Indian minorities should realized that Jinnah's vision about Hindutva was absolutely right - ISPR

[SrNair]

really ? internal matter

Yet your media and you people are obsessed with Pakistani internal matters and when we point the finger in a similar manner you claim it is an internal matter...

hypocrites.

People is not an issue.
Issue is when Govt officials and ministers interfere in the matter

 

[War Thunder]

he should mind his business... he have no right to comment on Indian internal matters...

And what are you going to do about it? Cry?

 

[graphican]

Indian Muslims are more munafak - we don’t need any other their offices here. After the Balakot Strike you should have seen the venom they were spewing especially on Zee TV by that bitch of a anchor they have among others.

Imagine the difficult job that Jinnah and Allama Iqbal did on the same low morale Muslims that they ended up creating Pakistan. We are the same Muslims who's forefathers were either born on the land or decided to migrate to it while others decided to stay back in the land called India.

Its disrespectful to call anyone munafiq. Let's not call our brothers left in India that. Zara num ho to ye matti beri zerhaiz hay saqi is still true.

 

[danger007]

And what are you going to do about it? Cry?

that's what you guys doing... opening several threads on same topic...

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Imagine the difficult job that Jinnah and Allama Iqbal did on the same low morale Muslims that they ended up creating Pakistan. We are the same Muslims who's forefathers were either born on the land or decided to migrate to it while others decided to stay back in the land called India.

Its disrespectful to call anyone munafiq. Let's not call our brothers left in India that. Zara num ho to ye matti beri zerhaiz hay saqi is still true.

Lol................indian so called "Muslims" are the biggest munafiqs planet Earth has EVER seen!..................they combine hinduism and Islam and claim it is the purest form of Islam....................they also hate Pakistan and Pakistanis even more than indian hindus and sikhs. It will be great if they all wipe each other out. They are the enemies of Pakistan.......they maybe your brothers but they certainly aren't the brothers and sisters of the Pakistani people. The Chinese and Turks are though.

 

[Wrath]

he should mind his business... he have no right to comment on Indian internal matters...

This is his business . If endians can do it , so can we .

 

[SIPRA]

Every two penny Tom, Dick and Harry, of Hindutva-Bhakt-Sanghi category, is trying to tell our DG(ISPR) his business and what he shall or shall not say.

 

[Protest_again]

DG ISPR should come with the 'number' of Indian minorities running to Pakistan for safety. This will add weight to his argument. Indian Muslims still choosing to stay in India invalidates all jinnah's theory. Separation of Bangladesh is also an invalidating point. DG ISPR is just clutching at straws when the verdict is being seen as an irrelevant event in India.

 

[TheGreatMaratha]

To all my Pakistani friends commenting here about injustice, let me just tell you that India has the largest number of mosques in the world. India has Muslim superstars (SRK, Salman, Aamir). India has had a Muslim captains (MD Azharuddin, Pataudi) of Indian cricket teams. India has had a Muslim President who is respected by everyone (Dr APJ Abdul Kalam). Muslim actresses, Muslim businessmen (Azim Premji). There are Muslims at my workplace who are as or even more patriotic than many Hindus. Not only Muslims but even the Christians, Buddhists, Sikhs, Parsis, Jews are loyal to India. I hope Pakistanis understand that India is much more diverse than Pakistan both culturally, religiously, ethnicity wise and language wise. You can't expect us to be all perfect.

Yes there have been lynchings and ~100 people have been killed/injured since 2014 but if you look at that number in a nation of 1.3 billion people, it is very small.

Please give me examples of Pakistani Hindus who have made it big. I'm not saying there are no Pakistani Hindus who have made it big but their numbers will be really small.

Anyway, I think both India and Pakistan should forget each other and just concentrate on development. Compete to be the first country to have $10000 GDP per capita or something like that.

 

[PradoTLC]

People is not an issue.
Issue is when Govt officials and ministers interfere in the matter

Like when India sends in terrorist like Yadav ?...or Bhukti Bhani or LTTE?...

 

[IceCold]

To all my Pakistani friends commenting here about injustice, let me just tell you that India has the largest number of mosques in the world. India has Muslim superstars (SRK, Salman, Aamir). India has had a Muslim captains (MD Azharuddin, Pataudi) of Indian cricket teams. India has had a Muslim President who is respected by everyone (Dr APJ Abdul Kalam). Muslim actresses, Muslim businessmen (Azim Premji). There are Muslims at my workplace who are as or even more patriotic than many Hindus. Not only Muslims but even the Christians, Buddhists, Sikhs, Parsis, Jews are loyal to India. I hope Pakistanis understand that India is much more diverse than Pakistan both culturally, religiously, ethnicity wise and language wise. You can't expect us to be all perfect.

Yes there have been lynchings and ~100 people have been killed/injured since 2014 but if you look at that number in a nation of 1.3 billion people, it is very small.

Please give me examples of Pakistani Hindus who have made it big. I'm not saying there are no Pakistani Hindus who have made it big but their numbers will be really small.

Anyway, I think both India and Pakistan should forget each other and just concentrate on development. Compete to be the first country to have $10000 GDP per capita or something like that.

Your comparison with Pakistan is flawed. Pakistan or Pakistanis dont hide behind secularism. We are very clear in who we are and that is an Islamic republic of Pakistan clearly defined in the constitution with Islam the guiding principle and under this constitution is where the rights of minorities fall, again defined by Islam. You on the other hand claim to be world largest secular democracy yet always fall shot of it. The point being raised here is why the charade? Why hide behind this whole secular fiasco when you are not. India is a hindu country and run by RSS led ultra leftist regime who do not believe India has room for any minority specially Muslims.
Still Pakistan had a Hindu Chief Justice even though we dont hide behind any fallacy. We have sikhs and Hindus in army, in police, in Parliament.
http://www.na.gov.pk/en/mna_list.php?list=minority

So please dont make any comparisons when we dont pretend unlike you lot.

 

[TheGreatMaratha]

Your comparison with Pakistan is flawed. Pakistan or Pakistanis dont hide behind secularism. We are very clear in who we are and that is an Islamic republic of Pakistan clearly defined in the constitution with Islam the guiding principle and under this constitution is where the rights of minorities fall, again defined by Islam. You on the other hand claim to be world largest secular democracy yet always fall shot of it. The point being raised here is why the charade? Why hide behind this whole secular fiasco when you are not. India is a hindu country and run by RSS led ultra leftist regime who do not believe India has room for any minority specially Muslims.
Still Pakistan had a Hindu Chief Justice even though we dont hide behind any fallacy. We have sikhs and Hindus in army, in police, in Parliament.
http://www.na.gov.pk/en/mna_list.php?list=minority

So please dont make any comparisons when we dont pretend unlike you lot.

Are you saying that it's ok if Pakistan treats its minorities unfairly just because it's a theocratic state and that's what theocratic states do? And it's not ok because India is secular and should truly be secular? If that's the case, you have a flawed thinking. And what makes you think Muslims are being discriminated at?

I'll give you my own personal experience:
At my workplace, two people one Hindu and one Muslim were due for promotion but only person could be promoted that cycle. The Hindu boss promoted the Muslim guy just because he was working for longer hours and on top that his work and contribution was also better.
When I play cricket with locals, I'm the captain usually and I always pick one Muslim (who is also a driver of a Hindu) guy in my team because of his big hitting ability. Afterwards, the same Muslim was looking for another job and my brother got him employed in his company as a driver (since he was a drive). Basically, my brother helped him get a job. What was my brother going to get? Nothing. He just helped him not even thinking of which religion that guy belonged to.

And that's just not me. People don't care about religion here. Don't use social media to judge a country. People spouting venom on social media can't even dare to spout venom in real life.

 

[SIPRA]

Are you saying that it's ok if Pakistan treats its minorities unfairly just because it's a theocratic state and that's what theocratic states do? And it's not ok because India is secular and should truly be secular? If that's the case, you have a flawed thinking. And what makes you think Muslims are being discriminated at?

I'll give you my own personal experience:
At my workplace, two people one Hindu and one Muslim were due for promotion but only person could be promoted that cycle. The Hindu boss promoted the Muslim guy just because he was working for longer hours and on top that his work and contribution was also better.
When I play cricket with locals, I'm the captain usually and I always pick one Muslim (who is also a driver of a Hindu) guy in my team because of his big hitting ability. Afterwards, the same Muslim was looking for another job and my brother got him employed in his company as a driver (since he was a drive). Basically, my brother helped him get a job. What was my brother going to get? Nothing. He just helped him not even thinking of which religion that guy belonged to.

And that's just not me. People don't care about religion here. Don't use social media to judge a country. People spouting venom on social media can't even dare to spout venom in real life.

I have read your post. My political analysis is that had even 50% of the elite Hindus been like you, as you have narrated, in British India; there would not have been any Pakistan.

 

[IceCold]

Are you saying that it's ok if Pakistan treats its minorities unfairly just because it's a theocratic state and that's what theocratic states do? And it's not ok because India is secular and should truly be secular? If that's the case, you have a flawed thinking. And what makes you think Muslims are being discriminated at?

I'll give you my own personal experience:
At my workplace, two people one Hindu and one Muslim were due for promotion but only person could be promoted that cycle. The Hindu boss promoted the Muslim guy just because he was working for longer hours and on top that his work and contribution was also better.
When I play cricket with locals, I'm the captain usually and I always pick one Muslim (who is also a driver of a Hindu) guy in my team because of his big hitting ability. Afterwards, the same Muslim was looking for another job and my brother got him employed in his company as a driver (since he was a drive). Basically, my brother helped him get a job. What was my brother going to get? Nothing. He just helped him not even thinking of which religion that guy belonged to.

And that's just not me. People don't care about religion here. Don't use social media to judge a country. People spouting venom on social media can't even dare to spout venom in real life.

What I am saying is that Pakistan is an Islamic Republic. We don't hide behind secularism. Anything else is your own opinion and your attempt to twist my words. I am not saying treatment of minority in Pakistan is idle, it's not but than your should be exceptional when you claim otherwise which it is not. Because that secularism that you hide behind is nothing more than a fasade, in reality you are only a hindu state ruled by extremists.

 

[danger007]

This is his business . If endians can do it , so can we .

just like you call endians i can find many names for you too... it just your tiny ego that driving you to call such names... be mature...