What's new

Prime Minister Sharif belittled his own army in meeting with Manmohan Singh, claims Indian newspaper

Pksecurity

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
306
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan Army has become a favorite target of scorn and criticism for jokers of all hues; politicians, media and so-called HR groups. It seems that it has become fashionable to humiliate Pakistani army, currently engaged in a fierce battle to combat home-based, foreign-sponsored terrorism in FATA and Balochistan. Whoever has to please Indian leaders and establishment has to criticize the army. If a report of India Today is to be believed, Pakistani Prime Minister, Nawaz Sharif was no exception. In a report titled, Pakistani PM Sharif belittles his own army, Sharif told his Indian counterpart, Manmohan Singh that he (Sharif) had less faith in the Pakistan Army than India. According to the report, he made these remarks when he met Prime Minister Singh in New York last month on the sidelines of UN General Assembly.

The newspaper terms it as a “sensational disclosure kept under wraps” and the remark was not in jest but came in the course of an intense discussion between the two premiers during their one-hour meeting on September 29. Sharif's remarks were reported in a 'Record of Discussion' (RoD) made by Indian prime minister's aides and compiled by the Prime Minister's Office to be shared with top government functionaries of the Indian government.

This remark was obviously music to the ears of the Indian PM but his government is really in a state of confusion as to which power center to deal with in order to normalize Indo-Pakistan relations. Sharif’s remark makes it clear that he was helpless as far as relations with India were concerned. Indian establishment believes that the present top-brass of Pakistan Army was hawkish and India-centric and an intelligence report that outgoing General Kayani might assume a new role as NSA on Kashmir and Afghanistan Affairs has given many sleepless nights to Indian Establishment.

Pakistan Army has, more than once, made it clear that their threat perception has undergone a fundamental paradigm shift; army now considers terrorists as a graver threat to national security than India. However, India has different ideas. A bulk of Indian defense assets have been deployed on Indo-Pakistan border though India claims to feel more threatened from China.

Some analysts in Pakistan believe that India has upped the ante in LoC area of disputed Jammu and Kashmir territory in order to distract Pakistan army’s attention from internal threat of TTP terrorists. TTP is believed to be sponsored by RAW, Indian intelligence agency, and India wants to encircle Pakistan both from Eastern and Western borders in line with its strategic plans. Army-bashing through some of Pakistani media elements is rampant and a storm has been raised after a leading channel, critical of army and ISI, was believed to be in league with Indian intelligence.

In this backdrop, it is highly unlikely that a third-term Pakistani premier would make the mistake of delivering an irresponsible remark in front of his Indian counterpart. He has an absolute majority in the parliament and is trying to keep the army under his thumb by delaying nomination of army chief and chairman JCSC.

http://www.allvoices.com/contribute...g-with-manmohan-singh-claims-indian-newspaper
 
.
And Sharif is right.
Which Army in the world formulates its own foreign policy, conducts wars and acts at all times without the direction of the Government.

And then deposes the Government when they question the Army.

Thats Pakistan Army for you.
 
.
Nawaz Sharif is a goon , he's a duffer

Pakistan's enemies know that the one institution holding fort in Pakistan is the armed forces thats why their ire is directed at the armed forces
 
.
and now the indians love him, wait till he says something anti india, and the same clowns will be up in arms against this very clown.
 
.
Coming this from NS should be of no surprise to anyone......at least not to me. Considering the history between him and the army, it is very much possible that he might have given such remarks to gain the good graces of the Indian sarkar. We have seen his past responses to the Indian violations of the LOC. Not once has he stood up like any other leader would have for his country. He continues to sing the song of so called peace while people continue to die from Indian violations.
 
.
ganja is on his way to make blunders..he is like a monkey wich cant sit calm.
 
.
Coming this from NS should be of no surprise to anyone......at least not to me. Considering the history between him and the army, it is very much possible that he might have given such remarks to gain the good graces of the Indian sarkar. We have seen his past responses to the Indian violations of the LOC. Not once has he stood up like any other leader would have for his country. He continues to sing the song of so called peace while people continue to die from Indian violations.

Give me one benefit that he is going to get by gaining good graces of so called Indian sarkar?? Let's not comment on the character...comment on the subject and then tell us where is he wrong....
 
.
And Sharif is right.
Which Army in the world formulates its own foreign policy, conducts wars and acts at all times without the direction of the Government.

And then deposes the Government when they question the Army.

Thats Pakistan Army for you.

We don't need your concern about our army ... We Pakistani more our army than our so-called politicians ... Sharif is a traitor I think that's enough ......
 
.
Give me one benefit that he is going to get by gaining good graces of so called Indian sarkar?? Let's not comment on the character...comment on the subject and then tell us where is he wrong....

The character and the subject are interrelated....are they not? Nawaz has a history with the army and he does not seem to be in the mood to let it go any time soon. As for the benefit, it is again no secret that when it comes to personal interests over national interests, Nawaz favors his personal agenda more than anything else.
 
.
And Sharif is right.
Which Army in the world formulates its own foreign policy, conducts wars and acts at all times without the direction of the Government.

And then deposes the Government when they question the Army.

Thats Pakistan Army for you.

LOLL; now which other Army on this Planet owns a Country? Not even the North Korean Army.
But OTOH it may be the Somalian Army, is it ? :undecided:
 
.
The character and the subject are interrelated....are they not? Nawaz has a history with the army and he does not seem to be in the mood to let it go any time soon. As for the benefit, it is again no secret that when it comes to personal interests over national interests, Nawaz favors his personal agenda more than anything else.

I beg to differ...Just because we believe he is against Army doesn't mean even if he is saying something right(which ends up being against army) one should just assume that he is wrong or have personal motives...that is why giving due-diligence to the merit of argument is also important....Your Army does have influence on foreign policy due to which there are two center of powers...making it almost impossible to work with pakistan...that unfortunately is a known fact...

b/w Politicians all across are alike...if you have doubts try to be in touch with Indian newspapers...we are in election time and you will see many instances on daily basis :)....
 
.
I beg to differ...Just because we believe he is against Army doesn't mean even if he is saying something right(which ends up being against army) one should just assume that he is wrong or have personal motives...that is why giving due-diligence to the merit of argument is also important....Your Army does have influence on foreign policy due to which there are two center of powers...making it almost impossible to work with pakistan...that unfortunately is a known fact...

b/w Politicians all across are alike...if you have doubts try to be in touch with Indian newspapers...we are in election time and you will see many instances on daily basis :)....

I have a question for you......why is it that one always hear such things about Pakistani politicians only? You say read Indian news paper.....let me ask you this when was the last time you read some news paper quoting sources about Manmohan belittling his own army?
If anything a person is judged by, is his actions and his past record. If history to be judged by than both accounts prove Nawaz to be fully capable of delivering such remarks about his own army. Not just Nawaz but politicians like Zardari too remember the mamogate scandal? This is unfortunate but true.
 
.
I have a question for you......why is it that one always hear such things about Pakistani politicians only? You say read Indian news paper.....let me ask you this when was the last time you read some news paper quoting sources about Manmohan belittling his own army?
If anything a person is judged by, is his actions and his past record. If history to be judged by than both accounts prove Nawaz to be fully capable of delivering such remarks about his own army. Not just Nawaz but politicians like. Zardari too remember the mamogate scandal? This is unfortunate but true.
What...haven't u heard about V.K Singh and whole fiasco regarding his age controversy...anyhow i am not for once suggesting that Nawaz can/can't say bad about Army...but in this particular context whatever he said is nothing but true....
 
.
Pakistani PM Sharif belittles his own army, Sharif told his Indian counterpart, Manmohan Singh that he (Sharif) had less faith in the Pakistan Army than India.
Now no one will talk about Article 6.
 
.
What...haven't u heard about V.K Singh and whole fiasco regarding his age controversy...anyhow i am not for once suggesting that Nawaz can/can't say bad about Army...but in this particular context whatever he said is nothing but true....

This can be your opinion however far far from the truth.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom