Before the "mods" disarm my logical arguments. Here it is.
My arguments:
So is every other city bro
Han bhai aisa hota hai. Ap akele nai ho. Ye propoganda bari der se chal rha hai. And it only increases the victimhood sentiments of folks like you.
Pura Pakistan Karachi port se business karta hai.
Ap log aise baat krte ho jese sab ap ka hi hai bas jo Karachi port p ata hai.
Yahi to keh raha bhai pure Pakistan ka paisa ata hai Karachi mein aur maal(goods) inland wapis jata hai. So technically it is not ALL your capital.
Baki Pakistanion k capital/maal ko bhi ap log apna zahir krte ho.
Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad se bahir dunya hai.
Lahore also dont have paani, kachra is everywhere as well, sarkain waha bhi tooti hui thin lekin Nawaz brothers really love makimg roads to zara behtri ayi hai. Warna pehle wo bhi aisa hi tha.
Abey woi to keh rha hu poora Pakistan Karachi mein invest krta hai maal import karta hai aur local and federal taxes deta hai.
Aqal zyadi moti ho gai Karachi propogande ki waja se??
Yar lahoriyon se ja k pucho bechare 80% sewage aur water lines mixed pani pete hain.
Bijli pure mulk me nahi ati thi in early 2000s lekin Geo news ki khabar me yahi ati tha "Karachi roshnion k shehar me bijli nahi a rahi". To BC jo baki mulk me andhera macha hua hai wo??
Waderey ka masla tum logon ko. Acha wadere/Sardar/Saeen/Chaudhry G/Zameendar sahb/Masharan pure Pakistan(Sindh, KPK, FATA, Balochistan, Punjab) waderon ne sab ko age lgaya hua hai.
Bare projects ki complaint. Acha g. Jab federal govt project lgane ati hai to tumhare Saeen log from PPP and Bhaya log from MQM say 18 tarmeem. Federal govt has no jurisdiction in Sindh, hamein funds de do. Then gharam all the funds go in PPP and neo-MQM bellies. Tum log baki Pakistanio ko hi koste reh jate ho.
Ajr kya complain hai??
Pura Pakistan similar problems se guzar rha hai. Chotey shehron mein adha adha din bijli/gas nahi ati tum logon ka randi rona nahi mukta.
Tum logon ko paisa dete to hain tumhare sardar/wadera/bhai log and various mafias kha jate hain to ham kya karein??
Apne ap ko bhi to thora theek karo.
Gen Amjad Shoaib was once saying in a video clip how Baloch Sardar pockets all the federal money and intentionally keeps his people dirt poor and uneducated to perpetuate hate against state of Pakistan and keep them under hos control.
So above is one example
Ye kab keh rha hu mai. Tum logo k liye khas packages announce hote hain wo sab paisa idhar udhar ho jata hai to bhai ham kya karein.
Dasso??
Voice raise krne me aur randi roney me farq hota hai. Ap logon me victim mentality kuch ziyada hi barh gai hai. And I don't think it is accidental. Rather well planned to break Karachi/Sindh from Pakistan.
To hamara bhi to Punjab govt ko jata hai saeen. Allah k bande.
Your whole premise is absed on:
Karachi sab paise tax wagera deta hai, Pakistan ka raziq hai, aur Karachi ko kuch nahi milta.
Maarey gaye, luttey gaye, barbaad ho gaye.
And the big bad Punjabi spectre is out to get us.
POOORA PREMISE IS BAAT PAR BASED HAI
And then you say:
Ye mera reply nahi tha kisi aur ne kiya. Me pas khara ho kar meley mein tamasha dekh rha tha.
Bottom line ye hai:
Karachi ki problems hain!!
Aur wo Karachi me rehne wale PPP/neoMQM and various mafias ki waja se hai
Lekin unhi same logon ne ap sab ko ye sikha diya hai k blame Punjab/Federation and play the victim card(the whole Punjabi Army propoganda which India gave to Sheikh Mujib he used it as weapon and then passed it on to Altaf, he shared it with others like Achaqzai and harri and murrys of Balochistan).
So they won't have to face any flak. Essentially diverting all blame on Punjab/Federal govt.
@AZ1 yahan a jao I'm gonna post your whole chain of thought as well.
My post as well:
All I'm saying instead of making Karachi into a false deity.
Go travel across Pakistan
And see that most of Pakistan is also going through same problems at hands of wadera class
Karachi is not some unique case
You people try to portray yourself as if you are in Kashmir or somthn
NOW
The karachiwala bhai jaans:
Which city paying 60% revenue and not even getting basic needs like clean streets, drinking clean water or better roads?
Its easy to pass judgement sitting outside because you are not at receivig end.
Broe aisa hota hai kia?
Yeh propaganda nahi hai bhai its reality and its not just me its whole karachi sufferig. My punjabi friend few days cursing PTI because he has no water he lives in karachi too. Was also complaining about his house street totally destroyed no work.
Yaha abhi lahore mai kachra nahi utha tou buzdar buzdar start higaya tha.
Propaganda se dar hai tou pehlay performance tou do then we will talk.
Aik tarsf ap bata bhi rahay ho ke yeh hai karachi ki value aur totallly neglect bhi kar rhaay ho due to ur hate towards karachi ppl?
Then there should be no issue we karachities asking to spend karachi money in karachi right?
Ap ko bora lag raha hai tou alternate use karlein ager hai tou. Karachities ais liye yaad karatay ke hum ko kia mil raha hai? Ais maal se ? Yani ap business karay jao using karachi ar karschi wala itna bhi sawal na karay ke clean water hi dei do pinay ke liye.
tou ap ko mubarak ho wo dunya bhai jaha ap reh rahey ho. hamari yahi dunya hie hum ko ais ko fix karney do
Theek hei lahore main bhi issue but jaha jaha issue hie wo voice raise kareinge ya nah? ya ap kaho ge propaganda hie yeh.
Remember karachi jitna build hoga utna revenue generate karey ga for whole pakistan they will do business in karachi as you said.
trust me aesa hi hie, road street lights etc gutter cleaning etc apnay hi paiso se kar rahey hie aker dekho tou sahi. Boaring apney paiso ka, peenay ke liye paani alag se mangwatey hie apno paiso ka. phir water bill alag se detay hie aur aus mei 10% tax alag se detay hie. Mai nie kaha na it's easy to say come live in karachi for 5 years then you will understand.
Milay ga tou idher udher hoga na. Sindh ko jata hie govt ko
tou baba ji ap alag se thread banao punjab ke liye waha rona roo na kis nie mana kara hie? hum tou nahi kaheinge ke propaganda kar rahey ho(I listened made a seperate thread for you
)
abhi karachi ko jo banaya hie aus per yeh haal hie tou ager hum ais ko paris bana denge tou phir tou pata nahi kai hoga.
aur sarey kaam hum karei? ap beth kar bahshan do karachi per?
ap yeh sab kaam kartay ho bas country se bahar reh kar.
mei mqm aur ppp ke game mei nahi parta but ager ap nie yeh kaha hie tou bata deta ho ap check karlo 2008 ka karachi aur aj ka karachi lag pata jana hie.
AND ABOUT 6 PAGES MORE......
My main premise/argument
Bottom line ye hai:
Karachi ki problems hain!!
Aur wo Karachi me rehne wale PPP/neoMQM and various mafias ki waja se hai
Lekin unhi same logon ne ap sab ko ye sikha diya hai k blame Punjab/Federation and play the victim card(the whole Punjabi Army propoganda which India gave to Sheikh Mujib he used it as weapon and then passed it on to Altaf, he shared it with others like Achaqzai and harri and murrys of Balochistan).
So they won't have to face any flak. Essentially diverting all blame on Punjab/Federal govt
Karachiwala bhai jaan(Karachiite kaho ga to ghussa lage ga) premise/main argument.
Your whole premise is absed on:
Karachi sab paise tax wagera deta hai, Pakistan ka raziq hai, aur Karachi ko kuch nahi milta.
And the big bad Punjabi spectre is out to get us.
Lo bai sab PDF walo everything is in front of you. You be the judge. Ap sab log mere shahid hain. Maybe not Dubious. But that's okay.
KaPow PDF hall of famers
@Metal 0-1 ap ko nai bhoola.
@Horus @AgNoStiC MuSliM @araz @airomerix @Arsalan @AZADPAKISTAN2009 @BHarwana @Foxtrot Alpha @Irfan Baloch @Imran Khan @Jango @krash @LeGenD @Moonlight @Side-Winder @Rocsa
@waz @Aamir Hussain
@Ahmet Pasha @aliyusuf @ARMalik @Angry Easterling @crankthatskunk @Cookie Monster @Counter-Errorist @Dil Pakistan @Gryphon @GumNaam @HRK @khansaheeb @Liquidmetal @Muhammad Omar @NA71 @Nasr @notorious_eagle @Pakistani Fighter @PAKISTANFOREVER @Path-Finder @PDFChamp @PWFI @Rafi @Reichsmarschall @Riz @Safriz @Shane @Signalian @Starlord @Stealth @StormBreaker @Thorough Pro @TsAr @Trango Towers @undercover JIX @Verve @ziaulislam @Zulfiqar
