What's new

Russia should help India in developing n-triad: expert

RPK

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
6,862
Reaction score
-6
Country
India
Location
United States
Russia should help India in developing n-triad: expert -  International News ? News ? MSN India


Moscow, Oct 5 (PTI) Ahead of Defence Minister Anatoly Serdyukov''s New Delhi visit, a top defence expert has said Russia should help India in developing its "wholesome" nuclear triad to further advance bilateral defence cooperation.

"In my view, Russia must help India in the development of its wholesome nuclear triad, so that it has naval, air and land platforms for its nuclear delivery systems," Ruslan Pukhov, Director of the Moscow-based Centre for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies (CAST) said.

Pukhov is also a member of Public Advisory Board of the Russian Ministry of Defence and will accompany Serdyukov on his New Delhi visit beginning tomorrow during which the India-Russia intergovernmental commission on military- technical cooperation co-chaired by Defence A K Antony is to hold its annual session.

"Why shouldn''t we jointly work for the development of an Indian SSBN (nuclear submarine for launching ballistic missiles)?" Pukhov told PTI.

He suggested that India and Russia could jointly develop a "de facto" common naval system of nuclear deterrence similar to one the US and Britain have.

"In case China develops its fleet of aircraft carriers, Russia could offer Project 949 (Nato codename Oscar-II) nuclear submarines, naval Tu-22M3 bombers and even, although could sound incredible, the nuclear propelled missile cruisers of Project 1144 (Orlan class)," Pukhov said.

Reacting to India''s apprehensions about China''s growing military clout, Pukhov termed as false reports that Moscow was giving superior weapons and technologies to Beijing.

"The type of harmony and complementarity of the military-political interests Russia has with India, will simply never be in our relations with China. This would contradict the elementary norms of geopolitics," he said.

"You will never hear Russian officials expressing concern at the growing Chinese military might, but all of them are well aware of its implications and very well understand that PRC poses a potential threat to Russia''s Far East and Eastern Siberia," he said.

The massive wargames Vostok-2010 (Orient 2010) involving thousand of servicemen and warships in the Far East and Eastern Siberia, during which the Russian troops also practiced the use of tactical nuclear weapons are the reflection of this concern, he said.

"The Indian Air Force''s Sukhoi Su-30MKI is a generation ahead of Su-30MKK/MK2 fighters given to China. Same can be said about Talwar class stealth frigates built for India and ''Sovremenny'' class destroyer sold to China.

"While India and Russia are jointly developing hypersonic BrahMos cruise missiles, fifth generation fighter (FGFA) and futuristic multirole transport aircraft (MTA), no such project is underway with China," Pukhov noted.
 
.
Is another indigenous failure announcement due>??

The submarine isn't doing too well seems like?

After closing a round of US weapon deals India is appeasing its cold-war ally?
 
. .
Is another indigenous failure announcement due>??

The submarine isn't doing too well seems like?

After closing a round of US weapon deals India is appeasing its cold-war ally?

where in the article has India appeased anybody?...if you can read clearly you will find that it was a Russian was giving out those statements ....please read an article fully rather than the bold parts which are to highlight something important
 
.
where in the article has India appeased anybody?...if you can read clearly you will find that it was a Russian was giving out those statements ....please read an article fully rather than the bold parts which are to highlight something important

I did and made the comments in context to Russian sense of humor..pity you don't know the attitude of your "best ally!"

Popular Russian style of mocking someone is to speak of them highly with added spicy comments.
 
.
He suggested that India and Russia could jointly develop a "de facto" common naval system of nuclear deterrence similar to one the US and Britain have.

"In case China develops its fleet of aircraft carriers, Russia could offer Project 949 (Nato codename Oscar-II) nuclear submarines, naval Tu-22M3 bombers and even, although could sound incredible, the nuclear propelled missile cruisers of Project 1144 (Orlan class)," Pukhov said.

I liked this part..Tu22M3 and Orlan class cruisers are the systems which i would love to see in IN inventory....Lets see when Russia offers them..
BTW this statement coming 2 months before the arrival of Russian premier and highchances of Re-election of PUTIN in next term is very very interesting..
 
.
I did and made the comments in context to Russian sense of humor..pity you don't know the attitude of your "best ally!"

Popular Russian style of mocking someone is to speak of them highly with added spicy comments.

that was a pathetic attempt to cover up for your hastiness in bashing india
 
. .
I liked this part..Tu22M3 and Orlan class cruisers are the systems which i would love to see in IN inventory....Lets see when Russia offers them..
BTW this statement coming 2 months before the arrival of Russian premier and highchances of Re-election of PUTIN in next term is very very interesting

NAVY ALREADY HAS 4 TU 22M thats wat wiki tells us but this is news to me,can anybody confirm??
 
Last edited:
.
Is another indigenous failure announcement due>??

The submarine isn't doing too well seems like?

After closing a round of US weapon deals India is appeasing its cold-war ally?
:blah:

wait a moment my dear friend n chek who is appeasing n whom:lol:
btw u have any indigenous submarine programme?
 
.
You didnt see the lines...

The writer wants defence co-op far beyond buyer/seller rel. And and cement it on the lines of US-UK relations....

The Best Defence Tech is Shared equally... And Its like We face common threats and counter them jointly.... And if you consider, Russia .. India is the Best suited ally..
 
.
You didnt see the lines...

The writer wants defence co-op far beyond buyer/seller rel. And and cement it on the lines of US-UK relations....

The Best Defence Tech is Shared equally... And Its like We face common threats and counter them jointly.... And if you consider, Russia .. India is the Best suited ally..

who want to see the line lol
 
. .
Is another indigenous failure announcement due>??

The submarine isn't doing too well seems like?

After closing a round of US weapon deals India is appeasing its cold-war ally?

Which one are you talking about? Tell us some. If a Russian diplomat proposing close cooperation between India and Russia in the line of UK-USA is that make anything failure?!!! Strange!!! than all of the UK's nuke delivery platforms are also failure. :rolleyes:

Conspiracy is good but repeating it every time makes it funny.
 
.
The most important part to me is this one:

You will never hear Russian officials expressing concern at the growing Chinese military might, but all of them are well aware of its implications and very well understand that PRC poses a potential threat to Russia''s Far East and Eastern Siberia," he said

There is a lot of talk these days that India swift towards the US, especially with China in mind, but this quote makes clear why Russia is the better alley for India with China in mind. Because both countries have land borders with China and acknowledge them as a possible threat for our sovereignty.
The US instead acknowledge as a rising power, but has no immediate threat because of them, "only" alley countries like South Korea, Japan and of course Taiwan have the risk here.
It's good to have the US closer to us, moreover it's good to have closer relations to Japan and S. Korea, but in a war situation only the Russians could pose a real threat to China with a second front.
And it seems that the Russians hopes for the same in return, in case their eastern borders are in trouble too.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom