Is Editor Dawn Zafar Abbas a Traitor?

[Leader]

Ed Dawn Zafar Abbas not ignorant but when working for BBC he stood in AJK & called as "Pak occupied Kashmir"

can the guy be termed as a traitor as he objects to territorial integrity of our State?

 

[truthseeker2010]

No because what he said is truth.

just like the other part "indian occupied kashmir" is true?

 

[jarves]

just like the other part "indian occupied kashmir" is true?

Yeah but we have occupied it legally unlike Pakistan

 

[Chronos]

Ed Dawn Zafar Abbas not ignorant but when working for BBC he stood in AJK & called as "Pak occupied Kashmir"

can the guy be termed as a traitor as he objects to territorial integrity of our State?

I feel the word 'traitor is thrown around too loosely these days.

Can he be rebuked, chastised or castigated if what you said had happened? You are free to do so.

Is he really a traitor? For me, that is a weighted charge to throw around. Unless he actively starts actively collaborating with the enemy then No.

Plus, we don't know what the BBc editorial stance is.

No matter how unpopular an opinion expressed is, think twice before the label 'traitor' is thrown. It is used too much in the current times to shut down debate.

@Leader your avatars have been brilliant lately. Whta cultures do the people in your avatar recently belong to

 

[Leader]

Yeah but we have occupied it legally unlike Pakistan

you can carry your trolling elsewhere. this is not a debate thread about Kashmir and its occupation.

I feel the word 'traitor is thrown around too loosely these days.

Can he be rebuked, chastised or castigated if what you said had happened? You are free to do so.

Is he really a traitor? For me, that is a weighted charge to throw around. Unless he actively starts actively collaborating with the enemy then No.

Plus, we don't know what the BBc editorial stance is.

No matter how unpopular an opinion expressed is, think twice before the label 'traitor' is thrown. It is used too much in the current times to shut down debate.

thanks, an unpopular opinion should not damage the integrity of the State. I was thinking in terms of State Law. not freedom of speech point of view.

 

[Chronos]

you can carry your trolling elsewhere. this is not a debate thread about Kashmir and its occupation.



thanks, an unpopular opinion should not damage the integrity of the State. I was thinking in terms of State Law. not freedom of speech point of view.

Not familiar with Pakistani Law. D you have laws that says that you will be punished or your speech be seen as seditious if you say AJK is Pakistan occupied Kashmir?

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

@Leader bhaiya, if freedom of speech is a part or your country's constitution . . . then you can't declare him a traitor

(i guess so)

 

[truthseeker2010]

Yeah but we have occupied it legally unlike Pakistan

Everything that india and indian does is legal right?

 

[Luftwaffe]

Ed Dawn Zafar Abbas not ignorant but when working for BBC he stood in AJK & called as "Pak occupied Kashmir"

can the guy be termed as a traitor as he objects to territorial integrity of our State?

Na deen ka na dunya ka, no point in tagging him with anything, apna kharcha pani poora kar raha hai. Almost 99% of our media is like him...so this guy is only ignorant fool minus smartarse.

 

[Leader]

Not familiar with Pakistani Law. D you have laws that says that you will be punished or your speech be seen as seditious if you say AJK is Pakistan occupied Kashmir?

not specifically, but its a common understanding that a traitor is the one who undermine the constitution or conspiracy against the State with outsiders against the integrity of the State.

 

[Luftwaffe]

If this guy is sincere he would have pointed out how peaceful AzadJK, its development and over all conditions compared to occupied Kashmir on the other side...see these types of idiots are everywhere in media when you switch on tv you won't see what changes PTI brought in KPK but only only -VE news every now and then specially for the past 3 months its so pathetic I only watch CN/natgeo/discovery.

 

[Kompromat]

@Leader
Any source available?

 

[Indischer]

your avatars have been brilliant lately. Whta cultures do the people in your avatar recently belong to

Since he didn't answer it, I'm here to make a guess. They look like the Kalash of Chitral and the Burusho of Hunza Valley.

 

[Contrarian]

Pakistani's seem to be obsessed and very liberal with the word 'Traitor' and the word 'Exposed'.

Every Pakistani has his/her list of 'traitors' in Pakistan. More often than not, they are just people with different views than themselves or their clique's.

 

[That Guy]

Ed Dawn Zafar Abbas not ignorant but when working for BBC he stood in AJK & called as "Pak occupied Kashmir"

can the guy be termed as a traitor as he objects to territorial integrity of our State?

No, because he was simply following BBC guidelines. BBC refers to both sides as occupied.

Pakistani's seem to be obsessed and very liberal with the word 'Traitor' and the word 'Exposed'.

Every Pakistani has his/her list of 'traitors' in Pakistan. More often than not, they are just people with different views than themselves or their clique's.

And you seem to be obsessed with blanket statements about Pakistanis. This isn't the first time you've done this.