What's new

REMEMBERING THE ETHNIC CLEANSING OF THE MIDDLE EAST'S JEWS

Solomon2

BANNED
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
19,475
Reaction score
-37
Country
United States
Location
United States
245904

COMMENT: REMEMBERING THE ETHNIC CLEANSING OF THE MIDDLE EAST'S JEWS
BY TZAHI GAVRIELI

NOVEMBER 29, 2017 11:57

This is the untold story of the Jewish forgotten refugees. These Jews, who survived ethnic cleansing and were systematically expelled, were now forgotten.

The Forgotten Refugees (YouTube / 4IL)

My family was expelled from Iraq in 1951. My grandfather Haim owned a successful business with several trucks, while my grandmother Gazelle ran the home. They lived in a spacious three-story house while maintaining a simple life. For years my grandparents tried to maintain a good relationship with their Arab neighbors while practing the same Jewish traditions that had been passed down in Iraq for centuries.

All this came crashing down within weeks. With the creation of Israel, the Iraqi government declared that all of their property was to be stripped from them and nationalized while the local Jewish population was to be expelled. The authorities let these soon-to-be refugees leave with only one suitcase each after it had been carefully searched to ensure no gold or jewelry was taken with them. My 4-year-old mother took her favorite rag doll, which served as a solemn reminder for decades to come of our family’s storied past in Iraq.


Just like my family, hundreds of thousands of Jews were expelled from many other Arab countries and Iran. They had to leave everything they cared for behind, their homes, loved ones and possessions, while making their way to Israel.

They ventured into the unknown to come to a new country struggling for its survival. They lived in tents and tin shacks, lived with food rationing, were given new names and began their new lives. With nothing but a suitcase and a rag doll, my family was expelled from a country they had resided in for hundreds of years.

In 1948, the year Israel was declared a state, 265,000 Jews lived in Morocco, 150,000 in Iraq, 140,000 in Algeria, 100,000 in Egypt, 100,000 in Tunisia, 55,000 in Lebanon, 40,000 in Libya, 30,000 in Syria and thousands more throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa, for a grand total of 880,000. Shortly thereafter, over 850,000 Jews were expelled from the very countries they called home. The Arab League rejected the establishment of the State of Israel and ultimately decided in forcing out the absolute majority of Jews from their countries.


My family’s expulsion happened overnight but not before being preceded by years of persecution against Iraq’s local Jewish population. My grandmother would tell my siblings and me about how her family had to hide in June 1941 during the “Farhud”, a two day pogrom of mass murder, looting and terror against Iraq’s Jewish population. 179 were killed, 2,100 were wounded, 242 children were orphaned and more than 50,000 households and businesses were ransacked.

Then, in 1947, the demonstrations against the UN resolution on the establishment of a Jewish state brought up memories of the Farhud and led the Jewish population to go into hiding once again. Hundreds of kilometers away in the city of Aleppo in Syria the situation and results were all too familiar: 75 Jews were murdered, a fifth-century synagogue was destroyed and hundreds of homes were devastated.

This is the untold story of the Jewish forgotten refugees. In the Palestinian struggle to preserve the narrative of refugees, it was all too easy to conceal the fact that nearly one million Jews were forcibly banished their homes. These Jews, who survived ethnic cleansing and were systematically expelled, were now forgotten.

It is precisely because of this that the US House of Representatives decided in 2008, with House Resolution 185, to recognize the importance of the Jewish refugees from the Arab countries and Iran. And precisely because of this, the government of Israel recognized their rights and dedicated November 30th as a day marking “Jews who were forced to flee Arab countries”.

This date is not coincidental. The day after November 29 1947, when the United Nations General Assembly decided to establish a Jewish state in British Mandate Palestine, many Jewish communities in Arab countries immediately began feeling the pressure to leave. There was looting, riots and laws enacted against them and the Zionist movement.

The young State of Israel, while fighting for its very existence, absorbed hundreds of thousands of Jews from surrounding countries. Under conditions of extreme poverty, a severe lack of resources, being housed in transit camps, without knowing the language and regardless of their relatives left behind, these refugees started over.

Seventy years after the United Nations established a Jewish state in the Land of Israel, hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees from Arab countries and Iran are still living in Israel. Many of them, including my mother, remember the exact moment they became refugees and how hard it was in the beginning to start from scratch. But they decided to build again, to give up their refugee narrative, to understand that the years following World War II created a new reality for not only themselves, but tens of millions of others as well.

The Jewish refugees from the Arab countries and Iran, together with hundreds of thousands of other Jewish refugees from Europe, built, created and persisted in order to establish a family, a state and a future for their people.

On the other hand, the preservation of the seven decade old narrative of Palestinian refugees is still in full force. It continues to serve political goals and is used as a tool to delegitimize Israel and not recognize it as the homeland of the Jewish people. The call for the return of millions of Palestinian refugees to Israel is just another means in the quest to destroy the Jewish state.

On this day, the story of the forgotten refugees needs to be told. Fortunately, these refugees had Israel as a home to take them in. Many of them never survived the deadly pogroms suffered at the hands of Arab regimes. It is for this reason it is so important to learn their story, for any injustice somewhere, is a threat to justice everywhere.


The author is the Director of the National Campaign for Countering De-Legitimization & Deputy Director General at the Ministry of Strategic Affairs and Public Diplomacy. The Video was produced by the Ministry's 4IL campaign
 
.
Solomon2 comment: The article is good but the author forgot one important thing: the Jews' expulsion from Middle East countries was illegal, a violation of the post-WWI Mandates which established not just the Palestine Mandate, but those of Iraq and Syria and Jordan as well, thus calling into question the legitimacy of those regimes.

By contrast, Israel's expulsion of hostile Arabs and its refusal to allow them to return afterwards was and is legal. That's because under the Palestine Mandate the Jews not just gained political rights but retained the civil and property rights they had under the Ottomans - including the right to peace and security. And the Ottomans' punishment for civil rebellion was expulsion or death.

Ben-Gurion trained as an Ottoman lawyer. He knew what he was doing.
 
Last edited:
. .
That was a valid comment Solomon2 but sadly, a situation
being lawful doesn't equate being just!

For most of the duration of the Shoah, the process was lawful.
Of course under a regime void of any trait of humanity but ...
lawful nonetheless!

Slavery was lawful a while ago ... somewhere it was solved with
a powerful law : the 13th Amendment and yet that perfection of
intent had to be completed by the 14th Amendment to work out
... only to give us the Corporation and again less moral in the end.

I'm neutral-good myself.

Have a good day mensch, Tay.
 
.
live and let live should be the policy. The idea of uprooting ppl just bcos they are not like themselves is horrible. I like idea of EU not only they allow free movement of ppl but also have overcome the prejudices of nationalism or religion.
 
.
By contrast, Israel's expulsion of hostile Arabs and its refusal to allow them to return afterwards was and is legal.

Bull shit, Jews from every where from Poland to Russia to France subjugating and trying to ethnically cleanse was legal?????

The only world where the above is legal is in a world where burning Jews in ovens is legal
 
.
BS article, full of lies..Jews were never expulsed from any Arab land.. they were rather not allowed to join Usrael..
 
.
That was a valid comment Solomon2 but sadly, a situation
being lawful doesn't equate being just!
True. But does that really apply to "the Palestinian cause"? Pakistan's politics demand you say "yes" but what is the real truth?

Have a good day mensch, Tay.
Thanks. Out of time, we'll work on this next week. Toodles!
 
.
Bull shit, Jews from every where from Poland to Russia to France subjugating and trying to ethnically cleanse was legal?????

The only world where the above is legal is in a world where burning Jews in ovens is legal
Lawyers have determined that the most reasonable paths for determine what is legal and what is illegal, is to use the laws created by the Ottomans before they signed away their claims.

The laws of the Ottomans were designed to allow the Ottomans to legally take over land abandoned by the previous users.

If a piece of land is not used, the ”owner” loses the ownership to the state.
The term is ”Dead Land”.
By making unwanted citizens flee, they enriched themselves. Many Greeks lost their property in what is now modern day Turkey this way.

If the inhabitants flee, like many Palestinians did, incited by the neighbouring countries did,
they also lost ownership.

Ownership was not formalized until late in the Ottoman Empire. No papers.
When the Empire started to register ownership, there were significant drawbacks in registering yourself as an owner, making yourself liable for taxation and perhaps military services.
Local farmers did not register themselves as owners.
Whether this was because they did not own the land, they were trying to outsmart the Empire,
or they were simply unaware of the importance of beeing the registered owner is not known.
Somehow, the legal ownership of the land were a few landlords, who were all too happy to
sell off their lands to immigrant jews, converting low yielding lands to hard cash.

The jews, having bought the property to establish kibbutzes, naturally wanted to assume
full ownership, and terminates leases.
All perfectly legal, but not very popular with the evicted farmers.

The Israeli Supreme Court has established that Israel, as the occupying power on the West Bank,
is the natural successor to the Ottoman Empire.
The occupying power do not have the rights to change the property laws, so they remain.
The Israeli Government thus makes claim to any Dead Land within the West Bank - fully legal.
That is why You find settlements on rocky hilltops.
They cannot be farmed, and can be legally taken over.
There are quite a lot of settlements which are established, not according to the law of Dead Land, and the Israeli courts are known to reject such settlements after lawsuits,
often initiated by Israeli organisations.

@Taygibay is 100% correct that something beeing legal, does not equate to it beeing just.

This is not a venue explored by the Palestinians and supporters which adamantly argues
the legality of the situation, which must be deemed a futile effort.

In the end, the blame must be on the Ottoman Empire, and the Arabs enriching themselves.
The current leadership of both Israel and the Palestinians are not prepared to make the neccessary compromises needed.
 
.
If the inhabitants flee, like many Palestinians did, incited by the neighbouring countries did,
they also lost ownership.

Balls!!!!

Ottomans, Lawyers, Dead Land, your not a jew are you, because it sounds like your trying to justify and legalise what is simple theft, occupation and colonial subjugation

That of non locals turning up snd stealing the homes and lands of the local population
 
.
Balls!!!!

Ottomans, Lawyers, Dead Land, your not a jew are you, because it sounds like your trying to justify and legalise what is simple theft, occupation and colonial subjugation

That of non locals turning up snd stealing the homes and lands of the local population

You mean that if foreigners turn up bringing their brethren, and cashing in 91%
of the revenue, leaving 9% for the locals, it is illegal?
Does that sound illegal to you?
Sounds like a business agreement to me...

When You enter a country according to immigration laws, buy land from the locals and start farming on the land you bought, it is neither illegal, nor colonization.

I have been in a Synagogue once, in the US, attending a party when I was on a child exchange.
If that converts me from Christianity to become Jew, it is more contagious than Ebola :D.
 
.
You mean that if foreigners turn up bringing their brethren, and cashing in 91%
of the revenue, leaving 9% for the locals, it is illegal?
Does that sound illegal to you?
Sounds like a business agreement to me...

When You enter a country according to immigration laws, buy land from the locals and start farming on the land you bought, it is neither illegal, nor colonization.

I have been in a Synagogue once, in the US, attending a party when I was on a child exchange.
If that converts me from Christianity to become Jew, it is more contagious than Ebola :D.

We have an business deal with chinese allies, they can prosper under the law and business deal as much as they want

What they cant do is claim the entire country subjugate and kill the locals, they csn buy a house but they can't drive local people from their homes and then claim them

Even if the jews bought all the houses on a street they cant claim the street

What they did was enact a colonial plan worked out decades previously to steal the land

Why should muslims, arabs, palestinians accept it and surrender and not fight for their rights and land

Where they are either occupied or second class citizens, where a jew from the opposite side of the world can come and supercede them in terms of rights
 
.
We have an business deal with chinese allies, they can prosper under the law and business deal as much as they want

What they cant do is claim the entire country subjugate and kill the locals, they csn buy a house but they can't drive local people from their homes and then claim them

Even if the jews bought all the houses on a street they cant claim the street

What they did was enact a colonial plan worked out decades previously to steal the land

Why should muslims, arabs, palestinians accept it and surrender and not fight for their rights and land

Where they are either occupied or second class citizens, where a jew from the opposite side of the world can come and supercede them in terms of rights
You are soo lucky, that the Ottomans did not write Your laws then.
If someone leave the house, voluntarily or involuntarily, it can be confiscated
according to Ottoman law.
When the Palestinians left to allow the Arab armies to slaughter jews,
they forfeited their rights according to the Ottoman law.

Why should Muslims accept a law designed to allow muslims to ”steal” from non muslims,
when it works the other way? You tell me...

E37DA235-F0E8-435A-BB74-B823E98F66EF.jpeg
 
Last edited:
.
When the Palestinians left to allow the Arab armies to slaughter jews,

The above is jew propaganda!!

They began to slaughter, murder and run off arabs from their homes and lands and then stole their homes and lands as the arabs became refugees..

The propaganda machine them went into business and suddenly you have this jew blood libel against innocent refugees who have lost their homes because jews wanted a state in the middle east a Plan they had come up with almost a century prior to it being implemented


Why should palestinians, muslims, arabs or any decent right minded human being tolerate such injustice and not support the Palestinians in increasing their population and fighting for their rights, homes against a apartheid, colonial occupation by foreign jews
 
.
The above is jew propaganda!!

They began to slaughter, murder and run off arabs from their homes and lands and then stole their homes and lands as the arabs became refugees..

The propaganda machine them went into business and suddenly you have this jew blood libel against innocent refugees who have lost their homes because jews wanted a state in the middle east a Plan they had come up with almost a century prior to it being implemented


Why should palestinians, muslims, arabs or any decent right minded human being tolerate such injustice and not support the Palestinians in increasing their population and fighting for their rights, homes against a apartheid, colonial occupation by foreign jews

You must have been getting a ”custom” education.
It would probably help if you widened your sources, instead of only reading modern
equivalents of Der Stürmer.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom