shuntmaster
BANNED
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2010
- Messages
- 2,916
- Reaction score
- -26
- Country
- Location
Pakistan no country for foreign journalists [ Two Indian Journalists kicked out of Pakistan] - DAWN
After having lived in Islamabad for five and a half years, Rezaul Hasan Lashkar had to pack up and leave in just a little over two weeks.
His sin - he was an Indian and a journalist reporting on Pakistan. And one hot day in the middle of June he was informed that his presence was no longer acceptable to someone, somewhere - through a phone call and a letter.
But despite the unceremonious departure, his one regret - at least in recent days - is that he will not be able to get "some nihari from Kale Khan in Pindi before [he] leave."
Perhaps he has more regrets too - about friends he could not say goodbye too or places he was not allowed to visit but such are the state of affairs between his country and Pakistan that he refuses to talk about the issue at all. The longing for nihari too was gleaned from his twitter account.
And this silence says far more than any lengthy interview he may have given. The few details that are available came from someone close to him who spoke on the basis of anonymity.
Hasan - as always - was waiting for a renewal of his visa when on June 13 he got a letter informing him that he should leave by June 23.
The journalist panicked as he had no valid visa by then, without which he could not even leave. Much effort, phone calls and visits later, he was given a 'generous' extension till June 29.
The valid visa came on June 25 - finally making him eligible to leave.
"Two thirds of his time in Pakistan was spent waiting for an extension of his lapsed visa," says the someone.
So much so that twice at least when his wife's father had a heart attack, her family kept the news from her - because neither she nor Hasan could visit India and the ailing father.
Nothing of Hasan's stay is unusual for an Indian journalist in Pakistan but his departure surely is.
The tradition is that "the journalist is allowed a short overlap with his successor for a smooth transition". But both Hasan and Anita Joshua, the second Indian journalist in Pakistan, who were scheduled to leave in any case and were only waiting for their successors to show up, were denied this in recent months.
Indeed, Hasan's abrupt departure came hot on the heels of the return of his counterpart - Anita Joshua of The Hindu - who was asked to leave shortly after the elections (but before the new government took charge) while New York Times' Declan Walsh was bundled out a day after May 11, his notice period even shorter than the Indians.
The story of these three proves that Pakistan is fast turning into not just one of the most dangerous countries for journalists but also one of the most inhospitable.
"What else would you call a place that so abruptly orders out those who have been living here for years on such a short notice," says a senior journalist.
When Walsh was thrown out, Pakistani journalists whispered that it happened because there was no empowered political government in place and the spooks got a chance to avenge past grievances.
But Joshua and Hasan were told to leave after Nawaz Sharif - the statesman who wanted and wants peace with India - has taken over. Yet there is not a peep out of the new government.
As Mariana Babar, a senior journalist, puts it, "These cases show how powerful the security establishment is. Indian journalists were reluctantly issued visas for a few days on eve of elections. The process started during the caretaker government and continued as Sharif government was in the process of settling. Now as The Hindu and Press Trust of India (PTI) have requested visas for new representatives, we will wait and see how much authority Sharif asserts."
Admittedly, the India-Pakistan journalist exchange is notoriously reflective of the poor bilateral relations - the feel-good rhetoric of the politicians notwithstanding.
Both countries only allow two journalists from the other side to be stationed in the host country - but while the Indians use these positions, the Pakistanis are so uninterested in understanding our 'worst enemy' that no Pakistani reporter is based in India.
The PTI and the Hindu have a correspondent each based in Islamabad and what a welcome they are extended.
They are not allowed to move outside of Islamabad without permission (even Rawalpindi is out of bounds) and they are constantly shadowed by those who cannot prevent terrorist attacks but are aware of every nook and corner visited by the two Indian hacks in the soap dish sized Islamabad.
Yet these two people never forget to remind the one billion people living next doors that there is more than Taliban and extremism to Pakistan. And for those who want proof of this, they need not google the stories that Hasan and Joshua did - they should read the blog, "the Life and Times of Two Indians in Pakistan".
Written mostly by Hasan's wife, the posts paint a warm and engaging picture of her former host country (by the time this story appears in print, the couple will be on their way back to Delhi). Beyond the suo motu notices and the Taliban, these posts are about the more colourful characters that inhabit Islamabad; Mehmal the Lahori journalist; Pakistani music ("Still, give me Pakistani music any day" she writes) and the not to be missed post - about the testosterone filled spooks who follow her around.
After having lived in Islamabad for five and a half years, Rezaul Hasan Lashkar had to pack up and leave in just a little over two weeks.
His sin - he was an Indian and a journalist reporting on Pakistan. And one hot day in the middle of June he was informed that his presence was no longer acceptable to someone, somewhere - through a phone call and a letter.
But despite the unceremonious departure, his one regret - at least in recent days - is that he will not be able to get "some nihari from Kale Khan in Pindi before [he] leave
Perhaps he has more regrets too - about friends he could not say goodbye too or places he was not allowed to visit but such are the state of affairs between his country and Pakistan that he refuses to talk about the issue at all. The longing for nihari too was gleaned from his twitter account.
And this silence says far more than any lengthy interview he may have given. The few details that are available came from someone close to him who spoke on the basis of anonymity.
Hasan - as always - was waiting for a renewal of his visa when on June 13 he got a letter informing him that he should leave by June 23.
The journalist panicked as he had no valid visa by then, without which he could not even leave. Much effort, phone calls and visits later, he was given a 'generous' extension till June 29.
The valid visa came on June 25 - finally making him eligible to leave.
"Two thirds of his time in Pakistan was spent waiting for an extension of his lapsed visa," says the someone.
So much so that twice at least when his wife's father had a heart attack, her family kept the news from her - because neither she nor Hasan could visit India and the ailing father.
Nothing of Hasan's stay is unusual for an Indian journalist in Pakistan but his departure surely is.
The tradition is that "the journalist is allowed a short overlap with his successor for a smooth transition". But both Hasan and Anita Joshua, the second Indian journalist in Pakistan, who were scheduled to leave in any case and were only waiting for their successors to show up, were denied this in recent months.
Indeed, Hasan's abrupt departure came hot on the heels of the return of his counterpart - Anita Joshua of The Hindu - who was asked to leave shortly after the elections (but before the new government took charge) while New York Times' Declan Walsh was bundled out a day after May 11, his notice period even shorter than the Indians.
The story of these three proves that Pakistan is fast turning into not just one of the most dangerous countries for journalists but also one of the most inhospitable.
"What else would you call a place that so abruptly orders out those who have been living here for years on such a short notice," says a senior journalist.
When Walsh was thrown out, Pakistani journalists whispered that it happened because there was no empowered political government in place and the spooks got a chance to avenge past grievances.
But Joshua and Hasan were told to leave after Nawaz Sharif - the statesman who wanted and wants peace with India - has taken over. Yet there is not a peep out of the new government.
As Mariana Babar, a senior journalist, puts it, "These cases show how powerful the security establishment is. Indian journalists were reluctantly issued visas for a few days on eve of elections. The process started during the caretaker government and continued as Sharif government was in the process of settling. Now as The Hindu and Press Trust of India (PTI) have requested visas for new representatives, we will wait and see how much authority Sharif asserts."
Admittedly, the India-Pakistan journalist exchange is notoriously reflective of the poor bilateral relations - the feel-good rhetoric of the politicians notwithstanding.
Both countries only allow two journalists from the other side to be stationed in the host country - but while the Indians use these positions, the Pakistanis are so uninterested in understanding our 'worst enemy' that no Pakistani reporter is based in India.
The PTI and the Hindu have a correspondent each based in Islamabad and what a welcome they are extended.
They are not allowed to move outside of Islamabad without permission (even Rawalpindi is out of bounds) and they are constantly shadowed by those who cannot prevent terrorist attacks but are aware of every nook and corner visited by the two Indian hacks in the soap dish sized Islamabad.
Yet these two people never forget to remind the one billion people living next doors that there is more than Taliban and extremism to Pakistan. And for those who want proof of this, they need not google the stories that Hasan and Joshua did - they should read the blog, "the Life and Times of Two Indians in Pakistan".
Written mostly by Hasan's wife, the posts paint a warm and engaging picture of her former host country (by the time this story appears in print, the couple will be on their way back to Delhi). Beyond the suo motu notices and the Taliban, these posts are about the more colourful characters that inhabit Islamabad; Mehmal the Lahori journalist; Pakistani music ("Still, give me Pakistani music any day" she writes) and the not to be missed post - about the testosterone filled spooks who follow her around.
his visa period expired. so you back apply again get a new visa and come back.
