.
But, very unfortunately, the ground reality is quite opposite. Practically, it has failed to keep its own words. It could never hold local body’s elections during its tenure whenever it came in power. Sindh is the biggest example of this where PPP has been ruling since 2008 continuously, but no elections have yet been held for this which is an open violation of Article 140-A of the Constitution.
Further, instead of making devolution of power and authorities to the lower level, PPP has tried to centralize them. Consequently, an Army General`s relatively independent city government system has become completely dependent to the provincial government as far authorities and resulted powers are concerned. In fact, this is the non-democratic attitude of PPP due to which the people of Urban Sindh feel the need of their own independent administrative unit or province.
It is worth-noticing that PPP has been extending its support for Hazara and Siraiki provinces from the beginning. It also submitted a resolution to the National Assembly in the same connection which indicates that it agrees to the need of forming new provinces in the country. However, when it comes to Sindh, PPP leadership takes a complete U-turn by opposing such a need here. The question is, how does a PPP`s own constitutional demand for new provinces in Punjab and KPK, lose all its legality and validity in Sindh? What else should it be called if not a double standard from PPP towards Urban Sindh? The Shajeel Memon`s recent statement and the Bilawal Bhutto`s tweet represent the same hypocrisy.
How awkward it looks that, on one hand, MQM`s representatives give logical arguments with constitutional and legal references in support of new administrative in the country, but, on the other hand, PPP`s top leadership is responds by tweeting, “Marsoon Marsoon, Sindh Na Daisun” in return? Would any of PPP`s legislators especially including Raza Rabbani and Aitezaz Ahsan like to explain which Article, clause or section of the Constitution of Pakistan Bilawal Bhutto Zardai quotes typing “Marsoon Marsoon” as a response to the demand of new provinces in Sindh? If it is not a provoking remarks or an ethnically-motivated threat to the people of Urban Sindh, is “Marsoon Marsoon Sindh Na Desaisun” a new democratic term that BBZ might have derived from the British democratic system during his study period there?
Frankly speaking, PPP`s such an attitude is actually justifying the reasons for a new province in Sindh. It seems if the PPP leadership does not resolve the seriously developing grievances of urban Sindh and keeps adopting the prevailing dictatorial behavior towards it, then it would surely lead to the formal demand of Sindh`s division from the people.

This Is My View:: Why Is PPP Leadership Bent On Dividing Sindh?
 
.
No. PPP, with its rural (and poorer) vote bank would never want to divide Sindh-that would lose Pakistan's biggest cashcow: Karachi.
I think Sindh, along with much else of Pakistan, should be made into smaller administrative units **eventually**. But at this point no point in causing new controversies.
PS. One thing to be noted that Karachi has been relatively peaceful for several months and that's because PMLN acted like a neutral party (because PMLN doesn't have a huge political stake in Karachi yet--unlike ANP, PPP, MQM). At least I appreciate PMLN role in that--it only helps Pakistan and Karaciites.
 
.
Punjab should be divided into 3 units, and Sindh into 2. As much as I despise the MQM, unless Sindh is divided, Karachi will remain every politician's slave hooker who they use as they please. Otherwise, they should just turn Karachi into a Federally Administered Area just like in China where the biggest cities are controlled by the federal govt. Also @Meengla - relatively peaceful? more than 10 people have already died in the past 1 week. yes the karachi operation must be lauded because even if it's not a giant leap of faith it is making gradual baby steps forward. Criminals die literally every die in encounter with the LEAs but that doesn't stop them. extortion and murders still happen on a daily basis.
 
.
@Secur @HRK - Marsoon Marsoon, Sindh Na Daisun ! :angry:

Khabardaaar Sindh key Division key baaat key aap loggon neiii ! :pissed:
 
. . .
Also @Meengla - relatively peaceful? more than 10 people have already died in the past 1 week. yes the karachi operation must be lauded because even if it's not a giant leap of faith it is making gradual baby steps forward. Criminals die literally every die in encounter with the LEAs but that doesn't stop them. extortion and murders still happen on a daily basis.

I think you and I are on the same page on this one, no? There IS improvement in Karachi, however small, it is improvement over where the situation was and that's precisely a neutral party (PMLN) came into picture. We people of Karachi--at least Urdu Speakers--some time live in false idea/paranoia that NS wants to destroy Karachi so that 'industry' shifts north. I don't believe that.
 
. .
I think you and I are on the same page on this one, no? There IS improvement in Karachi, however small, it is improvement over where the situation was and that's precisely a neutral party (PMLN) came into picture. We people of Karachi--at least Urdu Speakers--some time live in false idea/paranoia that NS wants to destroy Karachi so that 'industry' shifts north. I don't believe that.


Not NS but in reality PPP is trying to destroy Karachi ..........
 
. . .
I think you and I are on the same page on this one, no? There IS improvement in Karachi, however small, it is improvement over where the situation was and that's precisely a neutral party (PMLN) came into picture. We people of Karachi--at least Urdu Speakers--some time live in false idea/paranoia that NS wants to destroy Karachi so that 'industry' shifts north. I don't believe that.
1. PPP 2. MQM 3. Illegal Afghanis and ANP - together these 4 are the reasons Karachi has crumbled into pieces. If it wasn't for them, Karachi would've developed into 'the' place to be in South Asia.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom