What's new

Pakistanis to Remit Extra $10 Billion for Post-Floods Reconstruction?

RiazHaq

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
6,611
Reaction score
70
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Members of Pakistani diaspora must remember their compatriots in distress as we celebrate Eid today.

While there have been high-profile recent efforts by overseas Pakistanis to raise millions of dollars to fund rescue and relief efforts after the recent devastating floods, it is now time to begin to shift focus on to the much longer term and significantly more expensive reconstruction phase that will requires billions, not millions, of dollars.

World Bank economist Sanket Mohapatra has said in a recent post that remittances by overseas Pakistanis have played a significant role in Pakistan's economic improvement. Not only have such remittances contributed to significant poverty reduction in Pakistan "by an impressive 17.3 percentage points between 2001 and 2008 (from 34.5 percent in 2001-02 to 17.2 percent in 2007-08)", but "continued strong growth in worker’s remittances in the past few years has also contributed to improvements in the external current account balance” and “have facilitated improvement in the country’s external position”, according to a World Bank report released on July 30, 2010.

World Bank's Mohaptra adds that "there is now a risk that devastating floods that have hit Pakistan, killing more than 1,200 people and leaving 2 million people homeless, could reverse some of the gains in poverty achieved in the last few years, which were already believed to have been weakened in the wake of the recent financial crisis and rise in food prices. During past natural disasters, migrants have sent additional remittances to help their families and friends in need – for example, during the Pakistan earthquake in 2005, in Philippines after typhoons Ondoy and Pepeng in 2009, after an earthquake in Haiti in early 2010, and in other countries in Asia, Africa and Latin America. It is likely that the Pakistani diaspora will send additional financial resources to help their family, friends and even larger communities. These person-to-person transfers could complement official aid efforts".

The cost and the task of post-flood reconstruction may appear to be monumental, but I feel confident that global Pakistani community is equal to it. Already, non-resident Pakistanis have been sending home nearly ten billion US dollars a year in remittances to their home country. And their invested assets are estimated to be in hundreds of billions of US dollars in different parts of the world. I believe Pakistani diaspora can double their remittances in the next twelve months, thereby boosting Pakistan's overall economy by a $10 billion stimulus for reconstruction.

If a significant part of this additional $10 billion in remittances goes into special, professionally managed, investment funds specifically for post-floods reconstruction and rehabilitation, it will be an even greater boost to Pakistan's overall economy. To put it in perspective, the $10 billion in a year would be 5 times the annual foreign aid, and twice the peak FDI Pakistan received in 2007, the last year of healthy economic growth in 2007-2008.

Haq's Musings: Can Global Pakistanis Invest $10 Billion in Post-Floods Reconstruction?
 
.
We keep remitting and we get no benefits in return..even the small initiative taken by Mushy gov to reward over seas Pakistanis is pretty much dead...and what ever money we remit back to the country turns us no benefit...there arent much business oppurtunities to invest our savings.
 
.
We keep remitting and we get no benefits in return..even the small initiative taken by Mushy gov to reward over seas Pakistanis is pretty much dead...and what ever money we remit back to the country turns us no benefit...there arent much business oppurtunities to invest our savings.

I don't think the primary purpose of remittances by overseas Pakistanis should be to seek any benefits for the remitters. It should really be focused on giving back to the country that gave us the opportunities with education to make a better living for ourselves.

As to stock investments, Pakistan has produced much better results over the last decade and higher ROIs than the vast majority of other countries, including the so-called BRIC nations.

One way to use extra remittances is to invest in infrastructure reconstruction projects like power, water and toll roads to produce a good return through privately managed country funds.

Haq's Musings: Karachi Tops Mumbai in Stock Performance
 
.
I don't think the primary purpose of remittances by overseas Pakistanis should be to seek any benefits for the remitters. It should really be focused on giving back to the country that gave us the opportunities with education to make a better living for ourselves.

As to stock investments, Pakistan has produced much better results over the last decade and higher ROIs than the vast majority of other countries, including the so-called BRIC nations.

You need to be clear if what you are looking for are regular remitances or one time aid(charity). why would an overseas Pakistani remit money to Pakistan if he is not getting any value for that money (this does not include the money one sends back home to families). He has worked hard for that money, pays taxes on it in the land of his abode, so is entitled to expect return on his hard earned money. A one time relief contribution (as in the case of the present floods) is a different matter altogether.

Pakistan neds to create enough avenues to make investments by overseas Pakistanis attractive in Pak. that way it would make economic sense for them to invest, which in turn would give some roots to the dismal economic backbone of the country and furhter enable the govt to build on that foundation to create institutions that then attract FDI. It is a self perpetuating cycle once the basics are in place- just look at the chinese model of growth for inspiration. (this is Economics 101 an dsurely the Pakistani govt. is aware of what needs to be done- its just a matter of will)
 
.
The reason why remitting alone is not cure


Becasue industrlial power of nation is rusting away ...every thing of value and engineering is brought pre made from out side

Unless its fix , remiting will not solve anything


More remittance = more funds for local ecnomy , inflation will eat up all the extra funds, or increased oil and service charges and all the remittance will indirectly go out of country

I think all the land from fuedal lords should be taken back anything given to them by old british gov should be confiscated
 
.
I don't think the primary purpose of remittances by overseas Pakistanis should be to seek any benefits for the remitters. It should really be focused on giving back to the country that gave us the opportunities with education to make a better living for ourselves.

As to stock investments, Pakistan has produced much better results over the last decade and higher ROIs than the vast majority of other countries, including the so-called BRIC nations.

One way to use extra remittances is to invest in infrastructure reconstruction projects like power, water and toll roads to produce a good return through privately managed country funds.

Haq's Musings: Karachi Tops Mumbai in Stock Performance

Hi, man of a very familiar name;
I agree with the first half of your post
we as Expat workers are sending back as much as possible with NO expectations what so ever from the govrment

however it kills me what I see ministers roaming about in Lexus and Mercs in Saudi Arabia, UAE on my money.

It kills me when I am treated like a thief at custom counter when ever I go back home.

It kills me when I see politicians pay less tax together as national assembly than quarterly remittance.

It kills me when I had to prove my education, and get my original degrees attested so I could make money and send back home;
where as these politicians steal that money by virtue of fake degrees.

and yet being Pakistanis we will keep doing what is right.
 
.
There are potentially hundreds of projects in Pakistan in power generation, dasalination, manufacturing, agriculture where money from overseas Pakistanis can be invested for the benefit of both the investors and the country.
Yes, stock are one way to invest but to some people (like me) stocks are too volatile. Better options would be to initiate actual projects managed by trust-worthy funds whose heads can be people of unquestionable personal integrity. Pakistan has plenty of them. I mean, PLENTY. While I am not a fan of either Musharraf or Imran Khan, they are men of great personal integrity and sincerity. There are many others who can be brought onboard.
As a nation Pakistanis have to realize there is a race against time: The more the people are educated and well-fed the more they will contribute to the betterment of Pakistan. On the other hand, the more the population growth, the less the opportunities, the more there is poverty and crimes/terrorism. Even the most backward thinking people will be no longer the same with opportunities around them.
If there can a 'genius' of Pakistani nation then that would be to form a government of national consensus for next 10 years, start rock-solid funds managed by persons of integrity, and mobilize all Pakistanis--both within and outside of Pakistan to invest. Guarantee return on investment. Look at Germany: Their government has a plan to guarantee 7+% return on investments in solar/renewable energy resources. And it is already working out for Germany despite their lesser solar potential.
So....can we get our Zardari or Nawaz or Altaf phobias? Can we get over love for unworkable models like 'revolution' or Army Rule? There are plenty of alternate, and, YES, practical ways to go around making things right for Pakistan.
 
.
If there can a 'genius' of Pakistani nation then that would be to form a government of national consensus for next 10 years, start rock-solid funds managed by persons of integrity, and mobilize all Pakistanis--both within and outside of Pakistan to invest. Guarantee return on investment. Look at Germany: Their government has a plan to guarantee 7+% return on investments in solar/renewable energy resources. And it is already working out for Germany despite their lesser solar potential.
So....can we get our Zardari or Nawaz or Altaf phobias? Can we get over love for unworkable models like 'revolution' or Army Rule? There are plenty of alternate, and, YES, practical ways to go around making things right for Pakistan
.

aren't government formed to MAKE and STEAL money ?
at least in the same part of the world I call home.
Correct me where I go wrong;
 
.
aren't government formed to MAKE and STEAL money ?
at least in the same part of the world I call home.
Correct me where I go wrong;

I don't know what you are trying to say but if your assumption is that governments the world over are out to steal money only then it is not a correct assumption.

Politics is a high-stake and dirty game. And I think most politicians the world over go into it to grab power and translate that power to make money for themselves and their lobbies (if present). Sure, there are high intention and self-less people too but ultimately it is about power. They make money via kickbacks and contracts. The legal way a lot of times. But, in return, at least some benefits do reach to a large number of people--even non-tax paying ones.

A government is always better than a mob!

Pakistan's politicians are immature and may be more corrupt then the Western ones but they reflect their respective societies. In Pakistan, when Ramzan month comes, prices go up. In Christmas season, there are great reduction sales.

Anyway, all that is for another topic.

What I tried to say in my post above to find a non-government solution of trust-funds headed by leaders of impeccable integrity to generate fiscal rewards for both the investors and the invested. Sure, if a 10-year govt. of national consensus can be formed then great. If not then don't wait for a perfect govt. Use what we have or bypass it and do on citizenry-level instead.
 
.
The reason why remitting alone is not cure


Becasue industrlial power of nation is rusting away ...every thing of value and engineering is brought pre made from out side

Unless its fix , remiting will not solve anything


More remittance = more funds for local ecnomy , inflation will eat up all the extra funds, or increased oil and service charges and all the remittance will indirectly go out of country

I think all the land from fuedal lords should be taken back anything given to them by old british gov should be confiscated

And who's going to change Pakistan for the better?

Are you waiting for Messiah?

If you are, good luck! It'll be very very long wait!

WE HAVE TO CHANGE THINGS.

AS SOMEONE SAID AT A RECENT TEDX KARACHI CONF:

""If not now, when? If not us, who?"

Light a candle! Stop cursing darkness!!

After the floods, this is an opportunity to drive the last nails in the coffin of feudalism in Pakistan by helping the poor peasants escape from the clutches of their oppressive feudal lords.

Haq's Musings: TEDx Karachi Inspires Hope, Ideas, Call For Action
 
.
Here's a video clip of Pakistan's billionaire real estate developer Malik Riaz Husain pledging $2 billion of his own wealth to help the flood victims rebuild:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
We give, we give and we give.

Then when we go back and land at ISB, customs and every other crook at that diseased airport are lining up to skin us for whatever they can. Do they value is? Absolutely not.

That country needs to fix up internally. Demands for handouts is understandable, but when you refuse (yes refuse) to change internally, whether that be land reform, the tax system, eliminating corruption, then our cash is effectively like sand through a sieve.

A pointless exercise IMO.
 
.
We give, we give and we give.

Then when we go back and land at ISB, customs and every other crook at that diseased airport are lining up to skin us for whatever they can. Do they value is? Absolutely not.

That country needs to fix up internally. Demands for handouts is understandable, but when you refuse (yes refuse) to change internally, whether that be land reform, the tax system, eliminating corruption, then our cash is effectively like sand through a sieve.

A pointless exercise IMO.

Yours is a defeatist attitude. If everyone thought like you, there would be no change and no progress anywhere in the world, including Pakistan.

Jacqueline Novogratz of the Acumen Fund, who happens to be Chris Anderson's wife, spoke at TEDx Karachi earlier this year with an urgent call for action. She asked, "If not now, when? If not us, who?" As an example, she mentioned the work of Tasneem Siddiqui in "Khuda Ki Basti", a low-cost housing project to deal with the housing crunch from growing rural-to-urban migration in Karachi, and the second similar project now underway in Lahore.

Each of us needs to light a candle to spread the light, rather than curse darkness.

Haq's Musings: Light a Candle, Don't Curse Darkness
 
.
I think the VAT , and sales tax is a good recommendation by IMF if a nation does not pays its taxes , it should pay it on goods it consumes and property it owns works well in Western Civilization


The only problem is the tire burning and 'danga fasaaaaaaaaad'

Can't keep depending on the remittance as means to run a country , middle eastern states are growing in population and their generation of educated class is already hitting the job market wink wink


But the rich class politicians should get charged - specially the ones that drive in expensive cars and declare as poor and having no cars becasue its in their relative's name
 
.
And who's going to change Pakistan for the better?

Are you waiting for Messiah?

If you are, good luck! It'll be very very long wait!

WE HAVE TO CHANGE THINGS.

AS SOMEONE SAID AT A RECENT TEDX KARACHI CONF:

""If not now, when? If not us, who?"

Light a candle! Stop cursing darkness!!

After the floods, this is an opportunity to drive the last nails in the coffin of feudalism in Pakistan by helping the poor peasants escape from the clutches of their oppressive feudal lords.

Haq's Musings: TEDx Karachi Inspires Hope, Ideas, Call For Action


I support confiscation of all lands given by british to their servants during their government , before Pakistan was created

Such land should all be retaken by the estate , and the fuedal lords should be given a pension.

The land should be Pakistan's government controled , used by ministry of agriculture.


VAT , sales tax should be imposed , and any sales person not agreeing to it their business should be closed.


Peopel who are not paying their taxes , should be put into a prison or their personal belongings should be confiscated e.g cars, jewlery , and any item that can be auctioned


Also all the provinces should be broken down with NO REFERENDUM ... and only national language should be used English/Urdu

Any one want to learn punjabi , sindhi , paktoon, balouchi should pay private school fees and these should also be TAXED

Kalabagh should be built - and any opposition should be jailed like they do in China

All the punchayet , or local jirga should be BANNED , and rule of court should be ultimate authority and consititution

All religious schools , gov funded should be ran by educated ppl

NO politicians allowed who have no University degree , and criminal offence for ppl who lie about education

Educated class will invest back more , with out proper justice system its hard , so we need imran Khan or mushrif or Mustafa kamal to fix the issue in Pakistan on political level
 
Last edited:
.
Back
Top Bottom