Tamil Nadu | Posted on Mar 19, 2012 at 12:08pm IST
TN: Khaki blind to Dalit plight
indianexpressSangeetha Neeraja
CHENNAI: Over two years ago, Usha (28) saw her husband Raja being lynched by a caste Hindu mob in Villupuram in broad daylight. Over 100 people armed with sickles, iron bars, knives and stones, hit my husband in front of me and my daughters;� broke his skull and gouged his eyes out before killing him. What did the police do? Nothing. Two years have passed since the incident occurred. No action has been taken so far, says Usha.
She was narrating her plight at a recent public hearing on the Atrocities and Non-implementation of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act and Tamil Nadu Rules in the city. Ushas presentation put the glare on caste bias that is very much alive and kicking in our backyard.
In fact, less than one per cent of the accused get convicted under the SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities (PoA) Act, according to statistics released by the National Crime Records Bureau in 2009. And almost 95 per cent of complaints filed by members of the SC/ST community are not even recorded. Of the five per cent of complaints based on which First Information Reports (FIRs) are filed, hardly any move forward as counter cases filed by the accused to render them ineffective.
As Bharathan, a Dalit rights activist, who had helped Dalits file 218 FIRs in 2008 under the SC/ST(PoA) Act, points out, Unless some civil society groups or NGOs support the victim, their complaints are never accepted by the cops.
What is sad to note is, the police often advise the accused on how to come up with the best counter-case, to nullify the victims complaint. Cops prefer to investigate the counter cases, ignoring the original complaints filed by the victims. Often, FIRs are not filed under the SC/ST Act but under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code (minor injury) or under Section 294-B of the IPC (singing, reciting or uttering any obscene song, ballad or words, in or near any public place), so it becomes easy later to force Dalits to settle for a compromise.
To prove his point, he cites the case of a Arunthaiyar woman, who registered a complaint at Surandai police station in Tirunelveli on February 22. A caste Hindu verbally abused her in public. Though the cops gave the woman a CRS receipt after filing an FIR, they changed the case to that of causing public nuisance, after allegedly consulting the towns panchayat chairman. The case was closed after later.
When a case gets past the FIR into the investigation level, the person who wrote the FIR is king. The way he words it is very important. Most of the time, it is mildly worded with an intention to water down the intensity of the atrocity. Which is one reason why the charges rarely stick and the accused gets acquitted easily. The DSP, who is supposed to investigate the case as per the SC/ST Act is forever missing in action, says Bharathan.
On rare occasions, the DSP files a fair investigation report. If and when that happens, he is transferred after the case comes to court, he argues And the investigation is handed over to the local police, who try their best to get the case nullified.
Under the SC/ST Act, every district is supposed to have a SC/ST Act monitoring cell, which is a five-member body, presided by the district collector. If a DSP dismisses a case, he has to present it to this cell. Sadly, the district-level monitoring cells are entirely dysfunctional.
When Dalit or tribal women go to police stations, they end up interacting with male cops, not policewomen. The policemen hardly listen to them or take down their grievances, charges Kalpana, advisor, Tamil Nadu Federation of Women Panchayat Leaders. Besides, policemen are often not polite to Dalits, she points out.
In fact, 18 per cent of the population in Tamil Nadu comprises Dalits. Tribals constitute one per cent of the population. Yet, job vacancies reserved for them are not filled up, citing spurious reasons, such as lack of suitable candidates, observes Kalpana.
There are about 450 types of discrimination and atrocities practiced by caste Hindus against SC/STs, out of which 32 are visible. The rest fall under various heads of visibility. Some are so well disguised that you can figure them out only if you happen to be a Dalit.
For example, a Block Development Officer who was previously posted in the Villathikulam panchayat Union office, would get up every time the Dalit Panchayat president visited him. He would keep standing till the conversation was over often stretching to 25-30 minutes to avoid asking the Dalit to take a seat, argue activists.
At the public hearing, cases broadly falling under social exclusion infringement of customary rights to public places like water, road, graveyard, police atrocities resulting in custodial deaths, rape and sexual assault, abuse of women in power at the panchayat level were discussed.
Indian agencies need to act to stop these atrocities it is simply not good enough to make laws to protect Dalits if the ones who are in place to stop illegal acts ignore them
TN: Khaki blind to Dalit plight
indianexpressSangeetha Neeraja
CHENNAI: Over two years ago, Usha (28) saw her husband Raja being lynched by a caste Hindu mob in Villupuram in broad daylight. Over 100 people armed with sickles, iron bars, knives and stones, hit my husband in front of me and my daughters;� broke his skull and gouged his eyes out before killing him. What did the police do? Nothing. Two years have passed since the incident occurred. No action has been taken so far, says Usha.
She was narrating her plight at a recent public hearing on the Atrocities and Non-implementation of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act and Tamil Nadu Rules in the city. Ushas presentation put the glare on caste bias that is very much alive and kicking in our backyard.
In fact, less than one per cent of the accused get convicted under the SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities (PoA) Act, according to statistics released by the National Crime Records Bureau in 2009. And almost 95 per cent of complaints filed by members of the SC/ST community are not even recorded. Of the five per cent of complaints based on which First Information Reports (FIRs) are filed, hardly any move forward as counter cases filed by the accused to render them ineffective.
As Bharathan, a Dalit rights activist, who had helped Dalits file 218 FIRs in 2008 under the SC/ST(PoA) Act, points out, Unless some civil society groups or NGOs support the victim, their complaints are never accepted by the cops.
What is sad to note is, the police often advise the accused on how to come up with the best counter-case, to nullify the victims complaint. Cops prefer to investigate the counter cases, ignoring the original complaints filed by the victims. Often, FIRs are not filed under the SC/ST Act but under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code (minor injury) or under Section 294-B of the IPC (singing, reciting or uttering any obscene song, ballad or words, in or near any public place), so it becomes easy later to force Dalits to settle for a compromise.
To prove his point, he cites the case of a Arunthaiyar woman, who registered a complaint at Surandai police station in Tirunelveli on February 22. A caste Hindu verbally abused her in public. Though the cops gave the woman a CRS receipt after filing an FIR, they changed the case to that of causing public nuisance, after allegedly consulting the towns panchayat chairman. The case was closed after later.
When a case gets past the FIR into the investigation level, the person who wrote the FIR is king. The way he words it is very important. Most of the time, it is mildly worded with an intention to water down the intensity of the atrocity. Which is one reason why the charges rarely stick and the accused gets acquitted easily. The DSP, who is supposed to investigate the case as per the SC/ST Act is forever missing in action, says Bharathan.
On rare occasions, the DSP files a fair investigation report. If and when that happens, he is transferred after the case comes to court, he argues And the investigation is handed over to the local police, who try their best to get the case nullified.
Under the SC/ST Act, every district is supposed to have a SC/ST Act monitoring cell, which is a five-member body, presided by the district collector. If a DSP dismisses a case, he has to present it to this cell. Sadly, the district-level monitoring cells are entirely dysfunctional.
When Dalit or tribal women go to police stations, they end up interacting with male cops, not policewomen. The policemen hardly listen to them or take down their grievances, charges Kalpana, advisor, Tamil Nadu Federation of Women Panchayat Leaders. Besides, policemen are often not polite to Dalits, she points out.
In fact, 18 per cent of the population in Tamil Nadu comprises Dalits. Tribals constitute one per cent of the population. Yet, job vacancies reserved for them are not filled up, citing spurious reasons, such as lack of suitable candidates, observes Kalpana.
There are about 450 types of discrimination and atrocities practiced by caste Hindus against SC/STs, out of which 32 are visible. The rest fall under various heads of visibility. Some are so well disguised that you can figure them out only if you happen to be a Dalit.
For example, a Block Development Officer who was previously posted in the Villathikulam panchayat Union office, would get up every time the Dalit Panchayat president visited him. He would keep standing till the conversation was over often stretching to 25-30 minutes to avoid asking the Dalit to take a seat, argue activists.
At the public hearing, cases broadly falling under social exclusion infringement of customary rights to public places like water, road, graveyard, police atrocities resulting in custodial deaths, rape and sexual assault, abuse of women in power at the panchayat level were discussed.
Indian agencies need to act to stop these atrocities it is simply not good enough to make laws to protect Dalits if the ones who are in place to stop illegal acts ignore them
But there are quite a few cases still pending judgement. I cant find the article right now, but I remember reading an article in ToI that the number of pending cases is in the thousands, if not hundreds of thousands.
