What's new

Was Aurangzeb the most evil ruler India has ever had?

Here is the aurangazeb farman which is prserved in Banaras Hindu University. Farman orders against destruction of temples and harassing brahmins. Its really hard to think that guy who ordered this farman would do injustice against brahmins or Hindus. If there were some incidents that could have some reason

Aurangzeb in Banaras Hindu University | Indian Muslims

Translated copy
5829022903_8e6b67a158.jpg
 
.
Many "great" emperors killed their own blood. I believe Suleiman the Magnificent and Peter the Great can be included in this list.

They generally do that to become king but auranzeb did that through out his life. If you think that it is ok for emperor than I do not have any objection.
 
.
Here is the aurangazeb farman which is prserved in Banaras Hindu University. Farman orders against destruction of temples and harassing brahmins. Its really hard to think that guy who ordered this farman would do injustice against brahmins or Hindus. If there were some incidents that could have some reason

Aurangzeb in Banaras Hindu University | Indian Muslims

Translated copy
5829022903_8e6b67a158.jpg
Aurangzeb should be rehabilitated and his way of life, his edicts should be ideally reimplemented in India. :tup:
I like how well Aurangzeb's courts translated his edicts and firmans into English. We would have been a developed nation by this time had we remained true to our Mughal masters.
 
.
Aurangzeb should be rehabilitated and his way of life, his edicts should be ideally reimplemented in India. :tup:
I like how well Aurangzeb's courts translated his edicts and firmans into English. We would have been a developed nation by this time had we remained true to our Mughal masters.

take this for Tipu:
Sri Sacchidananda Bharati III (1770 - 1814) - Sringeri Sharada Peetham

He is the sea of knowledge that expounds Vedanta’s essence which is Thou art That; His visage beams with wisdom like the Moon; I bow to Sacchidananda Yogi!
Hyder-Ali demonstrated his profound respect for the new Jagadguru by directing his ministers to render all assistance to the Mutt.
Tipu, who succeeded Hyder, was opposed by the Marathas, the Nizam and the British. In the course of the campaigns of the Third Mysore War (1790 – 1792), Parasuram Bhau marched on Bednur. His hosts commanded by a Patwardan foolishly plundered Sringeri. In the letter commiserating the Acharya, Tipu wrote, “People who sin against such a holy place will at no distant date suffer the consequences of their misdeeds. Treachery to the Gurus will lead to all round ruin of the family.” He aided in the restoration of the temple and the re-consecration of the image of Sri Sharada.
On several occasions Tipu sought the blessings of the Acharya. He once wrote that he depended upon three sources of the strength – God’s grace, the Jagadguru’s blessings and the strength of his arms. He requested the Acharya to perform Satachandi and Sahasrachandi japa and homa. In the subsequent letter the Sultan acknowledged the miraculous effects of the Yaga that led to success in his enterprise and how rains poured and the land flourished.
The Acharya decided to go to Poona to seek redress for the spoliation of the Mutt. Tipu invited him to Srirangapatnam before proceeding to Poona. Not having heard from the Acharya for a long time after he reached Poona, Tipu requested in a letter expressing his conviction that wherever a godly personage like Acharya stayed, there was sure to be prosperity. After returning to Sringeri, the Acharya set out on a pilgrimage to Tirupati, and other holy places. While the Acharya was at Kanchi, Tipu requested him to bless his charities to the temples there and work of renovating the temples partly destroyed during his father’s campaigns.
Tipu even desired to make a pilgrimage to Sringeri, but the desire was not fulfilled. Between 1791 and 1798 Tipu wrote twenty-nine letters to the Acharya, and every one of them breathed the high veneration he had for the latter.
It is remarkable that Tipu’s enemies also sought the blessings of the Acharya. Nizam-Ul-Mulk, the founder of the Asaf Jahi dynasty in Hyderabad, evinced very high respect for the Sringeri Guru and issued several special privileges on the Mutt. In 1800 Peshwa Baji Rao II communicated his decision that agrapuja should be paid to the Sringeri Sharada Peetham in all religious assemblies. He further declared himself a disciple of the Mutt. During 1785-86, Basavappa Nayak of Jugali (Anekal taluk), Basavappa Nayak of Santebennur and Chamaraja Wodeyar of Mysore conveyed their respects to the Acharya with presents and grants.
 
. .
He destroyed the kahsi vishwanath temple,thats enough for his grave to be descereted.
 
. . . .
They generally do that to become king but auranzeb did that through out his life. If you think that it is ok for emperor than I do not have any objection.

The worst thing Aurangazeb did was a bloody suppression of the Sikh rebels led by their Guru, but didn't independent India kill far more Sikh in the 80s? Does that mean India is a bigoted Islamist state? No one likes anti-state/monarch activities.
 
.
The worst thing Aurangazeb did was a bloody suppression of the Sikh rebels led by their Guru, but didn't independent India kill far more Sikh in the 80s? Does that mean India is a bigoted Islamist state? No one likes rebellions.
if i have authority for +ve rattings i would give you 10:enjoy:
 
. .
take this for Tipu:
Sri Sacchidananda Bharati III (1770 - 1814) - Sringeri Sharada Peetham

He is the sea of knowledge that expounds Vedanta’s essence which is Thou art That; His visage beams with wisdom like the Moon; I bow to Sacchidananda Yogi!
Hyder-Ali demonstrated his profound respect for the new Jagadguru by directing his ministers to render all assistance to the Mutt.
Tipu, who succeeded Hyder, was opposed by the Marathas, the Nizam and the British. In the course of the campaigns of the Third Mysore War (1790 – 1792), Parasuram Bhau marched on Bednur. His hosts commanded by a Patwardan foolishly plundered Sringeri. In the letter commiserating the Acharya, Tipu wrote, “People who sin against such a holy place will at no distant date suffer the consequences of their misdeeds. Treachery to the Gurus will lead to all round ruin of the family.” He aided in the restoration of the temple and the re-consecration of the image of Sri Sharada.
On several occasions Tipu sought the blessings of the Acharya. He once wrote that he depended upon three sources of the strength – God’s grace, the Jagadguru’s blessings and the strength of his arms. He requested the Acharya to perform Satachandi and Sahasrachandi japa and homa. In the subsequent letter the Sultan acknowledged the miraculous effects of the Yaga that led to success in his enterprise and how rains poured and the land flourished.
The Acharya decided to go to Poona to seek redress for the spoliation of the Mutt. Tipu invited him to Srirangapatnam before proceeding to Poona. Not having heard from the Acharya for a long time after he reached Poona, Tipu requested in a letter expressing his conviction that wherever a godly personage like Acharya stayed, there was sure to be prosperity. After returning to Sringeri, the Acharya set out on a pilgrimage to Tirupati, and other holy places. While the Acharya was at Kanchi, Tipu requested him to bless his charities to the temples there and work of renovating the temples partly destroyed during his father’s campaigns.
Tipu even desired to make a pilgrimage to Sringeri, but the desire was not fulfilled. Between 1791 and 1798 Tipu wrote twenty-nine letters to the Acharya, and every one of them breathed the high veneration he had for the latter.
It is remarkable that Tipu’s enemies also sought the blessings of the Acharya. Nizam-Ul-Mulk, the founder of the Asaf Jahi dynasty in Hyderabad, evinced very high respect for the Sringeri Guru and issued several special privileges on the Mutt. In 1800 Peshwa Baji Rao II communicated his decision that agrapuja should be paid to the Sringeri Sharada Peetham in all religious assemblies. He further declared himself a disciple of the Mutt. During 1785-86, Basavappa Nayak of Jugali (Anekal taluk), Basavappa Nayak of Santebennur and Chamaraja Wodeyar of Mysore conveyed their respects to the Acharya with presents and grants.
Tipu was an enlightened ruler and it is only political Hindutva groups that are trying to muddy the history. It is a fact that he was a great patron of Hindus as well as Muslims. I have never denied his secular convictions.
 
.
Here is the aurangazeb farman which is prserved in Banaras Hindu University. Farman orders against destruction of temples and harassing brahmins. Its really hard to think that guy who ordered this farman would do injustice against brahmins or Hindus. If there were some incidents that could have some reason

Aurangzeb in Banaras Hindu University | Indian Muslims

Translated copy
5829022903_8e6b67a158.jpg

He destroyed three of our holiest temples and built mosques on top.

Even in this apology, he is clearly banning building new temples in the land of us Hindus.

No political reason for that btw, OTOH it can be argued that everything has a political reason.

I dont even know why you have love for that guy, just because he was a ''strict'' kind of muslim, like wahabis today?
 
Last edited:
.
The worst thing Aurangazeb did was a bloody suppression of the Sikh rebels led by their Guru, but didn't independent India kill far more Sikh in the 80s? Does that mean India is a bigoted Islamist state? No one likes anti-state/monarch activities.

The guy responsible for the Sikh massacre of 1984 and the party that he lead are widely despised in India today. So, shouldn't Aurangazeb also be despised? Logic 101.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom