What's new

Two-and-a-half wars? The Indian Air Force doesn’t have the squadron strength to fight even one

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
idrw.org
Two-and-a-half wars? The Indian Air Force doesn’t have the squadron strength to fight even one
5-6 minutes
SOURCE: SCROLL

62147-qrvpfadmfr-1499081301.jpg


In an interview to the Indian Express earlier this month, Air Chief Marshal BS Dhanoa said that against a sanctioned strength of 42 squadrons, the Air Force had only 32 operating currently. As he ruefully pointed out, this was akin to playing a cricket match with only seven players.

But even this is not a realistic picture. Of the 32 squadrons of combat aircraft currently in service, a bulk of them are past their use-by date and have not been phased out simply because the Air Force has run out of options.

Precarious fleet
If the tiny Gnat fighter was the hero of the 1965 war with Pakistan, it was the MiG-21 that stole the show in the 1971 war. It was a dreaded combat aircraft, with a tubular air frame and delta wings that gave it superb flying manoeuvres and had a complement of the best air-to-air and air-to-ground weapons. But as the years passed and the Air Force did not purchase any new aircraft in bulk or manufacture them under licence, the aircraft continued to age.

Even today, the bulk of the combat aircraft in the IAF belong to the MiG family and all of them are way beyond their official dates of service. For instance, the vulnerable MiG-21, has seen seen some upgrades, while the older variants have been retired. There are two squadrons of the MiG-29 and a few of the MiG-23 and the 27. The MiG-25, which was used as a platform for electronic warfare and surveillance, was retired from service a few years ago.

The Indian Air Force, which is expected to play a critical role in the event of a war, does not have enough aircraft to fight even a single war. The only good news is that Pakistan’s Air Force is in no better shape and is hoping that the Chinese combat aircraft will bail them out. China, meanwhile, is rapidly developing its Air Force and has already created a successful Fifth-Generation combat aircraft, the most advanced generation.

What is worrying the top brass of the Indian Air Force currently is the steady erosion of the current fleet with no replacements in sight. The bulk of the Air Force is made up of varying kinds of MiGs, numbering 230. It has two squadrons of the Jaguar, the MiG-29 and the Mirage-2000. Since 1998, it has been buying the Su-30 from Russia, but that has a different and specialised role. The indigenously developed Light Combat Aircraft, Tejas, which was supposed to be in service by now, is still waiting to be inducted, but the Air Force is clearly not very keen to have it. A plan to buy 126 Rafale aircraft came a cropper and as reported in Scroll.in earlier, India now plans to purchase just 36 aircraft, but even that deal is yet to be finalised.

The ad hoc induction has not only affected the Air Force quantitatively, it is also hurting it in qualitative terms. A large and varied fleet is a difficult one to maintain. With many aircraft nearing their end-of-life cycle in the next 10 years, chances are that the Air Force will go down to 26 combat squadrons before any new aircraft arrive.

Learning from the Indian Navy
When it comes to developing indigenous capabilities, no one beats the Indian Navy. For decades, naval officers have been posted with Defence Research and Development Organisation facilities to develop new technologies. This created a culture of design and development, which delivered some major successes.

Unfortunately, the Air Force, already reeling under a shortage of pilots, could not develop a similar culture.

Dependent on the Aeronautical Development Agency, a lab in Bengaluru, the Air Force has had to contend with the monopoly of the government, with not enough technical expertise on its side. The Aeronautical Development Agency offspring, Tejas, is years away from induction even though it has been nearly 30 years since it was conceptualised. Interestingly, the Navy has firmly rejected plans to develop a naval version of the Tejas.

The Indian Airforce is also caught in a time warp. As concepts of warfare changed, unmanned aerial weapons platforms took to the skies. The performance of unmanned combat aerial vehicles has proved so successful that more air forces are looking at drone warfare seriously. In the case of the Air Force, even the indigenous drone programme under development by the DRDO has not taken off. Currently, it is dependent on drones from Israel to carry out a suite of surveillance functions.

While Army Chief, General Bipin Rawat claimed last month that India is ready to fight two wars and handle insurgency simultaneously, his Air Force counterpart clearly disagrees. The hyperbole around India’s military capabilities in a politically charged environment is drowning out the inconvenient truth – the Air Force’s modernisation programme is in a shambles.



http://idrw.org/two-and-a-half-wars...have-the-squadron-strength-to-fight-even-one/
 
. . .
I am sick of this BS about squadron strength. IAF should determine required strength on some parameters.
If tomorrow IAF gets 100 5th gen planes, are they still going to talk about 42 squadron? That I believe is from an analysis of 30 years ago.

IAF should talk about keeping their maximum strength available and operational, reduce turn around time (time taken between missions). Few days ago I saw a video, Israel AF before six day war did an analysis. They determined that they can get the plane up in the sky again in 8 min (after refuel and quick check). Their understanding was that if they start bombing Egypt from morning, they will finish off most of their air force in few hours. This is the need, not this rona dhona about numbers.

I do hope and believe, Indian Air Force already does such things
 
.
India had this EXACT same problem of depleted squadron strength back in 2001 when they started the MMRCA to solve it.

Now it's 2017 and it's exactly the same situation.

(Except that now India is hoping to order some F-16's after 2020.)

India says they have learned their lessons about military preparedness, but they obviously haven't.

Indian border infrastructure still doesn't even reach the border in many places, it will take several days of hiking over extremely mountainous terrain just for their soldiers to reach the battlefield. They will arrive in a state of complete exhaustion, with sub-par equipment and lacking ammunition and further supplies. How do you expect them to win in such a situation is beyond me.
 
.
"......If the tiny Gnat fighter was the hero of the 1965 war with Pakistan, it was the MiG-21 that stole the show in the 1971 war....."
this single line proves that the article is plain "BS" by mr BS dhanoa.
 
.
Very true. India needs at least 50 squadrons to successfully defend and survive in a two front war.

Modi has been such a disappointment on this front.
 
.
Very true. India needs at least 50 squadrons to successfully defend and survive in a two front war.

Modi has been such a disappointment on this front.

The Tejas program was suppose to solve IAF's fighter gap problems, but it's still going no where. HAL is a basket case and something should be done to fix it. I say privatize it or sell it to another company. Enough is enough.
 
.
The Tejas program was suppose to solve IAF's fighter gap problems, but it's still going no where. HAL is a basket case and something should be done to fix it. I say privatize it or sell it to another company. Enough is enough.

Tejas program was suppose to solve only the Light weight category. MMRCA was supposed to solve the Medium category while FGFA was suppose solve the Heavy weight category.

All of these programs are in shambles.

Modi's government is being Penny wise Pound foolish.

India keeps negotiating year after year while China & Pakistan are actually inducting a new system after system

Pathetic performance.
 
.
The Indian Government needs to probably reduce the Made in India Clause and start purchasing more fighter aircrafts...
 
.
The Indian Government needs to probably reduce the Made in India Clause and start purchasing more fighter aircrafts...

Too easy to say. But made in india ain getting anywhere either.

Military budget, where will the funds come from?

I just cant help but feel india has overstretched itself under modi.

Defense is something carefully laid out over a period and not something to suddenly increase.

Hence thats why india facing severe infrastructure problem - its like a great leap forward without the resources
 
.
Very grave problem.just compare this strength against China.China now making all its planes missiles everything.India must buy weapons and open it. Read the circuits.try to make something.reverse engineering is possible.
 
.
Very grave problem.just compare this strength against China.China now making all its planes missiles everything.India must buy weapons and open it. Read the circuits.try to make something.reverse engineering is possible.

It's too late for India to try and go indigenous, since they are pushing for a conflict with China right now (along the Sikkim border).

It's better for them to buy more imported hardware. But it still took them almost 2 decades to buy the MMRCA planes, and the deal is not even final yet.

They need to buy some ready-made (or even second-hand) military imports right now, and sure they will have to pay a colossal amount to get it delivered so fast, but it's better than losing a border war.
 
.
It's too late for India to try and go indigenous, since they are pushing for a conflict with China right now (along the Sikkim border).

It's better for them to buy more imported hardware. But it still took them almost 2 decades to buy the MMRCA planes, and the deal is not even final yet.

They need to buy some ready-made (or even second-hand) military imports right now, and sure they will have to pay a colossal amount to get it delivered so fast, but it's better than losing a border war.

AMCA is coming up nicely along with LCA.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom