What's new

Journey of a shipbuilder: From exporter to loss-making venture

SMX 3.0

BANNED
Joined
Jun 11, 2021
Messages
650
Reaction score
-7
Country
India
Location
India
It has assets of Tk552 crore while debts have climbed up to around Tk2,000 crore

1635911586831.png


Western Marine Shipyard in Chattogram, which had gained prominence by building 150 ships in 20 years and earning remittance through exports, has almost lost its business to cash crisis.

Its operation remained suspended for one and a half years before it resumed activities about a couple of months ago on a very limited scale.

Western Marine has hardly received any domestic and foreign orders after failing to keep promises on a few international deliveries.

The sorry state of today has little resemblance with its past record of exporting 33 ships to 12 nations, including Germany, Finland, Denmark and the United Arab Emirates, bringing in Tk1,400 crore in remittance.

Wishing not to be named, a director of the company, said Western Marine Shipyard had assets of Tk552 crore at present while its debts had climbed up to around Tk2,000 crore.

1635911649509.png



Land owner Chaber Ahmed has erected a wall in the middle of the yard of Western Marine Shipyard due to long-standing rent arrears. Photo: Mohammad Minhaj Uddin/TBS

Western Marine has little hope of regaining its strength after breaching its commitment to international buyers, he said.

With the company going deep into a crisis, 19 banks and financial organisations are at risk over loan recovery.

Captain Tareque M Nasrullah, executive director of Western Marine, said, "We are trying to turn around and have already delivered a tugboat to the Chattogram port. Deliveries of two ships to Dubai and other large vassals to local parties have remained halted for the financial crisis."

The Business Standard, however, found the tugboat at the company's yard in a recent visit.

Ataul Hakim Siddique, assistant harbor master of Chittagong Port Authority told " We did not get any tugboat from Western Marine."

Debts and pending orders

Western Marine had easily secured loans as a company of an emerging industry but it did not pay back despite counting profits, said AKM Saiful Islam Chowdhury, an official of Bank Asia.

Deliveries of a cargo vessel of S Alam Group, a passenger vessel of Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Corporation, two tugboats of Chattogram and Payra port, and a landing craft of Bangladesh Army have become uncertain following advance payments.

Meanwhile, a Dubai based company, Al Rashid Shipping Limited, filed a lawsuit against Western Marine in June 2020 four months after it was scheduled to deliver two oil tankers.

The High Court on 19 August directed the Anti-Corruption Commission to investigate the payment of Tk23 crore to Western Marine by Chattogram port without receiving the delivery of a tugboat.

The ACC was asked to submit a probe report within two months.

The Chattogram Port Authority had inked an agreement to buy a tugboat for Tk37.75 crore and the tugboat was scheduled to be delivered by December 2018.

Western Marine has been working on another order for a tugboat by the Payra port authority. Company officials think the delivery will not be possible within the time agreed upon.

The need of the emerging industry

Executive Director Tareque said the government had launched "Ship Building Industry Development Policy" to provide long-term loans at low interest rates.

"Hopefully the company will be able to recover shortly," he added.

Captain Md Anam Chowdhury, president of Bangladesh Merchant Marine Officers' Association and Western Marine's independent director, said shipbuilding is a tech industry which can thrive on long-term and low interest loans.

Without any government support, this industry cannot survive.

1635911769082.png


Anam suggested launching a monitoring system to ensure proper utilization of loans.

It takes a long time to make profits and retain a positive business growth after investing in ship building, traders in this industry said.

But shipbuilders took short-term loans at high interest rates from banks and invested in long-term projects. Sometimes it takes around two years to build a ship which should be completed in six months due to unskilled workers and other obstacles, industry insiders said.

Therefore, company owners have to count losses for selling a vessel at a low price or pay a penalty for failing to meet the deadline for delivery, they added.

Not only Western Marine, other ship builders have also been facing similar challenges without a source of financing.

 
.
@Bilal9 isn't this the yard you were talking about...??

All that chest thumping about building 8000 tonne coastal vessels falls flat here.

This GE image from October 2020 shows abandoned rusting hulls as well as an abandoned yard.

wmsbd1.JPG


Also do note the area of the yard- A mere 33 acres. This yard had a turnover of just $35 million when it was profitable.

Please do tell me how this is worth boasting about.
 
Last edited:
.
comparing Indian govt owned shipyards to private shipyards

There is no comparison with Tier 1 Indian shipyards. This yard- with an area of 32 acres & a turnover of ~$30 million- is at the best comparable to a tier 2 Indian shipyard such as Chowgule, Goa.

And let's not forget that this is the biggest & the best you have. Our biggest commercial shipyard had a turnover of $480 million & PAT of $90 million in FY 2019-20.

receiving heavy subsidies

That's what your shipyards are demanding too...

Without any government support, this industry cannot survive.

There seems to be an other kind of ''support'' as well.

The High Court on 19 August directed the Anti-Corruption Commission to investigate the payment of Tk23 crore to Western Marine by Chattogram port without receiving the delivery of a tugboat.
 
Last edited:
.
Apparently Western Marine didn't pay off the loans to the banks. The company's assets and the assets of the owners should be sold to to pay off the loan, and only then they can seek additional funding from external sources.
 
.
Apparently Western Marine didn't pay off the loans to the banks. The company's assets and the assets of the owners should be sold to to pay off the loan, and only then they can seek additional funding from external sources.
Bold part: I think you are talking about mortgaging the assets of the company and the owners/ directors to seek a Bank loan and not selling the assets. But, are the land assets expensive enough?

The company's past experience/ records and technological prowess can be regarded as an asset as well.

The govt can serve better by giving an order to build one or two ships for which only a part of the loan money is extended in advance to be decided by negotiations between the GoB, Bank, and the company. For example, a few ferries.

Our great people have a record of getting loans from the banks which they send to Canada or somewhere and then migrate to that country. I personally know a few big loan thieves. So, a partial loan would serve better.

We are a bunch of shameless thieves, cheaters, and imposters, formerly domestic type and now international. Arrest news of another big thief.

বাগদাদ গ্রুপের চেয়ারম্যান গ্রেপ্তার
এফই অনলাইন ডেস্ক | Published: November 03, 2021 21:11:53
 
Last edited:
.
Bold part: I think you are talking about mortgaging the assets of the company and the owners/ directors to seek a Bank loan and not selling the assets. But, are the land assets expensive enough?

The company's past experience/ records and technological prowess can be regarded as an asset as well.

The govt can serve better by giving an order to build one or two ships for which only a part of the loan money is extended in advance to be decided by negotiations between the GoB, Bank, and the company. For example, a few ferries.

Our great people have a record of getting loans from the banks which they send to Canada or somewhere and then migrate to that country. I personally know a few big loan thieves. So, a partial loan would serve better.

We are a bunch of shameless thieves, cheaters, and imposters, formerly domestic type and now international. Arrest news of another big thief.

বাগদাদ গ্রুপের চেয়ারম্যান গ্রেপ্তার
এফই অনলাইন ডেস্ক | Published: November 03, 2021 21:11:53
What sort of accountant they had? So weird seeing this yard fail like this.
im not very worried though,the assets will be liquidated and will probably be bought by its competition ASSL which is bigger and turns good profits. This is capitalism 101, fail to be competitive and be left to rot.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom