Pakistan India Border Skirmish 1958 East Pakistan

[khair_ctg]

Dude can you remember other day I said to bring rebellion on us and oust us Bengalis, what about that? Can you torn a bal? And why we have our private army for? In one sense Im also a Muhajir from Murshidabad and Comilla, now in Khulna. What has gone wrong, we are the dominant people here no one opposed us but why you Muhajirs and Razakar Bengalis?

Bengali Muslims or Muslims in general are the dominant people in BD, my foot. if we were we wouldn't have kept Tagore literature and music to represent us, or have changed our own country East Pakistan into "Bangladesh", or have been under Indian military occupation in 1971. these are just few of those many things, we maybe majority-Muslim in this land, but it is the real-majority Hindus in BD and India socio-politically and socio-culturally ruling us. stop smoking whatever it is.

 

[bongbang]

Bengali Muslims or Muslims in general are the dominant people in BD, my foot. if we were we wouldn't have kept Tagore literature and music to represent us, or have changed our own country East Pakistan into "Bangladesh", or have been under Indian military occupation in 1971. these are just few of those many things, we maybe majority-Muslim in this land, but it is the real-majority Hindus in BD and India socio-politically and socio-culturally ruling us. stop smoking whatever it is.

Its our wish we will keep whatever we wish. Maybe great grandfather was Hindu and produced Tagore literature. So converting Muslim we will start to deny our heritage? And what have we Nazrul. Isnt he our national poet. And cant we find questionable elements in his works? Its our wish what we will take. We cant produce another man like Tagore so we bought and patented it. We are so talented. But you are behind illusion of Iqbal. Good good.
And there they killed in 15 August to establish Islamic valued country. Where they changed our flag to Moon and stars? Or changed the song suitable?

 

[Saiful Islam]

Its our wish we will keep whatever we wish. Maybe great grandfather was Hindu and produced Tagore literature. So converting Muslim we will start to deny our heritage? And what have we Nazrul. Isnt he our national poet. And cant we find questionable elements in his works? Its our wish what we will take. We cant produce another man like Tagore so we bought and patented it. We are so talented. But you are behind illusion of Iqbal. Good good.
And there they killed in 15 August to establish Islamic valued country. Where they changed our flag to Moon and stars? Or changed the song suitable?

Moon and star has been here since the time of the Bengal Sultanate, you talk as if this is something new to us. Tagore doesn't represent us but Hindu Bengal to the west, that is their heritage and culture. Rightly so Kazi Nazrul is our poet. And there is nothing wrong with Allama Iqbal he was a talented man who inspired thousands worldwide and is still revered by many.

United Pakistan was created so that the South Asian Muslims could have their own homeland, yes it was based on Islamic values but state would be a secular one.

Do you know anything about your 'Hindu forefathers'?

 

[khair_ctg]

Moon and star has been here since the time of the Bengal Sultanate, you talk as if this is something new to us. Tagore doesn't represent us but Hindu Bengal to the west, that is their heritage and culture. Rightly so Kazi Nazrul is our poet. And there is nothing wrong with Allama Iqbal he was a talented man who inspired thousands worldwide and is still revered by many.

United Pakistan was created so that the South Asian Muslims could have their own homeland, yes it was based on Islamic values but state would be a secular one.

Do you know anything about your 'Hindu forefathers'?

@bongbang is more interested in a certain Brahmin upper class from colonial era (where Tagore hails from) than in his Muslim forefathers or even any pre-Muslim forefathers. the Muslim population and culture from greater Pukhtoonkhwa to Bengal could not have emerged without converts from Hindus-Buddhists. the Indic-Mughal-Persian cultural fusion could not have happened without converts from Hindus-Buddhists. the Indo-Aryan languages associated with Muslims, particularly Urdu, could not have emerged and as our lingua franca without converts from Hindus-Buddhists. what is considered 'Muslim culture' or Allama Iqbal is a better representation of our pre-Islamic roots than Brahmin upper class only from colonial era as seen in the likes of Tagore and Bonkim Chandra.

even Kazi Nazrul Islam grew up among lots of Hindus and the majority of his work is Hindu culture (that is why he was accepted to a certain degree by Bengali Hindus). however what he did for Muslim culture is also truly marvelous. by the way, Kazi Nazrul Islam is originally Bihari, but later naturalized into a Hindu environment when his family moved to West Bengal. the fact that he is muhajir may be why bong bang is not too fond of him. bongbang is a self-hater who regrets having been born into a Muslim family (if what he says is true)/

 

[bongbang]

Kazi Nazrul Islam is originally Bihari, but later naturalized into a Hindu environment when his family moved to West Bengal. the fact that he is muhajir may be why bong bang is not too fond of him.

Its even better. If its true he was from Bihar (Never heard that). All foreigners come and take our culture as their own. Me likes. They can be on our top positions by their talents. What a marvelous piece of example.

bongbang is a self-hater who regrets having been born into a Muslim family (if what he says is true)/

Do you want to say that we Bengali Muslims are second class Muslims? Like your masters from west said? And want to purify our words. Do you expect that still now after getting bitch slap from us?

United Pakistan was created so that the South Asian Muslims could have their own homeland, yes it was based on Islamic values but state would be a secular one.

Do you know anything about your 'Hindu forefathers'?

Dude can I suggest you to not quote me? Because you are a 20 years old kid and do not understand things. And throw words all around. Plz go to study. And keep matters to your own country Britain.
I was talking about 15th August 1975. They Killed Sheikh Mujib keeping in mind to establish many agendas. One of them was to change country values for majority Muslim people.

 

[Saiful Islam]

Its even better. If its true he was from Bihar (Never heard that). All foreigners come and take our culture as their own. Me likes. They can be on our top positions by their talents. What a marvelous piece of example.



Do you want to say that we Bengali Muslims are second class Muslims? Like your masters from west said? And want to purify our words. Do you expect that still now after getting bitch slap from us?



Dude can I suggest you to not quote me? Because you are a 20 years old kid and do not understand things. And throw words all around. Plz go to study. And keep matters to your own country Britain.
I was talking about 15th August 1975. They Killed Sheikh Mujib keeping in mind to establish many agendas. One of them was to change country values for majority Muslim people.

Hasar math khoyleh zoleh (Telling the truth burns). That is all it is my brother. I am a Bengali and my parents hail from Bangladesh so I have a right to be interested in my parents homeland, you do not dictate my interests.

There isn't much to study about Bangladesh's brief history.

 

[khair_ctg]

Its even better. If its true he was from Bihar (Never heard that). All foreigners come and take our culture as their own. Me likes. They can be on our top positions by their talents. What a marvelous piece of example.

in a civilized non-fascist society or in a society that is not considered a joke, a settler from elsewhere generally does not forgo their native culture wherever it is from. the settler's offspring might not have the same culture as the settler but that is due to intermarriage or social influence. a society having permanent settlers from elsewhere never stays the same, or should not stay the same.

Kazi Nazrul Islam grew up with lots of Hindus. that is why his works have so much Hindu culture and mythology (because you are possibly a Hindu, you referred to the Hindus' culture as "our" culture). if Kazi Nazrul Islam worked only with Muslim culture and history, we probably would not have even heard of him - so dominant the Bengali Hindus were/are over Bengal Muslims.

 

[Saiful Islam]

in a civilized non-fascist society or in a society that is not considered a joke, a settler from elsewhere generally does not forgo their native culture wherever it is from. the settler's offspring might not have the same culture as the settler but that is due to intermarriage or social influence. a society having permanent settlers from elsewhere never stays the same, or should not stay the same.

Kazi Nazrul Islam grew up with lots of Hindus. that is why his works have so much Hindu culture and mythology (because you are possibly a Hindu, you referred to the Hindus' culture as "our" culture). if Kazi Nazrul Islam worked only with Muslim culture and history, we probably would not have even heard of him - so dominant the Bengali Hindus were/are over Bengal Muslims.

So unfortunate we were oppressed by Brits and their Hindu elite collaborators. May I ask did the same thing not happen in Pakistan (Punjab/Sindh) and other Muslim majority areas as they were all under Brit rule...