What's new

Solution for Rohingyas

Zabaniyah

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 24, 2011
Messages
14,925
Reaction score
7
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Myanmar president for deportation to a third country, UNHCR wants their citizenship

The Myanmar president told the UN yesterday that his government would send away the Rohingyas if any country accepted them.

Refugee camps or deportation was the "solution" for nearly a million Rohingya Muslims in the wake of communal unrest in the west of the country, he added.

Thein Sein, who had previously struck a more conciliatory tone during fighting that left at least 80 people dead in Rakhine State last month, told the chief of the United Nations refugee agency the Rohingya were not welcome.

"We will take responsibility for our ethnic people but it is impossible to accept the illegally entered Rohingyas, who are not our ethnicity," he told UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres, according to the president's official website.

The former junta general said the "only solution" was to send the Rohingyas -- which number around 800,000 in Myanmar and are considered to be some of the world's most persecuted minorities -- to refugee camps run by UNHCR.

"We will send them away if any third country would accept them," he added. "This is what we are thinking is the solution to the issue."

However, UNHCR thinks the solution is for the Rohingyas to get citizenship in Myanmar.

"Basically Myanmar does not consider these 7,35,000 Muslims in northern Rakhine state to be their citizens and we think the solution is for them to get citizenship in Myanmar," UNHCR's Asia spokeswoman Kitty McKinsey told AFP.

"So we would not be very likely to assist in transporting them out of the country and housing them somewhere else. As a refugee agency we do not usually participate in creating refugees."

McKinsey said the UN had been working for "several decades" in the area, trying to promote reconciliation and "benefit all communities, not just the Muslims".

Communal violence between ethnic Buddhist Rakhine and local Muslims, including the Rohingya, swept the state in June, forcing tens of thousands to flee as homes were torched and communities ripped apart.

Decades of discrimination have left the Rohingya stateless, with Myanmar implementing restrictions on their movement and withholding land rights, education and public services, the UN says.

Unwanted in Myanmar and Bangladesh -- where an estimated 3,00,000 live -- Rohingya migrants have undertaken dangerous voyages by boat towards Malaysia or Thailand in recent years.

According to the UNHCR around one million Rohingya are now thought to live outside Myanmar, but they have not been welcomed by a third country.

Bangladesh has turned back Rohingya boats arriving on its shores since the outbreak of the unrest.

Although security forces have quelled the worst of the unrest, tens of thousands of people remain in government-run relief camps with the UN's World Food Programme reporting that it has provided aid to some 100,000 people.

Both sides have accused each other of violent attacks, which were sparked following the rape and murder of a local Buddhist woman and subsequent revenge attack by a mob of ethnic Rakhines that left 10 Muslims dead on June 3.

A state of emergency is still in force in several areas.
http://www.thedailystar.net/newDesign/news-details.php?nid=241923

No surprises there :tsk:
 
.
Cross posting from another thread:

First of all, I want to salute brother r4rehan for his sentiments to help fellow Muslims in distress. We have discussed this issue in detail in many threads since news came out about the Rohingya riots and killings in Burma, here are some of the threads:

http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangladesh-defence/183835-myanmar-bangladesh-relations.html
http://www.defence.pk/forums/world-...cleansing-muslim-rohingyas-burma-myanmar.html
http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangladesh-defence/189021-helicopters-fire-rohingya-refugees.html
http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangladesh-defence/154682-peep-into-arakan-history.html
http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangladesh-defence/189387-history-chittagong-arakan.html

Please look at these threads for background information and news. Rohingya Muslims are being denied citizenship of Burma by the Burmese govt. Out of about 2-3 million Rohingya Muslims, they have kicked out most of them, only about 750,000 remain there. Many were killed in this ethnic cleansing process, and it continues as we speak.

If Muslim nations join hands, helping them may be possible:

- first we need to bring this up in OIC and see which Muslim nations come forward to help, we will call this group of nations "friends of Rohingya"
- then together we have to apply diplomatic pressure to Burma using India and China, its two main allies, so Burmese govt. accept them as citizens, take back all Rohingya refugees from different countries of the world and make sure that their human rights are not violated
- if diplomacy does not work, then "friends of Rohingya" group of nations should think about military intervention, and create a safe haven for them by occupying the state of Arakan
- "friends of Rohingya" will have to ensure that China or India do not interfere in this conflict
- remaining Rohingya's can be armed and trained as insurgents
- when they have sufficiently softened the Burmese Army in Arakan, this side of Arakan Yoma Mountain range (brown part next to Chittagong), then an invasion force can take over Arakan

443px-Burma_topo_en.jpg

arakanbrit.gif

rakhine_state.jpg
 
.
Thein Sein told the chief of the United Nations refugee agency the Rohingya were not welcome."We will take responsibility for our ethnic people but it is impossible to accept the illegally entered Rohingyas, who are not our ethnicity," according to the president's official website. ( From the OP's article)


Wow, that's huge! I wonder why no international news outlets pick it up.


Oops I found One thanks.
 
.
Thein Sein told the chief of the United Nations refugee agency the Rohingya were not welcome."We will take responsibility for our ethnic people but it is impossible to accept the illegally entered Rohingyas, who are not our ethnicity," according to the president's official website. ( From the OP's article)

Wow, that's huge! I wonder why no international news outlets pick it up.

Thanks for your expression of support.

We need to start a Boycott Burma campaign, just like the Apartheid regime in South Africa. Constructive engagement is producing negative result in case of Burman majority in Burma.
 
.
Ronhingyas can be given asylum in the Freinds of Rohingya countries if diplomacy fails. With so much combined land and wealth in the muslim world giving asylum to 700,000 Bangladeshi muslims shouldn't be a problem, and will be a cheaper and less destructive option than waging a war.
 
.
Ronhingyas can be given asylum in the Freinds of Rohingya countries if diplomacy fails. With so much combined land and wealth in the muslim world giving asylum to 700,000 Bangladeshi muslims shouldn't be a problem, and will be a cheaper and less destructive option than waging a war.

I only see hate from your words.....

Why not arm the 700'000 for self defence from Bharti terrorist state?

Where is UN? Where is peace army?
 
.
I only see hate from your words.....

Why not arm the 700'000 for self defence from Bharti terrorist state?

Where is UN? Where is peace army?

India has got nothing to do with this problem. We are already hosting few thousand Rohingya refugee. Its time maybe the "Friends of Rohingya" to step in.
 
.
I dont understand how can Bangladesh be so heartless about the Rohingyas, knowing very well that they are their own people.
Bangladesh should accept these Rohingyas back into their country unconditionally, becoz that is their real home.
Im sure tomorrow when we will also deport illegal Bangladeshis back into their country they would again make similar excuses.

Its so unfortunate to see a Nation turning so indifferent for its own people.
 
.
India has got nothing to do with this problem. We are already few thousand Rohingya refugee. Its time maybe the "Friends of Rohingya" to step in.

its time for you guys to pay respects in jerusalem to your jewish masters
 
.
[:::~Spartacus~:::];3175640 said:
its time for you guys to pay respects in jerusalem to your jewish masters

We don't have any masters, unlike you know who. I hope the NATO transit is going on smoothly.
 
.
We don't have any masters, unlike you know who. I hope the NATO transit is going on smoothly.

no you have masters, israel protects you, so its your duty to bow infront of jerusalem

most indians already have unconditional loyalty for israel same which is not reciprocated by israelis
 
.
[:::~Spartacus~:::];3175777 said:
no you have masters, israel protects you, so its your duty to bow infront of jerusalem

most indians already have unconditional loyalty for israel same which is not reciprocated by israelis

Thats just another reason Pakistanis have made up to hate India, as if there weren't enough:lol:
 
.
I am in favour of Arming the Rohingyas.
Pakistan should play the same tactic it player in Bosnia.
Airlift arms and ammunition in disguise of humanitarian aid.

It not like the Sh-T army of Burma is any match for PAF.
 
.
Really, there are already 100,000 stateless bedoins in Kuwait, when arabs don't care about their own people, will they be generous for Rohingyas.

Ronhingyas can be given asylum in the Freinds of Rohingya countries if diplomacy fails. With so much combined land and wealth in the muslim world giving asylum to 700,000 Bangladeshi muslims shouldn't be a problem, and will be a cheaper and less destructive option than waging a war.
 
.
Ronhingyas can be given asylum in the Freinds of Rohingya countries if diplomacy fails. With so much combined land and wealth in the muslim world giving asylum to 700,000 Bangladeshi muslims shouldn't be a problem, and will be a cheaper and less destructive option than waging a war.

How are they Bangladeshis? lolz...

I dont understand how can Bangladesh be so heartless about the Rohingyas, knowing very well that they are their own people.
Bangladesh should accept these Rohingyas back into their country unconditionally, becoz that is their real home.
Im sure tomorrow when we will also deport illegal Bangladeshis back into their country they would again make similar excuses.

Its so unfortunate to see a Nation turning so indifferent for its own people.

You are wrong there.

Please, read up some history.

I am in favour of Arming the Rohingyas.
Pakistan should play the same tactic it player in Bosnia.
Airlift arms and ammunition in disguise of humanitarian aid.

It not like the Sh-T army of Burma is any match for PAF.

Too late for that mate. The numbers of Rohingyas are too limited, and they have no combat experience whatsoever.

Although, we can work together to deny the Burmese economic opportunities in our power, and tarnish their national image. Pakistan shouldn't be supplying them with arms and remove them from the candidate list for the JF-17. Trust me, it really works.

If we had any real sense of unity, this treachery of the Burmese will not go unanswered. Even the Israelis are far more humane towards the Arabs! Brah...
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom