Punjab: Muslims Families Hide in Riverbed After Being Driven From Hoshiarpur Villages

[Maxpane]

Its there fault for not leaving


I know a lot of people in Sialkot who migrated from that place

my grand grand motger was from sialkot and they migrated from amritsar

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

we should send bangles to Indian Muslims.

This thread is not about Indian Muslims. It's about Punjabi Muslims.

Moreover I think all this is a drama to cry, "We are being oppressed."

- PRTP GWD

 

[jamahir]

The prevalent leftist culture there aside, they're just producing a factory of main stream lemmings.

JNU, other than its humanities courses ( political and social sciences ), also has technological science courses. Former JNU students like Kanhaiya, Shehla and Umar should devote some time to create a syncretic education system for the entire country by fusing JNU's humanities courses and its technological courses.

 

[peagle]

That is why countries like North Korea restrict access to social media. Ordinary people do not think deeply and are susceptible to rumors and misguidance.

And social rumors and misguidance in India have come also because the Indian education system largely makes one just literate and not educated.

You cannot lay blame on this, that and everything else, this does not happen in other countries and if it does it is a rare occurrence. In India, it has been happening regularly for decades and for the last many years it has become much worse. You people need to realise that India is full of hate.

There is always someone to blame, a minority group or Muslims or China and especially the favorite target Pakistan which also ends up effecting local Muslims again. Unless and until you people learn to stop blaming and stop hating, this will never stop and will destroy your country.

Seriously stop before it is too late.

 

[jamahir]

You cannot lay blame on this, that and everything else, this does not happen in other countries and if it does it is a rare occurrence. You people need to realise that India is full of hate.

There is always someone to blame, a minority group or Muslims or China and especially the favorite target Pakistan which also ends up effecting local Muslims again. Unless and until you people learn to stop blaming and stop hating, this will never stop and will destroy your country.

Seriously stop before it is too late.

I agree that India is a bunch of pockets of different communities resentful of each other but joined together by a common economic system and a vague sense of Hindu nationalism.

But I must also say that the literate-but-uneducated thing is also true of other South Asian countries. Don't you know of people collecting in mosques in Pakistan on a Friday despite government order of lock-down ??

All of South Asia must learn to evolve.

By the way, don't we also know of violent quarrels in Western shops for toilet paper and other essentials in the last few weeks ??

 

[padamchen]

I agree that India is a bunch of pockets of different communities resentful of each other but joined together by a common economic system and a vague sense of Hindu nationalism.

But I must also say that the literate-but-uneducated thing is also true of other South Asian countries. Don't you know of people collecting in mosques in Pakistan on a Friday despite government order of lock-down ??

All of South Asia must learn to evolve.

I disagree strongly.

India is a civilization now moulded together in a modern nation construct.

An unbroken civilization that's the oldest living one on earth.

 

[peagle]

I agree that India is a bunch of pockets of different communities resentful of each other but joined together by a common economic system and a vague sense of Hindu nationalism.

But I must also say that the literate-but-uneducated thing is also true of other South Asian countries. Don't you know of people collecting in mosques in Pakistan on a Friday despite government order of lock-down ??

All of South Asia must learn to evolve.

They don't go around hunting, killing and massacring minorities. Forcing them to eat cow dung and drink cow urine, or anything remotely similar.

I am glad you recognize the jigsaw puzzle that is India, but most of your compatriots do not. This false belief in historical Indian unity and the nostalgia of Bharat Mata is what is driving this hate. This hateful atmosphere will stop by recognizing the differences within India and the region, and moving forward towards a peaceful future.

I for one would love to visit Pakistan, take a train to Dehli or elsewhere and be back in Pakistan the same evening or next morning. This cannot happen if the mindset in India does not change.

 

[jamahir]

I disagree strongly.

India is a civilization now moulded together in a modern nation construct.

I understand you say that because of existence of Hinduism which is perhaps just over 3000 years old.

An unbroken civilization that's the oldest living one on earth.

Disagree.

West Asia, Egypt and also Sudan I think.

 

[padamchen]

They don't go around hunting, killing and massacring minorities. Forcing them to eat cow dung and drink cow urine, or anything remotely similar.

I am glad you recognize the jigsaw puzzle that is India, but most of your compatriots do not. This false belief in historical Indian unity and the nostalgia of Bharat Mata is what is driving this hate. This hateful atmosphere will stop by recognizing the differences within India and the region, and moving forward towards a peaceful future.

I for one would love to visit Pakistan, take a train to Dehli or elsewhere and be back in Pakistan the same evening or next morning. This cannot happen if the mindset in India does not change.

You would or may love it.

What's actually relevant is whether 1.3 billion of us would love it.

You don't drive national discourse in India.

You merely watch it unfold on TV and Twitter and WhatsApp.

 

[jamahir]

I for one would love to visit Pakistan, take a train to Dehli or elsewhere and be back in Pakistan the same evening or next morning. This cannot happen if the mindset in India does not change.

OK.

 

[padamchen]

I understand you say that because of existence of Hinduism which is perhaps just over 3000 years old.



Disagree.

West Asia, Egypt and also Sudan I think.

Bollocks.

A civilization is

Blood

Faith

Soil

Remove one and the thread continuum of that civilization is broken.

None of your examples have all three that have endured.

 

[jamahir]

Bollocks.

A civilization is

Blood

Faith

Soil

Remove one and the thread continuum of that civilization is broken.

None of your examples have all three that have endured.

You place too much stress on blood and faith. Yaar, it is 2020.

And isn't Damascus the oldest continuously inhabited city ??

 

[peagle]

You would or may love it.

What's actually relevant is whether 1.3 billion of us would love it.

You don't drive national discourse in India.

You merely watch it unfold on TV and Twitter and WhatsApp.

I really don't know what point you are trying to make???
Please be clear.

I have no intention of driving any discourse in India if I look at it from a pure political nation-state viewpoint. Please keep doing what you are doing, it is great. I hope Modi/BJP/RSS rule India for the next 50 years. If India survives for that long if things stay as they are.

But, as someone who sincerely believes we are the same people, not the same historical country which is a false understanding of South Asian history, and as the same people and as someone who wishes for a better future, I am merely trying to point out the obvious. Hoping you guys will see sense very soon.

Please wake up.

 

[padamchen]

I really don't know what point you are trying to make???
Please be clear.

I have no intention of driving any discourse in India if I look at it from a pure political nation-state viewpoint. Please keep doing what you are doing, it is great. I hope Modi/BJP/RSS rule India for the next 50 years. If India survives for that long if things stay as they are.

But, as someone who sincerely believes we are the same people, not the same historical country which is a false understanding of South Asian history, and as the same people and as someone who wishes for a better future, I am merely trying to point out the obvious. Hoping you guys will see sense very soon.

Please wake up.

One would argue that the Hindu has woken up.

You place too much stress on blood and faith. Yaar, it is 2020.

And isn't Damascus the oldest continuously inhabited city ??

No.

Banaras is.

And blood and faith is what makes a man.

The two on the soil a civilization.

 

[Nilgiri]

And isn't Damascus the oldest continuously inhabited city ??

Look up where damascus steel came from