PTI's wrong Plan: New Provinces in Punjab, but Karachi needs not to be made a province

[veg]

Do you agree with Imran Khan's vision where he is saying we need more provinces in Punjab, but Karachi needs not to be made a new province?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1015196377733742592

Am I missing something here?

Even if Imran Khan get seats from Karachi (while agencies did punctured MQM), still I don't see such success to long last.

If the problems of the people of Karachi are not solved, then sooner or later they will vote for MQM again, and responsible for this will be politicians and the establishment which didn't provide them with good enough alternative option.

 

[H!TchHiker]

Do you agree with Imran Khan's vision where he is saying we need more provinces in Punjab, but Karachi needs not to be made a new province?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1015196377733742592

Am I missing something here?

Even if Imran Khan get seats from Karachi (while agencies did punctured MQM), still I don't see such success to long last.

If the problems of the people of Karachi are not solved, then sooner or later they will vote for MQM again, and responsible for this will be politicians and the establishment which didn't provide them with good enough alternative option.

Sindhis don't want division...and further karachi seats are not important in politics..

 

[Men in Green]

Over the body's of Sindhi people's. For sindhi peoples Sindh is there mother like Pakistan how can one divide his mother.

 

[H!TchHiker]

Over the body's of Sindhi people's. For sindhi peoples Sindh is there mother like Pakistan how can one divide his mother.

Agreed ,, even when i talk to my educated sindhis friend they get emotional or ferocious about Sindh division..For them Sindh can't be divided like Pakistan can't be

 

[veg]

Sindhis don't want division...and further karachi seats are not important in politics..

So what is the message in it for the people of Karachi?

* that they should stay as the slaves of the Sindhis?
* that Karachi should stay as garbage?
* that Imran Khan doesn't care about the rights of the people of Karachi, but he cares about his personal political benefits where he could gain more in Sindh?
* that they should keep on voting MQM?

 

[H!TchHiker]

So what is the message in it for the people of Karachi?

* that they should stay as the slaves of the Sindhis?
* that Karachi should stay as garbage?
* that Imran Khan doesn't care about the rights of the people of Karachi, but he cares about his personal political benefits where he could gain more in Sindh?
* that they should keep on voting MQM?

Up-to the people of karachi whatever they perceive..Message is quite clear ..There would be no division of sindh...Sindhis are quite nationalistic about this

 

[veg]

Over the body's of Sindhi people's. For sindhi peoples Sindh is there mother like Pakistan how can one divide his mother.

How is making a southern Sindh province is dividing the mother?

Why not dividing Punjab is dividing the mother?

Pakistan was once a One Unit, then divided into 4 parts for good governance.

Why only the emotions of Sindhi people is important, while the emotions+rights of the people of Karachi have no meaning and value for PTI?

 

[BRAVO_]

i believe let the people decide ... if majority of population want karachi as a separate province then it should be... if they decide otherwise than bury this issue once an for all... same goes with punjab if people of south punjab want to have a separate province let them decide .. it is not a rocket science nor an issue of our personal egos

 

[Men in Green]

How is making a southern Sindh province is dividing the mother?

Why not dividing Punjab is dividing the mother?

Pakistan was once a One Unit, then divided into 4 parts for good governance.

Why only the emotions of Sindhi people is important, while the emotions+rights of the people of Karachi have no meaning and value for PTI?

You clearly Don't know the history of Sindh. Pakistan was not one. you clearly lake some knowledge. Go read books btw google will help to.

Karachi was and is and will be Part of Sindh if any one has balls try to divide Sindh.

 

[veg]

You clearly Don't know the history of Sindh. Pakistan was not one. you clearly lake some knowledge. Go read books btw google will help to.

Karachi was and is and will be Part of Sindh if any one has balls try to divide Sindh.

And you clearly blind enough to not to see the present situation where the majority of the population of Karachi want independence from the interior Sindh in order to prosper and run their fate themselves and don't become the slaves of the Wadayras and people of the interior Sindh.

 

[Men in Green]

And you clearly blind enough to not to see the present situation where the majority of the population of Karachi want independence from the interior Sindh in order to prosper and run their fate themselves and don't become the slaves of the Wadayras and people of the interior Sindh.

You are probably idiot enough to believe that, go elect someone who actually works instead of bhata khor killer and traitor then come here and bark,

No one has balls to divide Sindh, If you do that there will be civil war.

And go learn history of Sindh and Pakistan then come here to bark.

 

[veg]

i believe let the people decide ... if majority of population want karachi as a separate province then it should be... if they decide otherwise than bury this issue once an for all... same goes with punjab if people of south punjab want to have a separate province let them decide .. it is not a rocket science nor an issue of our personal egos

It is a dubious statement.
What do you mean by the Majority?
Is it the majority of the people of Karachi or the majority of the people of whole Sindh?

Probably you will choose the majority of the whole Sindh, while people of Karachi very clearly want to get rid of Wadayrahs of interior Sindh running their fate and making Karachi a garbage place with no drinking water and Tank Mafia and all kind of corruption in the police.

Nevertheless, let me tell you that you could not usurp the Basic Human Rights in the name of majority. If we would have gone the way of majority of whole combined India, then Muslim League would have lost it's demand for Separate Pakistan.

Therefore, if you say creation of Pakistan was correct, but creation of Southern Sindh Province is wrong due to the majority, then it is double standards and you are usurping the rights of the people of Karachi and you are a Zalim.

 

[BRAVO_]

You clearly Don't know the history of Sindh. Pakistan was not one. you clearly lake some knowledge. Go read books btw google will help to.

Karachi was and is and will be Part of Sindh if any one has balls try to divide Sindh.

Karachi originally was a small fisherman village settled by the Baloch tribes from Balochistan and Makran. Their first settlement was near the delta of the Indus River which they named as 'Kolachi’ village. The people of the original community yet inhabit the area on small island of Abdullah Goth situated near Karachi Port. The well-known neighbourhood ‘Mai Kolachi’ of Karachi still reminds the original name of the city.

 

[Yaseen1]

only time will tell ik is struggling only to become pm or for prosperity of Pakistan in real sense.if he fails he will face same fate as nawaz is facing today



V

 

[veg]

Let me repeat:

You could not usurp the Basic Human Rights of the people of Karachi in the name of majority of Sindhis. If we would have gone the way of majority of whole combined India, then Muslim League would have lost it's demand for Separate Pakistan.

Therefore, if you say creation of Pakistan was correct, but creation of Southern Sindh Province is wrong due to the majority, then it is double standards and you are usurping the rights of the people of Karachi and you are a Zalim.