The future of Muslims in India according to the Hindus

[Naofumi]

Where are you getting your flawed info bro?

Read Surveys of India from it's start to 1931.

 

[Cliftonite]

He will be treated as if a Musalli will change his baradari to Syed - no one will believe him and neither marry him.

Ugh I'm hearing the word Musalli the first time in my life from this Indian. Kahan kahan se leke aatay ho bhai?

 

[Naofumi]

Ugh I'm hearing the word Musalli the first time in my life from this Indian. Kahan kahan se leke aatay ho bhai?

Heard Chamar? Bhangi? Kanjar?

 

[Imran Khan]

someone should call this guy names abu ul kalam azaad

 

[xeuss]

Actually most of it is wrong assumption. We just don't want Tik-Tokias and Thookers, Burhan Wanis and Stone Pelters. You respect us and we will respect you. You burn a bogey full of pilgrims and we will make sure that you will learn a lesson that you wont forget.

Aah...so that is what it comes down to.

Some Muslims commit a crime in one part of the country, but other innocent Muslims are made to pay the price.

Basically, you want to kill Muslims, and are simply waiting for a reason. Great concept of justice you have.

 

[Cliftonite]

Read Surveys of India from it's start to 1931.

Exactly. Road surveys pe mat jaiye. Talk to an actual Pakistani or visit here before basing your assumptions. This is why I say you guys and us are not compatible anymore. No ummah chummah.

Aah...so that is what it comes down to.

Some Muslims commit a crime in one part of the country, but other innocent Muslims are made to pay the price.

Basically, you want to kill Muslims, and are simply waiting for a reason. Great concept of justice you have.

Bara late wazih hua aap pe. These UP Bihar sanghis want to kill you and the educated NRI Gujjus Marathi ones want to take away your voting rights and Indianize you.

 

[xeuss]

Profession based social stratification is caste system.

No it is not.

 

[Naofumi]

Exactly. Road surveys pe mat jaiye. Talk to an actual Pakistani or visit here before basing your assumptions. This is why I say you guys and us are not compatible anymore. No ummah chummah.

Same can be said to Pakistanis discussing Indian caste system, no?
And believe me I am the exception here, no one accepts caste system in Indian Muslims too. I did not too but have to because of hard evidence in it's direction.

 

[jamahir]

How to identify a Dalit?
@jamahir @ChennaiDude @Joe Shearer @Soumitra @Secularindian

I don't know really. Maybe for some Dalits there is the surname but for others it is not.

For example, Rohith Vemula was a young Dalit scholar at the Hyderabad University who committed suicide by hanging because of harassment by upper caste university authorities. His mother was from the Dalit caste called Mala but he used the surname of his father who was from the higher caste called Vaddera.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Hmmm. But what if a Dalit becomes a Professional like an Engineer or a Doctor?

That's a really interesting question.

There is this phenomenon of the escalator. There are numerous people who have climbed the caste ladder and established themselves comfortably in the middle classes, in the professional classes. The principal of Scottish Church College some fifty years ago was a Professor Mundle. Now a Mandal is not the highest of the high. This family got their exit by converting to Christianity and taking to education. The son, whom I knew briefly, is today a very big name in economics, of national stature.

I know of someone who climbed his way up from a plain ordinary agricultural background to the heights of his medical profession. On the way, he married someone who was a Kayastha, among the top three in Bengal. His daughter, who was a brilliant student, and a very attractive girl, was going around with a young man completely besotted with her, but different, socially. Unknown to either of them, the man's father called in her father, and asked him to stop his daughter from straying, and that was that. She married someone from the same social group, and together they climbed to the top of their profession as economists; the husband was easily considered ahead of his professor, Dipak Banerjee's son, Abhijit, but to everybody's surprise, Abhijit got the Nobel. The couple had twin daughters; both got PhDs and married happily, one a foreigner, another a Rajasthani, and live very happily.

 

[Cliftonite]

Heard Chamar? Bhangi? Kanjar?

Haha meri jaan kanjar is an insult, like a randi or a loose person. There is no caste known as kanjars in Pakistan. Neither is there a specific caste known as bhangis. It's a derogatory disgusting word used for any sweeper. Don't draw false analogies between your country and ours. Chamar too is an insult, you don't have a specific caste of leather workers and tanners known as Chamars anymore.

 

[Naofumi]

No it is not.

It is.

 

[Pakistani Fighter]

Heard Chamar? Bhangi? Kanjar?

Bhangi here in Karachi means Gutter Opener/Sweeper

 

[xeuss]

Bara late wazih hua aap pe. These UP Bihar sanghis want to kill you and the educated NRI Gujjus Marathi ones want to take away your voting rights and Indianize you.

No Johnny Come Lately, we are not as stupid as you think.

Don't mistake someone's helplessness or weakness in society as him being stupid.

 

[Joe Shearer]

No. So what Biradris are Dalits? Like a professional dalit starts calling himeslf Brahmin than?

Heh.

The official sequence was Das =>DasGupta =>DasSharma => Sharma. That is a joke. It means Sudra (not Dalit), to Vaidya to Vaidya-Brahmin to Brahmin.