No one can change history - we are the same people, says Pakistani author

[Pakistani shaheens]

Given a Million dollar to say that I will reject the offer. We have nothing to do with Pakistan.

Its Pakistan watching our movies , playing Indian movie songs in their marriage and Their kids imitating Indian culture.

lOl A NATION which has not yet decided what they are ? lol Arabs, Buddhist, dalits converted ?

History books fully distorted and No resemblance to IVC to prevailing culture of Pakistan.

We Pakistanis also watch hollywood, so does that means we are americans?

We know who we really are, but its you indians who are living under inferiority complex and always relates others with your self.

Leave it bro.We are the only one in the world that still follow IVC and for others it is just a Pagan beliefs.So let it keep that way.

India is a very diverse country. The south indians are different from north and eastern side of your country is totally different from the main land, infact each and every region of your country is distinct from others, you just cant say all indians have adopted IVC culture.

lol it should be but than it brings the question why do we hate each other? and that's not good for identity of Pakistan because Pakistani identity was made by hating India.

No! its the other way around, just look at your own country where your politicians get vote by delivering anti pakistan speeches and your media 24/7 remains busy in bashing Pakistan.
Frankly speaking we dont even give a dam about indians, it is only you insecure indians who always feel excited when some one gives candy to you guys by saying Pakistanis and indians are same people

 

[farhan_9909]

AFAIK Pakistan is an Islamic Emirate .

Ok but we don't follow our culture?please answer my this question

 

[gau8av]

well, you can't deny that there is much shared north Indian and Punjabi culture (I understand Pakistan has a big Punjab of their own ?)

 

[SrNair]

We Pakistanis also watch hollywood, so does that means we are americans?

We know who we really are, but its you indians who are living under inferiority complex and always relates others with your self.

India is a very diverse country. The south indians are different from north and eastern side of your country is totally different from the main land, infact each and every region of your country is distinct from others, you just cant say all indians have adopted IVC culture.

No! its the other way around, just look at your own country where your politicians get vote by delivering anti pakistan speeches and your media 24/7 remains busy in bashing Pakistan.
Frankly speaking we dont even give a dam about indians, it is only you insecure indians who always feel excited when some one gives candy to you guys by saying Pakistanis and indians are same people

FYI we adopted IVC culture whole heartedly and still remain as a strong unity factor among us.Its evolved form Hinduism is our culture where Lord Krishna is a God of NIndians,South Indians or entire Indians .

Ok but we don't follow our culture?please answer my this question

Actually I dont know the real culture of Pakistan .Pasthun may be Afghan culture .Dont know about others .
But I have read a lot of reply from Pakistanis in here about their foreign ancestry
So I got this concept only after some of the posts of your own countrymen in various threads.And quite amazingly you guys still love our Bollywood fim and other cultural aspects.
So in brief I dont know what you mean by these your own culture ?
Please explain .

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Is she talking about certain parts of Punjab and Sindh? Because Pashtun and Baloch certainly share nothing with Hindustan.

Do you know the words Pashtun and Baloch are both of Sanskrit origin?

 

[farhan_9909]

FYI we adopted IVC culture whole heartedly and still remain as a strong unity factor among us.Its evolved form Hinduism is our culture where Lord Krishna is a God of NIndians,South Indians or entire Indians .



Actually I dont know the real culture of Pakistan .Pasthun may be Afghan culture .Dont know about others .
But I have read a lot of reply from Pakistanis in here about their foreign ancestry
So I got this concept only after some of the posts of your own countrymen in various posts.And quite amazingly you guys still love our Bollywood fim and other cultural aspects.
So in brief I dont know what you mean by these your own culture ?
Please explain .

Each Ethnicity in Pakistan has a unique Culture,Such as Pashtun culture is similar to those of Afghanistan,Baloch Culture is completely Different to the rest of Pakistan,Sindhi and Punjabi Culture is somewhat similar but not exactly

In UAE,60% of the Audience in cinemas to watch hindi movies are arabs,in Afghanistan majority of the people watch Bollywood.People watch Bollywood for entertainment,not that they love indian culture or something related.They watch it because Bollywood does has some quality stuff coming out of them.

This is increasingly stupid to think that Pakistanis are indians because we watch indian movies/drama.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

OTOH - Pakistan and India were the same people. Then came 1947.
Now Pakistan is most certainly not 'Indian'. The opposite? Yes, to a large extent.
Pakistan has gone a different way - consciously. We have owned up to our ways, our history, our native culture, rituals etc. So yes, she is wrong.

And also importantly - HISTORY CAN be changed. Over a period of time.

 

[Pakistani shaheens]

Do you know the words Pashtun and Baloch are both of Sanskrit origin?

And a word "india" was derived from the river which flows across Pakistan. And the word "hindu" is the derived from our province Sindh which was previously called sindhu.

OTOH - Pakistan and India were the same people. Then came 1947.
Now Pakistan is most certainly not 'Indian'. The opposite? Yes, to a large extent.
Pakistan has gone a different way - consciously. We have owned up to our ways, our history, our native culture, rituals etc. So yes, she is wrong.

1947 was the outcome of the difference that we had. If we were same then the year1947 wouldn't be so much important.

FYI we adopted IVC culture whole heartedly and still remain as a strong unity factor among us.Its evolved form Hinduism is our culture where Lord Krishna is a God of NIndians,South Indians or entire Indians ..

No that's completely wrong assumption, the people of your country differs from eachother in all aspects. They are all different be it in terms of language, culture, color or any other thing.

And by then way you have mentioned that Lord Krishna is your god but there are other people are also living in your country who are not following lord Krishnas religion. So by saying that india is united because of culture or religion, is actually a wrong assumption, india is today United because of its army, not because of the culture and religion which is not actually common thing in your country

 

[SrNair]

Each Ethnicity in Pakistan has a unique Culture,Such as Pashtun culture is similar to those of Afghanistan,Baloch Culture is completely Different to the rest of Pakistan,Sindhi and Punjabi Culture is somewhat similar but not exactly

In UAE,60% of the Audience in cinemas to watch hindi movies are arabs,in Afghanistan majority of the people watch Bollywood.People watch Bollywood for entertainment,not that they love indian culture or something related.They watch it because Bollywood does has some quality stuff coming out of them.

This is increasingly stupid to think that Pakistanis are indians because we watch indian movies/drama.

So in sense .Dont have any unified culture except those religion.

 

[ChennaiDude]

And a word "india" was derived from the river which flows across Pakistan. And the word "hindu" is the derived from our province Sindh which was previously called sindhu.

1947 was the outcome of the difference that we had. If we were same then the year1947 wouldn't be so much important.

No that's completely wrong assumption, the people of your country differs from eachother in all aspects. They are all different be it in terms of language, culture, color or any other thing.

And by then way you have mentioned that Lord Krishna is your god but there are other people are also living in your country who are not following lord Krishnas religion. So by saying that india is united because of culture or religion, is actually a wrong assumption, india is today United because of its army, not because of the culture and religion which is not actually common thing in your country

Can be elaborate on the bolded part for me..Please.

 

[Pakistani shaheens]

We Marathas reached Attock and Peshawar and let us tell you that Pakistanis are very passive people. They needed Abdali to rescue them lol

Meanwhile you guys were seeking help from british. lol

Beta ji, indian Maurya, Gupta and Maratha conquered you people and took your women. Have some shame

Baba ji! Have you forgot what we Muslims did with you guys in the past and how you guys laid infront of your master british to get your self free from our rule.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

And a word "india" was derived from the river which flows across Pakistan. And the word "hindu" is the derived from our province Sindh which was previously called sindhu.

The name of our country is - Bharatiya Ganarajya. This is completely of native origin. Republic of India is the English for it.
Hindu is derived from Sindhu - this is true. Sindh is there in our national anthem as well. We love Sindh.

1947 was the outcome of the difference that we had. If we were same then the year1947 wouldn't be so much important.

We were the same. The difference was the God we prayed to. Funny don't you think? Just the method of worship made a West Punjabi and East Punjabi different... Ok, it's more tragic than funny considering the blood that flowed. As for the riots - they were engineered for politics. People were uneducated. There was no self radicalization as is now. There was no internet that one would watch some mullahs video and start a riot. No, they did because they were mobilized by efficient and ruthless politicians. That was all.

 

[Pakistani shaheens]

Can be elaborate on the bolded part for me..Please.

dont need to just look closely what's happening inside your country

 

[SarthakGanguly]

indian Maurya, Gupta and Maratha conquered you people and took your women.

Actually no Indic ruler had the distinction of doing mass rape anywhere. Even when the Marathas moved in, they did not destroy the mosques and did not touch the women. Let's not confuse them with barbarians.

 

[SrNair]

And a word "india" was derived from the river which flows across Pakistan. And the word "hindu" is the derived from our province Sindh which was previously called sindhu.

1947 was the outcome of the difference that we had. If we were same then the year1947 wouldn't be so much important.

No that's completely wrong assumption, the people of your country differs from eachother in all aspects. They are all different be it in terms of language, culture, color or any other thing.

And by then way you have mentioned that Lord Krishna is your god but there are other people are also living in your country who are not following lord Krishnas religion. So by saying that india is united because of culture or religion, is actually a wrong assumption, india is today United because of its army, not because of the culture and religion which is not actually common thing in your country

Absolutely wrong dude ,Absolutely .
India dont need Army for their unity.We all are Army and we all are one.Lord Krishna was just one example .But our evolved IVC culture ,Hinduism is a way of life .And Indians from Kanyakumari to Kashmir and Gujarat to NE still follow that way of culture.We have different culture ,language etc etc .
But you can see Sikh Pilgrims in Sri Padmanbhaswamy temple for the blessing of Hindu god Maha Vishnu in Souther Kerala.
That is the power of these culture.