What's new

Power cheaper in Pakistan than India: Riaz ul Haq sb

SoulSpokesman

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Dec 1, 2016
Messages
3,633
Reaction score
-15
Country
India
Location
India
http://www.riazhaq.com/2018/01/electric-power-rates-in-india-and.html

Pakistan National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) has cut electricity price by 2.99 rupees (2.7 U.S. cents) per unit under the fuel adjustment for the month of December, 2017, according to news reports. This reduction brings the price per kilowatt-hour to Rs. 5.11 (4.60 US cents), down from Rs. 8.10 (7.30 US cents).

Power Rate in Pakistan:

Reduction brings the price per kilowatt-hour to Rs. 5.11 (4.60 US cents), down from Rs. 8.10 (7.30 US cents). The CPPA (Central Power Purchasing Authority) said total energy was generated at the cost of Rs. 25.24 billion, or Rs. 3.52/unit for the month of November, 2017.

The reduction in the actual generation cost is mainly because of a decline in fuel prices, zero use of high-speed diesel in the power plants and higher contribution from the cheapest source – hydropower. The furnace oil (Rs. 9.03 per unit) has been replaced by domestic natural gas at Rs. 4.49 per unit and liquified natural gas (LNG) at Rs. 6.33 per unit.

This decision will not affect K-Electric consumers which is privately owned and generates its own power for residents of Karachi. K-Electric currently chargessignificantly higher rates of Rs. 12.77 per unit (11.50 US cents per unit).

Comparison With India:

Across the border in India, the nation's Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) has set the national average power purchase cost (APPC) at INR 3.48 (5.43 cents), barring a few states for open access. The APPC will apply during the financial year (FY) 2017-18 and until further orders for deviation settlement with respect to open access, according to Indian media reports.

The latest round of power rate cuts in Pakistan has brought the average electricity unit price (4.60 US cents) lower than that in neighboring India (5.43 US cents).

Future Power Rates:

The average cost per unit of power produced by new power plants being built in Pakistan as part of CPEC will likely be higher. It's mainly due to higher depreciation cost of new plant and equipment and higher guaranteed return on equity (ROE) of 17% for Chinese IPPs (Independent Power Producers). The 17% return on equity in Pakistan is higher than 4% to 15% ROE for power companies in India.

The average return on equity for almost 8,000 large US firms is 14.49%. The power utility companies – with an average of 10.13% – are on the lower end of the spectrum because they are viewed as less risky investments.

In the United States, the rate of return varies significantly from state to state, as each state regulator has exclusive authority to regulate utility operations as they choose.

In Advance Energy Economy (AEE) Power Portal database, which tracks ROE for over 100 investor-owned utilities across the country, the highest allowed ROE belongs to Alabama Power Co., at 13.75% and the lowest to United Illuminating Co. (CT) at 9.15%.

Within the US states, Alabama being seen as relatively less safe for investment, offers 13.75% return. So why is it such a surprise to see Pakistani regulator offer Chinese investors a higher rate of return of 17%?

Summary:

The current per unit average cost of electricity to consumers in Pakistan is 4.60 US cents while the average in India is 5.43 US cents. Per unit cost of electricity in Pakistan is likely to be bit higher with new capacity being built as part of China Pakistan Economic Corridor due to higher guaranteed rates of return offered to attract Chinese investors. However, plentiful supply of electricity from CPEC power projects will significantly boost economic growth and create millions of new jobs.
 
. .
Can any one please convert and say, how much Indian Rupees and Pakistan Rupees?

Do not convert value from Indian Rupees to Pakistan, please.
 
.
Can any one please convert and say, how much Indian Rupees and Pakistan Rupees?

Do not convert value from Indian Rupees to Pakistan, please.
1 indian rupee =1.74 pakistani rupee today
 
.
1 indian rupee =1.74 pakistani rupee today

Thanks Imran Bhai but I am asking electricity price in Indian and Pakistan Rupees because the article says cheaper then India ( without converting from 1 Indian rupess to 1.74 Pakistan Rupees).... Thanks

I didn't understand....
Pakistan is 4.60 US cents while the average in India is5.43 US cents.
 
.
Thanks Imran Bhai but I am asking electricity price in Indian and Pakistan Rupees because the article says cheaper then India ( without converting from 1 Indian rupess to 1.74 Pakistan Rupees).... Thanks

I didn't understand....
Pakistan is 4.60 US cents while the average in India is5.43 US cents.
largely because 1/3rd power is from dirt cheap decade old hydro plants
 
. .
Thanks Imran Bhai but I am asking electricity price in Indian and Pakistan Rupees because the article says cheaper then India ( without converting from 1 Indian rupess to 1.74 Pakistan Rupees).... Thanks

I didn't understand....
Pakistan is 4.60 US cents while the average in India is5.43 US cents.

What is there to understand??

About one cent difference.
 
. .
1 cent is almost 22% ie bijlee is more expensive in India by 22%. Accept that.

Regards


Petrol and Diesel prices in Pakistan is also lower than India, difference is quite substantial here...

DIcGNalUwAIp788.jpg
 
. .
@Pluralist

Thanks. Thats what my dear friend of old, Brof Riazul Haq sb (@RiazHaq) has been saying- that inspite of lower reported pc income, the average Pakistani has a better consumption level and standard of living than the average Bharati.

Regards
How you come to that conclusion???
Per capita power consumption of India is more than 50% that of Pakistan...
 
.
@Lil Mathew

Matthew anna,

You have a point, but per capita consumption in India is skewed towards the rich- the Ambanis and the Adanis eat up everything-the common man gets little (unlike in Pakistan). Brof sahib has written tonnes of post about that in PDF, chowk, his musings and elsewhere.

Regards
 
.
If i was one of those living on less then $2 a day, i rather be in Pakistan then in India thats very much for sure.
 
.
If i was one of those living on less then $2 a day, i rather be in Pakistan then in India thats very much for sure.

At second rank, India cheaper to live in than even Pakistan, Nepal: Survey
January 28 2018 09:36 IST

India is ranked second only to South Africa as the cheapest country to live or retire, according to a recent survey of 112 countries.

The survey by GoBankingRates ranked nations on the bases of four key affordability metrics provided by online pricing database Numbeo. The metrics are: Local purchasing power index, rent index, Groceries index, and Consumer price index.

With the second lowest rent index among the 50 cheapest countries (after neighbour Nepal), living in India can be cheaper compared to most of the countries.

India also has some of the lowest prices for consumer goods and groceries, with typical monthly expenses for these priced around $285 for a single person living in Kolkata.

The survey says that India, home to 1.25 billion residents, is the most populous among the 50 cheapest countries. Its major industries include textiles, chemicals and food processing. India also has a relatively high local purchasing power in the major cities that were surveyed.

India's local purchasing power is 20.9 per cent lower, rent is 95.2 per cent cheaper, groceries are 74.4 per cent cheaper, local goods and services are 74.9 per cent cheaper, the survey said.

India is cheaper than countries like Colombia ranked at 13, Pakistan (14), Nepal (28), Bangladesh (40).

The local purchasing power index measures the relative purchasing power of a typical salary in that country, compared to New York City. A lower purchasing power buys fewer goods, while a higher purchasing power buys more.

While the rent index compares typical rental prices in the country to New York City, the groceries index holds a similar comparison for typical grocery prices.

The consumer price index compares costs of local goods and services - including restaurants, groceries, transportation and utilities to New York City.

According to the survey, even among the 50 cheapest countries, rent is at least 70 per cent cheaper than in New York City, groceries are at least 40 per cent cheaper, and consumer goods and services cost less by 30 per cent or more. Local purchasing power does vary greatly among these cheap countries, however.

South Africa has topped the survey as the cheapest country to live or retire. Being the world's largest producer of platinum, gold and chromium, goes far to enrich the country and its economy. This resulted in a local purchasing power that is significantly higher than what New Yorkers face, which is the most favourable factor that helps South Africa top the list.

Along with a higher local purchasing power, South Africa also offers lower prices on consumer goods and groceries, and rent costs that are typical of the 50 cheapest countries. In the major city of Cape Town, for instance, monthly expenses total just under USD 400 while the average rent costs are reflected by the typical price to rent a one-bedroom in Durban of around USD 280 a month.
Among the most expensive countries in the survey are Bermuda (ranked 112), Bahamas (111), Hong Kong (110), Switzerland (109) and Ghana (108).

http://wap.business-standard.com/ar...ven-pakistan-nepal-survey-118012800038_1.html
 
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom