India not as sincere about our concerns as we are about theirs

[Black_cats]

India not as sincere about our concerns as we are about theirs​

India's foreign secretary Vinay Kwatra and the US state department's counselor Derek Chollet arrived on the same day on a visit to Bangladesh. Their visit is being considered significant in Bangladesh's political and geopolitical context. Former foreign secretary Md Touhid Hossain spoke to Prothom Alo in this regard.

Md Touhid Hossain
Published: 17 Feb 2023, 02: 28

Md Touhid Hossain

The Bangladesh visit of India's foreign secretary Vinay Kwatra may carry some political influence. However, I do not view this as part of the routine visits at the foreign secretary level between Bangladesh and India. Vinay Kwatra came and held talks with the Bangladesh foreign secretary. According to the norms, he paid courtesy calls on the prime minister and foreign minister. When Bangladesh's foreign secretary visits Delhi, in keeping with India's norms he meets their foreign minister and foreign secretary, but not the prime minister.

China, in particular, will keep a watch on which direction India-Bangladesh relations are turning. The US will do so too.

The Indian foreign secretary said that India has confidence in Sheikh Hasina's leadership. This statement may be a matter of courtesy, but then again, it may bear significance. After all, the relationship that has persisted long between the Indian government and the Bangladesh government, has been quite to India's satisfaction.

Vinay Kwatra commented that India-Bangladesh relations have reached a strategic level. I feel that the relations between the two countries have been at a strategic level for quite some time now. However, his statement that the entire world values Bangladesh-India relations, is not quite comprehensible.

Geopolitically and economically speaking, India is an important country. Bangladesh has a certain degree of importance globally too. So it would not be anything out of the normal for others to observe the relations between these two countries. China, in particular, will keep a watch on which direction India-Bangladesh relations are turning. The US will do so too.

We want good and strong relations with India where all bilateral issues will be taken into consideration and efforts will be made to resolve any existing problems. But whether I want to or not, I am forced to point out that for over the last 12 to 14 years, India has not displayed the same sincerity about Bangladesh's concerns as Bangladesh has towards resolving India's concerns. India always declares, neighbours first. But when it comes down to reality, we do not really see any reflection of these words. India has not addressed any important need of Bangladesh. Take the Teesta deal, for example. The Teesta deal was almost signed, but it never was actually done, even after so many years. Why? India does not say that the Teesta deal is unnecessary or unjustified. But Bangladesh's interests are being harmed due to India's domestic politics.

Concerning the issue of border killings, at one time both sides would say that efforts are being made to bring this down to zero. But in recent times we are hearing quite the opposite from some of India's leaders. The Rohingya problem poses as a huge burden on Bangladesh. But India simply pays lip service to the matter, does nothing tangible to this end. It should have applied pressure on Myanmar to take back the Rohingyas.

We can, after all, change many things, but we cannot change our neighbours

PIndia has invited prime minister Sheikh Hasina to attend the 18th session of the G-20 summit taking place in New Delhi in September this year. This is a positive step in the relations between the two countries. It will benefit Bangladesh if there are arrangements for the Bangladesh prime minister to meet with the heads of governments of other countries in the sidelines of the summit.

Bangladesh-India relations are vital for the development and advancement of both countries. We always want the relations to remain good and for both sides to uphold each other's interests. Bangladesh-India relations will remain important in the days to come. We can, after all, change many things, but we cannot change our neighbours.

* This commentary appeared in the print an online edition of Prothom Alo and has been rewritten for the English edition by Ayesha Kabir

India not as sincere about our concerns as we are about theirs

Over the last 12 to 14 years, India has not displayed the same sincerity about Bangladesh's concerns as Bangladesh has towards resolving India's concerns. India always declares, neighbours first. But when it comes down to reality, we do not really see any reflection of these words

en.prothomalo.com

 

[Imran Khan]

in south asia this is how husbands do to wives

 

[fallstuff]

What else is new ? The lesser one is always on the receiving end.

 

[That Guy]

I mean, this isn't really news. That's what dominant powers do to their junior partners.

 

[Destranator]

India not as sincere about our concerns as we are about theirs​

 

[Cheepek]

Ratified a 4 decade old land swap agreement, settled a 3 decade old maritime dispute, apart from co-operation in many other areas.
Serious negotiations and their outcomes take time. Unlike dictatorships, we have a quasi federal structure with immense powers to the states for governance.
If a former foreign secretary cannot grasp the complexities involved, and comes hopping with a to-do wish list; what more can be said about the common lungi

 

[bluesky]

Our Hasina Bibi gives India all the privileges on the expectation of getting Indian help to resolve American sanctions but with failure.

Hasina should better give up on asking for Indian help and arrange a fair election. Why should she fear elections though non-election has created an acute autocrat in her.

 

[Abu Shaleh Rumi]

BAL is the main culprit here.