Interview of Australian geoint analyst Nathan Ruser on Galwan standoff

[BL33D]

Basic summary:
Ajai Shukla's claim doesn't hold up based on available evidence
Chinese buildup mostly with in the claim line, or lac, except for one location about 500m in the Indian side.
At that location, there are at most a few dozen tents and no permanent structures yet, disproving Shukla's claims about thousands of Chinese troops in Indian controlled territory and bunker construction
India matching Chinese deployments only a few hundred meters away.

@Nilgiri @silent_poison @Jugger

 

[Death Professor]

Better, more informative in-depth analysis than some paid mouth-piece. Just go to his twitter, most of his post are anti-China. Although Parwin Swahney posts are anti China too in one sense, but his arguments are much more objective than any tom, dick and harry indian media manage to find on the internet.

 

[BL33D]

Praveen Sawhney is a smart guy with some good opinions. which I respect. I prefer actual evidence though. Sawhney has been making doomsday predictions for over a decade, most of which never came true.

 

[graphican]

This guy is young as 18 perhaps, and Indian journalist is asking him "In your opinion is that the hostile situation". How can he answer such questions other than verbalising what is visible in the photos?

 

[Whirling_dervesh]

Rush the whiteys in to lend legitimacy, an age old habit

 

[masterchief_mirza]

I mean come on, India has got some kid to apply Burnol now. Can't some politician at least open his mouth and defend Indian territorial integrity?

 

[BL33D]

I mean come on, India has got some kid to apply Burnol now. Can't some politician at least open his mouth and defend Indian territorial integrity?

I believe Mr. Ruser's credentials speak for themselves. And forget about those ad-hominem attacks, you satellite imagery is pretty clear about the ground realities.

https://www.aspi.org.au/bio/nathan-ruser

 

[newb3e]

Rush the whiteys in to lend legitimacy, an age old gangu habit

crazy right even after their supa powa claims slave run back to white master for legitimacy!

Why haven't we heard the Might of Brahmos yet?

And where is Bippin?

All this time telling the world of TwoPhrunt War and now he has his chance....but sweet Bippin is missing... like post 27thFeb19!!!

boobs brahmos ki seat peh beth keh cheen peh hamla karay ga!

 

[masterchief_mirza]

I believe Mr. Ruser's credentials speak for themselves. And forget about those ad-hominem attacks, you satellite imagery is pretty clear about the ground realities.

https://www.aspi.org.au/bio/nathan-ruser

Well as long as there's plenty of space under the carpet to brush this, Who am I to question how India rationalises these things. Btw, "kid" is hardly an ad hominem "attack" now is it? It's a perfectly reasonable descriptor unless someone is overly sensitive. Fair enough, he's qualified enough.

 

[xeuss]

Basic summary:
Ajai Shukla's claim doesn't hold up based on available evidence
Chinese buildup mostly with in the claim line, or lac, except for one location about 500m in the Indian side.
At that location, there are at most a few dozen tents and no permanent structures yet, disproving Shukla's claims about thousands of Chinese troops in Indian controlled territory and bunker construction
India matching Chinese deployments only a few hundred meters away.

@Nilgiri @silent_poison @Jugger

Manu Pubby and Indian Express are also making similar claims. That China is occupying Indian territory.

I don't think all three are fabricating the situation on the ground.

 

[rott]

Rush the whiteys in to lend legitimacy, an age old gangu habit

Clear evidence of white worshipping.

 

[TNT]

Indians and their white slave mentality. I remember they ised to invite that other crazy american white lady, untill she embarrassed their whole nation infront of their army and airforce on TV.

 

[Imran Khan]

PDF think tanks know better then this kid . indians just looking for face saving now .

 

[BL33D]

i wonder if any Pakistani will actually comment on the content of the interview, some good information is actually discussed. But then again, it shows that India has successfully pushed back Chinese attempting to infiltrate and continued building infrastrcture Chinese claim as their own, so i understand why this makes Pakistanis so butthurt.

 

[Rafi]

The Chinese are doing well here, goodluck to them in fighting back the indian sub humans.