What's new

Saudi Arabia has been granted full membership of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Repeating the same nonsense lie again and again does not make it true. KSA had no independent vote until Friday. The GCC is composed of 6 sovereign nations. To pretend that KSA had some final say is some kind of bad joke given the FACT that there is currently internal trouble within the GCC thanks to Qatar's ridiculous behavior. Let us forget Qatar for a while go take a look at the close relations of Oman with India under the current clueless and naive Omani Sultan.

It is a well known fact that Saudi influence over other GCC countries is absolute and that no GCC country goes against Saudi decision. It was Saudi decision to vote in favor of Pakistan in the initial vote and then to vote against Pakistan in the re-voting which led to our Grey listing. It is also well known that Saudi Arabia sold us out for a full membership of FATF.



You can side with Iran in an imaginary world but that will not change anything fundamentally on the ground. Arabs still outnumber Iranians by a factor of 6-10 on almost every single field. From population, geographic size, natural resources etc. The problem is internal. Divisions within the Arab world and incompetent regimes. If there were sane leaderships and leaderships that reflected the people we would not have the current mess in 4-5 Arab countries (Yemen, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Lebanon (Hezbollah)). So let us leave that discussion aside.

The day we withdraw our military umbrella from Saudi Arabia would be the day you start losing sleep. That is a nightmare which you do not even want to consider, ever.



As for KSA, we are in the process of building 16 nuclear power plants and guess with who that likely will be? Russia, China, South Korea and maybe the US as well.

Guess who we have worked extremely closely with to create an indigenous ballistic missile program for 30+ years? China.

Who are we working with in the most profitable business in the world (oil) to help regulate that market on a WEEKLY basis? Russia.

Bailing Pakistan out and helping it at EVERY time of need (serious) is "symbolic", ok. With that kind of attitude (that are not representative for 95% of Pakistanis) it is hard to have any sane discussion.

You have all kinds of toys and yet you cannot use them yourself, you need professionals to use those toys even when you need to defend your own borders. It has to be the US or the UK or Pakistani Military. Your inclination to warfare and fighting, well, it is known. You know what saddens me the most, it is the fact that you will spend hundreds of billions in procuring US weapons but will NOT get Transfer of Technology as does India. After spending trillion of USD on procurement, you could have been a production powerhouse of western technology and yet you hardly have any such industry and still need to keep pouring Billions of USD to retain your monarchy lest the US decide to bring democracy to the kingdom.

And don't be delusional, the only reason you 'bail' your favorite Governments in Pakistan is to ensure the military safety net that you require from Pakistan. The day you don't need that will be the day you start bowing to Indian PM's such as Modi, the Muslim killer.



KSA is not investing "trillions of USD" in the West but ALL across the world. Do you even have a clue who our largest trade partner is? Let me give you a hint, it is the most populous country of the world.

As for investing in Pakistan in the past on a wide scale, you are fully aware of the difficulties of doing that and ALSO fully aware that not even many expat Pakistanis are doing that let alone the richest Pakistanis. It is due to a largely ineffective and corrupt system. KSA has tried to kickstart numerous project related to agriculture, petrochemical sector, energy in the past and what I have been told many were almost sabotaged from elements within the Pakistani political spectrum and the rampant corruption. You don't have such problems when investing in say China where there is a strong rule of law and corrupt is combated in extreme ways (death penalty even). It seems that things are moving in the right direction under Imran Khan which is why business relations have expanded and KSA has announced quite a lot of promising JOINT projects inside Pakistan and pledged to invest a large sum of money. Let us hope that it will be different this time around.

In regards to your weak argument about your kingdom's reluctance to invest in Pakistan, your guarantor is the Military, always and so your investment is always secure. Things would have been different under Shah Fahad and Shah Faisal.
 
. .
It is a well known fact that Saudi influence over other GCC countries is absolute and that no GCC country goes against Saudi decision. It was Saudi decision to vote in favor of Pakistan in the initial vote and then to vote against Pakistan in the re-voting which led to our Grey listing. It is also well known that Saudi Arabia sold us out for a full membership of FATF.





The day we withdraw our military umbrella from Saudi Arabia would be the day you start losing sleep. That is a nightmare which you do not even want to consider, ever.





You have all kinds of toys and yet you cannot use them yourself, you need professionals to use those toys even when you need to defend your own borders. It has to be the US or the UK or Pakistani Military. Your inclination to warfare and fighting, well, it is known. You know what saddens me the most, it is the fact that you will spend hundreds of billions in procuring US weapons but will NOT get Transfer of Technology as does India. After spending trillion of USD on procurement, you could have been a production powerhouse of western technology and yet you hardly have any such industry and still need to keep pouring Billions of USD to retain your monarchy lest the US decide to bring democracy to the kingdom.

And don't be delusional, the only reason you 'bail' your favorite Governments in Pakistan is to ensure the military safety net that you require from Pakistan. The day you don't need that will be the day you start bowing to Indian PM's such as Modi, the Muslim killer.





In regards to your weak argument about your kingdom's reluctance to invest in Pakistan, your guarantor is the Military, always and so your investment is always secure. Things would have been different under Shah Fahad and Shah Faisal.

In which imaginary world is that influence "absolute". Care to explain the Qatar rift/dispute then? Or why Oman is toying their own semi-neutral policy and very pro-India policy to the extend that the Indians have some kind of military presence (apparently if I recall) in Oman? Why are Omani-Iranian ties so close? They just recently held a naval exercise together even! You are blabbering utter nonsense to fit your self-constructed picture.

With such kind of ignorance, it is hard to have any sane discussion.

How many times do you need to be told that KSA DID NOT have a separate vote until this Friday? Or that the GCC does not equal KSA or its whims?

Are you really so sure about that because it has little to do with the real world.

You realize that KSA has been engaged (alongside the Arab coalition and legitimate Yemeni government) with practically zero outside support let alone Western? The same West has not even officially declared the Houthis to be a terrorist group. So much for that support. Western media is toying the Houthi propaganda lie as well ignoring every single Houthi crime or the fact that they are a rogue terrorist cult who make a VIOLENT coup d'etát back in September 2014 which started all the recent mess in the first place!

Which world are you living in when it has been official KSA policy to have at least a degree of ToT in every military deal where this is possible? Have you taken a look at the Saudi Arabian defense industry of late and how it is booming.

I suggest visiting the "Made in KSA" thread on the Arab Section to gain a bit more knowledge as you are clearly not too informed about this topic. Or some of the 10's of threads that I and users like @The SC have created.

LOL. Arabs/our Semitic pre-Arab ancestors have had trade ties with South Asia for millennia (this includes modern-day Pakistan and India) since before even IVC emerged.





KSA is doing trade with India like every other Muslim country, including Pakistan itself. India is home to 200 million Muslims as well. Many with ties to KSA/Arab World. Some even fairly recent arrivals like in Hyderabad (Yemenis of Hadhrami origins) who were an important part of the Nizam of Hyderabad who ironically claims/claimed Arab paternal ancestry.

Did you forget 70+ years of alliance with the US (world's sole superpower) and our deep, deep military and economic ties (China is our largest trade partner) with China?

Pakistan and KSA both need each other (both can survive without each other though) but the deep states of both countries are clever enough to understand that this relationship is very deep in most regards and transcends the rulers or deep states.

As I have stated many times and which you for some reason keep ignoring, there are cultural, ancient historical, religious, linguistic, ancestral and even geographic proximity between Arabia and Pakistan.

This map from 2000 years ago (!) clearly illustrates just the incredibly close trade ties alone.

 
.
Saudi tumharay baap ka ghulam Hain Jo tumhain bachain ga
When they asked Pakistan to join Yemen war people like you were saying we are not mercenary and on the other hand you expect them to help you whenever you are in need of help

Brother, I already countered that contradiction (without a reply so far) but what he is saying is untrue. KSA DID NOT have an independent vote until this Friday. He claims that KSA has "total dominance" over the GCC. If what he says is true, why is KSA and Qatar at odds for 2 years running and waging a propaganda war and proxy war in the region while we speak and why is the Omani Sultan so close to the Iranian regime? So many contradictions. He is all over the place with all due respect.

I do not understand why he is attacking me when I am 100% pro Pakistan and has talked about the need to increase Arab-Pakistani ties on every front for years here and had numerous discussions about this and created numerous threads.

This individual does not know that Saudi Arabians and Pakistanis (millions of them) know each other very well and understand the very close ties on almost every front. Even the people look alike often. Very strange behavior!

Thank you for your kind words hopefully we do it soon as far as Imran Khan concern like u i m hopeful at least that guy is trying and honest unlike previous ones.Allah give him success

Welcome. My avatar (MbS) is someone I have great hopes in too and I have liked many of his decisions (obviously not all but which leader is perfect) so that is why I am using that avatar. Seems to attract anti-KSA and anti-Arab trolls though so might be forced to change it in order to prevent idiotic "discussions" in the future.

Wallah I'll get back to this post of yours....I am munching on some tandoori at the moment lol

Take your time brother. Worth waiting for sure given our past discussions. As you see, I was sucked into another "discussion", lol. Time wasted. Got to learn to ignore it.
 
. .
Because he is not pro Pakistan and I know this from his posting history

Well, I cannot judge that nor is it my business to judge this as a non-Pakistani all I can say is that his priorities are messed up and that a lot of what he is writing is simply not based on ground realities or any measurable fact hence my posts and that of others. I do not care about his sect, political viewpoints etc. He can hate Arabs, KSA etc. (his choice) but nonsense should be called out.

I wrote this initially. If KSA (now that it has an independent vote) somehow miraculously starts voting against Pakistan, then the criticism aimed at the government is 100% understandable.

Also may I refer to my post 153 in this thread that also talks about some simple historical facts that transcend government to government relations. Something he keeps ignoring for some reason as well. Last time I checked none of us here are King Salman, MbS, Imran Khan etc. or have direct power over foreign policy etc.
 
.
I hope online trolls don't deter you thanx god govt don't decide policies on online forum opinions in that case we may already faced ww4 and 5 too if survive :rofl: sit tight my friend with tomorrow's more US sanction on Iran u r going to face lot and lot of heat from Iranians and their supporters :enjoy::enjoy:
I do not understand why he is attacking me when I am 100% pro Pakistan
 
.
Saudi tumharay baap ka ghulam Hain Jo tumhain bachain ga
When they asked Pakistan to join Yemen war people like you were saying we are not mercenary and on the other hand you expect them to help you whenever you are in need of help

You did not have to go full retard and expose your upbringing. And No, Saudi Arabia is not a slave of anybody's father but since Saudi Arabia is a brotherly Muslim country, it is expected to support Pakistan.

P.S. In which world did I ever say that we shouldn't get involved in the Saudi war in Yemen, find me a single post by myself and I will concede, else you can run and hide in shame.
 
.
.S. In which world did I ever say that we shouldn't get involved in the Saudi war in Yemen, find me a single post by myself and I will concede, else you can run and hide in shame.

I said people like you not you

but since Saudi Arabia is a brotherly Muslim country, it is expected to support Pakistan.

like they expected Pakistan to help them in Yemen war
 
.
Everything good here. Still based in Europe and gaining valuable work experience. Still hellbent on doing everything on my own as much as possible despite constant crying from the family of "help". No fun or challenge using such a tactic even more so when you want to be 100% independent.

Don't be too harsh brother. Pakistan has its important struggles and in my mind needs to rediscover itself (IMO) but similar problems are rampant in the Arab world as well (sadly) and even in KSA things (albeit I will not complain as that would selfish and ungrateful) can and should get better on numerous fronts.

You are probably well aware of KSA-Thailand ties, lol, after that event involving those diamonds etc. A bit of a shame as I have heard that Thailand is very beautiful indeed and there is the Muslim South that we Arabs have had long-term ties with in the past. Having visited Malaysia and Indonesia, I imagine that there must be a lot of similarity weather, cuisine and landscape wise. Did you prefer Thailand over Malaysia?

INteresting. Would love to visit. watched that half Chinese/Half American Youtuber (the one with the many views and funny faces when eating food from across the world) and he is based in Bangkok and I once saw a video where he visited the Muslim South. The cuisine looked absolutely amazing.

BTW, as always I am hoping (as usual) that relations of countries could reflect the people. I honestly believe that without corruption etc. and if the Saudi Arabian and Pakistani people only had a say, that relations would be even much, much closer, more dynamic and even more meaningful.

I might be ignorant here (correct me please) but I like what I have seen from Imran Khan so far and hopefully he can change the Pakistani system from within and fulfill the great potential.

Yes I am aware of the whole diamond saga, however, word on the street is that the Thai government would really want tourists from Saudi and would want a closer cooperation with the Saudi government. This will create a lot of employment opportunities for Thai Muslims (halal tourism).

I prefer Thailand over Malaysia, even though Malaysia is a more developed country. Thailand has that nice balance of being a bit more laid-back, natural, chaotic, and opportunities for being an entrepreneur. The North of Thailand (upwards of Bangkok and all the way to Chiang Mai) are very different than the South (Phuket and all the way down South to Yala/Patani) in terms of people. I prefer the South. The cuisine in the South of Thailand (Yala/Pattani etc.) is quite similar to Malay food, but more spicy. Here is another observation, the ingredients such as the spices, the meat, as well as the vegetables are much better tasting than Malaysia. The people from the Muslim South are quite practising, and deeply respect the Arabs. In fact, when the insurgency was at its peak and the Thai government was cracking down hard, a lot of Muslim Thais went abroad to Egypt, Jordan, Saudi etc to study. I was surprised that some of them can speak fluent Arabic. I know a couple of families who own business in Saudi Arabia as well.

Imran Khan is a man of dignity, honour, and understanding. He's an educated man and someone I am proud to refer to as my Prime Minister. It is evident that the other world leaders also see such qualities in him and accord him the desired respect despite the woeful reputation of Pakistani leaders, Pakistani diplomats, Pakistani people, and the overall nation of Pakistan. InshaAllah I hope he succeeds.
 
.
In which imaginary world is that influence "absolute". Care to explain the Qatar rift/dispute then? Or why Oman is toying their own semi-neutral policy and very pro-India policy to the extend that the Indians have some kind of military presence (apparently if I recall) in Oman? Why are Omani-Iranian ties so close? They just recently held a naval exercise together even! You are blabbering utter nonsense to fit your self-constructed picture.

With such kind of ignorance, it is hard to have any sane discussion.

How many times do you need to be told that KSA DID NOT have a separate vote until this Friday? Or that the GCC does not equal KSA or its whims?

Are you honestly telling me that it was because of Qatar or some other country that Saudi Arabia pulled support from Pakistan at FATF which resulted us in getting Grey listed? You know what the fact of this matter is, it is the fact that we were present at FATF as opposed to many many others on this forum, including you. But let us consider your stand for the time being and wait until the next FATF plenary in 3-4 months and now that SA does have a vote, let's see how SA decides to vote next.



Are you really so sure about that because it has little to do with the real world.

You realize that KSA has been engaged (alongside the Arab coalition and legitimate Yemeni government) with practically zero outside support let alone Western? The same West has not even officially declared the Houthis to be a terrorist group. So much for that support. Western media is toying the Houthi propaganda lie as well ignoring every single Houthi crime or the fact that they are a rogue terrorist cult who make a VIOLENT coup d'etát back in September 2014 which started all the recent mess in the first place!

I am NOT influenced by one sided stories, as it happens I wanted us to participate in Saudi wars and defend Saudi Arabia. Not just that, I have posted, many a time on this forum and others, that we should negotiate with Saudi Arabia and raise a half a million strong military composed of Pakistanis, train and arm them and post them permanently in Saudi Arabia at their disposal. This would take our relation to the next step, create a lot of jobs for Pakistanis and create revenue streams for Pakistan while providing Saudi Arabia will a solid, professional and dedicated Military force.



Which world are you living in when it has been official KSA policy to have at least a degree of ToT in every military deal where this is possible? Have you taken a look at the Saudi Arabian defense industry of late and how it is booming.

I suggest visiting the "Made in KSA" thread on the Arab Section to gain a bit more knowledge as you are clearly not too informed about this topic. Or some of the 10's of threads that I and users like @The SC have created.

I will do this and will get back to you.
 
. .
I said people like you not you

And so you assumed that people like me were against aiding Saudi Arabia whereas people like me were advocating going to Saudi aid ASAP.



like they expected Pakistan to help them in Yemen war

As I recall, it was Imran Khan who forced the then Government of NS to take the matter to Parliament where the move was eventually defeated by PTI and PPP coalition.
 
.
As I recall, it was Imran Khan who forced the then Government of NS to take the matter to Parliament where the move was eventually defeated by PTI and PPP coalition.

Whoever it was i don't care but the reality is Pakistan didn't joined them to please Iranians

And so you assumed that people like me were against aiding Saudi Arabia whereas people like me were advocating going to Saudi aid ASAP.

I assumed this because people like you are always against anything good for Pakistan
 
.
Are you honestly telling me that it was because of Qatar or some other country that Saudi Arabia pulled support from Pakistan at FATF which resulted us in getting Grey listed? You know what the fact of this matter is, it is the fact that we were present at FATF as opposed to many many others on this forum, including you. But let us consider your stand for the time being and wait until the next FATF plenary in 3-4 months and now that SA does have a vote, let's see how SA decides to vote next.





I am NOT influenced by one sided stories, as it happens I wanted us to participate in Saudi wars and defend Saudi Arabia. Not just that, I have posted, many a time on this forum and others, that we should negotiate with Saudi Arabia and raise a half a million strong military composed of Pakistanis, train and arm them and post them permanently in Saudi Arabia at their disposal. This would take our relation to the next step, create a lot of jobs for Pakistanis and create revenue streams for Pakistan while providing Saudi Arabia will a solid, professional and dedicated Military force.





I will do this and will get back to you.

Brother, the GCC is not a single entity let alone a country. It is a 40 year old political organization made up of monarchies that happen to be located in the Arabian Peninsula. Throughout the ages it has developed into a political, economic, military etc. bloc and eased trade, business, create visa-free travel for citizens of the GCC etc. Yet a country like Iraq (that should and WOULD have been a member if not for Saddam) is not a member state, nor Yemen, nor Jordan etc.

I am sure that you have heard about that "little" dispute between KSA, UAE, Bahrain, Egypt etc. on one hand and Qatar and allies on the other hand. I don't want to dwell into the nature of this dispute as it is too complicated and both sides have committed mistakes not to mention that it is completely unnecessary but the conflict exists. Hence KSA and Qatar view things very differently on certain fronts in the region.

Not even going to repeat myself in regards to Oman.

So in conclusion your baseless claim of "KSA as of 2019 having ABSOLUTE control of the GCC" is nonsense with all due respect. Complete and utter nonsense. Not even going to talk about the fact that the GCC is composed of 6 sovereign nations so to claim that GCC = KSA is a fallacy.

Is that not what I wrote from the very beginning before even our discussion? Namely that criticism aimed at KSA's government will be 100% sensible from now on should KSA (now with an independent vote) vote against Pakistan, somehow.

Neither am I. I know Yemen (as a country) very well and the complexity of the Yemeni civil war, the fact that Zaydis of Northern Yemen have close ties to people of Southern KSA on every front etc. That Houthis are a 25 year old cult-like movement who is now hijacking Zaydi (peaceful traditionally) Islam and declaring themselves "leaders and saviors" of the Zaydis of Northern Yemen all while conspiring with an foreign regime (Iran) that is only interested in flaming the flames of the war all while they have no relationship to the Yemeni people, do not share geography nor anything else. Not even going to talk about their non-existent help to Yemen before or after the conflict unlike KSA who has been the economic lifeline of Yemen for numerous decades. Or the fact that KSA supported Northern (Zaydi) Yemen against the communists from the South in the 1960's during the Cold War and the "Arab cold War" between Arab nationalist republics lead by Nasser and anti-communist/socialist monarchies aligned with the West and not the USSR.

You have misunderstood something completely here.

As @Metanoia can attest I was always AGAINST Pakistani support for KSA or the Arab coalition or the legitimate Yemeni government. You know why? Because it is not your war and because this conflict (while unfortunate in its nature) has served as a great lesson and wake up call for KSA and allies. As well as given us invaluable experience in mountain warfare and all kind of warfare (guerrilla etc.) against the most heavily armed militia in the world in highly challenging territory. Also because I believe that it is a joke for the Arab world, even if we only include the GCC, to rely on anyone with our potential, population, resources, economy, HISTORY and LEGACY (military included) etc.

Please do so.

@The SC I am sure will be helpful with all the links as I was not active on PDF for almost 1 year until some weeks ago.

Bro, why do you care so much? Lol. Just ignore.

Well, we all have our faults.:rofl: No harm done. As long as it is civil. Which it has been despite disagreements expect for his uncalled for hidden result that I countered beautifully and objectively. Anyway no harm done, we can all get a bit heated online.

Yes I am aware of the whole diamond saga, however, word on the street is that the Thai government would really want tourists from Saudi and would want a closer cooperation with the Saudi government. This will create a lot of employment opportunities for Thai Muslims (halal tourism).

I prefer Thailand over Malaysia, even though Malaysia is a more developed country. Thailand has that nice balance of being a bit more laid-back, natural, chaotic, and opportunities for being an entrepreneur. The North of Thailand (upwards of Bangkok and all the way to Chiang Mai) are very different than the South (Phuket and all the way down South to Yala/Patani) in terms of people. I prefer the South. The cuisine in the South of Thailand (Yala/Pattani etc.) is quite similar to Malay food, but more spicy. Here is another observation, the ingredients such as the spices, the meat, as well as the vegetables are much better tasting than Malaysia. The people from the Muslim South are quite practising, and deeply respect the Arabs. In fact, when the insurgency was at its peak and the Thai government was cracking down hard, a lot of Muslim Thais went abroad to Egypt, Jordan, Saudi etc to study. I was surprised that some of them can speak fluent Arabic. I know a couple of families who own business in Saudi Arabia as well.

Imran Khan is a man of dignity, honour, and understanding. He's an educated man and someone I am proud to refer to as my Prime Minister. It is evident that the other world leaders also see such qualities in him and accord him the desired respect despite the woeful reputation of Pakistani leaders, Pakistani diplomats, Pakistani people, and the overall nation of Pakistan. InshaAllah I hope he succeeds.

Wonderfully informative post bro.

As you know, KSA hosts one of the largest Rohingya communities in the world and has done so for decades so with Burman being next door to Thailand, it does not surprise me that Thai Muslims have a rather close connection (at least historically but also nowadays it seems as you mention) to KSA and Arabia. They are just rather rare to spot or people might just confuse them for the many Muslim Indonesian, Filipino (naturalized and non-naturalized alike), Malay etc. people that live in KSA. Or maybe at times even the significant Uzbek community, many naturalized as well. Hijaz is truly a melting pot.

Yes, that is my impression of Imran Khan as well. Honesty before anything else. You can see when someone is truly passionate and wants change. I feel the exact same with MbS. Whether the methods or road used by both will succeed only time will tell but I truly hope that they both will as this will no doubt benefit both countries directly or indirectly.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom