Roadside bomb kills three U.S. troops near Afghan city of Ghazni

[YeBeWarned]

You are correct that it is time for US to leave. It is also time for the Afghan leadership to learn not make the same mistake as their predecessors -- Mullah Omar and company.

Which leadership ? the one America backs , or the One's Afghans wants ? Last time i remember Afghans give Authority to Taliban to lead them so America invade them , come on man you know America has to invade Afghanistan not for WoT but for its own self interest , Destabilizing Pakistan , keeping eye on China etc

They want to guard the poppy fields and a backdoor to russia for containment

That's a billions of dollars worth of Business .. seems like Americans are dying in Afghanistan for some Hashish

 

[GiannKall]

In last three years 30000 or 30 Afghan soldiers?

https://www.rferl.org/a/ghani-says-...ce-2015-partial-nato-withdrawal/29605544.html

Afghan president has admitted that since 2015, 29.000 soldiers have been killed. So who cares about 3 US soldiers

 

[YeBeWarned]

https://www.rferl.org/a/ghani-says-...ce-2015-partial-nato-withdrawal/29605544.html

Afghan president has admitted that since 2015, 29.000 soldiers have been killed. So who cares about 3 US soldiers

Afghans fighting and Dying for their Country, what Americans are fighting and dying for ???
you can't win a insurgency as a invading force, I am shocked that America continue this even after their exit from Iraq admitting that they failed there as well ..

 

[gambit]

Which leadership ? the one America backs , or the One's Afghans wants ?

Does not matter which.

Last time i remember Afghans give Authority to Taliban to lead them so America invade them , come on man you know America has to invade Afghanistan not for WoT but for its own self interest , Destabilizing Pakistan , keeping eye on China etc

Actually, no.

We invaded Afghanistan because Mullah Omar hosted Osama bin Laden and Al-Qaeda. We pleaded with Omar for TEN YRS to stop.

Do not say anything about your memory because simply -- you do not have any. I was an adult when 9/11 happened.

 

[YeBeWarned]

Does not matter which.


Actually, no.

We invaded Afghanistan because Mullah Omar hosted Osama bin Laden and Al-Qaeda. We pleaded with Omar for TEN YRS to stop.

Do not say anything about your memory because simply -- you do not have any. I was an adult when 9/11 happened.

I think it does matter which leadership Afghans choose for themselves, You would't like if some other country decide which leader will be ruling America..

You invaded Afghanistan in 2001 , same year as 9/11 happened .. so even if wasn't as that old but at least i understand America did give them few months at most before invading .. Plus You did not pleaded with anyone , you just give an ultimatum to Afghans to hand over OBL , despite knowing that Afghan culture is highly based on tribal customs which will not hand over a guest .. I am sure CIA has done their homework before that .

 

[GiannKall]

Actually, no.

We invaded Afghanistan because Mullah Omar hosted Osama bin Laden and Al-Qaeda. We pleaded with Omar for TEN YRS to stop.

Do not say anything about your memory because simply -- you do not have any. I was an adult when 9/11 happened.

The same excuse for Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria, Yemen wars...Oh wait

 

[Trango Towers]

hmmm rip to the fallen hero ( obviously the IED ) .

Ouch....thats real tongue and cheek

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/26/...fghanistan.html#click=https://t.co/T5tia548ud

In other news American and Czech soldier beat to death an Afghan soldier

It took two cowards to beat one afghan. We may not like them but we prefer them to americans and indians

I think it does matter which leadership Afghans choose for themselves, You would't like if some other country decide which leader will be ruling America..

You invaded Afghanistan in 2001 , same year as 9/11 happened .. so even if wasn't as that old but at least i understand America did give them few months at most before invading .. Plus You did not pleaded with anyone , you just give an ultimatum to Afghans to hand over OBL , despite knowing that Afghan culture is highly based on tribal customs which will not hand over a guest .. I am sure CIA has done their homework before that .

GAMBIT IS INDIAN

 

[hunter_hunted]

Hmmm...Another masturbation thread for those too chickenshit to come out behind their keyboards.

You kill afghans or afghan kill you, both are same for us.

 

[gambit]

I think it does matter which leadership Afghans choose for themselves, You would't like if some other country decide which leader will be ruling America..

It does not matter which, as long as they learned the hard lesson we gave.

Plus You did not pleaded with anyone , you just give an ultimatum to Afghans to hand over OBL , despite knowing that Afghan culture is highly based on tribal customs which will not hand over a guest .. I am sure CIA has done their homework before that .

If your guest committed crimes, and you know it, would you still host him as the codes of hospitality expects? I doubt it.

In this case, the 'crime' was war against the US. Mullah Omar knew it. It is also common sense in war that if you allow your land to be used as a base by one party in the war, you forfeit any kind of moral protection. Am sure Omar understood that as well.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

https://www.rferl.org/a/ghani-says-...ce-2015-partial-nato-withdrawal/29605544.html

Afghan president has admitted that since 2015, 29.000 soldiers have been killed. So who cares about 3 US soldiers

3 US soldiers have died. Who cares about 30,000 Afghan soldiers.

Anyway, I find it hard to believe the figure of 30,000.

 

[Zibago]

You are correct that it is time for US to leave. It is also time for the Afghan leadership to learn not make the same mistake as their predecessors -- Mullah Omar and company.

Afghanistan will plunge into civil war soon US can only delay it and hurt itself in the process

 

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

It's terrible. The vast majority of US soldiers is Mexican American young men who join the army just to go to college. RIP.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

Big deal for colonialists. Considering the fact that in the last 3 years 30.000 Afghan soldiers have being killed its nothing

Afghans are cannon fodders.

 

[YeBeWarned]

GAMBIT IS INDIAN

No he is not, he is one of the Professional well knowledgeable person on PDF.

It does not matter which, as long as they learned the hard lesson we gave.

You know Afghans might say the same when America will leave Afghanistan ..

If your guest committed crimes, and you know it, would you still host him as the codes of hospitality expects? I doubt it.

In this case, the 'crime' was war against the US. Mullah Omar knew it. It is also common sense in war that if you allow your land to be used as a base by one party in the war, you forfeit any kind of moral protection. Am sure Omar understood that as well.

Its not my code but Tribal's , As for a criminal If America wants to negotiate with Mullah Omar, they would have given him more time to think/Investigate/conclude , Taliban could have been persuaded to avoid a blood bath but truth is that America didn't even wait for 6 months after 9/11 ..

If i go by your logic, than why you didn't Attack KSA ? majority of the Attackers were Saudi's and yet America still to this date are their allies .. Taliban are not well educated you can't expect to bring some evidence which is not even backed by American courts and blame someone , than ask to hand over .. as i say Tribal culture does not work like that, If An American is their Host, and some Communist ask them to hand him over these Tribal would fight to protect him as well to their own death ..

 

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

I guess Iran can arm Taliban with ATGM to target US army vehicles in Afghanistan?