What's new

Strangest border Ever : world's only 3rd order enclave near India -bangladesh border

Aarush

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jan 27, 2014
Messages
1,174
Reaction score
-1
Country
India
Location
United States
interesting....just came through to this info..while browsing...

Wg4RT.jpg


You know what an enclave is -- it's a bit of one country that exists inside another country, like an island. On rare occasions, another island of territory winds up inside the enclave, and this is called a counter-enclave. So the enclave would be shaped like a doughnut, and driving across it would let you go out, in, out and back into your country again. Still with us?

OK, now imagine you live in the Indian district of Dahala Khagrabari. It's surrounded by part of Bangladesh, which is surrounded by part of India, which is surrounded by Bangladesh -- the world's only counter-counter-enclave.

POgbV.jpg


So when driving across it in a straight line, it'd go India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh.

Due to India and Bangladesh being, we guess, on crack or something when they drew up their borders, they have around 160 enclaves within each other's territories. But none as crazy as Dahala Khagrabari, which apparently came about after the two nations suddenly signed a peace treaty after a long history of wars, freezing in place whatever territories had been captured by either side.

OtqXF.jpg


As ridiculous as it seems to the rest of us, the residents aren't laughing. Probably because they're stuck there for life. Although they're Indian citizens, they can't leave their immediate neighborhood without passing through Bangladesh, for which they need a passport. But they can only get a passport from mainland India -- which they can't get to without passing through Bangladesh. Twice.

Likewise, for India to try to provide these people with basic amenities would be a logistical nightmare, so they don't. Without electricity or anything else we take for granted, Dahala Khagrabari is basically stuck in the Stone Age, while everyone around them modernizes. The only possible consolation is that the sliver of Bangladesh that's trapping them is in the same situation.

Dahala-3.png


Indiaception: Enclave Within Enclave Within Enclave
 
. .
Both countries should work for the benefit of citizens...its a political problem...and poor people are suffering..
its pain from partition. it was not happened properly...
 
.
Both countries should work for the benefit of citizens...its a political problem...and poor people are suffering..
its pain from partition. it was not happened properly...

Mamata B is the only one opposing to resolve this issue now.
 
. . . .
This is really weird.:crazy:

The whole of the enclave should go to Bangladesh and if the Indians in there do not want to be Bangladeshi then they should be free to move to India.
 
.
Do they have a vote ?
Being Indian citizens they are entitled to vote, but the nearest polling booth is accessed by crossing into bangladesh and then into india and then into bangladesh and then into india, so I don't think any of them actually get to vote.

Dahala Khagrabari - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The author is right, whoever drew the map for that region must have been high on crack or acid.
 
. . .
This is really weird.:crazy:

The whole of the enclave should go to Bangladesh and if the Indians in there do not want to be Bangladeshi then they should be free to move to India.

I agree... also..a equal chunk of the land should be ceded to india.. ;)
 
.
I agree... also..a equal chunk of the land should be ceded to india.. ;)

Well there was the 2011 agreement to do this for all enclaves in BD and India but this is being held up by the Indian side.
It is a human tragedy for the people caught in the enclaves and should have been solved a long time ago.
 
. .
interesting....just came through to this info..while browsing...

Wg4RT.jpg


You know what an enclave is -- it's a bit of one country that exists inside another country, like an island. On rare occasions, another island of territory winds up inside the enclave, and this is called a counter-enclave. So the enclave would be shaped like a doughnut, and driving across it would let you go out, in, out and back into your country again. Still with us?

OK, now imagine you live in the Indian district of Dahala Khagrabari. It's surrounded by part of Bangladesh, which is surrounded by part of India, which is surrounded by Bangladesh -- the world's only counter-counter-enclave.

POgbV.jpg


So when driving across it in a straight line, it'd go India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh.

Due to India and Bangladesh being, we guess, on crack or something when they drew up their borders, they have around 160 enclaves within each other's territories. But none as crazy as Dahala Khagrabari, which apparently came about after the two nations suddenly signed a peace treaty after a long history of wars, freezing in place whatever territories had been captured by either side.

OtqXF.jpg


As ridiculous as it seems to the rest of us, the residents aren't laughing. Probably because they're stuck there for life. Although they're Indian citizens, they can't leave their immediate neighborhood without passing through Bangladesh, for which they need a passport. But they can only get a passport from mainland India -- which they can't get to without passing through Bangladesh. Twice.

Likewise, for India to try to provide these people with basic amenities would be a logistical nightmare, so they don't. Without electricity or anything else we take for granted, Dahala Khagrabari is basically stuck in the Stone Age, while everyone around them modernizes. The only possible consolation is that the sliver of Bangladesh that's trapping them is in the same situation.

View attachment 23656

Indiaception: Enclave Within Enclave Within Enclave

These enclaves are ridiculous. @BDforever first told me about these.

1. The enclaves need to be exchanged. Any Indian Bengali politician refusing to do this should be quartered in this third order enclave. A Joint Border Commission can be setup to facilitate this.

2. There should be a complete population transfer. All Indians(primarily Hindus) will have to move out to the newly exchanged enclaves while all Bangladeshis will have to move out. Say enclave A is Indian and B is Bangladeshi. And A is given to Bangladesh while B to India(with border modifications). People of B will have to go to A and A to B. No exceptions.

3. Scores of Bangladeshi illegals can also be pushed to one of these enclaves and then the enclave can be handed over to Bangladesh. Any further attempt to infiltrate will end with a bullet in the head.

4. These lands do us no good. They do the people no good. A mean line should be drawn and the border made more logical.
It's easy but requires political will.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom