What's new

Opinion: Facilities in Pakistan much safer than India for sportswomen

Zibago

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2012
Messages
37,006
Reaction score
12
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Opinion: Facilities in Pakistan much safer than India for sportswomen
Kiran Khan
India may be way ahead of Pakistan in terms of sports infrastructure, but in Pakistan sports facilities don't pose a danger of sexual harassment. (Getty Images)

#india #pakistan #sai #sports authority of india
It shook me across the border. I am sure the ground in India was badly shaken as well, for I never thought the situation in a country that has far better talent and and far better facilities could be this bad for budding athletes.

As disturbing as this incident was, that four girls took this step to end there life, the thing that bothers me is that many young girls have no choice but to either hide or keep secret any harassments they are subjected to. They do this in fear of what their families and society will think of them if discovered. They realise that whatever they do, whatever action they take, reflects back on the honour of their families. They would much rather suffer in silence than allow themselves the brunt for getting their voices heard.

Furthermore, many girls, who wish to pursue sports, realise that they live in a society where women are, for the most part, quick to be blamed for the wrongdoings of their male counterparts; a society where women are more than often seen as someone who should not be allowed to live on her terms. Men do everything in their power to stay as invisible as possible, especially when it comes to the sensitive issue of sexual harassment.

Introducing you to the situation in Pakistan, women's participation in sports here has a long history; a history evident by discrimination but also one tugged with major accomplishments by female athletes. Pakistani women in sports marked excellence in heaps.

We have numerous successful stories when it comes to women in sports. Athletes likes Naseem Hamid (athletics), Lianna Swan (swimming), Palwasha Bashir (badminton), Farwa Babar (table tennis) and Ushna Suhail (tennis) are some of the best female athletes in Pakistan.

It has never been easy and simple for Pakistani women who play sports in a Muslim and a male-dominating country but yet they are sweating it out and making a lot of effort.

In Pakistan, sexual harassment is probably not a deterrent for women to take up sports. It's a Muslim country. While a girl may face sexual harassment, she has a family hurdle to cross too. It's the parents who fear and are scared to send girls out alone. And I don't blame the fear of those parents. I blame our men; the way they look at you is no less harassment.

But there have been incidents even here. If you belong to a stronger family background, they [men] wouldn't even dare to raise their eyes. But I have seen girls who themselves get frank with the coaches and things happen. I have witnessed it and I seriously have no clue who to blame.

But definitely in terms of infrastructure, India is way ahead of Pakistan.

"I think Pakistan is a country where there are certain activities/professions that women may feel conscious to peruse because of our thinking and the way our society thinks," tennis player Ushna Suhail told me in a conversation. "Being a Pakistani sportswoman, I have limitations regarding my sport facilities. In such a situation, it is important that Pakistani girls are supported and looked after by trusted elders, preferably parents, to protect them from any mental or sexual torture that may come their way."

The Pakistan Association of Women Sport, affiliated with the national sports organisation, is active in promoting women's participation in sports within Pakistan. The association also promotes the importance of sports as a mean for bridging cross-cultural difference which enhances cooperation, peace and development in the country and internationally.

Besides several engendering social problems, training and coaching is major concern for those women who want to excel in the field of sports. Pakistan lacks in providing female coaches to female athletes; however, now former players have stepped in to help these dedicated athletes.

But nothing may work for a girl, be it India or Pakistan, if she has to counter sexual harassment during training. The focus will go for a toss. Forget about developing 'champion athletes', we might end up taking care of 'depressed patients' if it doesn't stop.
Opinion: Facilities in Pakistan much safer than India for sportswomen - IBNLive
 
Both are by and large backward societies, with Pakistan being a bit more conservative. The suicide pact incident was really shocking, all for being taunted for having a beer... fuk'd up

I guess in more conservative Pakistan, teenage girls generally wont have a beer.. much safer
 
Both are by and large backward societies, with Pakistan being a bit more conservative. The suicide pact incident was really shocking, all for being taunted for having a beer... fuk'd up

I guess in more conservative Pakistan, teenage girls generally wont have a beer.. much safer

But when did they say it was 'sexual' harassment??? They said 'harassment' as in wanton torture- apparently the instructor would hit the girls with an oar or something.
 
But when did they say it was 'sexual' harassment??? They said 'harassment' as in wanton torture- apparently the instructor would hit the girls with an oar or something.
yeah, there was no 'sexual' harassment, but there were reports of oar beatings. I think the author is confused, or maybe she was making a broader point.
 
But when did they say it was 'sexual' harassment??? They said 'harassment' as in wanton torture- apparently the instructor would hit the girls with an oar or something.
yeah, there was no 'sexual' harassment, but there were reports of oar beatings. I think the author is confused, or maybe she was making a broader point.

It wasn't sexual harassment at all - in fact one of the victims had reportedly alleged physical harassment by the fellow senior sportswomen at SAI to be the cause. The matter is under investigation - the writer should have the patience to wait for the outcome of the investigation at least.

Rowing athlete Aparna's kin allege seniors harassed her - timesofindia-economictimes

Though the fault of SAI can't be overlooked in this case - They should have mental counsellors or psychologists in their centers.
 
Last edited:
yeah, there was no 'sexual' harassment, but there were reports of oar beatings. I think the author is confused, or maybe she was making a broader point.
No she is a deluded feminist crying for attention. Instead of creating a future where families understand sexual harassment and discourage it ,where women are strong enough to report the crimes and not buckle under them she whines about everything else. BTW what has infrastructure have to do with harassment, lack of infrastructure is a bane which all sportsmen of this country face,she is talking as if it is good for men and women are lacking.
What I hate with them is that they don't provide solutions but just nag all along, these days feminists want to consider even the looks of a man as harassment LOL how will you prove such things in court? with the women don't lie fallacy? don't look at everything from a feminist prism lady.
 
It wasn't sexual harassment at all - in fact one of the victims had reportedly alleged physical harassment by the fellow senior sportswomen at SAI to be the cause. The matter is under investigation - the writer should have the patience to wait for the outcome of the investigation at least.

Rowing athlete Aparna's kin allege seniors harassed her - timesofindia-economictimes
agree, but this was not so much India bashing as just general talk.. she also went on to say that:

"Being a Pakistani sportswoman, I have limitations regarding my sport facilities. In such a situation, it is important that Pakistani girls are supported and looked after by trusted elders, preferably parents, to protect them from any mental or sexual torture that may come their way."
 
I guess in more conservative Pakistan, teenage girls generally wont have a beer.. much safer

Good thing ain't it? minors shouldn't be served alcohol anyways....
No she is a deluded feminist crying for attention. Instead of creating a future where families understand sexual harassment and discourage it ,where women are strong enough to report the crimes and not buckle under them she whines about everything else. BTW what has infrastructure have to do with harassment, lack of infrastructure is a bane which all sportsmen of this country face,she is talking as if it is good for men and women are lacking.
What I hate with them is that they don't provide solutions but just nag all along, these days feminists want to consider even the looks of a man as harassment LOL how will you prove such things in court? with the women don't lie fallacy? don't look at everything from a feminist prism lady.
You should try burqa i highly recommend it!
 
IBN is not a Pakistani news group

You just scraped an article off the internet,without any idea about who wrote it, didn't you ?

Firstly, find out, what Opinion Section means.. and secondly, the author is a former Pakistani swimmer.

@ this bakwas topic..

What kind of cherry picking is this ?

What is the author actually trying to say ?

India may be better than Pakistan economically, in terms of sports and in terms of women safety too, but, if you superimpose the sets, then you may come out with a small subset, which portrays Pakistan in a better light. And the veracity for such a comparison is again highly debatable.

I have been closely related to sports all my life and from my experience I can very well say, nobody has ever conducted any such comparative analysis. What the author is saying is figments of her own imagination, cheap publicity stunt at best.

If she is former respectable sports woman from Pakistan, then she should do something about her own field, rather than trying to take potshots at India.
Last time I checked Pakistan Hokey Federation had to be offered bail-out money by Hokey India, which they had to decline due to political pressure.
 
Last edited:
Indian people in different sports are mostly people with filthy attitude. Right from coach to ground support crew !
 
Last edited:

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom