The fallacy of this argument is so obvious that it renders this argument , well stupid.
True, that Hindu community belong to creamy layer, but then barring Christian community, each and every community that migrates to US belongs to creamy layer.
Why are Muslim-Americans not performing as well as Hindu Americans? It is not like Muslims in US are of gutter breed. They too are not only creamy layer of their society, but thanks to oil wealth and a blank cheque from Seikhdoms, start from a much better place that Hindus.None of Arab muslim student is encumbered with education loans that a Hindu has to work a decade to pay off.
SO why are they not on the top?