Vlog China | Tahir khan | Kabir Khan Afridi, What city is this?what language do they speak?

[beijingwalker]

Vlog China | Tahir khan | Kabir Khan Afridi, What city is this? and what language do those two guys speak?

 

[Pakistansdefender]

Vlog China | Tahir khan | Kabir Khan Afridi, What city is this? and what language do those two guys speak?

They are speaking urdu.
And they are in some Chinese city. You must know better. They mention shaoson airport

 

[beijingwalker]

They are speaking urdu.
And they are in some Chinese city. You must know better. They mention shaoson airport

I think they look more middle easterners than south Asians, I thought they must be from some middle east nations.

 

[Gangetic]

I think they look more middle easterners than south Asians, I thought they must be from some middle east nations.

They are Pathans.

 

[313ghazi]

Thier surnames are Khan and Afridi, which are typically Pukhtun surnames (although Khan is used across other ethnicities too). The Pukhtun people are lighter skinned typically. Their urdu accents also have a pukhtun accent.

 

[Dubious]

I think they look more middle easterners than south Asians, I thought they must be from some middle east nations.

Pakistan is a diverse country!

You will see people of all skin tones /facial features in Pakistan

 

[tower9]

I think they are obviously Pakistani.

I think they are in Shaoxing.

 

[beijingwalker]

Regarding your minorities, then everyone knows how communist love their minorities.

Yes, we do have preferential treatment for minorities, they didn't even have to comply with China's one child policy in the past.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action_in_China

It's like he completely ignored what you said. Wonder how much he gets paid.

As much as you get paid.

Pakistan is not a homogeneous state. The population goes from blonde and blues eyes to black and curly hair.

Most countries do, especially big continental size countries like Russia, China and India.

 

[Rasengan]

I think they look more middle easterners than south Asians, I thought they must be from some middle east nations.

Pakistan just like China has many different ethnic groups and they all have different skin tone and eye colour.

 

[Dubious]

China has a large ethnic Han population

yes greater than 90% that is basically very homogeneous!

Yes, we do have preferential treatment for minorities, they didn't even have to comply with China's one child policy in the past.

Yes but they cant even pray openly...

What is the "excuse" given to ban prayers?

Most countries do, especially big continental size countries like Russia, China and India.

Actually on the contrary most countries are homogeneous and not that diverse!

China has a 90% han population that is almost all!

Present day Russia is also relatively homogeneous but they have Tartars and slavic people in large numbers!

The Russians share many historical and cultural traits with other European peoples and especially with other East Slavic ethnic groups, specifically Belarusians and Ukrainians. Many ethnic groups had a common history within the former Soviet Union and Russian Empire, which was influential in spreading of Russian culture and language. The Russian language is official in Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan, and also spoken as a secondary language in many former Soviet states.

Ethnic groups

Russian 77.7%, Tatar 3.7%, Ukrainian 1.4%, Bashkir 1.1%, Chuvash 1%, Chechen 1%, Black 0.1% other 10.2%, unspecified 3.9% note: nearly 200 national and/or ethnic groups are represented in Russia's 2010 census (2010 est.)

While india CAN be considered VERY diverse!

For Pakistan MOST people are VERY mixed so you wont find like China where you can say 90% Han! In Pakistan there is no such thing as that large of a population makeup! Even if you find Punjabis (even less than 50%) as the largest group...they themselves are diverse!

Ethnic groups in Pakistan
Punjabi
44.7%

Pashtun (Pathan)
15.4%

Sindhi
14.1%

Saraiki
8.4%

Muhajir
7.6%



Balochi
3.6%

Other
6.3%

Which make up of Seddi:

Kalash:

Kashmiri:

Hazara:

Pakistan just like China has many different ethnic groups and they all have different skin tone and eye colour.

I dont think he can comprehend that...For them to have even 5% non Han is a big deal!

 

[vi-va]

yes greater than 90% that is basically very homogeneous!


Yes but they cant even pray openly...

What is the "excuse" given to ban prayers?


Actually on the contrary most countries are homogeneous and not that diverse!

China has a 90% han population that is almost all!

Present day Russia is also relatively homogeneous but they have Tartars and slavic people in large numbers!

The Russians share many historical and cultural traits with other European peoples and especially with other East Slavic ethnic groups, specifically Belarusians and Ukrainians. Many ethnic groups had a common history within the former Soviet Union and Russian Empire, which was influential in spreading of Russian culture and language. The Russian language is official in Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan, and also spoken as a secondary language in many former Soviet states.

Ethnic groups

Russian 77.7%, Tatar 3.7%, Ukrainian 1.4%, Bashkir 1.1%, Chuvash 1%, Chechen 1%, Black 0.1% other 10.2%, unspecified 3.9% note: nearly 200 national and/or ethnic groups are represented in Russia's 2010 census (2010 est.)

While india CAN be considered VERY diverse!

For Pakistan MOST people are VERY mixed so you wont find like China where you can say 90% Han! In Pakistan there is no such thing as that large of a population makeup! Even if you find Punjabis (even less than 50%) as the largest group...they themselves are diverse!

Ethnic groups in Pakistan
Punjabi
44.7%

Pashtun (Pathan)
15.4%

Sindhi
14.1%

Saraiki
8.4%

Muhajir
7.6%



Balochi
3.6%

Other
6.3%

Which make up of Seddi:

Kalash:

Kashmiri:

Hazara:

I dont think he can comprehend that...For them to have even 5% non Han is a big deal!

Many Pakistan ethnics looks handsome and pretty. Pakistan should support your Hollywood and go to the world stage. The diversity in ethnics and cultures is the fortune for good movies, musics and drama. A prosperous Pakistan has huge potential.

 

[beijingwalker]

Yes but they cant even pray openly...

What is the "excuse" given to ban prayers?

That's a very strange accusation, first, very few minority groups pray, and the numbers of Han Christians and Buddists are hundreds of millions, they are not ethnic minorities. Second, China has countless churches, Buddist templse and mosque sin every city, town and even village where we see people pray all the time, why do you say they can't pray, should I believe my own eyes or you say so?

Ethnic groups in Pakistan
Punjabi
44.7%

Pashtun (Pathan)
15.4%

Sindhi
14.1%

Saraiki
8.4%

Muhajir
7.6%



Balochi
3.6%

Other
6.3%

Which make up of Seddi:

Kalash:

Kashmiri:

Hazara:

I can post more pictures showing China's diversity than you do, but that's not my point, my point is China has over 100 million minorities, the reason why China is usually being consider as a homogeneous nation is because over 90% of her population is Han, that's also true. But those who really traveled in China are still amazed by China's diversity, if you go to Tibet, Xinjiang, some part of inner Mongolia..., each of those regions is bigger in size than Pakistan and you sense that you are not traveling in China.

China is homogeneous, yes, China has great diversity, yes.

 

[beijingwalker]

So these are your minorities ...I am asking about the diversity in the 90% HAN

Many Han people from Guangdong and Guangxi look very south eastern Asian.

We Pakistanis do admit there are SOME problems and on the other thread I did clarify the Asia bibi case which was one of the bigger cases that the West had entangled itself in!

So when will you have the balls to admit there is some wrong in what China is doing?

Right or wrong depends on people's perspetive and position, China did make mistakes like cultural revolution, we admitted, no one is perfect, but in Xinjiang we did the right thing, at least based on the Chinese position, we achieved every postive result we wanted.

 

[Dubious]

Many Han people from Guangdong and Guangxi look very south eastern Asian.

Ok..they still look Chinese!

Right or wrong depends on people's perspetive and position, China did make mistakes like cultural revolution, we admitted, no one is perfect, but in Xinjiang we did the right thing, at least based on the Chinese position, we achieved every postive result we wanted.

So it is positive for a different people to lose their culture and not practice religion?

So in the 21st century you guys are doing what imperial China did few centuries back?

they're culturally similar; because they have been sinicized for a very long time, since the old dynasties of China.

Killing your diversity and then trying to claim you have some is really sad!

 

[beijingwalker]

Ok..they still look Chinese!

Maybe In your eyes, not in East Asians, like we Chinese can never tell the difference between Pakistanis or Indians, you may think all Chinese look the same.