What's new

Vietnam Cracks Down on Growing Wave of Migrant Workers From China

Viet

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
29,950
Reaction score
0
Country
Viet Nam
Location
Germany
Reports
china-technicians-102920.jpg

Hundreds of Chinese technicians gather at the Sino-Vietnamese Friendship Pass in Guangxi hoping to find work in Vietnam, Oct. 20, 2020.


Vietnamese authorities say they are cracking down on a growing number of migrants crossing the border illegally from neighboring China, in an apparent reversal of previous trends.

Police in the border area of Lang Son in northern Vietnam, across the border from the southwestern Chinese Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, recently arrested 20 foreign nationals and three Vietnamese drivers on suspicion of smuggling.

Lt. Col. Nguyen Chang Shan of the No. 2 Highway Checkpoint traffic police said Lang Son police had intercepted a group of "stowaways" at around 1.00 p.m. local time on Oct. 26 hiding in two Toyota off-road vehicles and one Toyota commercial vehicle, traveling down the highway from Quang Ninh in the direction of Haiphong and Hanoi, according to a Vietnamese news account on China's Tencent Weibo social media platform.

"The arrested persons were taken to the Lang Son Public Security Bureau for further investigation by the police," the report said.

Kuo Hai-kuang, a Taiwanese businessman based in Binh Duong province, said there have been a growing number of migrants from China seeking work in Vietnam since the coronavirus pandemic hit the national economy at the start of this year.

"There have been a lot more in recent years, most of them coming down from the north [of Vietnam]," Kuo said. "They cross the border illegally on minor roads and paths."

"They come over from Guangxi, and some from Yunnan province, on the Chinese side."

Kuo said the detainees will likely be held in custody for a time, before being fined and repatriated.

"Vietnamese police don't mess about," he said. "They lock you up, investigate, then they drive you right back where you came from."

Migrants lost factory jobs

The Vietnam Public Security Border Bureau has reported arresting more than 100 stowaways from Guangxi, China, in the area near the Chinese border, according to state media reports.

The migrants had lost jobs in factories in the southern Chinese province of Guangdong, and had been hoping to find work in Vietnam, state media reported.

In one case, border patrols in the northern Vietnamese province of Lao Cai found 76 smuggled migrants from China, while a further 25 Chinese nationals were found by police in Ha Giang province.

On Oct. 20, video footage of around 1,000 Chinese migrant workers gathering near the border checkpoint in Guangxi, readying themselves to seek work in Vietnam, was posted to social media.

While they may struggle to find work in larger, foreign-invested companies, such workers are often quietly taken on by Chinese-invested firms across the border, according to Kuo.

"Most wouldn't dare [to hire them], except for mainland Chinese companies," he said. "But we are talking about small companies, not the larger ones."

A Guangxi-based businessman surnamed Chen told RFA that many are lured by the promise of stronger economic growth and a more liberal form of government in Vietnam than is currently available back home.

"Right now, Vietnam's economic development is like Shenzhen back in the day," Chen said. "It is probably much stronger than the open areas of mainland China."

"That's basically what is behind the movement of labor into Vietnam," he said. "The pay and conditions there are better, especially for skilled workers, so a lot of people are going. A friend of mine went."

China's economy 'deteriorating'

Beijing resident Sun Yuchen said the reversed trend is food for thought for those living under the rule of ruling Chinese Communist Party general secretary Xi Jinping.

"At the very least, illegal migration to Vietnam shows that there aren't that many opportunities in China," Sun said. "It shows that the economy in mainland China is deteriorating."

Reports have also emerged that China is constructing a wall along its border with Vietnam in a bid to stem the outward flow of smuggled migrant workers.

Video footage recently uploaded to social media revealed the construction of a two-meter-high concrete wall in the border regions.

Some social media comments appeared to confirm the content of the video.

"It's not surprising that they are in such a hurry to build a wall along the Sino-Vietnamese border," one Guangxi resident told RFA, adding sarcastically: "It's to prevent [Chinese citizens] from going astray and suffering all that freedom and democracy entails."

Some said the wall would eventually stretch the entire length of the 1,300 land border between the two countries, but RFA was unable to confirm this.

Back in 2015, when Beijing was keen to stem the flow of illegal migrant workers in the opposite direction, from Vietnam into China, official media announced the government would build an eight-kilometer fence in Guangxi to prevent cross-border "smuggling."

The apparent reversal of fortune has led Chinese social media users to quip that while the U.S. built a wall to prevent people from getting in, Beijing needs to build one to stop its own citizens from escaping
 
. .
Lol RFA. Higher pay in Vietnam... But don't you Vietnamese brag about your low labor cost? How can labor cost be low but wages high?
They only get 281 usd per month in CN while they can get 430 USD per month in VN luxshare 😸

-----
There r hundred millions Cnese workers only earn only 281 usd/ month. Ur Govt failed to create good jobs for them. Thats why they desperately trying to enter vn (to work in VN Luxshare wt 430 usd/month) by hiding inside the washing machines :cool:
------
Dongguan Chang An Mattel Toys, one of the world’s largest doll makers, is one of the few factories still actively recruiting. It used the shared worker programme to recruit 250 workers from another factory

 
.
They only get 281 usd per month in CN while they can get 430 USD per month in VN luxshare 😸

-----
There r hundred millions Cnese workers only earn only 281 usd/ month. Ur Govt failed to create good jobs for them. Thats why they desperately trying to enter vn (to work in VN Luxshare wt 430 usd/month) by hiding inside the washing machines :cool:
------
Dongguan Chang An Mattel Toys, one of the world’s largest doll makers, is one of the few factories still actively recruiting. It used the shared worker programme to recruit 250 workers from another factory


Luxshare is a Chinese company. The profits all go to China where they're used to pay engineers, managers and accountants.

Why would Luxshare pay more to hire Chinese workers in Vietnam if they could pay Chinese workers less in China itself?
 
.
Reports
china-technicians-102920.jpg

Hundreds of Chinese technicians gather at the Sino-Vietnamese Friendship Pass in Guangxi hoping to find work in Vietnam, Oct. 20, 2020.


Vietnamese authorities say they are cracking down on a growing number of migrants crossing the border illegally from neighboring China, in an apparent reversal of previous trends.

Police in the border area of Lang Son in northern Vietnam, across the border from the southwestern Chinese Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, recently arrested 20 foreign nationals and three Vietnamese drivers on suspicion of smuggling.

Lt. Col. Nguyen Chang Shan of the No. 2 Highway Checkpoint traffic police said Lang Son police had intercepted a group of "stowaways" at around 1.00 p.m. local time on Oct. 26 hiding in two Toyota off-road vehicles and one Toyota commercial vehicle, traveling down the highway from Quang Ninh in the direction of Haiphong and Hanoi, according to a Vietnamese news account on China's Tencent Weibo social media platform.

"The arrested persons were taken to the Lang Son Public Security Bureau for further investigation by the police," the report said.

Kuo Hai-kuang, a Taiwanese businessman based in Binh Duong province, said there have been a growing number of migrants from China seeking work in Vietnam since the coronavirus pandemic hit the national economy at the start of this year.

"There have been a lot more in recent years, most of them coming down from the north [of Vietnam]," Kuo said. "They cross the border illegally on minor roads and paths."

"They come over from Guangxi, and some from Yunnan province, on the Chinese side."

Kuo said the detainees will likely be held in custody for a time, before being fined and repatriated.

"Vietnamese police don't mess about," he said. "They lock you up, investigate, then they drive you right back where you came from."

Migrants lost factory jobs

The Vietnam Public Security Border Bureau has reported arresting more than 100 stowaways from Guangxi, China, in the area near the Chinese border, according to state media reports.

The migrants had lost jobs in factories in the southern Chinese province of Guangdong, and had been hoping to find work in Vietnam, state media reported.

In one case, border patrols in the northern Vietnamese province of Lao Cai found 76 smuggled migrants from China, while a further 25 Chinese nationals were found by police in Ha Giang province.

On Oct. 20, video footage of around 1,000 Chinese migrant workers gathering near the border checkpoint in Guangxi, readying themselves to seek work in Vietnam, was posted to social media.

While they may struggle to find work in larger, foreign-invested companies, such workers are often quietly taken on by Chinese-invested firms across the border, according to Kuo.

"Most wouldn't dare [to hire them], except for mainland Chinese companies," he said. "But we are talking about small companies, not the larger ones."

A Guangxi-based businessman surnamed Chen told RFA that many are lured by the promise of stronger economic growth and a more liberal form of government in Vietnam than is currently available back home.

"Right now, Vietnam's economic development is like Shenzhen back in the day," Chen said. "It is probably much stronger than the open areas of mainland China."

"That's basically what is behind the movement of labor into Vietnam," he said. "The pay and conditions there are better, especially for skilled workers, so a lot of people are going. A friend of mine went."

China's economy 'deteriorating'

Beijing resident Sun Yuchen said the reversed trend is food for thought for those living under the rule of ruling Chinese Communist Party general secretary Xi Jinping.

"At the very least, illegal migration to Vietnam shows that there aren't that many opportunities in China," Sun said. "It shows that the economy in mainland China is deteriorating."

Reports have also emerged that China is constructing a wall along its border with Vietnam in a bid to stem the outward flow of smuggled migrant workers.

Video footage recently uploaded to social media revealed the construction of a two-meter-high concrete wall in the border regions.

Some social media comments appeared to confirm the content of the video.

"It's not surprising that they are in such a hurry to build a wall along the Sino-Vietnamese border," one Guangxi resident told RFA, adding sarcastically: "It's to prevent [Chinese citizens] from going astray and suffering all that freedom and democracy entails."

Some said the wall would eventually stretch the entire length of the 1,300 land border between the two countries, but RFA was unable to confirm this.

Back in 2015, when Beijing was keen to stem the flow of illegal migrant workers in the opposite direction, from Vietnam into China, official media announced the government would build an eight-kilometer fence in Guangxi to prevent cross-border "smuggling."

The apparent reversal of fortune has led Chinese social media users to quip that while the U.S. built a wall to prevent people from getting in, Beijing needs to build one to stop its own citizens from escaping
RFA? Omg. They are lacking workers in Guangdong now, my cousin just told me, and here you are telling me they wanna earn dongs. I would believe if their old boss asked them to cross over yo help our the factory and doesn't want to apply permits, read that they are technicians, since locals don't have the skill to run the factories, normally mainland bosses will want their old staff to run the technical parts. That's why Viets are low level 200$ assemblers.
Luxshare is a Chinese company. The profits all go to China where they're used to pay engineers, managers and accountants.

Why would Luxshare pay more to hire Chinese workers in Vietnam if they could pay Chinese workers less in China itself?
Exactly, that doesn't make sense. And last I heard Viets get paid 200$, that's the reason they relocate, nowadays the normal Chinese low end worker is paid minimum 500 usd $
 
Last edited:
.
RFA? WTF, but, but,
Damn, vietnamese women are doomed, every one of those poor peasants will bring multiple vn women to China from the jungle caves...
Damn, vietnamese women are doomed, every one of those poor peasants will bring multiple of them to China from the jungle caves...
 
Last edited:
.
Luxshare is a Chinese company. The profits all go to China where they're used to pay engineers, managers and accountants.

Why would Luxshare pay more to hire Chinese workers in Vietnam if they could pay Chinese workers less in China itself?
See, most of Cnese r jobless or just pathetic employee begging bosses to stay in CN to save their Jobs, thats why u guys dont understand why Luxshare pay VN workers 430 USD per month.

Thats your own problem, dude. Ur IQ is too.low to understand even why rich Cnese like Luxshare boss quit Cnese while he/she can pay CN workers less.

CN investors will keep leaving CN even when they can pay CN workers less ( even just 281 usd per month for CN workers while paying 430 usd per month for VN workers) 😸😸
 
.
See, most of Cnese r jobless or just pathetic employee begging bosses to stay in CN to save their Jobs, thats why u guys dont understand why Luxshare pay VN workers 430 USD per month.

Thats your own problem, dude. Ur IQ is too.low to understand even why rich Cnese like Luxshare boss quit Cnese while he/she can pay CN workers less.

CN investors will keep leaving CN even when they can pay CN workers less ( even just 281 usd per month for CN workers while paying 430 usd per month for VN workers) 😸😸

proof that VN workers make 430 USD per month?

VN average wages: $148 per month.
 
.
proof that VN workers make 430 USD per month?

VN average wages: $148 per month.
Same link wt Cnese workers got only 281 USD per month in CN.

----
VN workers assembling Apple products like airpod got the total income is 10,4 millions vnd ( 430 usd) per month .
 
.
Same link wt Cnese workers got only 281 USD per month in CN.

----
VN workers assembling Apple products like airpod got the total income is 10,4 millions vnd ( 430 usd) per month .

you linked yourself. I linked a real statistic. you try to provide proof for your statement by linking another statement made by yourself?
 
.
you linked yourself. I linked a real statistic. you try to provide proof for your statement by linking another statement made by yourself?
I Google trans clearly there and make everyone know that Luxshare pay VN workers 430 usd per month .No one care if a jobless Cnese cant read.

Cnese will keep trying to enter VN illegally due to CN companies like Luxshare, TCL, tire-auto parts factories quit CN to VN :cool:

----
The total income of a worker working 9.3 hours / day for 26 days will be 10.4 million VND ( 448 usd for today exchange)

Luxshare-ICT based in Shenzhen, China, was established in the year 2004
(
Tổng thu nhập của một công nhân làm việc khoảng 9,3 giờ/ngày trong 26 ngày sẽ là 10,4 triệu đồng

Luxshare-ICT có trụ sở tại Thâm Quyến, Trung Quốc, được thành lập vào năm 2004)



 
.
proof that VN workers make 430 USD per month?

VN average wages: $148 per month.
99% of vietnamese do not know what a private car looks like, while ~30 million new cars added to our roads every year, let alone the luxury cars...
So much for vn 430 usd per month salary...lol... 430 usd is really reallly A LOT OF fortune for 100 million dirt poor vietnmense, though...
 
.
A super bragging power in Vietnam with a GDP less than the GDP of a city in China hahahahaha :omghaha: :omghaha: :rofl: :rofl: :guns::guns::china::china:
99% of vietnamese do not know what a private car looks like, while ~30 million new cars added to our roads every year, let alone the luxury cars...
So much for vn 430 usd per month salary...lol... 430 usd is really reallly A LOT OF fortune for 100 million dirt poor vietnmense, though...
China produces and sells more than 25 million cars every year. Large cities in China have long restricted the purchase of gasoline cars. If gasoline cars are not restricted, China's annual car sales would have broken 30 million cars earlier.
 
Last edited:
.
Viet:lower labour cost in VN, CN manufacturing is doomed.
Also Viet:CN labour coming into VN for higher wage, CN is manufacturing is doomed.


Whatever you say, buddy. China is shifting away from 1980s economic model, that's why we revaluate RMB to make sure we lead in Asian bloc ‘flying-geese paradigm’. It's good for both that VN transform into 1980s China role.
 
.
99% of vietnamese do not know what a private car looks like, while ~30 million new cars added to our roads every year, let alone the luxury cars...
So much for vn 430 usd per month salary...lol... 430 usd is really reallly A LOT OF fortune for 100 million dirt poor vietnmense, though...
Okay, but hundreds Cnese trying to enter VN illegally now is real. No use to deny it.
Whatever you say, buddy. China is shifting away from 1980s economic model, that's why we revaluate RMB to make sure we lead in Asian bloc ‘flying-geese paradigm’. It's good for both that VN transform into 1980s China role.
Bad news for u, CN economy is shifting to Nowhere.

Selling 5G ?? Dead outside CN market. Huawei Honor has to sell to another company.

Selling AI cameras ?? Hikvision spy cam got ban, Bkav ( VN AI camera company) took the EU-US market. Hikvision also in big debt due to hard ban.

Luxshare, Samsung, LG, Pegatron ,shoes garment factories, tire-auto part factories also left CN to VN.

No hope on CN manufacturing sector anymore.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom