What's new

Is there anything missing now to effectively counter S-400 ?

Muhammad Saftain Anjum

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 8, 2021
Messages
2,080
Reaction score
-2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Combined land and air Warfare is necessary to counter any defence system and luckily we are getting the things ready in our arsenal to counter the defence systems of India.

1-Stealth is the most critical part to counter any defence system.
Despite investment in high supersonic and Hypersonic weapons,US and European defence Companies are actively pushing for further improvement in Stealth Subsonic cruise missiles for anti ship roles(NSM,LRASM,etc are new arrivals in Subsonic stealth category) because the importance of stealth to counter the WarShip's defence systems is equally recognised in Western/US war philosophy.
The upcoming Taimoor Stealth Subsonic cruise missile is the evidence of Pakistan's matured Subsonic cruise missile technology and it is going to be key part of Pakistan's SEAD/ DEAD missions.
FpV2kRNaIAMLvNj.jpeg

A volley of these missiles approaching the defence systems from different routes can do the job.

2-Detecting the position of Defence system is the first part of SEAD/DEAD mission.For this,UAVs have proved to be very affective and expendable weapon against Defence systems.They have proved their value in SEAD/DEAD missions in Russia-Ukraine and Nagorno-Karabakh conflicts.Even if they are shot down,they will expose the position of defence system.
Seeing the wide use of UAVs in modern world conflicts, Pakistani Military planners have put huge focus on UAVs and now have considerable UAV fleet (Both Imported+ Indigenous)
000_1N414K_0.jpg

Bayraktar-Akinci-e1661406071187.jpg

FpaYfMhaYAYYQf6.jpg

CH-4-cropped.png

Capture-7.jpg
Shahpar-II.jpg

Usually,the threat to UAVs is EW jamming by the enemy forces as effectively demonstrated by Russia in Ukraine.
0x0.jpg

But Akinci UAV in Pakistan's UAV fleet have huge payload capacity to carry Electronic Counter Measure (ECM) pods.If Pakistan can develop a net-centric environment for it's UAVs,Akinci can save other UAVs in operation from enemy's EW weapons thus enhancing their SEAD/DEAD efficiency.
(Does Pakistan have this net-centric capability in its UAV fleet is unknown yet.)

3-Along with Air Force,Land Forces will also have the responsibility to counter defence systems of enemy(so a concept of Combined Warfare).So real time data sharing b/w these two branches of military is a key here.
If the UAV/or any other surveillance assest of Land/Air Forces detects the defence system, saturation attack by Rockets can effectively neutralize the Enemy's defence systems.
Pakistani Army has recently tested Fatah-1 Rocket System with a range of 140km.This Guided MLRS system very effectively fits in the equation of SEAD/DEAD mission.
5ff6e4728e623.jpg

4-Now only thing missing here is Swarm drone tech,once it becomes available,SEAD/DEAD mission can even be more effectively carried out.
 
.
Combined land and air Warfare is necessary to counter any defence system and luckily we are getting the things ready in our arsenal to counter the defence systems of India.

1-Stealth is the most critical part to counter any defence system.
Despite investment in high supersonic and Hypersonic weapons,US and European defence Companies are actively pushing for further improvement in Stealth Subsonic cruise missiles for anti ship roles(NSM,LRASM,etc are new arrivals in Subsonic stealth category) because the importance of stealth to counter the WarShip's defence systems is equally recognised in Western/US war philosophy.
The upcoming Taimoor Stealth Subsonic cruise missile is the evidence of Pakistan's matured Subsonic cruise missile technology and it is going to be key part of Pakistan's SEAD/ DEAD missions.
View attachment 919038
A volley of these missiles approaching the defence systems from different routes can do the job.

2-Detecting the position of Defence system is the first part of SEAD/DEAD mission.For this,UAVs have proved to be very affective and expendable weapon against Defence systems.They have proved their value in SEAD/DEAD missions in Russia-Ukraine and Nagorno-Karabakh conflicts.Even if they are shot down,they will expose the position of defence system.
Seeing the wide use of UAVs in modern world conflicts, Pakistani Military planners have put huge focus on UAVs and now have considerable UAV fleet (Both Imported+ Indigenous)
View attachment 919047
View attachment 919048
View attachment 919052
View attachment 919053
View attachment 919054 View attachment 919055
Usually,the threat to UAVs is EW jamming by the enemy forces as effectively demonstrated by Russia in Ukraine.
View attachment 919056
But Akinci UAV in Pakistan's UAV fleet have huge payload capacity to carry Electronic Counter Measure (ECM) pods.If Pakistan can develop a net-centric environment for it's UAVs,Akinci can save other UAVs in operation from enemy's EW weapons thus enhancing their SEAD/DEAD efficiency.
(Does Pakistan have this net-centric capability in its UAV fleet is unknown yet.)

3-Along with Air Force,Land Forces will also have the responsibility to counter defence systems of enemy(so a concept of Combined Warfare).So real time data sharing b/w these two branches of military is a key here.
If the UAV/or any other surveillance assest of Land/Air Forces detects the defence system, saturation attack by Rockets can effectively neutralize the Enemy's defence systems.
Pakistani Army has recently tested Fatah-1 Rocket System with a range of 140km.This Guided MLRS system very effectively fits in the equation of SEAD/DEAD mission.
View attachment 919058
4-Now only thing missing here is Swarm drone tech,once it becomes available,SEAD/DEAD mission can even be more effectively carried out.

No missile defense system is 100% impenetrable, and also, no drone or MLRS can easily strike on S 400s because these are not deployed at the country's borders. This makes it incredibly difficult to destroy them because India is not Afghanistan, Iraq, or Ukraine, and no other air defense protections avaiable.

Before entering or getting to nearby S400s, the majority of the drones will be destroyed at borders.

If you haven't already, take a look at India's Air Defense Multi Systems, which are already deployed and being deployed very immediately.

There are many programs, just completed the below one also.
 
Last edited:
.
No missile defense system is 100% impenetrable, and no drone or MLRS can strike India directly because S 400s are not deployed at the country's borders. This makes it incredibly difficult to destroy them because India is not Afghanistan, Iraq, or Ukraine, and no other air defense protections avaiable.

Before entering or getting to nearby S400s, the majority of the drones will be destroyed at borders.

If you haven't already, take a look at India's Air Defense Multi Systems, which are already deployed and being deployed very immediately.

There are many programs, just completed the below one also.
You people could not shoot down a few glide bombs on 27 feb, u indians are on some next level drugs, no matter how u guys get spanked, you won't understand nor learn. So F off.
 
.
You people could not shoot down a few glide bombs on 27 feb, u indians are on some next level drugs, no matter how u guys get spanked, you won't understand nor learn. So F off.

Do you know the distinction between a basic tense situation and a normal situation?

For your understanding, the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) makes a bravo after only outlining the route of the Brahmos missile after one day. even on February 26th, unable to act in a timely manner.

If you check with them, they will tell you that we would not repeat the errors since we would be on alert mode under hostile circumstances.

It doesn't work that way that you get up tomorrow morning and say, "Let's go, fellas, destroy the S 400 missile systems."
 
Last edited:
.
Do you know the distinction between a basic tense situation and a normal situation?

For your understanding, the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) makes a bravo after only outlining the route. Even on February 26th, unable to act in a timely manner.

If you check with them, they will tell you that we would not repeat the errors since we would be on alert mode under hostile circumstances.

It doesn't work that way that you get up tomorrow morning and say, "Let's go, fellas, destroy the S 400 missile systems."
You **** head can u read, i said was ur air defense was not able to shoot down those glide bombs, they knew for sure pak will strike, yet they couldn't intercept those glide bombs, don't know which fantasy world u indians live in.
 
.
You **** head can u read, i said was ur air defense was not able to shoot down those glide bombs, they knew for sure pak will strike, yet they couldn't intercept those glide bombs, don't know which fantasy world u indians live in.

If Afghanistan has training aircraft also, they can drop bombs at borders in pakistan.

The deep strike is simply different from border bombing by any nation. Pakistan squandered the opportunity to act as well as India in the typical circumstances. Anyone can overlook it

Yet, crossing the border in hostile or combative conditions will be difficult, especially with slow-moving objects like drones. It can be picked up and destroyed with ease.
 
Last edited:
.
Well GMLRS and UAV systems are for any defence system near border.
For deep strike,i think stealth is the key.
And we are making good progress in this department.
Though i have mentioned S400 in title but while writing my focus was on any general defence system deployed near border.
If India pushes S400 deep inside it's territory,then we need some more advanced tech to counter them.


No missile defense system is 100% impenetrable, and also, no drone or MLRS can easily strike on S 400s because these are not deployed at the country's borders. This makes it incredibly difficult to destroy them because India is not Afghanistan, Iraq, or Ukraine, and no other air defense protections avaiable.

Before entering or getting to nearby S400s, the majority of the drones will be destroyed at borders.

If you haven't already, take a look at India's Air Defense Multi Systems, which are already deployed and being deployed very immediately.

There are many programs, just completed the below one also.
 
.
Well GMLRS and UAV systems are for any defence system near border.
For deep strike,i think stealth is the key.
And we are making good progress in this department.
Though i have mentioned S400 in title but while writing my focus was on any general defence system deployed near border.
If India pushes S400 deep inside it's territory,then we need some more advanced tech to counter them.

In my opinion, drones are overrated since they are only useful against opponents who lack robust or decent air defenses.

The accuracy will be the deciding element against these moving platforms, so a hypersonic stealth missile is a good alternative against these missile defense systems, but the error margin is also quite small.
 
.
SAMs are so outdated. Just swarm $5000 drone swarms to let them waste their million dollar SAM missiles then send the real package
 
.
Use AI or autonomous flying systems to deploy armed aircraft like old f-7 and f-6 to take out AD systems. If they get shot down they will deplete expensive S-400 missiles.
Then use f-16/j-10/jf-17 with impunity.
 
.
SAMs are so outdated. Just swarm $5000 drone swarms to let them waste their million dollar SAM missiles then send the real package
This was done by Israel against Egypt in 1967. This is not a new insight or hitherto unthought of tactic. All air forces around the world know about it, including the IAF and PAF.

You people could not shoot down a few glide bombs on 27 feb, u indians are on some next level drugs, no matter how u guys get spanked, you won't understand nor learn. So F off.
What did the glide bombs hit or destroy?
 
.
No missile defense system is 100% impenetrable, and also, no drone or MLRS can easily strike on S 400s because these are not deployed at the country's borders. This makes it incredibly difficult to destroy them because India is not Afghanistan, Iraq, or Ukraine, and no other air defense protections avaiable.

Before entering or getting to nearby S400s, the majority of the drones will be destroyed at borders.

If you haven't already, take a look at India's Air Defense Multi Systems, which are already deployed and being deployed very immediately.

There are many programs, just completed the below one also.

No one needs to strike the actual S400,
the system has a finite capacity in terms of missiles and range,
only have to inundate the system until exhausted.

Lastly, air power is only a tool to ensure land dominance,
be it Navy or Air force, eventually it's the infantry that will rule.
 
.
No missile defense system is 100% impenetrable, and also, no drone or MLRS can easily strike on S 400s because these are not deployed at the country's borders. This makes it incredibly difficult to destroy them because India is not Afghanistan, Iraq, or Ukraine, and no other air defense protections avaiable.

Before entering or getting to nearby S400s, the majority of the drones will be destroyed at borders.

If you haven't already, take a look at India's Air Defense Multi Systems, which are already deployed and being deployed very immediately.

There are many programs, just completed the below one also.
The Indian IADs is the actual threat compared to any Rafale but the tit for tat will continue on both sides to counter things. What has actually emerged out of Ukraine is that a layered IADs makes life very difficult for aircraft but near suicidal for helicopters. So anyone investing in Attack helicopters beyond very specific roles is now making a folly knowing what is cooking in their neighborhood .
 
.
Combined land and air Warfare is necessary to counter any defence system and luckily we are getting the things ready in our arsenal to counter the defence systems of India.

1-Stealth is the most critical part to counter any defence system.
Despite investment in high supersonic and Hypersonic weapons,US and European defence Companies are actively pushing for further improvement in Stealth Subsonic cruise missiles for anti ship roles(NSM,LRASM,etc are new arrivals in Subsonic stealth category) because the importance of stealth to counter the WarShip's defence systems is equally recognised in Western/US war philosophy.
The upcoming Taimoor Stealth Subsonic cruise missile is the evidence of Pakistan's matured Subsonic cruise missile technology and it is going to be key part of Pakistan's SEAD/ DEAD missions.
View attachment 919038
A volley of these missiles approaching the defence systems from different routes can do the job.

2-Detecting the position of Defence system is the first part of SEAD/DEAD mission.For this,UAVs have proved to be very affective and expendable weapon against Defence systems.They have proved their value in SEAD/DEAD missions in Russia-Ukraine and Nagorno-Karabakh conflicts.Even if they are shot down,they will expose the position of defence system.
Seeing the wide use of UAVs in modern world conflicts, Pakistani Military planners have put huge focus on UAVs and now have considerable UAV fleet (Both Imported+ Indigenous)
View attachment 919047
View attachment 919048
View attachment 919052
View attachment 919053
View attachment 919054 View attachment 919055
Usually,the threat to UAVs is EW jamming by the enemy forces as effectively demonstrated by Russia in Ukraine.
View attachment 919056
But Akinci UAV in Pakistan's UAV fleet have huge payload capacity to carry Electronic Counter Measure (ECM) pods.If Pakistan can develop a net-centric environment for it's UAVs,Akinci can save other UAVs in operation from enemy's EW weapons thus enhancing their SEAD/DEAD efficiency.
(Does Pakistan have this net-centric capability in its UAV fleet is unknown yet.)

3-Along with Air Force,Land Forces will also have the responsibility to counter defence systems of enemy(so a concept of Combined Warfare).So real time data sharing b/w these two branches of military is a key here.
If the UAV/or any other surveillance assest of Land/Air Forces detects the defence system, saturation attack by Rockets can effectively neutralize the Enemy's defence systems.
Pakistani Army has recently tested Fatah-1 Rocket System with a range of 140km.This Guided MLRS system very effectively fits in the equation of SEAD/DEAD mission.
View attachment 919058
4-Now only thing missing here is Swarm drone tech,once it becomes available,SEAD/DEAD mission can even be more effectively carried out.

To beat the S-400 or really any air defense system, you would need lots of different Loitering munitions like the Harpy or Harop, etc. lots of standoff anti radiation munitions(cruise missiles, next gen anti radiation missiles like AGM-88G AARGM-ER), and significant Electronic Warfare platforms. And very extensive SEAD capabilities and platforms. Not simply a few tactical drones, regular drones are good, but they are only one piece of a very complex puzzle(case in point we see less TB2 sorties b/c of the layered and established air defense).
 
. .

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom