Remembering non Muslims who chose Pakistan over India.

[itsanufy]

@Baibars_1260 , do you know who was
Jogendra Nath Mandal

 

[Baibars_1260]

@Baibars_1260 , do you know who was
Jogendra Nath Mandal

He chose Pakistan and then went to India. So did L.K. Advani, Jagan Nath Azad and Gopi Chand Narang .
Likewise there were people in India who chose India then went to Pakistan like General Rahimuddin Khan who was the nephew of the President of India Zakir Husain. But Rahimuddin Khan doesn't count because he was a Muslim.
This thread is about Non-Muslims who belonged to Pakistan and stayed in Pakistan .
Like Tirath Khemlani and Justice Rana Bhagwan Das.

 

[Dalit]

RSS arse on fire. I love it how these sanghis and pajeets burn in every Pakistani topic. It gives immense pleasure.

 

[padamchen]

Doc - you need to come out of a patriarchal mindset. Parsis need to consider men and women as equal.

If Ruttie ceased to be Parsi due to her marriage to a Muslim, then by your own logic, Dina ceased to be a Muslim due to her marriage to a Parsi.

It's got nothing to do with marriage.

Anyways, this is not the thread for it.

Hindus decide who is bamman and who is shudra.

Muslims decide all the time who is Muslim and who is kafir.

Similarly Zoroastrians too follow the tenets of their very ancient faith and there is a Zoroastrian here telling you what it is.

You are making the mistake of assuming he is debating with you.

Cheers, Doc

 

[WinterFangs]

the amount of saltiness I see in this thread is sad.

 

[colonel rajesh]

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=10158591056487663&id=146828502662

We tell the story of non Muslim heroes who chose Pakistan over India during the Pakistan Movement.

Share - Like - Follow Pakistan Defence for more original stories.

mr mandal the first law minister was forced to leave pakistan because mullas were not ready to tolerate a hindu minister .

 

[Sheikh Rauf]

mr mandal the first law minister was forced to leave pakistan because mullas were not ready to tolerate a hindu minister .

It was a mistake we regret it but india is still doing it.

 

[srshkmr]

This is what it is.

Technically, per the true Zoroastrian orthodoxy, Ruttie ceased to be Mazdayasni too.

It's only over the last 10-15 years that Indian courts have forced their pseudo-secular liberal interpretation of personal faith on to us.

Simply put, we donot even accept Juddin blood as transfusions, and arrange for Zoroastrian donors.

You are saying a half Muslim is a Parsi?

Cheers, Doc

Does that list include not eating food that was not grown, made by Zoroastrians, and Medicines that were not developed by Zoroastrians?

 

[padamchen]

Does that list include not eating food that was not grown, made by Zoroastrians, and Medicines that were not developed by Zoroastrians?

No it does not.

Both are ingested, processed, excreted.

No different from air or water.

Cheers, Doc

 

[srshkmr]

No it does not.

Both are ingested, processed, excreted.

No different from air or water.

Cheers, Doc

Well in the same technicality blood contains plasma, RBC, WBC, and platelets.

 

[padamchen]

Well in the same technicality blood contains plasma, RBC, WBC, and platelets.

Ancient Aryan religions (yours included, just that you've mingled too much and been way too secularised and liberalized over the centuries of rule of foreign semitiic ideas) do not look at blood and life force and the energy portal between man and his God in quite the same way.

Our Juddin are what were your Mlecchas.

Think Avatar. And the holy tree.

That is the Atash for the Mazdayasnis and Ahura Mazda.

Anything that defiles or breaks that portal is quickly removed. And the portal energy cleansed.

Cheers, Doc

 

[itsanufy]

He chose Pakistan and then went to India. So did L.K. Advani, Jagan Nath Azad and Gopi Chand Narang .
Likewise there were people in India who chose India then went to Pakistan like General Rahimuddin Khan who was the nephew of the President of India Zakir Husain. But Rahimuddin Khan doesn't count because he was a Muslim.
This thread is about Non-Muslims who belonged to Pakistan and stayed in Pakistan .
Like Tirath Khemlani and Justice Rana Bhagwan Das.

Rahimuddin Khan choosing India first then going to Pakistan is not known to me. Can you provide more details of he being moving out.

But Mondal was one of the 96 founding fathers of Pakistan, he was in the first cabinet of Pakistan and a minster of Minister of Law and Labour. You must be knowing the later history.

 

[SoulSpokesman]

With due respects Doc @padamchen being a Parsi and being well versed in the Zoroastrian law and tradition needs to decide who is a Parsi or not. Dina, Nusli they are all good Indians and human beings, but if they dont qualify as being Parsis, let that be,

To answer someone's Q here, possibly Dina wasnt a Parsi at birth and ceased to be Muslim by marriage. No great tragedy if you ask me.

Regards

 

[padamchen]

With due respects Doc @padamchen being a Parsi and being well versed in the Zoroastrian law and tradition needs to decide who is a Parsi or not. Dina, Nusli they are all good Indians and human beings, but if they dont qualify as being Parsis, let that be,

To answer someone's Q here, possibly Dina wasnt a Parsi at birth and ceased to be Muslim by marriage. No great tragedy if you ask me.

Regards

So it's interesting.

Parsi is a ethnoreligious term.

Zoroastrian a religious one. Formal ... divinely ordained.

Dina was born a half Parsi by blood.

But every Parsi child becomes (is ordained into the fold of the faith) a full-fledged Zoroastrian only after his or her Navjote (Sudreh Pooshi) sacred investiture ceremony before puberty.

So it's possible for a born Parsi not to grow up to be a Zoroastrian.

Cheers, Doc

 

[SoulSpokesman]

@padamchen

Thanks, Doc for clarifying.

Regards