What's new

Two million, mostly Muslims, face statelessness as India publishes controversial citizenship list

HAIDER

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
33,771
Reaction score
14
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
5d6a1db77681b.jpg


Almost two million people in northeast India were left facing statelessness on Saturday after the state of Assam published a citizenship list aimed at weeding out “foreign infiltrators”, in a process the central government wants to replicate nationwide.

A total of 31.1 million people were included in a National Register of Citizens (NRC), but 1.9 million were deemed ineligible, according to the Assam government. A large chunk of those excluded were expected to be Muslims.

Assam has long seen large influxes from elsewhere, including under British colonial rule and around Bangladesh's 1971 war of independence, when millions fled into India.

For decades this has made Assam a hotbed of inter-religious and ethnic tensions, adding to pressure for a lasting solution. Sporadic violence has included the 1983 massacre of around 2,000 people.

Security was beefed up in Assam ahead of the release of the NRC, with some 20,000 extra personnel brought in and gatherings banned in some locations.

Only those who can demonstrate that they or their forebears were in India before 1971 could be included in the list.

But navigating the complex process is a huge challenge for many in a region of high illiteracy where many lack documentation.

'Termites'
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party runs Assam — and critics say the NRC process reflects the BJP's goal to serve only its co-religionists.

In January, India's lower house passed legislation that grants citizenship to people who moved to India from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan as recently as six years ago — as long as they are not Muslims.

This has stoked fears among India's 170-million Muslim minority for their future.

Home Minister Amit Shah, Modi's right-hand-man, has called for the ejection of “termites” and said before the BJP's thumping re-election victory in May that it would “run a countrywide campaign to send back the infiltrators”.

On August 5, New Delhi suspended the autonomy of Indian-administered Kashmir. The Muslim-majority region is currently in its fourth week of a near-total communications blackout.

Those left off the NRC have 120 days to appeal at special Foreigners Tribunals, which the government says are being expanded in number.

But activists say that tribunal members are often under-qualified and are subject to “performance” targets, and that the process has been riddled with inconsistencies and errors.

The number of mistakes and the fact that those left off the NRC were expected to include large numbers of Bengali-speaking Hindus has also turned some in the BJP against the process.

“We have lost hope in the present form of the NRC,” Himanta Biswa Sarma, a local BJP minister, said Friday. The party was already mulling a “fresh strategy on how we can drive out the illegal migrants”.

Camps and suicides
Those who have been rejected by the tribunals and have exhausted all other legal avenues can be declared foreigners and — in theory — be placed in one of six detention centres with a view to possible deportation, although Bangladesh is yet to signal its cooperation.

Ten new such camps have been announced. One with space for 3,000 is being constructed in Goalpara, west of Assam's biggest city, Guwahati.

The camps currently hold 1,135 people, according to the state government, and have been operating for years.

Nur Mohammad, 65, spent almost 10 years in one such camp until a Supreme Court order saw him released this month.

“I was born here and lived in Assam all my life,” he told AFP this week. “I don't know if my name will be in the NRC or not.” Media reports say that there have been more than 40 suicides caused by concern over the NRC.

Samujjal Bhattacharya from the All Assam Students' Union (AASU), a key driver behind the NRC, said the register was necessary to protect Assam's indigenous “sons of the soil”.

“We are not ready to live here like a second-class citizens in our own motherland,” he told AFP.

PM Imran tweets about the issue
Prime Minister Imran Khan has also voiced his concern on the matter, saying, "Reports in Indian and international media on Modi government's ethnic cleansing of Muslims should send alarm bells ringing across the world that the illegal annexation of Kashmir is part of a wider policy to target Muslims."



The tweet accompanied a link to a news piece discussing the India's measure of issuing a list of people who have been deemed citizens of Assam.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1502769/t...ndia-publishes-controversial-citizenship-list
 
Out of ~20 million, there are 15 Million Muslims and 5 Million Non-Muslims.

Here is link


Where in the link it was said that 5 lakh is non Muslim and 15 lakh is muslim?

Even when 4 million was excluded Muslim was 1.2-1.5 million. Now the figure has been reduced to more than half. There are no reason still 1.5 million Muslim are excluded.

That BJP extremist was doing some coverup of the propaganda that they have created!!
 
Where in the link it was said that 5 lakh is non Muslim and 15 lakh is muslim?

Even when 4 million was excluded Muslim was 1.2-1.5 million. Now the figure has been reduced to more than half. There are no reason still 1.5 million Muslim are excluded.

Did you watch the video that I posted?

BJP is very unhappy with the NRC results (assumed).

Official figures would only be presented to the Supreme Court of India which is monitoring and managing this NRC.

Everything else is speculation at this time.
 
Did you watch the video that I posted?

BJP is very unhappy with the NRC results (assumed).

Official figures would only be presented to the Supreme Court of India which is monitoring and managing this NRC.

Everything else is speculation at this time.

I did but did not see any part which confirmed where it said 1.5 million muslim are excluded unless you are referring the figure when 4 million were excluded. BJP is unhappy because they have been exposed for their propaganda and heresy that they were propagating for long.
 
I did but did not see any part which confirmed where it said 1.5 million muslim are excluded unless you are referring the figure when 4 million were excluded. BJP is unhappy because they have been exposed for their propaganda and heresy that they were propagating for long.

Did you see they were discussing about 19 Lakh people being left out of NRC?

upload_2019-8-31_12-0-14.png
 
Did you see they were discussing about 19 Lakh people being left out of NRC?

View attachment 576759

That we already know. On which part it’s said 1.5 million is Muslim. Provide the minute n second.

eastmojo%2F2019-08%2F01026976-056c-4698-9004-b495b717f8fd%2FMukut.jpg

ASSAM
NRC Assam: Blame game starts as parties gear up to move SC

By Team EastMojo

August 31, 2019 at 8:33 PM

www.eastmojo.com/amp/story/assam%252F2019%252F08%252F31%252Fnrc-assam-blame-game-starts-as-parties-gear-up-to-move-sc

Guwahati: Even though the much-awaited National Register of Citizens (NRC) was released on Saturday, some of the front-ranking organisations of the state, including the All Assam Students’ Union (AASU), Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Asom Gana Parishad (AGP), have expressed unhappiness over the number of people excluded from the final list.

While the Congress party and the All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) lashed out at the BJP over the NRC in Assam, organisations like the All Assam Minority Students Union (AAMSU) believes that names of genuine Indian citizens have figured among the list of people excluded from the final list.

Announcing that it will appeal against the final NRC in the Supreme Court, AASU general secretary Lurinjyoti Gogoi said that there were some deficiencies in the updating process of the NRC. “We are not happy at all. It seems there were some deficiencies in the updating process. We believe that it is an incomplete NRC. We will appeal to the Supreme Court to remove all the faults and discrepancies in this NRC,” Gogoi said.

The AASU is a signatory to the Assam Accord, a 1985 document that provided for “detection, deletion and deportation” of illegal foreigners from Assam.

The NRC in the state has been updated under the monitoring of the Supreme Court to include only genuine Indian nationals. “The final figure of exclusion did not reach near the figures officially announced by the authorities on various occasions over the years,” it regretted.

The students’ body also criticised both the Centre and state governments for their various policies in this regard.

AASU leaders addressing media persons in Guwahati on Saturday
eastmojo%2F2019-08%2F1f36f175-26e9-4798-83e8-6c5ad2c1a676%2FAASU.jpeg

Terming the number of exclusions of people from the final NRC appear to be "ridiculously small”, president of the AGP and state Cabinet minister Atul Bora, said, “We (AGP) are not at all happy about it (the exclusions). The figure of 19,06,657 exclusions in the final NRC is too less and we just cannot accept it. There is scope for its review in the Supreme Court,” Bora said, adding: “The people of Assam had hoped for a free and fair NRC but it now seems that the very existence of the Assamese will be further threatened.”

The AGP will hold discussions and chalk out its future course of action regarding a review of the NRC in the Supreme Court, he added.

Assam BJP president Ranjit Kumar Dass expressed serious concern over the number of people excluded from final list of the NRC
eastmojo%2F2019-08%2F9a43263e-84fc-4a81-9994-4ca41ffe3884%2FDas.jpg

Addressing a press conference soon after announcement of the NRC list, president of the state unit of the BJP Ranjit Kumar Dass expressed serious concern over the number of people excluded from the list. He also criticised the authorities in the NRC for ignoring the interest of the genuine Indian citizens of the country.

Earlier, Assam finance minister Himanta Biswa Sarma said that he was unhappy with the final list of the NRC in Assam. Sarma, the chief architect of BJP’s recent growth in the Northeast and a proponent of the NRC, said a number of people were included in the final NRC list because of “manipulation” of legacy data.

On one hand, Sarma alleged that a number of people made it to the final NRC list due to manipulation of data, while on the other hand he claimed that many Indians were excluded because the authorities refused to accept refugee certificates as documents for the NRC exercise.

“Names of many Indian citizens who migrated from Bangladesh as refugees prior to 1971 have not been included in the NRC because authorities refused to accept refugee certificates. Many names got included because of manipulation of legacy data as alleged by many,” Sarma said.

State Congress chief Ripun Bora held the BJP responsible for any discrepancies in the final NRC list
eastmojo%2F2019-08%2F26a604b6-b9fe-4218-bc9f-54b4d9786d23%2FBora.jpg

Ripun Bora, president of Assam Pradesh Congress Committee (APCC) and Rajya Sabha Member of Parliament, commented that the officials conducting the NRC process were the employees of the Assam government. He contended that it was the government’s duty to check whether the list contained the name of a ‘foreigner’ or that a bona fide Indian’s name was missing in the NRC. Bora held the BJP responsible for any discrepancies in the final NRC list.

Azizur Rahman, adviser, AAMSU expressed full faith in the Supreme Court and the NRC process
eastmojo%2F2019-08%2F49ec1488-ea8b-4310-9e55-ce682a8deb9c%2FAMSU.jpeg

Talking to media, Azizur Rahman, adviser, AAMSU, expressed full faith in the Supreme Court and the NRC process. “We have full faith in the Supreme Court of India and we believe that the apex court will take adequate initiatives to include the names of genuine Indians whose names have been excluded from the final list of the NRC,” Rahman said.

“NRC is a scientific process. Six layers of verification process were maintained before releasing the final NRC. I don’t think that it won’t be possible to include the names of the foreigners in the final NRC,” he added. The minority students’ leader also expressed serious concern that name of person like Sanaullah has been excluded from the finals list of the NRC.

Sanaullah, who served the Indian Army for more than three decades, was sent to a detention camp in Goalpara after he was declared a ‘foreigner’ by a Foreigners' Tribunal in Assam on May 23. Later, the division bench of Gauhati High Court granted interim bail to him with a surety amount of Rs 20,000.

The Prabajan Virodhi Manch (PVM), an anti-influx body of the state, led by Supreme Court lawyer Upamannyu Hazarika, blamed the ruling government of shedding crocodile tears. It alleged the state government of doing “too little and too late” when it comes to the NRC. Following the release of the first draft, PVM was among the first to demand a re-verification of NRC list.

AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi on Saturday lashed out at the BJP over the NRC in Assam
eastmojo%2F2019-08%2Fb4fd1d04-f061-412d-8039-d6b7eb87f485%2FAsa.jpg

All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) chief Asaduddin Owaisi on Saturday lashed out at the BJP over the NRC in Assam.

“BJP should learn a lesson. They should stop asking for NRC throughout the country in terms of Hindus and Muslims. They should learn from what has happened in Assam. The so-called myth of illegal migrants has been busted. Many people in Assam have told me that the parents’ names are included, but names of their children are excluded. For example, Mohammad Sanaullah, he has served in Army. His case is pending in High Court. I am sure that he will also get justice,” he said.

The final National Register of Citizens in Assam was finally released on Saturday. The list has identified 3.11 crore applicants as citizens, excluding names of 19.07 lakh hopefuls, the NRC state coordinator’s office said.
 
Back
Top Bottom