What's new

Public debt swells to Rs39.9tr

muhammadhafeezmalik

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
5,417
Reaction score
-17
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Public debt swells to Rs39.9tr

Government adds Rs15tr to debt in three years, according to central bank data

The government has added Rs14.9 trillion to the public debt during almost three years in power, which is equal to 140% of the total debt the previous Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government acquired in five years, shattering Prime Minister Imran Khan’s dream of reducing the burden.


According to the State Bank of Pakistan’s (SBP) annual debt bulletin, released on Monday, the public debt increased to Rs39.9 trillion by June this year, an addition of Rs14.9 trillion within three years.
The total public debt increased by a whopping 60% from July 2018 to June 2021, an unsustainable 20% increase on average each year.

The addition of Rs14.907 trillion to the public debt in just three years was equal to 82% of the gross public debt that the last two elected governments of Pakistan Peoples Party (2008-2013) and PML-N (2013-2018) had added in 10 years.

With the fresh addition from fiscal year 2018-19 to 2020-21, the total public debt as of June 30, 2021 increased to Rs39.9 trillion or 83.5% of the gross domestic product (GDP), the central bank reported.

However, in terms of the size of economy, the ratio was 4.1% less than the preceding fiscal year 2019-20. It was still higher by 11% of GDP than the level left behind by the PML-N and was also in violation of the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitation Act of 2005.

The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government added on an average Rs13.6 billion a day to the public debt, which was more than double the daily average addition of Rs5.8 billion by the PML-N government.

When the PML-N government completed its five-year term, the total public debt stood at Rs24.95 trillion, or equal to 72.5% of GDP. In just three years, it has surged to 83.5% of GDP, which is unsustainable and carries huge risks for the economy and the country’s foreign policy.

In February 2019, PM Khan had vowed to bring the public debt down to Rs20 trillion. He had been very critical of the economic policies followed by the previous PPP and PML-N governments and had set up the Debt Inquiry Commission to investigate the reasons behind the addition of Rs18 trillion to the debt stock in 10 years.

Despite completion of the inquiry, the premier has withheld the release of the report.
The accumulation of debt is a direct result of the gap between expenditures and revenues, which is widening due to the inelasticity of debt servicing and defence needs and the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) failure to enhance revenue collection to a sustainable level.

Steep currency depreciation also contributed to the federal government’s debt.

Read More: Short-term debt hits eight-month high

Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities also jumped to a record Rs47.8 trillion, an addition of Rs18 trillion in the past three fiscal years. The country’s total debt and liabilities were equal to 100.3% of GDP - a ratio that was 86.3% hardly three years ago.

Debt breakdown
The federal government’s total domestic debt increased to Rs26.2 trillion, an addition of Rs9.9 trillion or 60% in the last three fiscal years. At the end of the PML-N tenure, the domestic debt was Rs16.4 trillion.

The external debt of the federal government also increased 60% to Rs12.4 trillion in the last three fiscal years. There was a net increase of Rs4.6 trillion in the external debt, largely due to currency depreciation and building the foreign currency reserves through borrowing.

At the end of the PML-N tenure, the external debt had stood at Rs7.8 trillion.
The Rs12.4 trillion worth of external government debt does not include loans obtained for reserves building and currency swap arrangements. These loans are the responsibility of the central bank.

By June 2021 the rupee-dollar parity traded at Rs157.3 to a dollar. In June 2018, the value of the dollar was equal to Rs121.54, suggesting a massive depreciation of nearly Rs36 or 29.4%. The current parity is around Rs166.

Dollar-based total external debt

The total external debt and liabilities, which were $95.2 billion three years ago, jumped to a record $122.2 billion - an addition of $27 billion on the watch of the PTI government. In one year, the foreign debt rose by $9 billion. During the five year tenure of the PML-N, the total increase in the external debt was $34 billion.

The public external debt, which is the direct responsibility of the federal government, increased from $75.3 billion in June 2018 to $95.2 billion in June this year - an addition of $20 billion in three years.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) debt that was $6.1 billion three years ago has jumped to $7.4 billion by June this year, according to the central bank.

The direct consequence of mounting debt pile is huge increase in the cost of debt servicing. In June 2018, the country spent a total $7.5 billion in external debt repayment and its servicing. This cost has now increased to $13.4 billion - a surge of 79% in three years. But repayments are made by signing new loans.

The country’s foreign exchange liabilities also increased by three-fourth, mainly because of the government’s decision to build foreign exchange reserves by taking new loans.


 
.
Again hogwash and fabrication. There has been miniscule increase in terms of dollars. Devaluation and unstable currency is pushing debt up and down. Govt has not taken any debt from state bank in last 2 years. Unless we get significant dollar inflow there is no cure for this ballooning of debt in terms of rupees. Let not forget we have to pay back most of our debt in dollars and rupee appreciation and depreciation has no link to it except for inflation.
 
.
Again hogwash and fabrication. There has been miniscule increase in terms of dollars. Devaluation and unstable currency is pushing debt up and down. Govt has not taken any debt from state bank in last 2 years. Unless we get significant dollar inflow there is no cure for this ballooning of debt in terms of rupees. Let not forget we have to pay back most of our debt in dollars and rupee appreciation and depreciation has no link to it except for inflation.

Your assertion is completely wrong. Our total domestic debt is Rs26.2 trillion while our dollar based debt is Rs12.4 trillion, so most of the debt is our domestic debt.
 
.
Again hogwash and fabrication. There has been miniscule increase in terms of dollars. Devaluation and unstable currency is pushing debt up and down. Govt has not taken any debt from state bank in last 2 years. Unless we get significant dollar inflow there is no cure for this ballooning of debt in terms of rupees. Let not forget we have to pay back most of our debt in dollars and rupee appreciation and depreciation has no link to it except for inflation.

I am amazed how people are allowed to blatantly lie. This is world bank data, current till 2019. Between 2018 and 2019, debt increased approx. $7 billion. You can click on the breakdowns to see how it adds up:


This has gone up to $116 billion till first quarter of 2021


and the latest news items are showing a further increase.
 
.
Public debt swells to Rs39.9tr

Government adds Rs15tr to debt in three years, according to central bank data

The government has added Rs14.9 trillion to the public debt during almost three years in power, which is equal to 140% of the total debt the previous Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government acquired in five years, shattering Prime Minister Imran Khan’s dream of reducing the burden.

According to the State Bank of Pakistan’s (SBP) annual debt bulletin, released on Monday, the public debt increased to Rs39.9 trillion by June this year, an addition of Rs14.9 trillion within three years.
The total public debt increased by a whopping 60% from July 2018 to June 2021, an unsustainable 20% increase on average each year.

The addition of Rs14.907 trillion to the public debt in just three years was equal to 82% of the gross public debt that the last two elected governments of Pakistan Peoples Party (2008-2013) and PML-N (2013-2018) had added in 10 years.

With the fresh addition from fiscal year 2018-19 to 2020-21, the total public debt as of June 30, 2021 increased to Rs39.9 trillion or 83.5% of the gross domestic product (GDP), the central bank reported.

However, in terms of the size of economy, the ratio was 4.1% less than the preceding fiscal year 2019-20. It was still higher by 11% of GDP than the level left behind by the PML-N and was also in violation of the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitation Act of 2005.

The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government added on an average Rs13.6 billion a day to the public debt, which was more than double the daily average addition of Rs5.8 billion by the PML-N government.

When the PML-N government completed its five-year term, the total public debt stood at Rs24.95 trillion, or equal to 72.5% of GDP. In just three years, it has surged to 83.5% of GDP, which is unsustainable and carries huge risks for the economy and the country’s foreign policy.

In February 2019, PM Khan had vowed to bring the public debt down to Rs20 trillion. He had been very critical of the economic policies followed by the previous PPP and PML-N governments and had set up the Debt Inquiry Commission to investigate the reasons behind the addition of Rs18 trillion to the debt stock in 10 years.

Despite completion of the inquiry, the premier has withheld the release of the report.
The accumulation of debt is a direct result of the gap between expenditures and revenues, which is widening due to the inelasticity of debt servicing and defence needs and the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) failure to enhance revenue collection to a sustainable level.

Steep currency depreciation also contributed to the federal government’s debt.

Read More: Short-term debt hits eight-month high

Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities also jumped to a record Rs47.8 trillion, an addition of Rs18 trillion in the past three fiscal years. The country’s total debt and liabilities were equal to 100.3% of GDP - a ratio that was 86.3% hardly three years ago.

Debt breakdown
The federal government’s total domestic debt increased to Rs26.2 trillion, an addition of Rs9.9 trillion or 60% in the last three fiscal years. At the end of the PML-N tenure, the domestic debt was Rs16.4 trillion.

The external debt of the federal government also increased 60% to Rs12.4 trillion in the last three fiscal years. There was a net increase of Rs4.6 trillion in the external debt, largely due to currency depreciation and building the foreign currency reserves through borrowing.

At the end of the PML-N tenure, the external debt had stood at Rs7.8 trillion.
The Rs12.4 trillion worth of external government debt does not include loans obtained for reserves building and currency swap arrangements. These loans are the responsibility of the central bank.

By June 2021 the rupee-dollar parity traded at Rs157.3 to a dollar. In June 2018, the value of the dollar was equal to Rs121.54, suggesting a massive depreciation of nearly Rs36 or 29.4%. The current parity is around Rs166.

Dollar-based total external debt

The total external debt and liabilities, which were $95.2 billion three years ago, jumped to a record $122.2 billion - an addition of $27 billion on the watch of the PTI government. In one year, the foreign debt rose by $9 billion. During the five year tenure of the PML-N, the total increase in the external debt was $34 billion.

The public external debt, which is the direct responsibility of the federal government, increased from $75.3 billion in June 2018 to $95.2 billion in June this year - an addition of $20 billion in three years.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) debt that was $6.1 billion three years ago has jumped to $7.4 billion by June this year, according to the central bank.

The direct consequence of mounting debt pile is huge increase in the cost of debt servicing. In June 2018, the country spent a total $7.5 billion in external debt repayment and its servicing. This cost has now increased to $13.4 billion - a surge of 79% in three years. But repayments are made by signing new loans.

The country’s foreign exchange liabilities also increased by three-fourth, mainly because of the government’s decision to build foreign exchange reserves by taking new loans.


Laanat on nawazu begairat whol looted Pakistan and thrown us into mess
 
.
Again hogwash and fabrication. There has been miniscule increase in terms of dollars. Devaluation and unstable currency is pushing debt up and down. Govt has not taken any debt from state bank in last 2 years. Unless we get significant dollar inflow there is no cure for this ballooning of debt in terms of rupees. Let not forget we have to pay back most of our debt in dollars and rupee appreciation and depreciation has no link to it except for inflation.

What does "inflow" of dollars has to do with your national debt? The national debt is primarily loans taken out by your government(s) overtime. And report explains that there has been an insane climb in the past 3 years. Are there extremely large projects going on that require this much debt?

I looked at some economic sites, Pakistan's GDP is way down in the past few years. It seems as a few years ago it was moving up significantly.....
 
.
What does "inflow" of dollars has to do with your national debt? The national debt is primarily loans taken out by your government(s) overtime. And report explains that there has been an insane climb in the past 3 years. Are there extremely large projects going on that require this much debt?

I looked at some economic sites, Pakistan's GDP is way down in the past few years. It seems as a few years ago it was moving up significantly.....

Total debt includes dollar debt as well, which goes up and down on rupee value.

Asfar as internal dent which constitutes major portion of overall debt one has to break it down into government new debt ( primary surplus/deficit) and interest payments on existing debt ( which when incorporated into primary surplus / deficit becomes fiscal deficit). Its a classic case of classic twin deficit debt trap this government inherited.

Given in the year 2021 which ended in June. Government new debt which it took to run its expenses is - ve 1.34% that means government revenues were more than its expenditure. Whereas on part of interest payment on previous debt government paid nearly 4 trillion, that resulted in increase in overall debt figure, fiscal deficit, because inorder to pay the interest on existing loan government has to take new debt.

Both external and internal interest payment add to your debt at this point.


If you want to know how much is due to government spending than look at:

Primary surplus/ deficit on the domestic side.
CAD on the external side.
This will give you an indication of government performance, and help one differentiate between past government and this government performance.



One more point to note is debt to GDP ratio which has come down this year.

This government has performed better than any other government in terms of controlling expenditure both internal (primary surplus) and external (CAD). It will take us 10 years atleast to get out of classic debt trap which is a result of decade of economic abuse.
 
.
Total debt includes dollar debt as well, which goes up and down on rupee value.

Asfar as internal dent which constitutes major portion of overall debt one has to break it down into government new debt ( primary surplus/deficit) and interest payments on existing debt ( which when incorporated into primary surplus / deficit becomes fiscal deficit). Its a classic case of classic twin deficit debt trap this government inherited.

Given in the year 2021 which ended in June. Government new debt which it took to run its expenses is - ve 1.34% that means government revenues were more than its expenditure. Whereas on part of interest payment on previous debt government paid nearly 4 trillion, that resulted in increase in overall debt figure, fiscal deficit, because inorder to pay the interest on existing loan government has to take new debt.

Both external and internal interest payment add to your debt at this point.


If you want to know how much is due to government spending than look at:

Primary surplus/ deficit on the domestic side.
CAD on the external side.
This will give you an indication of government performance, and help one differentiate between past government and this government performance.



One more point to note is debt to GDP ratio which has come down this year.

This government has performed better than any other government in terms of controlling expenditure both internal (primary surplus) and external (CAD). It will take us 10 years atleast to get out of classic debt trap which is a result of decade of economic abuse.

Local debt has nothing to do with USD whereas it has gone up by whopping 26% this year 60% in three years, in fact PTI has performed relatively better on external debt.
 
.
Local debt has nothing to do with USD whereas it has gone up by whopping 26% this year 60% in three years, in fact PTI has performed relatively better on external debt.

Bro I don't think 26% is true. The total deficit is 3.4t Rs I think which includes both domestic and foreign borrowing to finance. Mind you majority of this is interest payment (which is unavoidable) , not government expenditure.

The fact that government is keeping a close lid on primary surplus/deficit shows their prudulent financial management.

Asfar as the rest of your post goes we have discussed in detail the breakdown of this debt multiple times.
 
.
What does "inflow" of dollars has to do with your national debt? The national debt is primarily loans taken out by your government(s) overtime. And report explains that there has been an insane climb in the past 3 years. Are there extremely large projects going on that require this much debt?

I looked at some economic sites, Pakistan's GDP is way down in the past few years. It seems as a few years ago it was moving up significantly.....
Aur sunao mr ferrari kia haal hy
 
.
Bro I don't think 26% is true. The total deficit is 3.4t Rs I think which includes both domestic and foreign borrowing to finance. Mind you majority of this is interest payment (which is unavoidable) , not government expenditure.

The fact that government is keeping a close lid on primary surplus/deficit shows their prudulent financial management.

Asfar as the rest of your post goes we have discussed in detail the breakdown of this debt multiple times.

This is over and above of debt payment.

Fiscal balance is historic high in this government.

1630491788552.png
 
Last edited:
.
This is over and above of debt payment.

Nope on account of interest component which we had to finance through new loans. Same goes for the interest payment on the external side.

We are not in a position in fact never have been. The positive note is primary surplus/deficit is limited. Which we have to give credit to the government for maintain financial discipline in its spending and not exceeding its revenue/income.
 
.
Your assertion is completely wrong. Our total domestic debt is Rs26.2 trillion while our dollar based debt is Rs12.4 trillion, so most of the debt is our domestic debt.

Increase is in foreign debt not domestic bcz of devaluation. Dollar value has increased by 50%. Lets not forget the debt increase of over a trillion RS bcz of energy debt parked by Ishaq dar in several purpose built companies to hide real debt figure. Artificially held dollar rate did us no service as well a fact admitted by miftah ismail previous Finance minister.
I am amazed how people are allowed to blatantly lie. This is world bank data, current till 2019. Between 2018 and 2019, debt increased approx. $7 billion. You can click on the breakdowns to see how it adds up:


This has gone up to $116 billion till first quarter of 2021


and the latest news items are showing a further increase.

I am not talking about external but rather public debt. My reply was about why public debt is swelling. No one lying at least bother to read context of someone's comment.
 
.
I am not talking about external but rather public debt. My reply was about why public debt is swelling. No one lying at least bother to read context of someone's comment.

You don't understand the meaning of 'public debt'.

In public finance, government debt, also known as public interest, public debt, national debt and sovereign debt,[1][2] is the total amount of debt owed at a point in time by a government or state to lenders. Government debt can be owed to lenders within the country (also described as internal debt) or owed to foreign lenders (external debt).
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom