What's new

Protests in MP after Christian weds Hindu, police declare marriage ‘invalid’

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
The police in Madhya Pradesh have declared a marriage between a Christian man and a Hindu woman invalid, after protests by right-wing groups.

Joseph Pawar, who is in his 20s, and Ayushi Wani, 19, reportedly eloped and married at an Arya Samaj temple in Bhopal on September 28. They were traced by the police to Pavagadh in Gujarat after the girl’s parents filed a complaint and the Hindu Jagran Manch and other right-wing organisations threatened to launch an agitation. The two hail from Jobat town in tribal-dominated Alirajpur district.
The town observed a bandh on Wednesday as the superintendent of police met the two families separately in his office. Meanwhile, hundreds of right-wing activists gathered outside the premises.

Ayushi reportedly told Alirajpur SP Akhilesh Jha that she was in love with Joseph, a nursing college student, and that she went with him of her own accord. She also refused to return to her parents, following which she was sent to Nari Niketan in Ujjain.
The activists said they wanted Joseph booked for allegedly luring Ayushi into marrying him, but the police said no case could be made against him since she was not a minor. Joseph was escorted to Indore under police protection to ensure his safety.
Police, however, declared the marriage invalid, saying that Joseph is not a Hindu and that in order to marry Ayushi, he would have to convert to Hinduism by following a procedure laid down under the Freedom of Religion Act.
According to the Act, a person who wants to convert as well as those who would preside over the ceremony are supposed to notify the district magistrate a month in advance.

Jha told The Indian Express that he took the decision to declare the marriage invalid because it seemed like the best option at the time, given that 300-400 activists had surrounded his office and the threat of arson and damage to government property loomed large. “There are both plus and minus points when an administrator takes a decision in such matters,” he said.
Joseph, meanwhile, said that the marriage in the Arya Samaj temple was carried out according to Hindu rituals.
Ayushi’s family had filed a complaint on September 26 when she did not return home from college. Right-wing activists threatened to take to the streets when it was revealed that she had eloped with a Christian man, and gave the police till September 30 to bring the couple back to Jobat.

The police discovered that after the marriage on September 28, the couple went to Pavagadh, from where the two were brought to Jobat on October 1.
The SP said the situation had returned to normal on Thursday, but added that it was not safe for Joseph to return. “It’s possible that he could apply to convert his faith,” he said.
Protests in MP after Christian weds Hindu, police declare marriage ‘invalid’ | The Indian Express
 
.
They married in arya samaj. Means the christian man converted to hinduism. What problem these protesters had?
 
.
The police in Madhya Pradesh have declared a marriage between a Christian man and a Hindu woman invalid, after protests by right-wing groups.

Joseph Pawar, who is in his 20s, and Ayushi Wani, 19, reportedly eloped and married at an Arya Samaj temple in Bhopal on September 28. They were traced by the police to Pavagadh in Gujarat after the girl’s parents filed a complaint and the Hindu Jagran Manch and other right-wing organisations threatened to launch an agitation. The two hail from Jobat town in tribal-dominated Alirajpur district.
The town observed a bandh on Wednesday as the superintendent of police met the two families separately in his office. Meanwhile, hundreds of right-wing activists gathered outside the premises.

Ayushi reportedly told Alirajpur SP Akhilesh Jha that she was in love with Joseph, a nursing college student, and that she went with him of her own accord. She also refused to return to her parents, following which she was sent to Nari Niketan in Ujjain.
The activists said they wanted Joseph booked for allegedly luring Ayushi into marrying him, but the police said no case could be made against him since she was not a minor. Joseph was escorted to Indore under police protection to ensure his safety.
Police, however, declared the marriage invalid, saying that Joseph is not a Hindu and that in order to marry Ayushi, he would have to convert to Hinduism by following a procedure laid down under the Freedom of Religion Act.
According to the Act, a person who wants to convert as well as those who would preside over the ceremony are supposed to notify the district magistrate a month in advance.

Jha told The Indian Express that he took the decision to declare the marriage invalid because it seemed like the best option at the time, given that 300-400 activists had surrounded his office and the threat of arson and damage to government property loomed large. “There are both plus and minus points when an administrator takes a decision in such matters,” he said.
Joseph, meanwhile, said that the marriage in the Arya Samaj temple was carried out according to Hindu rituals.
Ayushi’s family had filed a complaint on September 26 when she did not return home from college. Right-wing activists threatened to take to the streets when it was revealed that she had eloped with a Christian man, and gave the police till September 30 to bring the couple back to Jobat.

The police discovered that after the marriage on September 28, the couple went to Pavagadh, from where the two were brought to Jobat on October 1.
The SP said the situation had returned to normal on Thursday, but added that it was not safe for Joseph to return. “It’s possible that he could apply to convert his faith,” he said.
Protests in MP after Christian weds Hindu, police declare marriage ‘invalid’ | The Indian Express
@Contrarian another incident against minorities your country…. since that discussion we had this is the 3rd time i tagged u on such issue….
 
. .
Well, it seems the man had married in a official hindu manner. But he needs to convert officially it seems.
A really good romance gone sour. Modi should bring in UCC to prevent incidents like this. Anyone should be able to marry anyone.
 
.
@Contrarian another incident against minorities your country…. since that discussion we had this is the 3rd time i tagged u on such issue….
I dont see this as an incident against minorities. No crime has been committed against this couple. The procedure for marriage was not followed which is why the cops have declared the marriage illegal.
 
.
I dont see this as an incident against minorities. No crime has been committed against this couple. The procedure for marriage was not followed which is why the cops have declared the marriage illegal.
so for him to marry a girl he likes he has to become hindu in a secular country? and your ok with it?
what were you trying to preach to me then?
 
.
so for him to marry a girl he likes he has to become hindu in a secular country? and your ok with it?
what were you trying to preach to me then?
Ofcourse not. Please read the article carefully.
According to the Act, a person who wants to convert as well as those who would preside over the ceremony are supposed to notify the district magistrate a month in advance.
They do have to follow the procedure as laid down by law.
 
.
so for him to marry a girl he likes he has to become hindu in a secular country? and your ok with it?
what were you trying to preach to me then?

What is more lethal:
This
V

invalid.png


Or:

This
V

wsjp.png
 
.
so for him to marry a girl he likes he has to become hindu in a secular country? and your ok with it?
what were you trying to preach to me then?
There are three ways he can marry with the girl. First he can convert to Hinduism and marry the girl in temple or Hindu rituals as per laws in Hindu marriage law. Second he can convert the girl to Christianity and can marry in a church. Third both can retain their religion and can marry under special marriage act law. Now the problem is this in this case that he married the girl as per Hindu girl in Hinduism traditional way and that too in a Hindu temple while he was still Christian. There is the problem. It needs to be cleared whether he was Christian when he married the girl in temple. If he was indeed Christian then he violated the all three marriage acts in one go. He should have simply applied under special marriage act. Marriage between two different community members are still tough to go and that too when you are breaking the law. He should have followed any of the three above laws, then police also would have supported him. Its his own fault, going against society norms is one things but if you go against the law and then plead for support its shameful. I don't who was guiding them. They landed themselves in trouble. Thank you.
 
.
So hue and cry of Indians for rights of minorities when Minorities are treated like dirt in India...Time for some introspection before b!tching about others..
 
.
Look which country is talking about Minority...Where few days back a Christian got death sentence because he said something bad about Muhammed.
 
. .
So hue and cry of Indians for rights of minorities when Minorities are treated like dirt in India...Time for some introspection before b!tching about others..
Minority has to follow the rule in same way as majority has to. Person violated the rule of marriage act. There is no one stoping him to marry the girl if he does the right way. As I have listed all three applicable laws in India, one for Hindu marriage act, one for Minority marriage act and last special marriage act. He didn't follow any of the rules for marriage. May be his friends would have guided him wrongly or may be he didn't know exactly the laws at all. One doesn't need to know the details of marriage act but at least you should know the basic rules if you are going into a union with a girl whom you love so much. Fault lies with him, not society. I wouldn't bring Pakistan in it as I don't think they come any closer to us when it comes to flexibility in marriage acts. And mudslinging will get me no where. Thank you.

This news is fake, India is heaven for Minorities!! :D
News is correct so are the facts dear. we don't have any witch hunting going on here. religious orgnaisation do work for promoting their version of tradition. its all about coexistance. and in this case fault lies with the boy. he is just what 21 year old and girl 19 years. maybe they were just waiting to cross 18 year of legal age to get marry but if they would had spent some time on marriage planning they wouldn't have broken law and face law as well as both societies. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom