What's new

India's top court says no to national ban on cow slaughter

ito

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 5, 2014
Messages
9,177
Reaction score
-33
Country
India
Location
India
http://www.dawn.com/news/1311060/indias-top-court-says-no-to-national-ban-on-cow-slaughter

India's top court Friday rejected a petition seeking a nationwide ban on cow slaughter, a flash point issue for Hindus who consider the animal sacred.

The Supreme Court dismissed an activist's proposal to prohibit the slaughter of cows across India, a measure that would have effectively banned beef consumption in the nation of 1.25 billion.

Cows are revered in the Hindu scriptures as the 'mother' of civilisation and many worshippers equate the slaughter of cows or eating beef as blasphemy.

But millions from India's huge minority populations ─ including Muslims, Christians and lower caste Hindus ─ eat beef, which isn't widely available and is banned altogether in some states.

Just eight of India's 29 states permit the consumption of beef or the slaughter of cows.

"One state may ban slaughter, the other may not," the court said, rejecting the petition.

"We will not interfere in state laws."

Several radical religious groups, and the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, have long campaigned to implement a nationwide ban on cow slaughter.

The BJP won national elections in 2014 with a thumping majority, pledging in part to ban cow slaughter. But so far the government in Delhi has failed to convince the states to pass such sweeping measures.

Some BJP-ruled states have in recent years pushed through tougher penalties including ten-year jail terms for those convicted of cow slaughter or possession or consumption of beef.

Simmering tensions over the issue have spilled into violence since BJP's national ascent to power, with a string of attacks on minorities by right-wing Hindu vigilantes resulting in the deaths of at least 10 people.

In 2014, a 50-year-old Muslim man accused of slaughtering a cow and consuming its meat was murdered by a mob at his home near New Delhi.

The lynching prompted international outrage and accusations of a rise in religious vigilantism under the Modi administration.
 
. . .
Ban should be state-to-state basis depending on local customs.

Why? Local customs is a loose phrase; the local customs of Uttar Pradesh Hindus and of Uttar Pradesh Muslims differ; the local customs of upper-caste Hindus, and Dalits, Christians and Muslims in Tamil Nadu differ.

What local customs are we talking about?
 
. . . . . .
make the ban district wise. most violence occurs where minority dares to be insensitive...

it is not practical to implement such a ban all over India or the world. Wherever hindus are in majority ban slaughter through plebiscite...

what would happen if a non-muslim minority burns Quran to make food in emergency, he is a infidel so even God can't question him...
 
Last edited:
. . .
make the ban district wise. most violence occurs where minority dares to be insensitive...

it is not practical to implement such a ban all over India or the world. Wherever hindus are in majority ban slaughter through plebiscite...


just ban it outright after all it is already banned in majority of States of India . ONLY 8 states did not ban it completely or officially otherwise the reality is that fear of cow slaughter and getting lynched as a result is prevalent there
 
.
just ban it outright after all it is already banned in majority of States of India . ONLY 8 states did not ban it completely or officially otherwise the reality is that fear of cow slaughter and getting lynched as a result is prevalent there

it is not practical to implement it all over India, India is too diverse, but this ban can be implemented district wise through plebiscite. Fear of blasphemy law exists in Islamic countries, where life of a non-muslim is lower than a book(Quran).
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom