What's new

Navy to MOD: Avoid Mazagon Docks for Project-75I

sudhir007

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
4,728
Reaction score
1
Navy to MOD: Avoid Mazagon Docks for Project-75I | idrw.org

Indian Navy in its recommendation to Ministry of defence (MOD) has asked to avoid giving any orders to State-owned Mazagon Docks for local construction of new Conventional submarines under Project-75I.

Recommendation highlights major mistrust between Indian navy and Countries only State-owned Shipyards with any experience in building submarines in India. Experts say recommendation by India navy will not be easy to be ignored by MOD.

Navy observation says shipyard is overflowing with orders and does not have the capability to stick to deliveries. 6 Scorpène submarine under construction at Mazagon Docks is already behind schedule by four years, one of the major reason reported was due to Mazagon Docks inability to build capacity in house which lead to delays . recently Defence minister Manohar Parrikar in Rajya Sabha also confirmed that delays under Project-75 was due to Mazagon Docks inabilities to absolve TOT .

Indian navy is also against any order to be given to Hindustan Shipyard located at Vishakapatnam. Hindustan Shipyard has also come under heavy criticism for last few years after it botched up mid-life upgrade of a kilo class submarine INS Sindhukirti which has been under mid-life refits in shipyard from 2006 onward and even after 9 years Shipyard has not been able to deliver the submarine to Indian navy Delivery schedule is already delayed by 6 years from the original estimate of 3 years.
 
.
Navy and MDL must answer what they did with the ToT for HDW and Scorpene submarines. We paid lots of money for ToT.
 
. . .
Yes,

Time to kick the a**es of PSU. You could not refit a sub in 9 years and you want o build a sophesticated Sub you fools. Do some small jobs. You are not worth awarding this contract.
 
. .
Hell no I did'nt; which is why I'm not blabbering about it ....... unlike you! :rofl:
But I have an idea what level that TOT is at.... do you? ;)
No bro, I haven't but But than whats the point of ToT? Its main point is absorbing technologies.
 
.
I heard Navy had Pipav and L&T in mind while saying this. Since L&T was involved with homemade nuclear submarine Arihant , it sounds only natural that L&T is given preference.
But as far as Pipav is concerned then the timing of the buyout of Pipavav by Reliance Group coincides with the committee's assessment. Now this going to get controversial!!!
 
.
I heard Navy had Pipav and L&T in mind while saying this. Since L&T was involved with homemade nuclear submarine Arihant , it sounds only natural that L&T is given preference.
But as far as Pipav is concerned then the timing of the buyout of Pipavav by Reliance Group coincides with the committee's assessment. Now this going to get controversial!!!
Let it be but you can trust modi and parikkar 1000 times more than any of the past PM &DM in india
 
. .
I can trust Modi and Parrikar but not Reliance.

True, but you know the productivity of this PSU workers are one of the lowest you could find......... Remember listening to some one who knows how these guys works in CSL..... out of 8 hours, be happy if they work on the project for 2 hours....
 
.
True, but you know the productivity of this PSU workers are one of the lowest you could find......... Remember listening to some one who knows how these guys works in CSL..... out of 8 hours, be happy if they work on the project for 2 hours....
True!

Right now HSL's hands 're full after their deal with Hyundai(s.Korea) , i think they should be kept out this. But then again to bid for this order (of 6 submarines) HSL had formed a consortium with Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited and MDN (Mishra Dhatu Nigam). So I expected they would be able to work faster this time.
 
Last edited:
.
I heard Navy had Pipav and L&T in mind while saying this. Since L&T was involved with homemade nuclear submarine Arihant , it sounds only natural that L&T is given preference.
But as far as Pipav is concerned then the timing of the buyout of Pipavav by Reliance Group coincides with the committee's assessment. Now this going to get controversial!!!
If this deal goes in private sector then it would definitely goes to L&T, who have required infrastructure for this.
Apart from that LIC is largest stakeholder in L&T & you know who control LIC:azn:
 
.
Mazagon already having many orders from navy,so it won't affect there revenue. Good suggestion from navy ,it will give birth new capable shipyards for undertaking such hi-fi projects.
 
.
If this deal goes in private sector then it would definitely goes to L&T, who have required infrastructure for this.
Apart from that LIC is largest stakeholder in L&T & you know who control LIC:azn:
It is state owned.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom