What's new

Pakistan’s external debt, liabilities shoot to record at $96.7b

What kind of logic is this? Consider the size of Indian economy too...

Yea did consider it, 2.5 Tn GDP with 500 B external debt. to Pakistan's 305 B GDP with 95 B debt. And that's including all the martial laws and wars the country has suffered through. In the end I would say not bad, really a resilient nation.
 
.
and PTI fellows are donkeys and their kaptaan is donkey king . WHERE IS 200 billion $ which was promised to be collected from overseas and retire the debt ? shameless moneys.
LOL! That figure was provided by your own Finance Minister in parliament, Patwari Khotay:

$200bn of Pakistan in Swiss banks: Dar
Khawar Ghumman May 10, 2014

ISLAMABAD: Finance Minister Ishaq Dar staggered the National Assembly on Friday when he revealed that at least $200 billion of ‘Pakistani money’ was stashed away in Swiss banks.

In a written reply, Dar told the house that the government was engaging with Swiss authorities to get to the money, hidden away by various Pakistani nationals.

In a detailed response to a question raised by Dr Arif Alvi of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI), the minister quoted statements by a Swiss banker and a former Swiss government minister: “One of the directors of Credit Suisse AG stated on the record that $97 billion worth of Pakistani capital was deposited only in his bank. Similarly, Micheline Calmy-Rey, a former Swiss foreign minister, is reported to have put the amount of Pakistani money hidden in Switzerland at $200 billion — a statement that was never contradicted,” he revealed.

Saying that he believed the figures were correct, Mr Dar said the situation called for immediate corrective action. To put the enormity of this find into perspective, Pakistan’s total external debt stands at $150 billion and its gross domestic product is said to be around $300 billion. The country can, theoretically, pay off all its debt with the money in Swiss banks and still have nearly a quarter of it left over.

ARTICLE CONTINUES AFTER AD

The finance minister said the government was working under the ambit of a new Swiss law, known as ‘The Restitution of Illicit Assets Act, 2010’ (RIAA), which allows the Swiss government to exchange information — which was considered confidential up to now — regarding money that may have been obtained illegally and deposited in Swiss banks. He also briefed the house on the steps the government was taking to get the money back.

The minister said the federal cabinet in a meeting on Sept 20 last year had already approved renegotiation of the current Pak-Swiss tax treaty and Federal Board of Revenue officials and the Swiss authorities concerned had agreed to meet in August this year to upgrade the existing agreement.

In his reply, Mr Dar also referred to various international pressures that had forced the Swiss government to review its policy on clandestine banking.

Amid a global squeeze on tax evasion, money laundering and blatant outflows of capital, Switzerland’s 11 largest banks housed nearly $7 trillion of the world’s total offshore liquidity stock of $32 trillion.

Switzerland has traditionally been the oldest, the most formidable and the most popular secret banking jurisdiction, attracting massive sums of tax-evaded money from across the world into its banks with numbered-accounts. Since 2009, the US and EU have consistently been pressing Switzerland and other tax havens to allow international tax administrations to track illegal funds parked in their secretive banks.

Why troll?
He is not trolling. He actually believed his own Finance Minister Ishaq Dollar was telling the truth.

promises and big mouth of PTI was troll for sure .
Where is 200 billion dollars that your Ishaq Dollar said existed? PTI promised to bring back what your own Finance Minister said was stashed offshore, moron!
 
.
All parties make big promises when in opposition, once in power, reality hits them. IK is not infallible, your right to criticise, but if PML N won election. Pakistan would still need to approach Imf. PTI I think are implementing unpopular reforms in first year. Their hoping things will turn positive in years to come.
thats good to hear that PTI made unrealistic promises and are landing in the ocean of hard reality and the tall claims are crashing hard into ground. Economic team is useless and cant even coordinate on the issue of devaluation how can one expect them to deliver ? ministers of the govt are so careless that they openly criticise CPEC /CHINA , which consequently brought in the displeasure of Chinese govt. with this state of affairs when the defence budget increases by 20%, and local public spending decreases to half how on earth you could bet on this govt?
 
.
thats good to hear that PTI made unrealistic promises
What unrealistic promises? When your own finance minister was lying in parliament about total Pakistani money stashed abroad. How is it PTIs fault?
 
.
$417 billion out of $500 billion Indian external debt is commercial borrowing and therefore it is not going to be burden on people of India. This is exactly opposite in case of Pakistan.
india's total debts have already crossed 530 billions $ back in March 2018, current devaluation of india rupee has further added in its liabilities so you should be worried about that, pakistan has far lesser liabilities than india, the only issue govt is facing is the trust deficit of investors once it is restored back they will manage this balance easily
 
.
Economic team is useless and cant even coordinate on the issue of devaluation how can one expect them to deliver ?
How did external debt climbed to 96 billion before PTI government came in power? What economic team did your PMLN government used?
 
.
Why did your leadership accumulate that much external debt to begin with? Why did they run the country above their means that long? @Canuck786 @Tameem @BATMAN
Thanks for the tag; Well the last regime borrowed and built infrastructure which has been needed for prosperity and it shows inclusive of power and road projects. The present regime increased the debt just by bad governance as Imran Khan himself said that 1 rupee increase in the price of a dollar increases the debt by 100 billion rupees. How much has the rupee devalued against the dollar in last 30 days?
 
.
Whatever, as long as it isn't as much as India's external debt, which is 500B, it will be alright. Current balance of payments was an issue but I think gov. managed to handle it and is under control now.

Indian economy is 2.5 TRILLION (2500 billion) USD while your's is 200 billion. 100/200= 50% GDP debt while 500/2500=20% debt. Basic math, learn it.
 
.
I agree the buck lies mostly for sure with previous admin. Can't really blame I.K all that much (yet!). This admin will have to take concrete reform steps though. It cannot dawdle.
No new government can accumulate 100 billion dollars worth of external debt in mere 3 months. No sane person would believe that. Unless of course you are brainless patwari like @I FLY HIGH @Tameem @BATMAN
 
.
Yea did consider it, 2.5 Tn GDP with 500 B external debt. to Pakistan's 305 B GDP with 95 B debt. And that's including all the martial laws and wars the country has suffered through. In the end I would say not bad, really a resilient nation.
Even going by your own logic, India's external debt to GDP is like 20%
While Pakistan's is 31%.

And I do not think your nominal GDP would be 305 bn USD after all the devaluation in Pkr.

And considering your credit rating is junk and your industrial output is very low, comparing your situation with India doesn't seem a good comparison at all.

As of 2016, India's Industrial output in USD was 597 bn USD while Pakistan's was 50 bn USD.

https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/indicators/NV.IND.TOTL.CD/rankings
 
.
100 billion debt / 100 billion market cap = 100% leverage (With junk grade credit rating)...and there is another thread that says double leveraging is really starting to be problem in Pakistan...esp in short term debt liabilities.


Lol..where does market cap at stock exchanges comes into foray...a superfluous thing with not many companies registered at the stock in Pakistan, debt is always measured with GDP to debt ratio.


India...

Government Debt to GDP in India is expected to be 69.20 percent by the end of this quarter, according to Trading Economics global macro models and analysts expectations. In the long-term, the India Government Debt to GDP is projected to trend around 70.00 percent in 2020, according to our econometric models.


https://tradingeconomics.com/india/government-debt-to-gdp




Pakistan...

Government Debt to GDP in Pakistan is expected to be 72.80 percent by the end of this quarter, according to Trading Economics global macro models and analysts expectations. In the long-term, the Pakistan Government Debt to GDP is projected to trend around 74.00 percent in 2020, according to our econometric models.

https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/government-debt-to-gdp


a very minuscule difference of 2-3 percentage points...
 
.
Well the last regime borrowed and built infrastructure which has been needed for prosperity and it shows inclusive of power and road projects.
You can't do that. Government should only borrow to invest to boost exports that generate revenue. You can't borrow to build roads etc. That's why country is in a total financial crisis.
 
.
Why did your leadership accumulate that much external debt to begin with? Why did they run the country above their means that long? @Canuck786 @Tameem @BATMAN
mostly spent on power projects 15000 mwatts installed capacity and cpec motorways /infrastructure, war against terror and previous debt servicing . These projects added to the capacity of govt and state to move into the right direction of economy and created the assets inside the country. these assets create business/job opportunities inside the country and pti govt has put the same power plants on top of the the privatisation list . Pakistan was turned around from blood shed /14 hours power cuts , shut down industry into a regular operating country. now u tell where is the 10 billion dollar which is going out of the country and where is the money 5000 billion pkr which was being taken over by corruption as claimed by kaptaaan? where is that money ? use that money and dont blame any one for your own sins.
 
.
The present regime increased the debt just by bad governance as Imran Khan himself said that 1 rupee increase in the price of a dollar increases the debt by 100 billion rupees.
Where did you learn basic economics? You can't artificially control the price of dollar. This is what Ishaq Dollar did and destroyed Pakistans economy.
 
.
dont try to pass the ball, where are 200 billion dollars which kaptaan was to collect from overseas pakistanis and retire the debt ?
there is a difference between pre election politics and post elections politics, our entire race of politician make U turns even the recent biggest U turn was taken by NS in supream court where he simply disowned so called "Qatri Khat" prior entire case was built upon that letter ... did somebody talk about it ???? no where .. not at media nor any where in social circles, why duel standards for IK, NS and Zardaris??

generally our public is hasten by nature shadi kay dosray din he log pochna shoro kar daitay hain keh good news kab suna rahay ho ............ oo bahi wait karo thora :sarcastic:
 
.
Back
Top Bottom