Why Afghanistan needs to be balkanized?

[Abdul Rehman Majeed]

Why Afghanistan needs to be balkanized?

There are more Balochs and Pushtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Tajiks in Tajikistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Uzbeks in Uzbekistan than in Afghanistan

Afghanistan is a fake country.

 

[Skull and Bones]

Sure, start talking with TTP about the terms and conditions for balkanization.

 

[Rusty2]

During the 50s the Afghan's suggested a union with Pakistan. We rejected it due to how poor and undeveloped they were. Still the best decision we have ever made.

 

[alphapak]

At this rate I am more worried about Pakistan breaking again because they have learnt
nothing from 1971.

 

[Clutch]

At this rate I am more worried about Pakistan breaking again because they have learnt
nothing from 1971.

This seems to be the case. My prediction is that the PDM and establishment will kill Imran Khan which will lead to unprecedented rebellion in the KPK and the Taliban will align themselves with the aggrieved Pathans of Pakistan towards another 1971 dismemberment. Just like role India played in the breakup of East Pakistan... So too would the Afghan Taliban in Pakistan. All loyalty to the state has been destroyed by the establishment for the benefit of the corrupt.

 

[Goritoes]

It needs to be nuked, or less brutal way is to build a giant wall around the whole country and let them live, no one goes in that country and no one take anyone from them.

 

[That Guy]

Why Afghanistan needs to be balkanized?

There are more Balochs and Pushtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Tajiks in Tajikistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Uzbeks in Uzbekistan than in Afghanistan

Afghanistan is a fake country.

What a stupid thread.

I agree that Afghanistan should be broken, but your logic is stupid.

 

[Abdul Rehman Majeed]

What a stupid thread.

I agree that Afghanistan should be broken, but your logic is stupid.

If Turkiye is able to annex parts of Syria why can't Pakistan annex southern Afghanistan which has Pustun majority?

Once we control Southern Afghanistan then Durand line issue will be solved forever.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

If Turkiye is able to annex parts of Syria why can't Pakistan annex southern Afghanistan which has Pustun majority?

Once we control Southern Afghanistan then Durand line issue will be solved forever.

Is Pakistan in position and ready to fight with Taliban?

Think twice then give answer, pls

 

[khansaheeb]

If Turkiye is able to annex parts of Syria why can't Pakistan annex southern Afghanistan which has Pustun majority?

Once we control Southern Afghanistan then Durand line issue will be solved forever.

Erm you haven't dealt with Pathans have you, they are one the dumbest fu(kwits on the Indian Subcontinent as almost every neighbouring country has found out. They have no loyalty to anything except drugs and guns and treat their own women like cattle, sad as it may be. The US , the Russians and Britain before them gave up on them and even with the help of NATO couldn't tame and subdue these savages. Thanks to General Zia the Pathans have brought so much misery to Pakistan as their lawless way of lives hit the streets of major cities leading to no go areas and semi fiefdoms run by drug and trafficking warlords.

 

[Menace2Society]

Afghan Pashtuns need to be marginalized and removed from power.

A multi ethnic govt in Afg is impossible and ethnic cleansing is unrealistic.

Even if Afg is balkanized the pashtuns will control land next to Pakistan border and so nothing will change.

If Pakistan absorbs it then there will be many rebellions and potential for instability which is just not worth it if brute force cannot be used.

 

[That Guy]

If Turkiye is able to annex parts of Syria why can't Pakistan annex southern Afghanistan which has Pustun majority?

Once we control Southern Afghanistan then Durand line issue will be solved forever.

Because Turkey hasn't annexed any part of Syria. Stop making these stupid posts and replies about subjects you know nothing about.

Unless you want a shit ton of jahil loog from Afghanistan to be a part of Pakistan, annexation is out of the question. It does not benefit Pakistanbat all.

 

[INDIAPOSITIVE]

Afghan Pashtuns need to be marginalized and removed from power.

A multi ethnic govt in Afg is impossible and ethnic cleansing is unrealistic.

Even if Afg is balkanized the pashtuns will control land next to Pakistan border and so nothing will change.

If Pakistan absorbs it then there will be many rebellions and potential for instability which is just not worth it if brute cannot be used.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1604541253005152256

 

[Genghis khan1]

Why Afghanistan needs to be balkanized?

There are more Balochs and Pushtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Tajiks in Tajikistan than in Afghanistan

There are more Uzbeks in Uzbekistan than in Afghanistan

Afghanistan is a fake country.

As a matter of fact, Uzbek, Tajik and Hazaras also think on the similar lines and they want same thing. They they see Pashtuns to be the issue.

 

[Genghis khan1]

At this rate I am more worried about Pakistan breaking again because they have learnt
nothing from 1971.

This seems to be the case. My prediction is that the PDM and establishment will kill Imran Khan which will lead to unprecedented rebellion in the KPK and the Taliban will align themselves with the aggrieved Pathans of Pakistan towards another 1971 dismemberment. Just like role India played in the breakup of East Pakistan... So too would the Afghan Taliban in Pakistan. All loyalty to the state has been destroyed by the establishment for the benefit of the corrupt.

Punjabification of army with too many Bajwa’s has turned it into Punjab police. Idiots like Bajwas can’t think beyond their village mentality.

Erm you haven't dealt with Pathans have you, they are one the dumbest fu(kwits on the Indian Subcontinent as almost every neighbouring country has found out. They have no loyalty to anything except drugs and guns and treat their own women like cattle, sad as it may be. The US , the Russians and Britain before them gave up on them and even with the help of NATO couldn't tame and subdue these savages. Thanks to General Zia the Pathans have brought so much misery to Pakistan as their lawless way of lives hit the streets of major cities leading to no go areas and semi fiefdoms run by drug and trafficking warlords.

Education, once you educate them, they do just fine. There’s a hope.

Once we control Southern Afghanistan then Durand line issue will be solved forever.

Librate Kashmir, Afghan problem will resolve on its own. Once Afghans realize Pakistan mean business and has a spine to do what it take. They will calm the F down. Right now they are High on Indian fed, you can do it, 1971 propaganda.